TAYLOR v POLICE No. SCGRG-98-27 Judgment No. S6540

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

TAYLOR V POLICE

Bleby J

In this matter the appellant was charged on summons with two offences under the Road Traffic Act as follows:

1. That on the 25th day of September 1997, at Hackham, she drove a vehicle on a road, namely Main South Road, within a speed zone at a greater speed than the speed fixed for that zone, and indicated by a sign erected, and which complied with the requirements under s50 of the Road Traffic Act.  The allegation was that the sign erected indicated a speed of 80 kph and the speed of the vehicle was about 152 kph. 

2.That on 25 September 1997, at Hackham, she drove a vehicle, namely a motor vehicle, on a road, namely Main South Road, at a speed which was dangerous to the public contrary to s46 of the Road Traffic Act 1961.

The appellant appeared in the Magistrates Court at Christies Beach on 17 December 1997.  She entered a plea of guilty to count two, whereupon count one was withdrawn.  The magistrate hearing the charge entered a conviction and imposed a fine of $600, with court fees of $73, a levy of $28 and prosecution cost of $16, making a total of $717.  He further disqualified the appellant from holding and obtaining a driver's licence for a period of 12 months commencing at 12.01 am on 1 January 1998.  The appeal is against that penalty imposed by the magistrate. 

The range of possible penalties for a first offence under s46 of the Road Traffic Act is a fine of not less than $300 and not more than $600, and subs(3) of s46 provides that where a court convicts a person for an offence under subs(1) the court in the case of a first offence must disqualify the person from holding or obtaining a driver's licence for not less than six months.

There is, however, a qualification on that in subs(3)(b), which reads as follows:

“The disqualification prescribed by para(a) cannot be reduced or mitigated in any way or be substituted by any other penalty or sentence unless in the case of a first offence the court is satisfied by evidence given on oath that the offence is trifling, in which case it may order a period of disqualification that is less than the prescribed minimum period, but not less than one month.”

I should add that the penalty for second and subsequent offence is a fine of not less than $300 or more than $600, with an alternative of imprisonment for not more than three months and a disqualification of not less than three years. 

The circumstances of the offence as disclosed to the magistrate, and here I refer to the affidavit of Neil Hodgson sworn in this matter, were that the appellant's vehicle was detected by a speed camera at 7.58 pm on 25 September 1997, on Main South Road at Hackham, doing 152 kph in an 80 kph zone. 

The appellant was spoken to by police…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read TAYLOR v POLICE No. SCGRG-98-27 Judgment No. S6540 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] SASC 6540
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Taylor v Police, the appellant was convicted of driving at a speed dangerous to the public in breach of the Road Traffic Act. The appellant appealed against the penalty imposed by the magistrate, arguing that the circumstances of the offence were such that the offence could be considered trifling, and that the penalty was therefore excessive. The appeal was allowed on the basis that the magistrate had failed to inform the appellant of the possibility of a lesser penalty if the offence was found to be trifling, and the need for sworn evidence to establish this. The Court proceeded to hear evidence and submissions on the trifling nature of the offence, and whether the penalty imposed was appropriate. The Court found that the offence was not trifling, but that the penalty imposed was excessive, particularly given the appellant's clean driving record and cooperation with the police. The Court imposed a fine of $400 and a six-month disqualification from driving, with the fine and costs to be paid in monthly instalments.

The Court emphasised the importance of ensuring that unrepresented litigants are fully informed of their rights and the consequences of their actions, and that the penalty imposed should be appropriate to the circumstances of the offence. The Court noted that while the appellant's actions were driven by a concern for her daughter's safety, they were nonetheless dangerous and irrational, and the potential for harm to others was high. The Court also noted the appellant's clean driving record and cooperation with the police as mitigating factors. The Court certified the matter as fit for senior counsel, and ordered the respondent to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established