Tamworth Building Supplies Pty Ltd v Begovic

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read
WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR
CITATION: Tamworth Building Supplies Pty Ltd v Begovic [2008] NSWWCCPD 77
APPELLANT: Tamworth Building Supplies Pty Ltd
RESPONDENT: John Begovic
INSURER: QBE Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited
FILE NUMBER: WCC8841-07
DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION: 5 March 2008
DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: 24 July 2008
SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Weekly payments; section 40 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987; weekly amount which the worker is earning or would be able to earn; onus of proof of earnings.
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: Acting Deputy President Anthony Candy
HEARING: On the papers.
REPRESENTATION: Appellant: QBE In-House Legal
Respondent: Everingham Solomons, Solicitors
ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:

The decision of the Arbitrator dated 5 March 2008 is revoked and the matter is remitted to another Arbitrator for determination afresh in accordance with these reasons.

Each party is to pay his or its own costs of the appeal.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

  1. John Begovic (‘the worker’) was a truck driver employed by Tamworth Building Supplies Pty Ltd (‘the employer’) who injured his back and right shoulder in the course of his employment on 20 June 2002 while delivering material to a building site when he slipped on plastic sheeting.  Although he reported the injury he continued working and did not seek medical attention until after his services had been terminated by the employer on an unspecified date in late 2002. 

  2. The worker lodged a claim for workers compensation on 16 January 2003 which was referred by the employer to QBE Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited (‘the insurer’).  The claim was accepted and payments of compensation were made.  The insurer also arranged for the worker to receive appropriate rehabilitation assistance.

  3. Before his employment as a truck driver in early 2002, the worker had been self employed as a musician for ten years and had earlier been a member of the Royal Australian Navy for five years during which time he completed a Bachelor of Music degree at Melbourne University. He also had other employment for short periods outside the music industry.

  4. The worker first sought medical attention on 17 December 2002 from Dr Diebold, a general practitioner of Tamworth.  Dr Diebold considered the worker had a low back strain and was fit for suitable duties with restrictions on lifting. He continued to certify the worker as fit for suitable duties at regular intervals up to 18 January 2006 when he certified him fit for his pre-injury duties.  The worker then saw another general practitioner in Tamworth, Dr Croaker, who certified the worker fit for suitable duties only and has continued to do so.

  5. The insurer wrote to the Worker on 16 February 2006.  In that letter it denied liability and gave the following reason:

    “In our opinion your injury is no longer related to your employment and you no longer have an incapacity as a result.”

    That opinion was said to be based on:

    “ • A medical report issued by Dr Robert Smith dated…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tamworth Building Supplies Pty Ltd v Begovic and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NSWWCCPD 77
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Tamworth Building Supplies Pty Ltd v Begovic, the primary dispute concerned the calculation of weekly compensation payments owed to the worker, Mr Begovic, under section 40 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. Mr Begovic, who was injured in the course of his employment, claimed that the Arbitrator had erred in assessing his entitlement to weekly payments by not considering his actual earnings from both his employment as a truck driver and his work as a musician and owner of a recording studio. The dispute was heard in the court of appeal.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Arbitrator correctly assessed Mr Begovic’s entitlement to weekly compensation payments under section 40 of the 1987 Act. This involved determining the appropriate method for calculating the weekly amount which the worker is earning or would be able to earn, particularly given the difficulties in quantifying Mr Begovic’s earnings from his various occupations. Additionally, the court had to address the question of onus of proof concerning the worker’s earnings, and whether this burden was correctly discharged by Mr Begovic.

The court, after reviewing the relevant legal principles and authorities, found that the Arbitrator had indeed erred in focusing solely on Mr Begovic’s hypothetical earnings as a truck driver. The court emphasised the importance of considering the worker’s actual earnings, including from all sources of income, in determining the weekly compensation amount. The court also noted the confusion between actual earnings and the ability to earn in suitable employment, aligning itself with the High Court’s approach in Nelson. The decision of the Arbitrator was thus revoked, and the matter was remitted to another Arbitrator for re-determination in accordance with the court’s reasoning.

The final orders of the court were that the decision of the Arbitrator dated 5 March 2008 be revoked, and that the matter be remitted to another Arbitrator for a fresh determination. Each party was to bear its own costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decision of the Arbitrator dated 5 March 2008 is revoked and the matter is remitted to another Arbitrator for determination afresh in accordance with these reasons.

Each party is to pay his or its own costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

There has been some confusion in this case between the worker’s actual earnings after 1 May 2006 and his ability to earn in suitable employment. Because of the difficulty in saying how much the worker had earned from his work as a musician and from his recording studio the Arbitrator looked only at his hypothetical earnings as a truck driver for three hours per day and based his award on such calculation. That the worker bears the onus of proving all matters relevant to his entitlement to benefits under section 40 of the 1987 Act cannot be doubted (see J & H Timbers Pty Ltd v Nelson (1972) 126 CLR 625 (‘Nelson’)). Whether that onus has been satisfied is another matter and the High Court was divided in that case as to where the onus lay. Barwick CJ and Windeyer J considered that the onus was on the employer while the majority, Menzies, Owen and Gibbs JJ considered that the onus was on the worker. That was a case of a person who carried on his own business of hauling logs and selling timber but who was deemed to be a “worker” employed by someone else. Both pre and post-injury earnings were unable to be calculated with precision and the trial judge had found a difference between the two amounts without finding what those amounts were. In doing so the High Court held that he had fallen into error. The Chief Justice at 632 in speaking of the worker’s entitlement to be compensated under section 11 of the Workers Compensation Act 1926, the forerunner of section 40 of the 1987 Act, said this:“The difference of which s.11 speaks is not the difference between the net gains of the business before and after receipt of an injury but the difference in the appropriate remuneration for the physical labour of the worker in the business in the two periods of time.” (emphasis added) At 633 the Chief Justice went on:“Of necessity the question is rather by how much, whatever his labour would formerly command, it has been diminished in value by the continuing incapacity.” Although, as I have indicated, the Chief Justice was in the minority with Windeyer J the statements which I have quoted above correctly set out in my respectful view the appropriate approach to be taken in assessing the earnings of a person in his own business. Windeyer J said this at 643:“The Act is concerned with compensation for total or partial incapacity of a worker – that is, the destruction or diminution of his earning capacity measured by his earnings ‘as a worker’. The question is not the same as is involved in assessing ‘economic loss’ in an action for damages for personal injury. The earning capacity of a man as a worker is measured by the remuneration that is the fruit of his labour, his wages or their equivalent. It is not to be measured by the profits he derives by embarking his capital in a business or by his usual capital equipment in earning money.”This also, in my respectful view, represents a correct statement of the law in this regard. Nelson has been followed by the High Court in Commonwealth v Muratore (1978) 141 CLR 296 and Cage Developments Pty Ltd v Schubert (1983) 151 CLR 584.