Tarzia v National Australia Bank Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA   )
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY           )          No. NN 1622 of 1996
BANKRUPTCY DIVISION  )

Between:FRANCESCO TARZIA and

MARIA ROSA TARZIA

Debtors/Applicants

And:NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LTD

Creditor/Respondents

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

EINFELD J   SYDNEY   24 DECEMBER 1996

On 28 May 1996, the National Australia Bank Limited (the bank) issued a bankruptcy notice (the notice) against Francesco and Maria Rosa Tarzia (the debtors) requiring the payment, within 21 days of the service of the notice, of the sum of $238,646.78.  This sum was alleged to be the amount of a judgment given by the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory on 25 November 1994 plus interest to 24 May 1996.  The notice was served on each of the debtors on 19 September 1996, so that the time for compliance expired on 10 October 1996.

On 27 June 1996 the applicants filed an application to have the bankruptcy notice set aside and to have the time for compliance extended pending the hearing of the application.  On 10 September 1996 a Deputy Registrar dismissed the application to set aside with some costs.  After some discussions at the Sydney registry of the Court concerning those orders of the Deputy Registrar, the solicitors for the debtors, who practised in Canberra, faxed to the Sydney registry of the Court and the bank's solicitors, on 27 September 1996 what purported to be a handwritten "application" for review of the Deputy Registrar's orders on the ground of an overstatement of interest in the bankruptcy notice.  Although this application was rejected as incorrectly formulated, the debtors' solicitors also faxed to the bank's solicitors on the same day a handwritten notice under section 41(5) of the Bankruptcy Act disputing the validity of the amount due.

An application dated 3 October 1996 in accordance with Form 45 was sent to the Sydney registry via the document exchange seeking an order of review of the Deputy Registrar's order of 10 September 1996, an order setting aside the bankruptcy notice and an extension of the time for compliance with the notice.  This application was returned by the Court because the application for an order of review was out of time, the time for filing having expired on 1 October 1996 or 21 days after the original order had been made.  On 9 October 1996, an amended application was despatched to the Court seeking in addition an extension of time for the filing of the application.  This document was filed on 11 October 1996, one day after the time for compliance with the bankruptcy notice had expired.  An affidavit of the debtors' solicitor dated 3 October 1996 was filed in support of the application but it provided no evidence at all to support any of the orders sought in the amended application.

On 26 November 1996, I extended the time for filing the application for review but that application and the application to set aside the bankruptcy notice were  dismissed with some costs.  The application for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tarzia v National Australia Bank Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1996] FCA 1155
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Tarzia v National Australia Bank Ltd involved Francesco and Maria Rosa Tarzia, who were debtors, against National Australia Bank Limited, the creditor. The dispute centred around a bankruptcy notice issued by the bank against the debtors, demanding the payment of a substantial sum within a specified period. The debtors sought to have the bankruptcy notice set aside and to extend the compliance period, arguing that the amount claimed was overstated. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining the validity of the bankruptcy notice, the debtors' application to set it aside, and the application to extend the compliance period.

The court had to decide several legal issues, including whether the debtors' application to set aside the bankruptcy notice was filed within the prescribed timeframe and whether the court had jurisdiction to extend the time for compliance with the bankruptcy notice once the compliance period had expired. Additionally, the court needed to assess whether the debtors had instituted proceedings to set aside the underlying judgment bona fide and with due diligence, as required by the Bankruptcy Act.

The court found that while there was jurisdiction to extend the time for compliance with a bankruptcy notice if certain conditions were met, the debtors had not met the condition of filing their application to set aside the bankruptcy notice within the compliance period. Consequently, the court concluded that it did not have the jurisdiction to grant the extension of time. The court dismissed the application to extend time for compliance with the bankruptcy notice, and the application to set aside the bankruptcy notice was also dismissed. The debtors were ordered to pay the costs of the proceedings.

In summary, the Federal Court of Australia determined that the debtors' application to extend the time for compliance with the bankruptcy notice was beyond the jurisdiction of the court because the application to set aside the notice was not filed within the compliance period. The court dismissed both the application to extend time and the application to set aside the bankruptcy notice, and ordered the debtors to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

The National Australia Bank Limited issued a bankruptcy notice against Francesco and Maria Rosa Tarzia on 28 May 1996, demanding payment of $238,646.78 plus interest by 10 October 1996. The debtors filed an application to set aside the bankruptcy notice on 27 June 1996, which was dismissed on 10 September 1996. The debtors' solicitors attempted to appeal the decision via a faxed handwritten notice on 27 September 1996, which was rejected for being incorrectly formulated. A formal application for review of the order was sent on 3 October 1996 but was returned due to being filed out of time. An amended application was then filed on 11 October 1996, one day after the compliance time had expired. Despite this, the court extended the time for filing the application for review on 26 November 1996, but the application to set aside the bankruptcy notice and the application for an extension of time were dismissed. The judgment in this case pertains to the application to extend time after its expiry.

The procedural history of this matter began with the debtors filing an application to set aside the bankruptcy notice on 27 June 1996, which was dismissed by a Deputy Registrar on 10 September 1996. Following this, the debtors attempted to appeal the decision via a faxed handwritten notice on 27 September 1996, which was rejected for being incorrectly formulated. A formal application for review of the Deputy Registrar's order was sent on 3 October 1996, but it was returned by the court because it was out of time. An amended application was filed on 11 October 1996, seeking an order of review, an order setting aside the bankruptcy notice, and an extension of the time for compliance. The application for review and the application to set aside the bankruptcy notice were dismissed on 26 November 1996, and the application for an extension of time was adjourned part heard for written submissions. The judgment in this case pertains to the application to extend time after its expiry.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the court have jurisdiction to extend the time for compliance with a bankruptcy notice after the time for compliance has expired?
2. Was the application for an extension of time for compliance filed within the prescribed time limit?
3. Did the court have the authority to dismiss the application for an extension of time for compliance based on the lack of evidence provided in the affidavit of the debtors' solicitor?

Held
1. The court concluded that it had jurisdiction to extend the time for compliance with a bankruptcy notice after the time for compliance had expired, subject to certain conditions being met.
2. The application for an extension of time for compliance was not filed within the prescribed time limit.
3. The court had the authority to dismiss the application for an extension of time for compliance based on the lack of evidence provided in the affidavit of the debtors' solicitor.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court held that the jurisdiction to extend the time for compliance with a bankruptcy notice, despite the time for compliance having expired, derives from subsections (6A), (6B) and (6C) of section 41 of the Bankruptcy Act. This power is contingent upon the debtor instituting proceedings to set aside the judgment or order in respect of which the bankruptcy notice was issued or filing an application to set aside the bankruptcy notice within the time for compliance fixed by the notice. The court noted that in this case, the application to set aside the bankruptcy notice was not made within the required timeframe, thus the court could not exercise its power to extend the time for compliance. The court further held that it was within its authority to dismiss the application for an extension of time for compliance due to the lack of evidence provided in the affidavit of the debtors' solicitor. The court relied on its earlier decision in Re Howarth ex parte Mortgage Acceptance Nominees Limited [1993] 43 FCR 587, where it had extensively considered the power of the court to extend time for compliance with a bankruptcy notice. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the court can extend the time for compliance with a bankruptcy notice if certain conditions are met, but if those conditions are not met, the application is beyond the jurisdiction and power of the court to grant.