Taylor Farms (Aust) Pty Ltd v A Calkos Pty Ltd & Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES SUPREME COURT

CITATION:        Taylor Farms (Aust) Pty Ltd v A Calkos Pty Ltd & Ors [1999]  NSWSC 186

CURRENT JURISDICTION:         Admin Law Division

FILE NUMBER(S):          30048/98

HEARING DATE{S):      11/02/99, 12/02/99

JUDGMENT DATE:        12/03/1999
 PARTIES:

Taylor Farms (Australia) Pty Limited (Pl)
A Calkos Pty Limited (1 Def)
Union International (NSW) Pty Limited (2 Def)
Commercial Tribunal of NSW (3 Def)

JUDGMENT OF:              Kirby J     

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:              Commercial Tribunal of NSW

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):         1089/97

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:      Deputy Chairman Hoeben

COUNSEL:
Ms E A Collins (Pl)
Dr R J Desiatnik (Defs)

SOLICITORS:
S Barton Adams & Co (Pl)
Astley Thompson & Valtas (1 Def)
Blake Dawson Waldron (2 Def)
Stephen H Montgomery (3 Def)

CATCHWORDS:
Jurisdiction of Commercial Tribunal re damages Fair Trading Act 1987, and defence of promissory estoppel
Application of Retail Leases Act 1994 to assignment of lease.

ACTS CITED:
Commercial Tribunal Act 1983
Fair Trading Act 1987
Retail Leases Act 1994
Law Reform (Law and Equity) 1972

DECISION:
See para 87

JUDGMENT:

THE SUPREME COURT

OF NEW SOUTH WALES
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW DIVISION

KIRBY J

Friday 12 March 1999

30048/98  -  TAYLOR FARMS (AUSTRALIA) PTY LIMITED  v  A CALKOS PTY LIMITED & ORS

JUDGMENT

  1. HIS HONOUR: This is an appeal against a decision of Deputy Chairman Hoeben of the Commercial Tribunal, given on 9 April 1998.  The Tribunal determined that it had no jurisdiction to entertain certain matters raised by the defendant (Taylor Farms (Australia) Pty Limited (“Taylor Farms”) in a document headed “Amended Cross Claim and Further Defence to Claim”.  The pleading was struck out.

  2. A Calkos Pty Limited (“Calkos”) is the owner of a shopping centre near Penrith, known as the Emerton Shopping Centre.  On 20 July 1994, Calkos executed a lease of shop 37 within that centre.  The lessee was Angliss (NSW) Pty Limited (“Angliss”).  The lease was for a period of five years, commencing on 1 May 1994.  It was scheduled to end, therefore, on 30 April 1999.

  3. Within a short time Angliss decided to assign its interest in the lease.  A substitute tenant, Taylor Farms, was found.  The consent of the owner was sought and given.  A Deed of Consent and Assignment of Lease was drawn up.  The recitals to the deed were as follows:

    “A.The Lessor is the registered proprietor of the land referred to in Item 4 of the schedule to this Deed.

    B.The Lessor has granted the Lease to the Assignor.

    C.The Assignor wishes to assign all its right, title and interest in the Lease and the Premises to the Assignee.

    D.The Lessor has consented to the assignment of the Lease to the Assignee in accordance with this Deed.”

  4. The Deed defined a number of terms.  Amongst the definitions provided, were the following:

    “1.1 ‘Lease’ means the lease of the Premises granted by the Lessor to the Assignor and being of the date referred to in item 5 of the schedule to this Deed;

    1.2‘Premises’ means the premises referred to in item 6 to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Taylor Farms (Aust) Pty Ltd v A Calkos Pty Ltd & Ors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] NSWSC 186
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Taylor Farms (Aust) Pty Ltd brought proceedings against A Calkos Pty Ltd and others in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The dispute concerned the jurisdiction of a commercial tribunal in relation to damages and the applicability of the Fair Trading Act 1987. Additionally, the case addressed the defence of promissory estoppel and the application of the Retail Leases Act 1994 to the assignment of a lease. The court had to determine whether the assignment constituted a new lease under the Retail Leases Act 1994 and if the assignee could claim rights under the amended Act.

The court needed to decide whether the assignment of the lease created a new lease under the Retail Leases Act 1994 and if the assignee could exercise rights granted by the amended legislation. It also needed to examine if the commercial tribunal had the authority to hear the claim for damages and whether the defence of promissory estoppel could be raised. The court was required to interpret the Retail Leases Act 1994 and consider relevant case law, including Dileum Pty Ltd v J K Corporation Pty Ltd (1988) 1 WAR 244 and Re Malsons Pty Ltd (1991) 2 Qd R 61.

The court ruled that the assignment of the lease did not create a new lease for the purposes of the Retail Leases Act 1994. The assignment merely transferred the remaining term of the original lease, and no new rights were created. The court found that the commercial tribunal had jurisdiction to hear the claim for damages, but the defence of promissory estoppel was not applicable in this case. The court's reasoning was based on the interpretation of the legislation and the relevant case law, which established that the assignment did not constitute a new lease. Therefore, the assignee could not claim rights under the amended Act.

The final orders of the court were that the commercial tribunal had jurisdiction to hear the claim for damages, and the defence of promissory estoppel was not applicable. The assignment of the lease did not create a new lease under the Retail Leases Act 1994, and the assignee could not exercise rights granted by the amended legislation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Dileum Pty Ltd v J K Corporation Pty Ltd (1988) 1 WAR 244, the Full Court of Western Australia construed the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreement Act 1985. A lease was granted which included an option. The lessee exercised the option. Thereafter there was a change to the Act. The lessee subsequently assigned the lease. The new lessee sought to exercise certain rights which were only available if the assignment could be regarded as a new lease for the purposes of the legislation. The court held (Wallace J dissenting) that it could not. Kennedy J said this: (at 256)“Counsel for the appellant argued that the assignment itself constitutes a lease for the purposes of the Act. The assignment in question amounted to a transfer or conveyance by the original tenant of the balance of a pre-existing term. The assignment itself did not create any new term. Nor did it contain any grant by the lessors to the appellant of any entitlement to occupy the premises. The assignment contained no covenant by the lessors in favour of the appellant to observe the terms of the lease. The lessors’ grant and the covenants made by them are only to be found in the lease. So far as the lessors were concerned, the assignment simply records their consent to the assignment, albeit the price of that consent was a number of covenants by the appellant directly in favour of the lessors, together with certain undertakings and an acknowledgment with respect to the existing liquor store licence. The estate in leasehold which was assigned to the appellant was not the lessors’ to grant to the appellant. That had already been granted to Gordon Matheson Pty Ltd.” Shortly thereafter, a similar issue came before the Queensland Supreme Court, Re Malsons Pty Ltd (1991) 2 Qd R 61 (Thomas J). In that case the lease was executed in 1987. The lessors were given the right to determine the lease, should they require the property for redevelopment, and to do so without payment of compensation. In October 1988 the lease was assigned. In the same year the Retail Shop Leases Act 1984 was amended. The amendments required a lessor, in certain circumstances, to compensate a lessee where the premises were required for demolition or redevelopment. In 1990 the owner gave the lessee notice that the premises were required for redevelopment. The lessee then sought a Declaration that it was entitled to compensation under the 1988 amendment. Thomas J said this: (at 65)“It is true that when the present lessee applied for assignment of the lease, and when the lessor decided to consent to assignment of it to the new lessee, the assignee was acquiring the bundle of rights contained in the old lease, which included cl 15.13. but the law at that time included the 1988 Act which engrafted a particular right in favour of the tenant in leases coming into existence from then on. It did not matter what the parties wrote into their leases in that respect, or what they might adopt from existing documents, the legislative provision would prevail. Upon the lessor’s consent to this assignment a new set of rights and obligations was created as between this lessor and this lessee.”