Tarkine National Coalition Inc v Schaap

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

[2014] TASSC 66

COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA

CITATION:                 Tarkine National Coalition Inc v Schaap [2014] TASSC 66

PARTIES:  TARKINE NATIONAL COALITION INC
  v
  SCHAAP, Alex,

DIRECTOR, ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION AUTHORITY

ATTORNEY-GENERAL, The Hon Dr Vanessa Goodwin

FILE NO:  665/2014
DELIVERED ON:  17 December 2014
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATES:  11, 12 December 2014
JUDGMENT OF:  Estcourt J

CATCHWORDS:

Administrative Law – Judicial Review – Reviewable decisions and conduct – Decisions under an enactment – Particular cases – Director of Environmental Protection Authority – Decision [not] to issue Environment Protection Notice.

Judicial Review Act2000 (Tas), s 17(2).
Aus Dig Administrative Law [1013]

Environment and Planning – Environmental planning – Development control – Consents, approvals and permits – Modification – Generally – Whether development authorised by permit fundamentally changed by Environment Protection Notice.

Environmental Management and Pollution Control Act 1994 (Tas), ss 3(2), 44(10).
Land Use Planning and Approvals Act 1993 (Tas), s 3(1).
Moto Projects (No 2) Pty Ltd v North Sydney Council [1999] NSWLEC 280, considered.

Aus Dig Environment and Planning [240]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
             Applicant:  J Gobbo QC and J Forsyth
             Respondent:  M E O'Farrell SC and J Rudolf
Solicitors:
             Applicant:  Environmental Defenders Office (Tas) Inc
             Respondent:  Acting Director of Public Prosecutions

Judgment Number:  [2014] TASSC 66
Number of paragraphs:  72

Serial No 66/2014

File No 665/2014

TARKINE NATIONAL COALITION INC v ALEX SCHAAP, DIRECTOR, ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION AUTHORITY and ATTORNEY-GENERAL,
THE HON DR VANESSA GOODWIN

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  ESTCOURT J

17 December 2014

  1. The Tarkine National Coalition Inc has applied for orders pursuant to s 17 of the Judicial Review Act 2000 (the JR Act) setting aside as invalid an Environment Protection Notice No 8977/1 (the EPN) issued by the Director of the Environment Protection Authority (the Director) pursuant to s 44 of the Environmental Management and Pollution Control Act 1994 (the EMPC Act).

  2. The following summary of the rather complex factual background to the application is based (gratefully) upon the outline set out in the applicant's written submissions. Except where I have indicated otherwise I am satisfied that the facts and matters summarised are made out on the documents provided to me by the parties in the Court Books.

  3. In or about early December 2011, Shree Minerals Limited (Shree) lodged an application with the Circular Head Council (the Council) for a development approval for the Nelson Bay River Magnetite Mine (the Mine). In summary, the application was for the development and use of a new magnetite and hematite open cut mine and processing activities. The proposal was described in a Development Proposal and Environmental Management Plan (the DPEMP), which was submitted to the Council with the application.

  4. The proposal was defined as a level 2 activity under Sch 2, s (2)(e), of the EMPC Act, being "Mineral Works: the conduct of works for processing mineral ores, sands or earths processing 1,000 tonnes or more per year of raw materials".

  5. Section 25(1) of the EMPC Act required the Council to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tarkine National Coalition Inc v Schaap and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] TASSC 66
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Tarkine National Coalition Inc brought an application for judicial review against the Director of the Environmental Protection Authority, questioning the decision not to issue an Environment Protection Notice in relation to a proposed mine in the Tarkine region of Tasmania. The primary concern was the management of potentially acid-forming (PAF) waste rock, which had the potential to leach harmful substances into the environment. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The court was required to determine whether the Director's decision not to issue an Environment Protection Notice was legally sound. The key issues centred on whether the Environmental Protection Authority had correctly assessed the risks associated with the storage of PAF material and the adequacy of the proposed management strategies. Specifically, the court examined whether the EPA's findings regarding the volume of PAF material, the viability of the storage strategies, and the potential environmental impacts were reasonable and lawful.

The Federal Court found that the Environmental Protection Authority had properly exercised its discretion in assessing the risks and had correctly concluded that there was no need for an Environment Protection Notice. The court highlighted that the EPA had identified several critical issues, including the volume of PAF material, the limited space for storage on the mine site, and the necessity of permanent underwater storage for PAF material. The court also noted that the EPA had considered the proponent's commitment to not store PAF material elsewhere without Director approval. The court was satisfied that the EPA's decision not to issue an Environment Protection Notice was based on a reasonable assessment of the risks and was in accordance with the law.

The court dismissed the application for judicial review, affirming the Director's decision. The Federal Court found that the Environmental Protection Authority had appropriately exercised its discretion in determining that there was no need for an Environment Protection Notice given the risks associated with the storage of PAF material and the adequacy of the proposed management strategies.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Relevant findings of the EPA Board were:a)The key issues for assessment were the inter-related ones of acid and dissolved metal levels in drainage from various sources both during mine operations and, particularly, post-closure, all of which are influenced by the volume of PAF material to be excavated. (Emphasis added.)b)The EPA Division had concerns about the preconditions that would need to be met for the PAF material isolation strategy in the DPEMP to be viable, including that "there is very little spare space on the mine site, … to say nothing of the other issues arising from long-term above-ground storage of PAF". c)To manage the risk of acid mine drainage during the operation of the mine and into the long-term, post-closure, all PAF material must be stored in the DSO Pit, since this appears to be the only secure, long-term storage option. Permit condition OP2 as originally imposed by the EPA Board reflected that requirement. (Emphasis added.) d)Permanent underwater storage was the only acceptable solution for PAF material which has to remain on the site indefinitely. e)The volume of waste rock that would need to be treated as PAF might be substantially higher than the estimate in the DPEMP. f)It was likely that the project would run out of PAF material storage volume in the DSO Pit before mining of the Main Pit was completed, and that mining was to cease once the storage space in the DSO Pit was exhausted. g)The proponent had stated that it was supportive of a permit condition which did not allow storage of PAF material elsewhere (either above the ultimate flood level of the DSO pit or elsewhere on the site), unless approval from the Director was given. The proposed permit condition (OP2-1) does not provide Directorial discretion to approve storage of PAF material elsewhere than in the DSO Pit as it was considered unlikely that an appropriate alternative strategy was available or feasible. (Emphasis added.) On or about 26 July 2012, the EPA Board issued "Permit Part B Permit Conditions – Environmental No 8568" (the original Part B Permit Conditions). Of relevance to the present application are the definitions of DSO Pit and conditions G1, G4, G7, CN5 and OP2 of the original Part B Permit Conditions. The original Part B Permit Conditions also contain a list of "commitments". Of relevance to the application is commitment 38. The original Part B Permit Conditions were included in planning permit DA 2011/00171 granted by Council on 16 August 2012, alternatively 8 February 2013 (the original Permit). On 12 April 2013, the original Permit was corrected (the Permit). The subject of the correction is not directly relevant to the present application. Of relevance to the application are conditions 1 and 10 of the Permit. On or about 14 October 2013, the Director received the PAF Materials Separation & Verification Plan (version 4) (10 October 2013) (the PAF Materials Separation & Verification Plan). The PAF Materials Separation & Verification Plan showed a significant change in the quantity of PAF material expected to come out of the DSO Pit, revising the quantity of PAF waste rock from the DSO Pit from less than 14,000 m3 to 230,000 m3.