Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Summary available
Medium Neutral Citation: Tanious v South Eastern Sydney Local Health District [2015] NSWCA 356 Hearing dates: 16 November 2015 Decision date: 19 November 2015 Before: Basten JA, Meagher JA, Ward JA Decision: (1) Allow the appeal from the judgment of 9 October 2014 and set aside the orders made by Price J.
(2) In place thereof:
(a) set aside the orders of Harrison AsJ made on 12 February 2014 dismissing the proceedings with costs and in place thereof order that:
(i) the amended statement of claim filed on 26 November 2013 be struck out;
(ii) subject to the requirements specified in (iii) below, the plaintiff may file and serve a notice of motion in the Common Law Division, no later than 30 April 2016, seeking leave to file and serve a further amended statement of claim;
(iii) the notice of motion referred to in (ii) above shall be accompanied by a proposed further amended statement of claim which:(A) may name as defendants only South Eastern Sydney Local Health District and (if thought necessary) Dr Chris Dedousis;
(B) shall be accompanied by a report or reports by one or more experts (not being the plaintiff) qualified to express an opinion as to:(1) any allegation as to a breach of duty by the defendants in the treatment and care of the plaintiff’s late father;
(2) any harm caused to the plaintiff’s late father by the alleged breach of duty;
(3) any harm suffered by the plaintiff by the alleged breach of duty; and,
(4) the causal connection between any harm suffered by the plaintiff and any breach of duty to his father;(b) in the event that a notice of motion seeking leave to amend and purportedly complying with the conditions set out above is not filed and served within the time specified, the proceedings will stand dismissed;
(3) The appellant’s costs in this Court as an unrepresented litigant be his costs in the proceedings.
(c) the costs of the hearing before Harrison AsJ be costs in the proceedings;
(d) the costs of the plaintiff’s review motion before Price J be costs in the proceedings.Catchwords: APPEAL – amended notice of appeal filed pursuant to grant of leave to appeal – self-represented appellant – the form of the notice of appeal irregular – notice of motion to strike out the amended notice of appeal – whether motion should be granted
NEGLIGENCE – proceedings brought by son alleging harm suffered as a result of a negligent medical treatment of his father – elements of secondary or derivative claim – Lane v Northern NSW Local Health District (No 3) [2014] NSWCA 233; [2015] Aust Torts Reports 82-194 referred to
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – negligence proceedings – amended statement of claim struck out and proceedings summarily dismissed – decision upheld on review – amended statement of claim properly stuck out – whether proceedings properly dismissed – whether plaintiff should have been given…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Tanious v South Eastern Sydney Local Health District and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] NSWCA 356
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether the amended statement of claim had been properly struck out and whether the proceedings had been correctly dismissed. A key issue was whether the plaintiff should have been afforded an opportunity to replead his case, and if so, whether he was capable of articulating an available cause of action, particularly in light of the principles governing secondary or derivative claims in negligence, as discussed in cases such as *Lane v Northern NSW Local Health District (No 3)*.
The Court reasoned that while the amended statement of claim was indeed properly struck out, the plaintiff should be given a limited opportunity to replead. This decision was based on the principle that a plaintiff should generally be allowed to articulate a viable cause of action if one can be formulated. The Court outlined specific conditions for any further amendment, requiring expert reports to substantiate allegations of breach of duty, harm to the father, harm to the plaintiff, and the causal connection between these elements.
Consequently, the Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the orders dismissing the proceedings. It ordered that the amended statement of claim be struck out but granted the plaintiff leave to seek further amendment, subject to strict conditions regarding the content and accompanying expert evidence. If these conditions were not met by a specified date, the proceedings would stand dismissed. The costs of the earlier hearings were to be costs in the proceedings, and the appellant's costs in the Court of Appeal were also to be costs in the proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) Allow the appeal from the judgment of 9 October 2014 and set aside the orders made by Price J.
(2) In place thereof:
(a) set aside the orders of Harrison AsJ made on 12 February 2014 dismissing the proceedings with costs and in place thereof order that:
(i) the amended statement of claim filed on 26 November 2013 be struck out;
(ii) subject to the requirements specified in (iii) below, the plaintiff may file and serve a notice of motion in the Common Law Division, no later than 30 April 2016, seeking leave to file and serve a further amended statement of claim;
(iii) the notice of motion referred to in (ii) above shall be accompanied by a proposed further amended statement of claim which:
(A) may name as defendants only South Eastern Sydney Local Health District and (if thought necessary) Dr Chris Dedousis;
(B) shall be accompanied by a report or reports by one or more experts (not being the plaintiff) qualified to express an opinion as to:
(1) any allegation as to a breach of duty by the defendants in the treatment and care of the plaintiff’s late father;
(2) any harm caused to the plaintiff’s late father by the alleged breach of duty;
(3) any harm suffered by the plaintiff by the alleged breach of duty; and,
(4) the causal connection between any harm suffered by the plaintiff and any breach of duty to his father;
(b) in the event that a notice of motion seeking leave to amend and purportedly complying with the conditions set out above is not filed and served within the time specified, the proceedings will stand dismissed;
(c) the costs of the hearing before Harrison AsJ be costs in the proceedings;
(d) the costs of the plaintiff’s review motion before Price J be costs in the proceedings.
(3) The appellant’s costs in this Court as an unrepresented litigant be his costs in the proceedings.
Background
Background to the litigation
The appellant's amended statement of claim was struck out as it failed to articulate a proper cause of action. In addition to the failure to specify a viable cause of action, the claim was deemed to be without merit as it did not meet the elements of a secondary or derivative claim as outlined in Lane v Northern NSW Local Health District (No 3) [2014] NSWCA 233; [2015] Aust Torts Reports 82-194. This decision was made despite the appellant's attempts to argue that he should have been given an opportunity to replead and that there were other reasons to refuse leave to replead. The court found that the appellant's amended statement of claim was properly struck out, and the dismissal of the proceedings was justified.
Following the dismissal, the appellant sought a review of the decision by Price J. However, the review was unsuccessful, leading the appellant to file an amended notice of appeal. The respondent subsequently filed a notice of motion to strike out the amended notice of appeal due to irregularities in its form. The appeal process continued with the appellant, as an unrepresented litigant, navigating the complexities of the procedural aspects of the case. The case's focus remains on the factual events leading to the legal dispute, particularly the medical treatment of the appellant's late father and the subsequent claim for harm.
The matter in Tanious v South Eastern Sydney Local Health District originated as a claim in negligence brought by the son of the deceased, alleging that harm was suffered as a result of the negligent medical treatment of his father. The initial statement of claim was struck out by Harrison AsJ on 12 February 2014, and the proceedings were dismissed with costs. This decision was subsequently reviewed by Price J on 9 October 2014, who upheld the dismissal. The plaintiff, self-represented and proceeding pro se, filed an amended notice of appeal after being granted leave to appeal. The form of the notice of appeal was irregular, leading to a notice of motion to strike out the amended notice of appeal. The primary issue before the court was whether the motion to strike out the amended notice of appeal should be granted, among other procedural matters related to the ability of the plaintiff to articulate an available cause of action and the appropriate procedural steps to be taken.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the amended notice of appeal filed by the self-represented appellant was irregular and whether the notice of motion to strike it out should be granted.
2. What are the elements of a secondary or derivative claim in negligence proceedings, particularly in the context of Lane v Northern NSW Local Health District (No 3)?
3. Whether the amended statement of claim was properly struck out and the proceedings were properly dismissed.
4. Whether the plaintiff should have been given an opportunity to replead the amended statement of claim.
5. Whether the plaintiff was able to articulate an available cause of action in the proceedings.
6. Whether there were other reasons to refuse the plaintiff's leave to replead the amended statement of claim.
Held
1. Whether the amended notice of appeal filed by the self-represented appellant was irregular and whether the notice of motion to strike it out should be granted. The court concluded that the amended notice of appeal was irregular but decided not to strike it out because the appellant was self-represented and the irregularity did not significantly prejudice the respondent.
2. What are the elements of a secondary or derivative claim in negligence proceedings, particularly in the context of Lane v Northern NSW Local Health District (No 3). The court outlined that a secondary or derivative claim requires the plaintiff to establish a duty of care owed to the primary victim, a breach of that duty, harm to the primary victim, and a causal connection between the harm and the breach.
3. Whether the amended statement of claim was properly struck out and the proceedings were properly dismissed. The court held that the amended statement of claim was properly struck out but found that the proceedings were not properly dismissed as the plaintiff should have been given an opportunity to replead.
4. Whether the plaintiff should have been given an opportunity to replead the amended statement of claim. The court concluded that the plaintiff should have been given an opportunity to replead the amended statement of claim, as the dismissal of the proceedings without this opportunity was improper.
5. Whether the plaintiff was able to articulate an available cause of action in the proceedings. The court found that the plaintiff was able to articulate an available cause of action, subject to the conditions set out in the orders of the court.
6. Whether there were other reasons to refuse the plaintiff's leave to replead the amended statement of claim. The court determined that there were no other reasons to refuse the plaintiff's leave to replead, provided the conditions in the orders were met.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined whether the amended notice of appeal filed by the self-represented appellant was irregular and whether the notice of motion to strike it out should be granted. The court noted that the amended notice of appeal was indeed irregular as it did not comply with the procedural requirements outlined in the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW). Despite this irregularity, the court considered the broader context of the appellant being self-represented and exercising his right to appeal. The court held that while procedural irregularities are generally significant, they could be overlooked in cases where a party is self-represented to ensure fairness. Therefore, the court decided not to strike out the amended notice of appeal, allowing the appeal to proceed.
The court then addressed the elements of a secondary or derivative claim in negligence proceedings, particularly in the context of Lane v Northern NSW Local Health District (No 3). The court referred to the principles established in Lane, which outline that for a secondary claim to succeed, the plaintiff must establish a causal link between the harm suffered by the primary victim (the father in this case) and the subsequent harm suffered by the plaintiff. The court underscored that the plaintiff must demonstrate that the harm to the father was caused by the defendant's breach of duty, and that this harm, in turn, caused the plaintiff’s own harm. This principle was pivotal in evaluating the viability of the amended statement of claim.
Next, the court considered whether the amended statement of claim was properly struck out and the proceedings were properly dismissed. The court upheld the decision of Harrison AsJ to strike out the amended statement of claim, finding that the plaintiff had not adequately articulated a causal link between the harm suffered by the father and the subsequent harm to the plaintiff. The court also noted that the plaintiff failed to provide expert evidence to support the necessary causal connections. Given these deficiencies, the court concluded that the amended statement of claim was properly struck out.
The court further deliberated whether the plaintiff should have been given an opportunity to replead the amended statement of claim. The court reasoned that while there is a general principle to afford litigants the opportunity to rectify deficiencies in their pleadings, this must be balanced against the need for finality in litigation. The court found that the plaintiff had multiple opportunities to amend the statement of claim and had not provided sufficient grounds to warrant another chance. Thus, the court held that the dismissal of the proceedings was appropriate.
Regarding whether the plaintiff was able to articulate an available cause of action, the court found that the plaintiff had not demonstrated the necessary causal link required for a secondary claim. The absence of expert evidence and the failure to sufficiently establish the required connections meant that the plaintiff could not articulate a viable cause of action. The court emphasized that without such evidence, the plaintiff's claims remained speculative and insufficient to proceed.
Lastly, the court explored whether there were other reasons to refuse the plaintiff's leave to replead the amended statement of claim. The court noted the extensive history of the case, the multiple opportunities already given to the plaintiff to amend the pleadings, and the absence of any new evidence or arguments that would warrant another amendment. The court concluded that the primary reason to refuse leave to replead was the lack of a viable causal link, and there were no additional factors that would support granting leave to amend further.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this decision is that while procedural irregularities may be overlooked in the context of self-represented litigants, the substantive requirements of a secondary claim in negligence proceedings must be strictly adhered to. The plaintiff must provide clear evidence of a causal link between the harm to the primary victim and the subsequent harm to the plaintiff. Additionally, where a plaintiff has had multiple opportunities to amend their pleadings without success, the court may properly dismiss the proceedings to ensure finality.