Taylor v Santos Ltd & Ors No. Scgrg-96-2015 Judgment No. S430

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

TAYLOR V SANTOS LTD & ORS

[1999] SASC 430

  1. JUDGE BURLEY.    By application dated 18 May 1999 the plaintiff sought leave to administer interrogatories directed to the second, third and fourth defendants.  The application came on for hearing on 6 August 1999 when Mr Wells QC appeared for the plaintiff and Mr Gray QC appeared for the defendants.  I heard Mr Wells’ submissions in support of the application and Mr Gray’s submissions in opposition.  The application was then adjourned to 18 August 1999 to enable Mr Wells to put submissions in reply.  When the hearing resumed on 18 August 1999, Mr Wells sought an adjournment of the application for leave to interrogate because he wished to submit an amended set of proposed interrogatories.  The application for an adjournment was opposed.  Having heard the submissions of both counsel on the question of an adjournment I formed the view that, as a matter of fairness, the plaintiff should either pursue the application in relation to the proposed interrogatories then before the Court or withdraw the application.  On that basis I refused the application for an adjournment.  The plaintiff did not pursue the application for leave to interrogate (Document 126).  I then dismissed the application and awarded costs to the defendants.  The defendants sought costs on an indemnity basis. I reserved that question on the basis that I would hear submissions in that regard later that day.

  2. Submissions were unable to be completed on that day and so the application for costs on an indemnity basis was adjourned to 27 August 1999.  On that occasion I gave leave to the defendants to complete their submissions in reply by way of written submission.  I indicated to Mr Wells that if it were considered that the submissions in reply unjustifiably went beyond matters of reply, the matter could be brought on at the request of the plaintiff’s solicitor.  Written submissions in reply were received on 6 September 1999.

  3. On 15 September 1999 my secretary received a letter dated 14 September 1999 from the plaintiff’s solicitors seeking to have the matter re-listed so that the extent of the submissions in reply could be dealt with.  I refused to bring the matter on again because the plaintiff’s solicitors had taken more than a week to ask for the matter to be re-listed.  I considered that excessive in the circumstances given that this matter has had a past history of prolonged interlocutory proceedings.

  4. I mention that the letter dated 14 September 1999 from the plaintiff’s solicitors to my secretary referred to a direction from me that the parties seek an appointment on or before 17 September 1999.  It was said that that direction related to the question of bringing the matter on for the consideration of the extent of the defendants’ written submissions in reply.  Having re-read the transcript of what took place on 27 August 1999 I can only say that the plaintiff’s solicitors were mistaken in their interpretation of the directions I gave.  The direction related…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Taylor v Santos Ltd & Ors No. Scgrg-96-2015 Judgment No. S43... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] SASC 430
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, Taylor, filed an application seeking leave to administer interrogatories to the second, third, and fourth defendants in the case of Taylor v Santos Ltd & Ors. The defendants opposed the application, and the matter was heard before Judge Burley. The plaintiff sought an adjournment to submit amended interrogatories, which was refused. The plaintiff ultimately abandoned the application for leave to administer interrogatories. The defendants then sought indemnity costs for the costs incurred in opposing the application. The court examined the interrogatories and found them to be fundamentally flawed, with defects such as lack of context, assumptions of positive answers, and vagueness. Judge Burley considered the principles for awarding indemnity costs and concluded that the application for leave to administer interrogatories was doomed to failure due to the inadequacy of the interrogatories and the plaintiff's abandonment of the application.

The court awarded indemnity costs to the defendants for the costs incurred in opposing the application for leave to administer interrogatories. The decision was based on the fundamental flaws in the interrogatories, which rendered the application hopeless, and the plaintiff's strategic withdrawal of the application. The court found that any litigant properly advised would have realized that pursuing the application for leave to administer interrogatories carried a serious risk of refusal. The plaintiff's decision to abandon the application did not save them from an order for indemnity costs. The costs awarded by the court on the dismissal of the application would be taxed as between solicitor and own client, and the court would hear counsel regarding the costs of this application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established