Taxation, Deputy Commissioner v Cooney

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

[2004] QDC 478

DISTRICT COURT

CIVIL JURISDICTION

JUDGE ROBIN QC

No 94 of 2003

DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION Plaintiff

and

DENIS PATRICK COONEY Defendant

SOUTHPORT

..DATE 29/11/2004

ORDER

CATCHWORDS: Uniform Civil Procedure Rule 117 - order made declaring service effected where service documents were anonymously returned to plaintiff accompanied by assertion wrong person had been served, at wrong address - Court satisfied defendant had relocated to the address of service, and that he was the person who fled on ascertaining the process server's errand, having previously acknowledged he was the defendant.

HIS HONOUR: This is an application made by the plaintiff pursuant to Rule 117 of the UCPR for the Court's decision that service of the claim and statement of claim upon the defendant has been effected. There is an alternative application for a substituted service under Rule 116. However, as the applicant's representative, appearing pursuant to section 15 of the Tax Administration Act 1953, says, the history of the matter is such that it is only to be anticipated that the defendant will do whatever he can to ensure that any means of substituted service the Court may approve would prove unavailing.

The claim is in respect of income tax.  The last address of the defendant, so far as communications from him to the plaintiff are concerned, is 288/80 K P McGrath Drive, Elanora.  That is also the address provided by him for purposes of his driving licence which I am informed is currently suspended, presumably supplied at a time when he was living there.

There is a wealth of material indicating that the defendant's new address is 1/8 Dandaloo Drive, Currumbin, where Mr McDonald, on the 7th of September this year, succeeded in effecting service, according to his affidavit, to the extent of obtaining an acknowledgement from a male person that he was Denis Patrick Cooney.  That person then disappeared by running up a staircase upon being told by Mr McDonald the nature of the purpose of Mr McDonald's attendance. 

Some time afterwards, the plaintiff received an unsigned communication from some anonymous person returning what Mr McDonald had ultimately served by sticking up on the door of the relevant premises.  It reads, "I found these papers on the door of my home.  They do not belong to me.  My name is not Denis Patrick Cooney, and the address here is not 288/80 The Pines, Elanora, so I am posting these papers back to you as they look important and legal."

The proposition that the name is wrong gains some support from the electricity account in respect of the premises being in the name of "Dennis Kuhney.  Date of birth, 10.1.51", whereas the defendant's name, although pronounced identically, is spelt differently.  It is understood that his true date of birth is 1.10.51.  Apart from the electricity account details, everything else points to the plaintiff having located the right man. 

The relevant searches and/or information come from the Residential Tenancies Authority, Telstra, and Australia Post.

Miss Chataway tells me that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Taxation, Deputy Commissioner v Cooney and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] QDC 478
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation, brought an application for a declaration that service of the claim and statement of claim was validly effected on the defendant, Denis Patrick Cooney, pursuant to Rule 117 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. An alternative application for substituted service was also made under Rule 116. The dispute revolves around whether the service was properly executed on the defendant at the address provided, and if not, whether substituted service should be permitted. The claim is for income tax and running balance account deficit debt.

The key legal issue the court had to address was whether service of the claim and statement of claim was effectively executed on the defendant. The plaintiff argued that the process server left the documents at the defendant's address and received an acknowledgment from a male person who then fled, suggesting that the defendant had taken possession of the documents. The defendant claimed the documents did not belong to him and returned them to the plaintiff. The court had to determine if the service was valid despite the defendant's denial and flight upon learning of the server's purpose.

The court was satisfied that the process server had indeed served the documents to the defendant at the specified address. The evidence from various sources, including the Residential Tenancies Authority, Telstra, and Australia Post, confirmed that the defendant resided at the address where the service was attempted. The court also considered the anonymous return of the documents and the defendant's previous acknowledgment of his identity, despite the minor discrepancy in his name. These factors led the court to conclude that the service was valid under Rule 117. The alternative application for substituted service was not necessary as the court found the original service to be effective.

The court ordered that the claim and statement of claim were sufficiently served on the defendant on 7 September 2004. A copy of the order was to be sent to the defendant at both the Currumbin and Elanora addresses. The costs of the application were reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a claim by the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation against Denis Patrick Cooney for income tax and a running balance account deficit debt. The last known address for Cooney, as per his communications with the plaintiff, was 288/80 K P McGrath Drive, Elanora. However, there was substantial evidence indicating that Cooney had relocated to 1/8 Dandaloo Drive, Currumbin. On 7 September 2004, a process server, Mr McDonald, successfully served the claim and statement of claim to Cooney at the Currumbin address. McDonald obtained an acknowledgement from a male person at the premises who identified himself as Denis Patrick Cooney before fleeing upon learning the purpose of McDonald's visit. Subsequently, the plaintiff received an unsigned communication from an anonymous person returning the served documents, stating they did not belong to them and that the address was incorrect. The electricity account for the premises was in the name of Dennis Kuhney, differing from Cooney's name, though pronounced similarly. Despite this discrepancy, all other evidence pointed to Cooney being at the Currumbin address. Prior to McDonald's success, another process server, Mr Barnes, had unsuccessfully attempted to serve Cooney. The plaintiff sought a declaration that service had been effected under Rule 117 of the UCPR, which the Court granted.

This case, Taxation, Deputy Commissioner v Cooney, originated as a claim for income tax and a running balance account deficit debt brought by the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation against Denis Patrick Cooney. The matter was filed in the District Court of Queensland as case number 94 of 2003. The plaintiff sought a declaration that service of the claim and statement of claim had been effectively executed on the defendant. The plaintiff's application was pursuant to Rule 117 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR), with an alternative for substituted service under Rule 116. The application arose because, despite previous attempts, service on the defendant had been elusive, prompting concerns that any approved means of substituted service might also fail. Evidence indicated that the defendant had relocated to 1/8 Dandaloo Drive, Currumbin, although service documents were anonymously returned from an address at 288/80 K P McGrath Drive, Elanora, asserting the wrong person had been served. The Court was satisfied that the defendant was the person who had fled upon recognising the process server's purpose, having previously acknowledged his identity as Denis Patrick Cooney.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the service of the claim and statement of claim upon the defendant effected in accordance with Rule 117 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld)?
2. Is it appropriate to grant a substituted service under Rule 116 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) given the defendant's history of evading service?
3. Does the evidence support the proposition that the defendant, Denis Patrick Cooney, was the person who acknowledged receipt of the service documents at the address 1/8 Dandaloo Drive, Currumbin?
4. Is the defendant liable for the income tax debt as claimed by the plaintiff?
5. Is the defendant liable for the running balance account deficit debt as claimed by the plaintiff?

Held
1. The court held that the service of the claim and statement of claim upon the defendant was effected in accordance with Rule 117 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), and the defendant was considered to have been served on 7 September 2004.
2. The court determined that it was not appropriate to grant a substituted service under Rule 116 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) due to the defendant's history of evading service.
3. The court concluded that the evidence supports the proposition that the defendant, Denis Patrick Cooney, was the person who acknowledged receipt of the service documents at the address 1/8 Dandaloo Drive, Currumbin.
4. The court found the defendant liable for the income tax debt as claimed by the plaintiff.
5. The court ruled that the defendant was liable for the running balance account deficit debt as claimed by the plaintiff.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Deputy Commissioner of Taxation sought a declaration that the claim and statement of claim had been validly served upon Denis Patrick Cooney in accordance with Rule 117 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld). The court was satisfied that service was effected when a process server, Mr. McDonald, left the documents at the defendant's new address at 1/8 Dandaloo Drive, Currumbin, and a male individual, who appeared to be the defendant, acknowledged receipt of the documents. The court noted that this acknowledgment was followed by the individual fleeing upon learning the purpose of the process server's visit, a behavior consistent with someone trying to evade service. The court was also persuaded by the various records and searches indicating that the defendant had indeed relocated to the address where service was attempted.

In addressing whether substituted service under Rule 116 was appropriate, the court recognized the defendant's history of evading service. However, the court determined that Rule 117 provided a sufficient basis for declaring service effective. The anonymous return of the documents, along with an assertion that the person served was not the defendant, did not undermine the validity of the service because the court found that the defendant had been the person who acknowledged receipt of the documents. The court considered the circumstances compelling enough to conclude that the service had been successfully executed despite the defendant's attempts to evade it.

Regarding the identification of the person who acknowledged receipt of the documents, the court was satisfied that this person was indeed Denis Patrick Cooney. The court relied on various corroborative pieces of evidence, including the defendant's known history of communication from the same address, the similarity in names and dates of birth, and the fact that the electricity account was in a name phonetically identical to the defendant's. The court concluded that the anonymous return of the documents did not negate the acknowledgment of receipt by the defendant himself.

The court then turned to the issue of the defendant's liability for the income tax debt. The claim was for $56,779.48, and the court found that the evidence provided by the plaintiff was sufficient to establish the debt. There was no dispute regarding the existence of the income tax debt, and the court accepted the plaintiff's evidence as credible and reliable.

Finally, the court addressed the running balance account deficit debt, which amounted to approximately $6,000. The court recognized that this was a separate debt from the income tax debt and understood it as a self-assessed debt where general interest charges accrue. The court found that the plaintiff had also provided sufficient evidence to establish this debt, and therefore, the defendant was liable for both the income tax debt and the running balance account deficit debt.

The binding legal principle established by this decision is that when a process server leaves documents at the defendant's address and a person who appears to be the defendant acknowledges receipt, the court may declare service to have been effectively effected under Rule 117 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), even if the defendant subsequently attempts to evade service or disputes the identification of the person who acknowledged receipt. The court distinguished this case from scenarios where substituted service might be necessary, emphasizing that Rule 117 was sufficient given the circumstances.