TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS
WITH REASONS
Re:Trade mark application 750158 in the name of TELECOMMUNICATIONS INDUSTRY OMBUDSMAN LIMITED.
Background
Trade mark application number 750158 was filed on 2 December 1997 in the name of Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman Limited (the applicant). The applicant seeks to register the words telecommunications industry ombudsman as a trade mark in respect of the following services in class 42:
Services in class 42 being the reception of complaints and disputes regarding telecommunication services, the investigation of those complaints and disputes and the facilitation of their resolution.
Upon examination of the application, grounds for rejection were raised under section 41 of the Act on the basis that the mark directly describes the services for which registration is sought. The trade mark was said to be totally devoid of inherent adaptation to distinguish. The provisions of subsection 41(6) thus applied.
A further point was raised during examination concerning the nature of Ombudsman services and the function of the words telecommunications industry ombudsman as a trade mark. The point raised being that the applicant's mark did not appear to be a sign used in the course of trade and did not, therefore, fall within the definition of a trade mark prescribed by section 17 of the Act.
The Principal Examiner maintained the grounds for rejection and the applicant applied to be heard. The hearing took place before me in Melbourne on 3 June 1999. Mr Mark Goldblatt of Counsel represented the applicant on behalf of the applicant's attorneys, Corrs Chambers Westgarth.
Discussion
Section 17 - What is a trade mark?
The grounds for rejection raised under section 17 relate to the nature of Ombudsman services and the applicant's statutory rights under the TELECOMMUNICATIONS (CONSUMER PROTECTION AND SERVICE STANDARDS) ACT 1999 (Telecommunications Act). Ombudsman services are provided free to the public. On this basis, the Principal Examiner maintained that the applicant's mark was not used in the course of trade and, as such, the mark failed to fall within the definition of a trade mark (pursuant to section 17). The Principal Examiner also made the point that the applicant's monopoly in the services (via the Telecommunications Act) prevented competition and, as such, the mark could not serve to distinguish applicant's services from those of other traders.
Mr Goldblatt's submissions, on the whole, pertain to the applicant's rights under the Telecommunications Act. The relevant section of the Telecommunications Act provides that :
s128(3) To avoid doubt, there is only one Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman scheme, namely the scheme operated by Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman Limited (ACN 057 634 787).
The foremost requirement of section 17, Mr Goldblatt said, was that the applicant's sign distinguish its services. He submitted that the Telecommunications Act conferred upon the applicant exclusive rights to provide the designated services and, as such, the trade mark clearly distinguished the services of the applicant. He further submitted that, statutory rights aside, the mark distinguished the applicant from all other Ombudsmen who…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] ATMO 82
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the delegate were whether the proposed trade mark "telecommunications industry ombudsman" qualified as a trade mark under section 17 of the Act, and whether it was capable of distinguishing the applicant's services from those of other traders under section 41 of the Act. Specifically, the delegate had to determine if the applicant's services, provided free to the public but funded by industry members, constituted use "in the course of trade" for the purposes of section 17. Furthermore, the delegate had to assess whether the applicant's statutory monopoly, granted by the Telecommunications Act 1999, rendered the descriptive mark inherently adapted to distinguish the applicant's services, despite its descriptive nature.
The delegate reasoned that while the services were free to the public, the applicant's scheme was funded by its members (telecommunications carriers and service providers) based on complaint volumes. This funding mechanism, coupled with the applicant's obligation to its members, meant the services were dealt with or provided "in the course of trade" as defined by section 17, which allows for a broader interpretation than mere selling for value. Regarding section 41, the delegate considered the applicant's submission that its statutory monopoly under the Telecommunications Act precluded others from legitimately using the mark, thereby making it inherently adapted to distinguish. However, the delegate applied established case law, including *Michigan* and *Australian Airlines*, which hold that inherent adaptation depends on the intrinsic features of the mark itself and cannot be acquired or changed by use or other circumstances, such as statutory protection. The delegate concluded that the words "telecommunications industry ombudsman" directly describe the services and, absent the statutory protection, are not inherently adapted to distinguish them.
Consequently, the delegate found that the trade mark fell within the definition of a trade mark under section 17. However, the delegate determined that the mark was not inherently adapted to distinguish the application services, and therefore, the provisions of subsection 41(6) applied. As the applicant failed to meet the requirements of subsection 41(6), the application was rejected pursuant to subsection 41(2) of the Act.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.