Tate v Westpac Banking Corporation (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Tate v Westpac Banking Corporation (No 2) [2020] FCA 1374

File number: VID 145 of 2019
Judgment of: MIDDLETON J
Date of judgment: 22 September 2020
Date of publication of reasons: 25 September 2020
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – representative proceedings – approval of discontinuance of claims against the respondent – whether proposed discontinuance is fair and reasonable – discontinuance approved
Legislation:

National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Adams v Navra Group Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 1157

AUB19 v Commonwealth of Australia [2019] FCA 1722

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Westpac Banking Corporation [2020] FCAFC 111

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Westpac Banking Corporation (Liability Trial) [2019] FCA 1244

Davaria Pty Ltd v 7-Eleven Stores Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 1234

Hodges v Waters (No 4) [2014] FCA 472

Laine v Thiess Pty Ltd; Beetson v SunWater Ltd [2016] VSC 689

Mercedes Holdings Pty Limited v Waters (No 1) [2010] FCA 124

Simonetta v Spotless Group Holdings Limited [2017] FCA 1071

Sister Marie Brigid Arthur (Litigation Representative) v Northern Territory of Australia (No 2) [2020] FCA 215

Wotton v State of Queensland [2009] FCA 758

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Regulator and Consumer Protection
Number of paragraphs: 46
Date of hearing: 22 September 2020
Counsel for the Applicants: Jeremy Stoljar SC and Paul Batley
Solicitor for the Applicants: Maurice Blackburn
Counsel for the Respondent: Jeremy Kirk SC and Derek Wong
Solicitor for the Respondent: King & Wood Mallesons

ORDERS

VID 145 of 2019
BETWEEN:

IAN JOHN TATE

First Applicant

MICHELLE MARY TATE

Second Applicant

AND:

WESTPAC BANKING CORPORATION ACN 007 457 141

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

MIDDLETON J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 SEPTEMBER 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The discontinuance of this proceeding be approved pursuant to s 33V(1) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act).

2.Subject to order 1, by consent between the applicants and respondent, the proceeding be discontinued.

3.Pursuant to ss 37AF and 37AG(1)(a) of the Act, in order to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, the contents of:

a.the annexure marked “Confidential Annexure BJS-1” to the affidavit of Ben Slade filed on 31 August 2020; and

b.the confidential affidavit of Ben Slade affirmed on 21 September 2020 and the annexures marked “Confidential Annexure BJS-5” and “Confidential Annexure BJS-6”,

be kept confidential and not be disclosed to any person without leave of the Court.

4.If orders 1 and 2 above are made, by consent:

a.leave be given for the respondent to discontinue the cross claim filed by the respondent on 27 March 2020 (cross claim) with no order as to costs;

b.pursuant to Rule 1.31 and 1.34 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), the requirement under Rule 26.12(1) be dispensed with in respect of the Notice of Discontinuance for the cross claim;

c.the balance of the amount held by the Court as security for costs…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tate v Westpac Banking Corporation (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1374
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Tate v Westpac Banking Corporation (No 2), the applicants sought approval to discontinue the claims against Westpac under section 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The applicants had filed their statement of claim on 21 May 2019, and the proceeding shared some commonality with the Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Westpac Banking Corporation proceeding. The applicants amended their statement of claim on 18 October 2019, following the judgment in the ASIC Proceeding. However, the applicants accepted the Offer to Compromise on 27 July 2020, and the Full Court of the Federal Court handed down the ASIC Appeal judgment on 25 February 2020. The applicants’ funding ceased, and they considered whether to continue the proceeding without funding. The court was required to decide whether the proposed discontinuance was fair and reasonable.

The court considered the matters set out in the applicants’ submissions and Mr Slade’s evidence and found that the proposed discontinuance was fair and reasonable. The court noted that the discontinuance sought did not contemplate the release or extinguishment of any of the rights of group members. The court also noted that there was no suggestion that, and no basis upon which, group members could be liable for any costs of the proceedings. The court accepted that it would be contrary to the interests of group members to require the applicants to persist with the litigation when they had lost their funding. The court also noted that the respondent had consented to a proposed declaration to the effect that the discontinuance of the proceedings does not affect any rights of the applicants or any group member in the proceeding to pursue the claims that are the subject of this proceeding in another proceeding.

The court approved the discontinuance of the proceeding pursuant to section 33V(1) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The court also made orders to keep certain contents of annexures confidential, to vacate certain costs orders, and to release the balance of the amount held by the Court as security for costs of the proceedings. The court declared that the discontinuance of the proceeding did not affect any rights of the applicants or any group member in the proceeding to pursue the claims that are the subject of this proceeding in another proceeding. The court made no order as to costs of this application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The discontinuance of this proceeding be approved pursuant to s 33V(1) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act).

2. Subject to order 1, by consent between the applicants and respondent, the proceeding be discontinued.

3. Pursuant to ss 37AF and 37AG(1)(a) of the Act, in order to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, the contents of:

a. the annexure marked “Confidential Annexure BJS-1” to the affidavit of Ben Slade filed on 31 August 2020; and

b. the confidential affidavit of Ben Slade affirmed on 21 September 2020 and the annexures marked “Confidential Annexure BJS-5” and “Confidential Annexure BJS-6”,

be kept confidential and not be disclosed to any person without leave of the Court.

4. If orders 1 and 2 above are made, by consent:

a. leave be given for the respondent to discontinue the cross claim filed by the respondent on 27 March 2020 (cross claim) with no order as to costs;

b. pursuant to Rule 1.31 and 1.34 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), the requirement under Rule 26.12(1) be dispensed with in respect of the Notice of Discontinuance for the cross claim;

c. the balance of the amount held by the Court as security for costs of the proceedings paid by Harbour Fund IV, L.P on 5 December 2019, be released to the applicants;

d. all costs orders previously made in the proceeding be vacated, except for order 2 of the orders made by Justice Perram on 24 August 2020, that the applicants pay the respondent's costs of the proceeding, fixed in the amount of $250,000;

e. the Court notes that payment of $250,000 to the respondent pursuant to order 2 of the orders made by Justice Perram on 24 August 2020 has been satisfied by the applicant; and

f. subject to order 2 of the orders made by Justice Perram on 24 August 2020, each party pay his, her or its own costs of the proceeding.

5. No order as to costs of this application.

6. Order 8 of the orders made by Justice Middleton on 28 August 2020 be vacated.

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

7. Orders 1 and 2 do not affect any rights of the applicants or any group member in the proceeding to pursue the claims that are the subject of this proceeding in another proceeding.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For these reasons that follow, I consider it appropriate to approve the discontinuance in respect of the claims made against Westpac, and to make ancillary orders in connection with that discontinuance. BACKGROUND The applicants filed their statement of claim in this proceeding on 21 May 2019. Between 6 and 14 May 2019, Perram J heard the trial in Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Westpac Banking Corporation NSD 293 of 2017 (the ‘ASIC Proceeding’). The ASIC Proceeding and the current proceeding make claims against Westpac that share some commonality because the Australian Securities and Investment Commission (‘ASIC’) also alleged that Westpac breached its responsible lending obligations under the NCCPA in a number of ways. On 13 August 2019, Perram J published his decision in the ASIC Proceeding (see Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Westpac Banking Corporation (Liability Trial) [2019] FCA 1244 (the ‘ASIC Proceeding judgment’)). His Honour found that ASIC had failed to make out its claims against Westpac. On 10 September 2019, ASIC filed an appeal against the ASIC Proceeding judgment. On 18 October 2019, and in light of the ASIC Proceeding judgment, the applicants filed an amended statement of claim (the ‘ASOC’) in the current proceeding. The ASOC included a number of further allegations against Westpac. At the time of filing the ASOC, Westpac’s treatment of consumers’ living expenses in its assessment of home loan applications was a key issue in both the ASIC Proceeding and the current proceeding. However, there was a number of substantive and procedural distinctions between the two proceedings, including that:(1)the ASIC Proceeding was commenced by ASIC in its regulatory capacity, while the applicants commenced the current proceeding under Pt IVA of the FCA Act on behalf of themselves and group members;(2)the allegations in each proceeding were unique. In particular, the ASOC in the current proceeding contained allegations that Westpac contravened its obligations under sections:(a)130(1) of the NCCPA to make reasonable inquiries about the consumer’s requirements, objectives and financial situation, and to take reasonable steps to verify the consumer’s financial situation. The ASIC Proceeding contained no such allegations; and(b)131(4) and 133(4) of the NCCPA to assess the suitability of the credit contracts only on information comprising the consumer’s financial situation, requirements or objectives that it knew, or reasonably believed, to be true. The ASIC Proceeding contained no such allegations;(3)the ASIC Proceeding and the current proceeding claimed different types of relief. On 11 February 2020, the applicants filed a further ASOC (the ‘FASOC’) in the current proceeding. The FASOC contained a number of further amendments, including the deletion of allegations that Westpac breached its statutory duty pursuant to s 47 of the NCCPA and the claim for exemplary damages. On 25 February 2020, the Full Court of the Federal Court heard the appeal in the ASIC Proceeding (the ‘ASIC Proceeding Appeal’).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 27 July 2020, the applicants accepted the Offer to Compromise.ASIC Appeal judgment and ASIC’s decision not to appeal After the Full Court handed down the ASIC Appeal judgment, Mr Slade’s evidence is that he formed the view that:(1)the reasons of the majority in the Full Court (Gleeson and Lee JJ) significantly reduced the applicants’ and group members’ prospects of success in the current proceeding;(2)the reasons of the minority (Middleton J) in the Full Court were consistent with the applicants’ case in the current proceeding; and(3)if ASIC was to successfully seek special leave to appeal to the High Court and the High Court adopted an approach consistent with that of the minority, this would improve the applicants’ and group members’ prospects of success in the current proceeding. Following ASIC’s decision not to appeal, Mr Slade says he came to the view that the applicants’ and group members’ prospects of success in the current proceeding was adversely impacted by the ASIC Appeal judgment.Discontinuance and funding position The ASIC Proceeding judgment and the ASIC Appeal judgment have reduced the applicants’ prospects in the current proceedings. Following the ASIC Appeal judgment and in light of ASIC’s decision not to appeal, the Funder notified the applicants of its intention to cease funding the current proceeding. In these circumstances, Mr Slade says he considered whether another third party litigation funder could fund the proceeding, or alternatively whether Maurice Blackburn could continue to prosecute the proceeding without funding from a third party litigation funder. Mr Slade’s evidence is that he reached the view that another third party litigation funder would not agree to fund the current proceeding (in the event that the applicants did not accept the Offer to Compromise). If Maurice Blackburn were to continue to pursue the current proceeding on behalf of the applicants and other group members without third party funding, Mr Slade says the applicants would be exposed to the risk of adverse costs orders which would be significant and disproportionate to the applicants’ potential interests in the proceeding. Mr Slade also considered whether or not Maurice Blackburn should fund the current proceedings, including whether to offer an indemnity to the applicants against adverse costs. In order to pursue either or both of the options raised in the preceding paragraphs where there is no funding from a third party, Mr Slade says he would be required to make a submission to Maurice Blackburn’s Investment Committee, recommending that Maurice Blackburn enter into a conditional fee arrangement with the applicants or that Maurice Blackburn offer to indemnify the applicants against adverse costs. Mr Slade formed the view that the ASIC Appeal judgment so negatively impacts the applicants’ prospects of success in the current proceeding that he would not make either of these recommendations to the Investment Committee.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

However, the preferred approach in this Court has been that of Perram J, which I consider is sound in principle having regard to the principles upon which s 33V is based. CONSIDERATION Taking account of the matters set out in the applicants’ submissions, and the matters set out in Mr Slade’s evidence, I am satisfied that the proposed discontinuance is fair and reasonable having regard to the interests of all class members. I note the following matters upon which I have based my decision:(1)The discontinuance sought does not contemplate the release or extinguishment of any of the rights of group members. On the contrary, all such rights are preserved.(2)There is no suggestion that, and no basis upon which, group members could be liable for any costs of the proceedings. In substance, upon the discontinuance of the proceedings group members will be in the same position they were in before 21 February 2019, when these proceedings commenced.(3)The applicants are not aware of any looming limitation problem should any group member wish to privately pursue the respondent on the claims pleaded. Rather, by reason of s 33ZE(1) of the FCA Act group members have had the benefit of a suspension of any relevant limitation periods since the commencement of these proceedings. (4)That suspension would come to an end upon an order approving the discontinuance of these proceedings by reason of s 33ZE(2) of the FCA Act. However, by reason of s 33ZE, whatever time for commencing proceedings was available to a group member as at 21 February 2019 will be the time available to that group member from the date of discontinuance. On one view this has given group members wishing to commence their own proceedings an “extended” limitations period of some 18 months. On any view, the group member has been restored to the position he or she was in immediately prior to 21 February 2019.(5)It would be contrary to the interests of group members to require the applicants to persist with the litigation when they have lost their funding, since that could give rise to the proceedings being continued in a less than optimum way, which could result in a resolution of common issues in a manner that is binding upon, but not favourable to, group members.(6)The respondent has consented to a proposed declaration to the effect that the discontinuance of the proceedings does not affect any rights of the applicants or any group member in the proceeding to pursue the claims that are the subject of this proceeding in another proceeding. A declaration to such effect has been made in other applications for discontinuance: Simonetta at [29] (Yates J); Wotton at [36] and [39] (Rares J); AUB19 at [25] (Mortimer J). As noted in Simonetta, such a declaration has utility in that “group members are not left in any doubt that any rights they might have against the respondent are left intact and are not affected by the discontinuance that is approved”: at [29] (Yates J). I accept that it is impracticable for the applicants to continue to prosecute the proceeding in the absence of funding and in the face of what seems to be, on Mr Slade’s evidence, the unlikelihood of alternative funding being obtained. Although the current proceeding has been on foot since 2019, the parties have not substantively advanced beyond the close of pleadings. Taking account of the issues at stake, were the proceeding to continue there can be little doubt (particular in light of the ASIC Appeal judgment and ASIC’s decision not to appeal) that they would be complex, hard fought, and consequently expensive.