Technological Resources Pty Limited v RGC Minerals Sands Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

OFFICIAL NOTICE

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Application  :          No. 678375 in the name of Technological Resources Pty Limited

Title:          Upgrading Titaniferous Materials

Action: Opposition under section 59 by RGC Minerals Sands Limited, final determination.

Decision:          Issued            .

Abstract

The amendments made to the specification by the applicant overcome the deficiencies identified in the decision of 2 August 1999.  That decision held that there was no disclosure of an acid leach in the absence of an alkaline leach in the first provisional specification.  The amendments have removed the possibility of an acid leach alone from the claims.  The claims have also been amended to define formation of a siliceous liquid phase, in conformity with the decision of 2 August 1999.  There was no finding in the decision of 2 August 1999 that the claims needed to specifically define removing silica impurity in the alkaline leaching step.

The definition of an acid leach subsequent to an alkaline leach in new claim 23 was encompassed by "an acidic and/or alkaline leach" in the claims as accepted.  This had already been considered to be fairly based on the first provisional specification in the original decision and was not open to reconsideration.

As the deficiencies in the decision of 2 August 1999 have been overcome, the claims as amended are now fairly based on provisional application PL4105 filed 14 August 1992.  This is before the priority date of the prior art information contained in Australian patent application 676682, which was found to be 16 December 1992.  Therefore all of the claims as now amended are novel.

Direction that the application be sealed after 30 days from the date of this decision.  If the Commissioner has been served with a notice of appeal before that time, direction that sealing not occur until the appeal has been decided or discontinued.

Costs relating to the final determination awarded against the opponent.

PATENTS ACT 1990

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Re:Patent Application No. 678375 by Technological Resources Pty Limited, and an opposition under section 59 of the Patents Act 1990 by RGC Mineral Sands Limited; final determination.

BACKGROUND

Technological Resources Pty Limited (Technological Resources) filed patent application 678375 (46915/93) on 12 August 1993.  Patent application 678375 is associated with provisional patent applications PL4105 filed 14 August 1992 and PL7193 filed 10 February 1993.

Patent application 678375 was advertised accepted on 29 May 1997.  RGC Mineral Sands Limited (RGC) filed a notice of opposition to the grant of a patent on the application on 27 August 1997.  I heard the parties in relation to the substantive opposition in Melbourne on 22-23 April 1999.  Following that hearing, in a decision dated 2 August 1999 (Technological Resources Pty Limited v RGC Mineral Sands Limited (1999) APO 29 (2 August 1999)), I found that claims 1 to 17, 19, and 23 to 26 lacked novelty in the light of Australian patent application 45513/93. This followed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Technological Resources Pty Limited v RGC Minerals Sands Lim... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] APO 45
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Technological Resources Pty Limited (Technological Resources) filed patent application 678375 on 12 August 1993, which was opposed by RGC Mineral Sands Limited (RGC). The dispute centered on the novelty and fair basis of Technological Resources' claims in light of prior art, specifically Australian patent application 45513/93. The opposition was initially heard on 22-23 April 1999, resulting in a decision that certain claims lacked novelty. Technological Resources subsequently filed amendments to overcome these deficiencies, leading to a final determination hearing on 2 May 2001. The key issues revolved around whether the amended claims were fairly based on the provisional application and whether they complied with the Patents Act 1990.

The court examined the amendments to determine if they addressed the deficiencies identified in the earlier decision. Technological Resources had replaced "liquid oxide phase" with "siliceous liquid phase" and made other modifications to the claims and description. RGC argued that the amendments did not sufficiently address the deficiencies and that the new claims were not fairly based on the provisional application. They also contended that the amended claims did not comply with Section 40 of the Patents Act 1990 and that the applicant had not complied with the earlier decision's findings.

The court found that the amendments successfully overcame the deficiencies identified in the earlier decision. The court clarified that there was no requirement for the claims to specifically define the removal of silicon impurity in the alkaline leaching step. The amended claims defined the formation of a siliceous liquid phase and the use of an alkaline leach, with or without an acid leach, aligning with the provisional specification. The new claim 23, specifying an acid leach followed by an alkaline leach, was found to be encompassed by the broader phrase "an acidic and/or alkaline leach" and was thus fairly based on the provisional application. The court concluded that the amended claims were now fairly based on the provisional application and that all claims were novel.

The court directed that the patent application be sealed after 30 days from the date of the decision, provided no appeal had been lodged. Costs relating to the final determination were awarded against the opponent.

Background

Background to the litigation

Technological Resources Pty Limited (Technological Resources) filed a patent application 678375 on 12 August 1993, associated with provisional applications PL4105 filed on 14 August 1992 and PL7193 filed on 10 February 1993. Patent application 678375 was advertised as accepted on 29 May 1997. Subsequently, RGC Mineral Sands Limited (RGC) filed a notice of opposition to the grant of a patent on 27 August 1997. After a hearing on 22-23 April 1999, the delegate of the Commissioner of Patents found in a decision dated 2 August 1999 that certain claims lacked novelty and were not fairly based on the provisional specification. Technological Resources was granted 60 days to amend the application to address the deficiencies. On 30 September 1999, Technological Resources requested leave to amend the patent application under section 104 of the Patents Act 1990. Iluka Midwest Limited (formerly RGC) initially opposed the amendments but later withdrew the opposition and requested to be heard in relation to the final determination of the opposition. The final determination hearing took place on 2 May 2001.

Patent application 678375 was advertised accepted on 29 May 1997. RGC filed a notice of opposition on 27 August 1997. The substantive opposition hearing was held on 22-23 April 1999, resulting in a decision on 2 August 1999 that certain claims were not novel and not fairly based on the provisional specification. Technological Resources requested leave to amend the patent application on 30 September 1999, and Iluka opposed these amendments. Iluka later withdrew its opposition to the amendments and requested to be heard on the final determination. The final determination hearing was held on 2 May 2001.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Are the amended claims fairly based on the provisional application PL4105?
2. Do the amended claims comply with Section 40 of the Patents Act 1990?
3. Has the applicant complied with the findings of the hearing officer in the decision dated 2 August 1999?
4. Should the application be refused, or should the applicant be directed to further amend the application pursuant to Section 107 of the Patents Act 1990?

Held
1. The amended claims are fairly based on the provisional application PL4105.
2. The amended claims comply with Section 40 of the Patents Act 1990.
3. The applicant has complied with the findings of the hearing officer in the decision dated 2 August 1999.
4. The application is directed to be sealed after 30 days from the date of this decision, unless an appeal is lodged within that time. Costs of the final determination hearing are awarded against the opponent.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the issue of whether the amended claims were fairly based on the provisional application PL4105. The court found that the amendments made to the specification by the applicant overcame the deficiencies identified in the earlier decision. Specifically, the court found that the claims had been amended to define the formation of a siliceous liquid phase, which aligned with the earlier decision's findings. Furthermore, the court held that the claims were fairly based on the provisional application because the deficiencies identified in the earlier decision had been addressed.

Next, the court examined whether the amended claims complied with Section 40 of the Patents Act 1990. The court found that the claims met the requirements of the statute and were not invalid for lack of fair basis. The court noted that the definition of an acid leach subsequent to an alkaline leach in new claim 23 was encompassed by "an acidic and/or alkaline leach" in the claims as accepted, which had already been considered to be fairly based on the first provisional specification and was not open to reconsideration.

In considering whether the applicant had complied with the findings of the hearing officer in the decision dated 2 August 1999, the court found that the applicant had addressed the deficiencies identified in that decision. The court determined that the applicant had overcome the grounds of invalidity upheld by the hearing officer and had made the necessary amendments to the specification to ensure that the claims were fairly based on the provisional application.

Finally, the court addressed the issue of whether the application should be refused or whether the applicant should be directed to further amend the application pursuant to Section 107 of the Patents Act 1990. The court found that the application was in a suitable form to proceed to sealing and directed that the application be sealed after 30 days from the date of this decision, unless an appeal was lodged within that time. The court also awarded costs of the final determination hearing against the opponent, as the applicant had been successful in the proceedings.