Talbot v Boyd Legal (A Firm) (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Talbot & Ors v Boyd Legal (A Firm) & Ors (No 2) [2023] QSC 39

PARTIES:

AMANDA DIANNE TALBOT
(first plaintiff)
ALEXANDRA CECILE TALBOT
(second plaintiff)
CLAUDIA ELISABETH TALBOT
(third plaintiff)
BLEVIO PTY LTD (AS TRUSTEE)
(fourth plaintiff)
COLLETTE CRAMER PTY LTD (AS TRUSTEE)
(fifth plaintiff)
v
BOYD LEGAL (A FIRM)
(first defendant)
ARNOLD BLOCH LEIBLER (A FIRM)
(second defendant)
PAUL JAMES VINCENT AND WILLIAM FRANCIS BOYD (AS ADMINISTRATORS AND TRUSTEES OF THE ESTATE AND WILL TRUST OF KENNETH TALBOT, DECEASED)
(third defendant)
BRIAN DAVID BARTLEY
(first third party)
PAUL WILLIAM GLEESON
(second third party)
WILLIAM FRANCIS BOYD AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF KENNETH TALBOT
(third third party)

FILE NO:

BS 641 of 2019

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Claim

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

17 February 2023 (ex tempore)

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

17 February 2023

JUDGE:

Boddice J

ORDER:

1.   The plaintiffs’ claim against the first defendant be dismissed, and judgment entered for the first defendant.

2.   The plaintiffs’ claim against the second defendant be dismissed, and judgment entered for the second defendant.

3.   The second defendant’s third party claim against the first third party be dismissed, and judgment entered for the first third party, with no order as to costs.

4.   The second defendant’s third party claim against the second third party be dismissed, and judgment entered for the second third party, with no order as to costs.

5.   The second defendant’s third party claim against the third third party be dismissed, and judgment entered for the third third party.

6.   The plaintiffs pay:

(a)     the first defendant’s and third third party’s costs of the proceeding up to and including 10 June 2022 on the standard basis, and thereafter on the indemnity basis, to be agreed or assessed;

(b)     the second defendant’s costs of the proceeding up to and including 14 June 2022 on the standard basis, and thereafter on the indemnity basis, to be agreed or assessed;

(c)     the third defendants’ costs of the proceeding on the indemnity basis.

7.   The third defendants be indemnified against their costs of the proceeding out of the interests of Amanda Talbot, Alexandra Talbot, and Claudia Talbot in the Talbot Estate Trust.

8.   On the proper construction of clauses 11.2(a) and 15 of the will dated 29 November 2002 of Kenneth Talbot, deceased, the interests of Amanda Talbot, Alexandra Talbot and Claudia Talbot in the income and capital of the Talbot Estate Trust are as follows:

(a)     Amanda Talbot 18%;

(b)     Alexandra Talbot 17%;

(c)     Claudia Talbot 17%.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – INDEMNITY COSTS – RELEVANT CONSIDERATIONS GENERALLY – where the plaintiffs’ claims, and third party proceedings, were dismissed at trial – where the first, second and third defendants and third third party sought costs to be assessed on an indemnity basis – where the first defendant alleged the proceedings were initiated for an improper purpose – where…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Talbot v Boyd Legal (A Firm) (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QSC 39
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, Amanda Talbot, Alexandra Talbot and Claudia Talbot, initiated proceedings against the first defendant, Boyd Legal (A Firm), in relation to the administration of the estate of their late father, Kenneth Talbot. The plaintiffs also brought third-party proceedings against the administrators of the estate. The first and second defendants and the third parties sought indemnity costs following the dismissal of all claims. The first defendant argued the proceedings were commenced for an improper purpose, while the second defendant claimed the plaintiffs had unreasonably prolonged the proceedings. The third defendants, who became parties due to correspondence between the parties, sought their costs to be paid by the plaintiff beneficiaries rather than other beneficiaries. The first and second defendants had each made a Calderbank offer of settlement.

The court examined the relevant considerations for awarding indemnity costs, including whether the proceedings were brought or continued for an improper purpose, and whether the losing party had acted unreasonably. The court found that the first defendant's allegation of an improper purpose was not established. However, the court found that the second defendant's contention that the plaintiffs unreasonably prolonged the proceedings was made out. The court also found that the third defendants' costs should be paid by the plaintiff beneficiaries rather than other beneficiaries. The court concluded that the defendants and third parties were entitled to indemnity costs.

The court ordered that the plaintiffs' claims against the first and second defendants be dismissed, and that judgment be entered in their favour. The second defendant's third-party claims were also dismissed, with judgment entered in favour of the first and second third parties, and no order as to costs. The second defendant's third-party claim against the third third party was dismissed, and judgment entered in their favour. The plaintiffs were ordered to pay the first defendant's and third third party's costs up to and including 10 June 2022 on the standard basis, and thereafter on the indemnity basis. The plaintiffs were also ordered to pay the second defendant's costs up to and including 14 June 2022 on the standard basis, and thereafter on the indemnity basis. The third defendants were ordered to be indemnified against their costs of the proceeding out of the interests of Amanda Talbot, Alexandra Talbot and Claudia Talbot in the Talbot Estate Trust. Finally, the court construed clauses 11.2(a) and 15 of the will dated 29 November 2002 of Kenneth Talbot, deceased, and determined the interests of Amanda Talbot, Alexandra Talbot and Claudia Talbot in the income and capital of the Talbot Estate Trust.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The plaintiffs’ claim against the first defendant be dismissed, and judgment entered for the first defendant.

2. The plaintiffs’ claim against the second defendant be dismissed, and judgment entered for the second defendant.

3. The second defendant’s third party claim against the first third party be dismissed, and judgment entered for the first third party, with no order as to costs.

4. The second defendant’s third party claim against the second third party be dismissed, and judgment entered for the second third party, with no order as to costs.

5. The second defendant’s third party claim against the third third party be dismissed, and judgment entered for the third third party.

6. The plaintiffs pay:

(a) the first defendant’s and third third party’s costs of the proceeding up to and including 10 June 2022 on the standard basis, and thereafter on the indemnity basis, to be agreed or assessed;

(b) the second defendant’s costs of the proceeding up to and including 14 June 2022 on the standard basis, and thereafter on the indemnity basis, to be agreed or assessed;

(c) the third defendants’ costs of the proceeding on the indemnity basis.

7. The third defendants be indemnified against their costs of the proceeding out of the interests of Amanda Talbot, Alexandra Talbot, and Claudia Talbot in the Talbot Estate Trust.

8. On the proper construction of clauses 11.2(a) and 15 of the will dated 29 November 2002 of Kenneth Talbot, deceased, the interests of Amanda Talbot, Alexandra Talbot and Claudia Talbot in the income and capital of the Talbot Estate Trust are as follows:

(a) Amanda Talbot 18%;

(b) Alexandra Talbot 17%;

(c) Claudia Talbot 17%.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established