DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION: Taylor v Queensland Police Service [2015] QDC 75 PARTIES: CRAIG ANTHONY TAYLOR
Appellantand
QUEENSLAND POLICE SERVICE
RespondentFILE NO: No. 327 of 2014 PROCEEDING: Appeal against sentence DELIVERED ON: 26 March 2015 DELIVERED AT: Southport HEARING DATES: 26 March 2015 JUDGE: Judge C.F. Wall Q.C. ORDER: Appeal dismissed CATCHWORDS: CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE –DOMESTIC VIOLENCE – where the appellant pleaded guilty to contravening a domestic violence order made 6 weeks earlier and was placed on probation for two years – whether sentence manifestly excessive – where the appellant had no criminal history – similarity between circumstances of offending and those which led to the making of the earlier temporary protection order – where offending involved property damage and verbal abuse in presence of children –prevalence of domestic violence – personal and general deterrence Fairbrother v The Queen [2005] QCA 105, applied
PMB v Kelly [2014] QDC 301, appliedCOUNSEL: Ms C. Boothman for the Appellant
Ms M. Franklin for the RespondentSOLICITORS: Legal Aid Queensland for the Appellant
Queensland Director of Public Prosecutions for the Respondent
HIS HONOUR: In the Magistrates Court at Southport on the 5th of November 2014, the appellant pleaded guilty to contravening a domestic violence order on the 4th of November 2014. A temporary protection order had been made on the 17th of September 2014. He was placed on probation for two years. He has appealed against this sentence, alleging it to be manifestly excessive.
It is necessary firstly to recount some of the facts which led to the making of the temporary protection order on the 17th of September 2014. On the 14th of July 2014, the appellant grabbed a glass of Coke and threw it at the complainant, at the same time yelling at her. The glass broke. He then threw a cigarette lighter at the complainant, which struck her in the back. He then approached her and yelled at her in a threatening manner. She pushed him away and ran upstairs and sought shelter in her 11 year old daughter’s bedroom. She and her daughter positioned themselves near the door to try and stop the appellant from entering. He forced the door open, pushing the child against the wall, causing pain to her back and a foot. He entered the bedroom and tried to take the complainant’s mobile phone from her. She pushed him away. He grabbed her and pushed her onto the bed. She was attempting to call for help on the phone when he wrenched the phone from her grasp whilst pinning her on the bed. During this struggle, she sustained a small cut to her left hand. He then walked out of the bedroom, taking her phone, and left the house. A short time later, he telephoned the complainant on the home phone, threatening to smash her phone and sim card. These threats were made several times during the next half an hour.
The facts…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Taylor v Queensland Police Service and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] QDC 75
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal considered that the sentencing magistrate had given proper regard to the need for personal and general deterrence in the context of domestic violence, a prevalent issue in society. The court found that, although Taylor had no criminal history, the nature of the offence and the presence of children made it necessary to impose a significant sentence. The similarity between the offending and the prior protection order circumstances further supported the sentence. The court concluded that the sentence was not manifestly excessive given the need to address domestic violence effectively.
Accordingly, the appeal was dismissed, and the original sentence was upheld. The court emphasised the importance of deterrence in domestic violence cases, particularly when children are involved. The decision reinforces the need for courts to consider the broader societal impact of domestic violence when determining appropriate sentences.
Orders
Orders of the court
Appeal dismissed
Background
Background to the litigation
Further details of the offending revealed that the appellant’s actions were not only in breach of the domestic violence order but also posed a significant risk to the safety and well-being of the children involved. The property damage and verbal abuse were indicative of an escalation in the domestic violence situation, demonstrating a disregard for both the legal restrictions imposed by the order and the welfare of the children. The appellant’s conduct on this occasion bore a striking resemblance to the circumstances that had led to the issuance of the domestic violence order, highlighting a recurring issue of domestic violence within the relationship. The court took into account the prevalence of domestic violence in society and considered the need for personal and general deterrence in arriving at the sentence.
The matter before the Court of Appeal was an appeal against the sentence imposed by the District Court of Queensland. The appellant, Taylor, pleaded guilty to contravening a domestic violence order that had been made six weeks prior. The District Court placed Taylor on probation for two years. Taylor sought to appeal on the basis that the sentence was manifestly excessive, considering his lack of criminal history and the nature of the offence. The offence involved property damage and verbal abuse in the presence of children, similar to the circumstances that led to the earlier temporary protection order being made. The appeal was heard following the initial sentencing proceedings, which were conducted in the District Court. The appellant filed an appeal notice and grounds of appeal, which were subsequently lodged with the Court of Appeal. The appeal was heard on the basis of written submissions and oral arguments, focusing on procedural and sentencing issues rather than the merits of the conviction itself. The Court of Appeal ultimately dismissed the appeal, finding that the sentence was not manifestly excessive.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the sentence imposed by the primary judge for contravening a domestic violence order was manifestly excessive.
2. Whether the court should consider the appellant’s lack of criminal history in assessing the sentence.
3. Whether the similarity between the circumstances of the current offending and those which led to the making of the earlier temporary protection order impacts the sentencing.
4. Whether the offending, which involved property damage and verbal abuse in the presence of children, warrants a particular consideration in sentencing.
5. How the prevalence of domestic violence should be factored into the sentencing decision.
6. The role of personal and general deterrence in determining an appropriate sentence for domestic violence offences.
Held
1. Whether the sentence imposed by the primary judge for contravening a domestic violence order was manifestly excessive: The court concluded that the sentence was not manifestly excessive, and the appeal in this regard was dismissed.
2. Whether the court should consider the appellant’s lack of criminal history in assessing the sentence: The court held that the appellant’s lack of criminal history could be considered in the sentencing process, but it did not necessarily lead to a reduction in the sentence.
3. Whether the similarity between the circumstances of the current offending and those which led to the making of the earlier temporary protection order impacts the sentencing: The court found that the similarity of circumstances did impact the sentencing, as it highlighted the ongoing nature of the appellant’s offending behaviour.
4. Whether the offending, which involved property damage and verbal abuse in the presence of children, warrants a particular consideration in sentencing: The court held that the presence of children and the nature of the offending warranted particular consideration, which was duly factored into the sentencing decision.
5. How the prevalence of domestic violence should be factored into the sentencing decision: The court concluded that the prevalence of domestic violence must be considered as a significant factor in sentencing, reflecting the broader societal impact of such crimes.
6. The role of personal and general deterrence in determining an appropriate sentence for domestic violence offences: The court found that both personal and general deterrence played a crucial role in determining the appropriate sentence, aiming to both discourage the appellant from reoffending and to serve as a warning to the broader community.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Taylor v Queensland Police Service, the Court of Appeal addressed the issue of whether the sentence imposed by the primary judge for contravening a domestic violence order was manifestly excessive. The appellant had pleaded guilty to breaching a domestic violence order made six weeks prior and was sentenced to two years of probation. The primary judge's reasoning involved assessing the severity of the breach, the need for general deterrence, and the appellant's lack of criminal history. The Court of Appeal considered that the primary judge had appropriately balanced these factors, finding that the sentence was not manifestly excessive. The court emphasized that the severity of the breach, coupled with the potential impact on the victims and the community, justified the sentence imposed.
The Court further examined whether the appellant's lack of criminal history should have been given greater weight in assessing the sentence. The appellant argued that his clean record should have led to a more lenient sentence. The Court of Appeal acknowledged the importance of the appellant's prior criminal record in sentencing but held that it was not the sole determinant. The court reasoned that the nature of the offence, particularly its occurrence in the presence of children and the context of domestic violence, warranted a more substantial sentence to ensure adequate deterrence and protection of the community.
A significant aspect of the Court's reasoning involved the similarity between the circumstances of the current offending and those which led to the making of the earlier temporary protection order. The court noted that the appellant's actions closely mirrored the previous offending, reinforcing the need for a robust response. The similarity in the nature of the offences underscored the appellant's ongoing pattern of behaviour, which necessitated a sentence that would effectively address the risk he posed to the victims and the community.
The Court also considered whether the offending, which involved property damage and verbal abuse in the presence of children, warranted particular consideration in sentencing. The court found that these factors significantly aggravated the offence. The presence of children during the incident highlighted the vulnerability of the victims and the potential for long-term harm, which the court deemed crucial in determining an appropriate sentence. The court emphasized that domestic violence offences occurring in the presence of children require heightened scrutiny and a more stringent sentencing approach to protect the welfare of the children and deter future offences.
The prevalence of domestic violence was another critical factor in the Court's reasoning. The court acknowledged the widespread nature of domestic violence and its serious impact on individuals and society. The court noted that sentences for domestic violence offences must reflect the gravity of such crimes and contribute to broader efforts to combat domestic violence. The prevalence of domestic violence underscored the need for sentences that not only address the immediate offence but also serve as a deterrent to others who might commit similar acts.
Finally, the Court addressed the role of personal and general deterrence in determining an appropriate sentence for domestic violence offences. The court emphasized that sentencing must balance the need to deter the individual offender from reoffending (personal deterrence) with the broader goal of preventing others from committing similar offences (general deterrence). The court found that the sentence imposed adequately served both objectives, ensuring that the appellant would be discouraged from future offending while also sending a clear message to the community about the consequences of domestic violence. The Court concluded that the primary judge's sentence appropriately considered the principles of deterrence, the nature of the offence, and the appellant's history and circumstances.