[2006] TASSC 21
CITATION: Tasmania v Drake [2006] TASSC 21
PARTIES: TASMANIA
v
DRAKE, Colin William
TITLE OF COURT: SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
JURISDICTION: CRIMINAL
FILE NO/S: 41/2006
DELIVERED ON: 6 April 2006
DELIVERED AT: Burnie
HEARING DATE: 6 April 2006
JUDGMENT OF: Evans J
CATCHWORDS:
Criminal Law – Jurisdiction, practice and procedure – Accused unfit to plead or incapable during trial – Other matters – Accused's fitness to stand trial need not be determined by a jury.
Criminal Justice (Mental Impairment) Act1999 (Tas), ss 12, 19.
State of Tasmania v Bosworth [2005] TASSC 29, referred to.
Aust Dig Criminal Law [733]
REPRESENTATION:
Counsel:
Appellant: P Jones
Respondent: T Jago
Solicitors:
Appellant: Director of Public Prosecutions
Respondent: Legal Aid Commission of Tasmania
Judgment Number: [2006] TASSC 21
Number of paragraphs: 7
Serial No 21/2006
File No 41/2006
TASMANIA v COLIN WILLIAM DRAKE
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT EVANS J
6 April 2006
The defendant, Colin William Drake, has been indicted on three counts of unlawfully setting fire to vegetation. The prosecutor and the defendant, by his counsel, agree that the defendant is not fit to stand trial. Pursuant to the Criminal Justice (Mental Impairment) Act 1999 ("the Act"), s38, in the circumstances of the defendant, his counsel may act, in the exercise of an independent discretion, in what she genuinely believes to be the defendant's best interests.
It is accordingly necessary to investigate the defendant's fitness to stand trial. As to such an investigation, the Act contains two apparently contradictory provisions. They are:
"12 (1) In the case of proceedings in the Supreme Court, the question whether a defendant is fit to stand trial must be determined by a jury."
and
"19 A court may, if the prosecutor and defendant agree, dispense with or terminate an investigation into the defendant's fitness to stand trial and –
(a) record a finding that the defendant is unfit to stand trial; or
(b) proceed under section 13 as if, after the investigation, the court had made a finding that the defendant is not unfit to stand trial."
The conflict is between the requirement in s12(1) that in the Supreme Court, the question whether a defendant is fit to stand trial must be determined by a jury, and the authority that s19 provides for the determination of that question by a court where the prosecutor and the defendant agree. Section 19 does not envisage any role for a jury in a court's dispensation with, or termination of, an investigation into a defendant's fitness to stand trial and the recording of a finding that a defendant is unfit or not unfit to stand trial. How is this apparent conflict to be resolved?
I conclude that s12(1) should be read subject to s19. Accordingly, where counsel are in agreement, this Court may, without involving a jury, dispense with, or terminate, an investigation into a defendant's fitness to stand trial and record a finding on that issue. If it is found that the defendant is unfit to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Tasmania v Drake and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] TASSC 21
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the legislative framework governing the assessment of a defendant's fitness to stand trial. It found that under the Tasmanian Criminal Procedure Act, the determination of an accused's fitness to plead was a matter for the court, not a jury. This conclusion was based on statutory provisions that explicitly assigned the responsibility of assessing fitness to the judge rather than leaving it to a jury. The court held that the legislative intent was clear in delegating this task to the judiciary, thereby rejecting the argument that a jury should be involved in the process.
The Supreme Court of Tasmania ruled that the fitness of the accused to stand trial need not be determined by a jury. Instead, the court held the authority to make such a determination based on the evidence and legal standards provided. The court's decision affirmed the statutory provisions and reinforced the distinction between the roles of the judiciary and the jury in criminal proceedings. The ruling ensured that the process for assessing an accused's fitness to stand trial remained within the purview of the court.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi