TCN Channel Nine Pty Ltd v Scotney, R.S

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

CORPORATIONS - directors' liability - "reasonable grounds to expect" - discussion of principles - whether expected immediate revenue flows can be taken into account in assessing liability under Corporations Law s 592(1) - whether proposed expansion of company activities of any weight - whether adverse publicity could reasonably have been expected - whether decision of WA Supreme Court on similar matter of any weight.

Corporations Law s 592

Re New World Alliance Pty Limited (Receiver and Manager Appointed); Sycotex Pty Limited v Baseler (No 2) (1994)
51 FCR 425.

Rema Industries and Services Pty Limited v Coad (1992)
107 ALR 374

Commonwealth Bank v Friedrich (1991) 5 ACSR 115

3M Australia Pty Limited v Kemish (1986) 10 ACLR 371

Sandell v Porter (1966) 115 CLR 666

Hawkins v Bank of China (1992) 26 NSWLR 562

Jingles Australia Pty Ltd v Francis Peter Ciantar & Anor (Steytler J, Supreme Court WA, No. 1622 of 1994, 25 October 1994, unreported)

TCN CHANNEL NINE PTY LIMITED (ACN 001 549 560) v
ROSLYN SHIRLEY SCOTNEY

No NG 3236 of 1993

Tamberlin J
Sydney
26 April 1995

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )                 
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY )    No.  NG 3236 of 1993             
GENERAL DIVISION                 )

BETWEEN:          TCN CHANNEL NINE PTY LIMITED
  (ACN 001 549 560)
  Applicant

AND:              ROSLYN SHIRLEY SCOTNEY
  Respondent

CORAM:       TAMBERLIN J
PLACE:       SYDNEY
DATED:       26 APRIL 1995
'

MINUTE OF ORDERS

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

  1. The application be dismissed.

  1. The applicant pay the costs of the respondent, with the exception of any costs awarded to the applicant in interlocutory proceedings.

NOTE:     Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in accordance with Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY )    No. NG 3236 of 1993              GENERAL DIVISION   )

BETWEEN:     TCN CHANNEL NINE PTY LIMITED
  (ACN 001 549 560)
  Applicant

AND:         ROSLYN SHIRLEY SCOTNEY
  Respondent

CORAM:       TAMBERLIN J
PLACE:       SYDNEY
DATED:       26 APRIL 1995     

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

The applicant TCN Channel Nine Pty Limited ("TCN") instituted proceedings seeking judgment against the respondent, Mrs Roslyn Shirley Scotney ("Scotney") pursuant to s 592(1) of the Corporations Law in the sum of $164,223 and interest, said to arise from advertising booked and screened in late April to early May 1991, relating to a tooth whitening product known as "Bright & Beautiful Cosmetic Dental Cream".

The applicant alleges that at the time the debts were incurred there were reasonable grounds to expect that the company, Bright & Beautiful Pty Limited ("the company") of which Scotney was a director would not be able to pay all its debts as and when they became due. In the alternative, it is claimed that immediately before the time the debt was incurred there were reasonable grounds to expect that, if the company incurred the debt, it would not be able to pay all its debts as and when they became due. These allegations reflect the two limbs…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read TCN Channel Nine Pty Ltd v Scotney, R.S and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1995] FCA 250
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved TCN Channel Nine Pty Limited seeking a judgment against Roslyn Shirley Scotney for debts incurred by Bright & Beautiful Pty Limited, a company for which Scotney was a director. The debts in question arose from advertising booked and screened in late April to early May 1991, relating to a tooth whitening product known as "Bright & Beautiful Cosmetic Dental Cream". The applicant alleged that at the time the debts were incurred, there were reasonable grounds to expect that the company would not be able to pay all its debts as and when they became due, in contravention of s 592(1) of the Corporations Law. The legal issues that the court needed to decide included whether expected immediate revenue flows can be taken into account in assessing liability under s 592(1), whether proposed expansion of company activities could reasonably have been expected, and whether adverse publicity could reasonably have been expected. The court held that the applicant had not proven on the balance of probabilities the necessary absence of reasonable grounds as required by s 592(1). The court found that there were reasonable grounds to expect that all the debts of the company would be paid as and when they fell due, whether with or without taking account of the debt raised on the relevant dates. The court dismissed the application with costs, with the exception of any costs awarded to the applicant in interlocutory proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

TCN Channel Nine Pty Limited instituted proceedings against Roslyn Shirley Scotney seeking judgment for $164,223 plus interest, claiming that Scotney, as a director of Bright & Beautiful Pty Limited, had contravened section 592(1) of the Corporations Law. The debts arose from advertising booked and screened by TCN in late April to early May 1991 for a tooth whitening product called "Bright & Beautiful Cosmetic Dental Cream". TCN alleged that there were reasonable grounds to expect that Bright & Beautiful Pty Limited would not be able to pay all its debts as and when they became due at the time the debts were incurred. Bright & Beautiful Pty Limited was placed into liquidation on 29 July 1991 with an estimated deficiency of $848,470. Scotney denied the allegations and relied on section 592(2) of the Corporations Law but did not provide evidence to support her defence.

The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, New South Wales District Registry, General Division. The matter came before the court as an application by TCN Channel Nine Pty Limited against Roslyn Shirley Scotney. The court was asked to determine whether Scotney, as a director of Bright & Beautiful Pty Limited, was liable for the debts under section 592(1) of the Corporations Law. The applicant presented evidence and arguments, while the respondent relied on documentary evidence. The court dismissed the application with costs, except for any costs awarded to the applicant in interlocutory proceedings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether there were reasonable grounds to expect that Bright & Beautiful Pty Limited would not be able to pay all its debts as and when they became due immediately before the time the debts were incurred.
2. Whether there were reasonable grounds to expect that, if Bright & Beautiful Pty Limited incurred the debts, it would not be able to pay all its debts as and when they became due.
3. Whether expected immediate revenue flows can be taken into account in assessing liability under Corporations Law s 592(1).
4. Whether proposed expansion of company activities can be taken into account in assessing liability under Corporations Law s 592(1).
5. Whether adverse publicity could reasonably have been expected.

Held
1. There were not reasonable grounds to expect that Bright & Beautiful Pty Limited would not be able to pay all its debts as and when they became due immediately before the time the debts were incurred.
2. There were not reasonable grounds to expect that, if Bright & Beautiful Pty Limited incurred the debts, it would not be able to pay all its debts as and when they became due.
3. Expected immediate revenue flows can be taken into account in assessing liability under Corporations Law s 592(1).
4. Proposed expansion of company activities cannot be taken into account in assessing liability under Corporations Law s 592(1).
5. Adverse publicity could reasonably have been expected.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by noting the objective nature of the test under Corporations Law s 592(1), which requires reasonable grounds to expect insolvency to exist without reference to the director's or manager's personal knowledge. The court examined the evidence to determine if there were reasonable grounds to expect insolvency at the time the debts were incurred. The applicant argued that there was a trading loss and the company was in financial free fall, but the court found that the immediate revenue flows from the advertising campaign were sufficient to reasonably expect the company would be able to meet its debts. The court accepted that the previous successful advertising experience justified an expectation of a 3:1 return on advertising costs. Although the company faced financial difficulties later, the court concluded that there were reasonable grounds to expect solvency on 24 April and 3 May 1991. The court also found that while proposed expansion activities were optimistic, they were too speculative to be considered. Lastly, the court acknowledged that adverse publicity could not have been reasonably expected, but this did not affect the conclusion on the existence of reasonable grounds to expect solvency at the relevant times.