Temwell Pty Ltd (ACN 082 656 157) v DKGR Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Temwell Pty Ltd (ACN 082 656 157) v DKGR Holdings Pty Ltd [2003] FCA 806

TEMWELL PTY LTD (ACN 082 656 157)  -v-  DKGR HOLDINGS PTY LTD (formerly known as DYNAMIC DATA SYSTEMS PTY LTD) (In Liquidation) (ACN 062 778 616),  mCOM SOLUTIONS INC, DRAGON VENTURES. COM INC, mCOM SOLUTIONS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (In Liquidation) (ACN 091 375 950), DAVID HAINS, ROBERT VAN ZANTEN, DRAGONVENTURES.COM LTD, RICHARD HAINS  and  IAN MORRIS KIEFEL

V 663 of 2000

RYAN J

5 AUGUST 2003
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY V 663 of 2000
BETWEEN: TEMWELL PTY LTD (ACN 082 656 157)
Applicant
AND: DKGR HOLDINGS PTY LTD (formerly known as DYNAMIC DATA SYSTEMS PTY LTD) (In Liquidation) (ACN 062 778 616)
First Respondent
mCOM SOLUTIONS INC.
Second Respondent
DRAGON VENTURES. COM INC
Third Respondent
mCOM SOLUTIONS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (In Liquidation) (ACN 091 375 950)
Fourth Respondent
DAVID HAINS
Fifth Respondent
ROBERT VAN ZANTEN
Sixth Respondent
DRAGONVENTURES.COM LTD
Seventh Respondent
RICHARD HAINS
Eighth Respondent
IAN MORRIS KIEFEL
Ninth Respondent

JUDGE:

RYAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

5 AUGUST 2003

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The affidavit of June Wilson sworn 26 July 2002 and each of the affidavits of Peter Rayner respectively sworn 31 July 2002 and 9 May 2003 and the several exhibits to the said affidavits of June Wilson and Peter Rayner be removed from the file.

2.The applicant have leave further to amend the further amended statement of claim by appending to paragraph 46 thereof particulars of loss and damage conforming with those set out in the further amended further and better particulars of loss and damage filed herein on 17 June 2003 but excluding paragraph (iii) thereof.

3.The respondents’ costs thrown away as a result of the orders made in paragraphs 1 and 2 hereof and the costs of all parties of and incidental to the hearings on 18, 19, 23 and 24 June 2003 be reserved.

Note:    Settlement and entry of Orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY V 663 of 2000
BETWEEN: TEMWELL PTY LTD (ACN 082 656 157)
Applicant
AND: DKGR HOLDINGS PTY LTD (formerly known as DYNAMIC DATA SYSTEMS PTY LTD) (In Liquidation) (ACN 062 778 616)
First Respondent
mCOM SOLUTIONS INC.
Second Respondent
DRAGON VENTURES. COM INC
Third Respondent
mCOM SOLUTIONS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (In Liquidation) (ACN 091 375 950)
Fourth Respondent
DAVID HAINS
Fifth Respondent
ROBERT VAN ZANTEN
Sixth Respondent
DRAGONVENTURES.COM LTD
Seventh Respondent
RICHARD HAINS
Eighth Respondent
IAN MORRIS KIEFEL
Ninth Respondent

JUDGE:

RYAN J

DATE:

5 AUGUST 2003

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR RULINGS ON ADMISSIBILITY OF EXPERT EVIDENCE

The present form of the statement of claim

  1. The third further amended statement of claim filed on behalf of the applicant (“Temwell”) discloses several courses of action which I have endeavoured to outline in what follows.  This outline does not reflect arguments which might be advanced by either side…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Temwell Pty Ltd (ACN 082 656 157) v DKGR Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] FCA 806
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Temwell Pty Ltd brought a claim against DKGR Holdings Pty Ltd in the Federal Court of Australia, contesting the admissibility of expert evidence presented by two witnesses, June Wilson and Peter Rayner. The primary concern of the court was whether the evidence provided by these witnesses was relevant and whether they were qualified to provide expert opinions. Temwell sought to rely on the latest reports of Wilson and Rayner, prepared in June 2003, which they argued superseded earlier reports. The respondents contended that the evidence contained irrelevant material and that the deponents were not qualified experts. The court had to decide whether the latest reports were admissible and whether the reliance on earlier reports was justified.

In addressing these issues, the court examined the content of the latest reports by Wilson and Rayner. Wilson's report involved a valuation of application software using a relief from royalty method and considered the mCom forecasts, which were projections prepared by DDS staff. Rayner's report, on the other hand, involved an analysis of a subscription option agreement. The court noted that the admissibility of their opinions depended on the proof of the facts contained in the forecasts and other assumptions. The court held that while the opinions of Wilson and Rayner were not yet inadmissible, their acceptance would require acceptable proof of the underlying facts. The court also observed that Temwell should further amend its statement of claim to provide particulars of the loss and damage claimed, excluding references to comments made by respondents during earlier hearings.

The court ordered the removal of earlier affidavits and exhibits from the file, granted Temwell leave to amend its statement of claim, and reserved the costs for later determination. The court's decision indicated that while the expert evidence was not outright inadmissible, its acceptance would depend on the proof of the facts on which the opinions were based. The court emphasised the need for clear evidence supporting the assumptions underlying the expert opinions. The final orders reflected these considerations, ensuring that the proceedings moved forward with a clear and amendable statement of claim and reserving costs for appropriate adjudication.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The affidavit of June Wilson sworn 26 July 2002 and each of the affidavits of Peter Rayner respectively sworn 31 July 2002 and 9 May 2003 and the several exhibits to the said affidavits of June Wilson and Peter Rayner be removed from the file.

2. The applicant have leave further to amend the further amended statement of claim by appending to paragraph 46 thereof particulars of loss and damage conforming with those set out in the further amended further and better particulars of loss and damage filed herein on 17 June 2003 but excluding paragraph (iii) thereof.

3. The respondents’ costs thrown away as a result of the orders made in paragraphs 1 and 2 hereof and the costs of all parties of and incidental to the hearings on 18, 19, 23 and 24 June 2003 be reserved.

Note: Settlement and entry of Orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Paragraph 46 of the third further amended statement of claim alleges;‘By reason of the matters aforesaid, the applicant has suffered loss and damage and will continue to suffer such loss and damage unless the conduct is restrained by this Honourable Court.’It is proposed that the particulars of loss and damage discussed below should be appended to the paragraph just quoted. Admissibility of expert evidence(a) Ms Wilson In the first half of May this year, submissions were addressed on behalf of the second and fifth to ninth respondents (“the mCom respondents”) to the admissibility of evidence of two witnesses claimed by Temwell to be experts. That evidence was contained in an affidavit by June Wilson sworn 26 July 2002 and two affidavits by Peter Rayner sworn respectively 31 July 2002 and 9 May 2003. For the mCom respondents it was contended that those affidavits contained irrelevant material or deposed to matters in respect of which the deponents had not been qualified as experts. After the mCom respondents had developed their arguments, Counsel for Temwell indicated, on 19 June 2003, that it no longer intended to rely on the affidavit of June Wilson sworn 26 July 2002. Instead, it was indicated, Temwell proposed to rely on a report prepared by Ms Wilson in June this year. Accordingly, I shall confine my consideration of the admissibility of Ms Wilson’s evidence to that report. On 15 May 2003, Temwell was given leave to file further affidavits which was exercised by the filing of an affidavit by Ms Wilson to which was exhibited her report of June 2003. By the same order of 15 May 2003, Temwell was directed to file and serve particulars of the loss and damage alleged in par 46 of its third further amended statement of claim. In her report of June 2003, Ms Wilson set out her understanding of the “background to the claim” and identified her role as being “to carry out a valuation of the Application Software as at 24 March 2002.” She claimed to have determined the fair market value of the software as at that date by applying a “relief from royalty” method. In summary, she arrived at a valuation within the range $9.6 million to $11.2 million, by taking into account the following components: In the latest version of her report, Ms Wilson relies heavily on what she calls “the mCom forecasts” which were contained in a six-page document marked “List Confidential” and dated 16 March 2000. Ms Wilson’s understanding of the provenance of that document and an indication of the use which she has made of it is set out in this passage from section 2.1 of her report;‘I have been instructed on 18 June 2003 that the mCom respondents in the proceeding have advised that the mCom forecasts were used by mCom in submissions to the ANZ Bank for financing for mCom, but that these forecasts were prepared by existing DDS staff and represent their assessment of the likely profits and cashflows over the two years following 16 March 2000. I am furthermore instructed that enquiry concerning the matter, following matters revealed by the mCom respondents on 18 June 2003, has indicated that Mr Robert van Zanten, the General Manager of DDS (who shortly after the 16 March 2000 became General Manager of mCom) was very likely the person who played the predominant role in the preparation of the mCom forecasts. I have prepared my report on the basis that the mCom forecasts represent an accurate and reasonable assessment of the matters contained therein. Should these instructions change, I will need to reconsider my opinion to have regard to the matters in the mCom forecasts which are said not to be accurate and reasonable.’

Decision

Reasons for decision

“The Investors” are defined in the identification of the parties to the TOOA as Sharsbury Pty Ltd and Sidstone Pty Ltd. As with the contention that Mr Rayner’s opinion has been invalidated in one respect by his disregard (on instructions) of the ANZ Acknowledgment, if, as a matter of construction, Temwell had no interest, either beneficially or as agent or trustee for others, in enforcing the Subscription Option, Mr Rayner’s analysis of that option will be irrelevant. However, I am not prepared to anticipate the answer to that question of construction by ruling that part of his evidence inadmissible.Conclusion For the reasons which I have endeavoured to explain, I have been unable to conclude at this stage of the proceedings that the opinion evidence of either Ms Wilson or Mr Rayner as contained in their several reports of June 2003, is inadmissible. It may be necessary to revisit that question in the course of the trial when a clearer appreciation can be made as to whether there is admissible evidence supporting the various assumptions on which those opinions are founded. As Heydon JA observed in Makitsu (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles (2001) 52 NSWLR 705 at 743 “so far as the opinion is based on ‘assumed’ or ‘accepted’ facts, they must be identified and proved in some other way.” As outlined above, acceptance of the opinions of Ms Wilson and Mr Rayner will depend on acceptable proof of the facts contained in the projections in the “mCom forecasts” of 16 March 2000 and the opinions expressed by Mr Goldstein and Prof. Goldschlager. It seems to be common ground that the opinions expressed earlier by Ms Wilson and Mr Rayner have been superseded by their latest reports prepared in June this year. I shall therefore order that the affidavits exhibiting those earlier reports be removed from the file. It also follows from the views expressed about proof of damage earlier in these reasons that Temwell should have leave further to amend its statement of claim to append to par 46 thereof the particulars of loss and damage reproduced at [18] above. However, as I indicated in the course of argument, I do not regard it as appropriate to furnish particulars of loss and damage by reference to “comments” made by Counsel for the respondents during earlier interlocutory hearings. The grant of leave shall therefore not extend to par (iii) of the proposed particulars of loss and damage. My provisional view is that the respondents should have their costs thrown away as a result of the substitution of the June 2003 reports of Ms Wilson and Mr Rayner for the earlier evidence of those witnesses. However, to permit full argument at an appropriate point, I shall order that the costs of all parties of the hearings on 18, 19, 23 and 24 June 2003 and the costs of the respondents thrown away as a result of the orders made this day be reserved.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established