Tait v Village Community Co-Operative Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Civil)

TAIT v VILLAGE COMMUNITY CO-OPERATIVE LTD

[2017] SASC 109

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Nicholson

21 July 2017

ASSOCIATIONS AND CLUBS - EXPULSION, SUSPENSION AND DISQUALIFICATION - POWER TO EXPEL, SUSPEND AND DISQUALIFY

TORTS - TROVER AND DETINUE - WHAT CONSTITUTES CONVERSION - GENERALLY

BAILMENTS - IN GENERAL

PERSONAL PROPERTY - OWNERSHIP AND POSSESSION

This is an appeal by Caroline Theresa Tait from a decision of a Magistrate who was required to determine a claim by Village Community Co-operative Limited, the respondent, for the sale or disposal of the appellant’s goods, pursuant to the Unclaimed Goods Act 1987, together with a counter-claim brought by the appellant.

The Co-operative purported to expel the appellant from membership in October 2011. For some time prior thereto and from that time on, the Co-operative sought to have the appellant remove a very substantial quantity of her personal belongings from the Kuitpo property. She has failed to do so. As a consequence, the respondent instituted proceedings in the Magistrates Court pursuant to the Unclaimed Goods Act 1987. In her defence and counterclaim, the appellant asserted that her expulsion was invalid, that the Co-operative had no entitlement under the Unclaimed Goods Act to have the goods removed or sold and claimed damages under various causes of action.

Held:

1. The Magistrate’s findings and orders concerning the validity of the expulsion of the appellant in paragraphs [50]-[54] of the Magistrate’s Reasons are set aside.

2. Nevertheless, the appellant has not succeeded in having the expulsion set aside and it remains in force.

3. The Magistrate’s order permitting the respondent to offset the sum of $3,000 in the manner set out in paragraph [56] of the Magistrate’s Reasons is set aside.

4. In all other respects, the Magistrate’s orders concerning the respondent’s unclaimed goods action in paragraph [56] of the Magistrate’s reasons are confirmed.

5. The Magistrate’s findings and orders concerning the demolition of the incomplete extension in paragraph [57] of the Magistrate’s Reasons are set aside.

6. In all other respects, the appeal is dismissed.

7. The stay given on 20 June 2016 of the Magistrate’s orders (as now varied) is vacated.

Co-operatives Act 1997 s 84, s 187, s 188, s 191, s 216, s 217; Magistrates Court Act 1991 s 8, s 10, s 10A, s 25, s 26, s 32, s 40; Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 r 286; Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 9; Unclaimed Goods Act s 5, s 6, s 7, referred to.
CSR Ltd v Della Maddalena [2006] HCA 1, (2006) 224 ALR 1; Fox v Percy [2003] HCA 22, (2003) 214 CLR 118; Roberts T/A Contract Refrigeration Services v Kowshu Enterprises Pty Ltd [1999] SASC 158; The Registrar of Motor Vehicles v McIver [2014] SASC 51; Sherriff v Dudley [2000] SASC 324; Penfolds Wines Pty Ltd v Elliott (1946) 74 CLR 204, considered.

TAIT v VILLAGE COMMUNITY CO-OPERATIVE LTD
[2017] SASC 109

Magistrates…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tait v Village Community Co-Operative Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] SASC 109
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Tait v Village Community Co-Operative Ltd concerned a dispute between Caroline Theresa Tait and Village Community Co-Operative Limited regarding the validity of Tait's expulsion from the Co-operative and the right to remove Tait's belongings from Co-operative property. The case was ultimately determined by the Supreme Court of South Australia, which was reviewing a decision made by a Magistrate. The primary issues for the court to resolve included the legitimacy of Tait's expulsion under the Co-operative's rules and whether the Co-operative had the right to remove Tait's goods under the Unclaimed Goods Act 1987. Additionally, Tait sought damages for various causes of action, including conversion, trespass, and negligence.

The Supreme Court examined the evidence presented during the extensive trial, ultimately upholding the Magistrate's findings. The court found that the Co-operative had valid grounds for expelling Tait under rule 8(1)(a) of its rules, as Tait had failed to meet her obligations. The court also determined that the expulsion process was conducted in accordance with the Co-operative's rules, providing Tait with adequate notice and opportunity to be heard. Furthermore, the Supreme Court rejected Tait's claims for damages related to personal injury and property damage, finding insufficient evidence to support her assertions. The court concluded that much of Tait's property had deteriorated due to neglect and was therefore worthless.

In light of these findings, the Supreme Court dismissed Tait's appeal and upheld the Magistrate's orders. Tait was required to remove her belongings from the Co-operative property within three months, after which the remaining goods would be sold or disposed of by the Co-operative in accordance with the Unclaimed Goods Act 1987. The Co-operative was permitted to claim storage fees and the value of Tait's share in the Co-operative from any proceeds of the sale of Tait's goods. Each party was ordered to bear their own costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

NICHOLSON J
By its defence to the counter-claim filed on 22 September 2014, the Co-operative denied each of the appellant’s causes of action. The Magistrate’s decision Following a seven-day trial spanning more than a year, a judgment was delivered on 6 April 2016.The Magistrate was unimpressed with the appellant as a witness. His Honour made these observations.[4][The appellant] has a very good memory for dates and events, but was clearly disorganised, rambling, acrimonious and obsessed by feelings of victimisation.It appears that, consistent with her behaviour in court [the appellant at the expulsion meeting] rambled initially on point and then drifted into various unrelated and irrelevant topics.[emphasis supplied][4] Magistrate’s Reasons at [41], [52]. The Magistrate found that the Co-operative had proper grounds to expel the appellant in accordance with rule 8(1)(a) of the Co-operative’s Rules[5] and that the appellant had been provided with sufficient notice of the proposed special resolution for her expulsion. His Honour further found that the appellant had been provided with a “reasonable opportunity to be heard”, as required by rule 8(3)(a) and held that the process had been conducted in accordance with the Co-operative’s Rules such that the special resolution passed by the Co-operative was valid. [5] Rule 8(1)(a) provides: “A member may be expelled from the co-operative if the co-operative by special resolution determines that the member should be expelled on the ground that –(a)the member has filed to discharge the member’s obligations to the co-operative under the Act or these rules.” The Magistrate found that no claim for personal injury was made out and, in particular, that there was insufficient evidence to substantiate the claim for emotional distress, loss of amenity, and pain and suffering.[6] As for the appellant’s claim for damage to her personal property, the Magistrate found that the values attributed by the appellant with respect to her list of possessions could not be substantiated and did not take into account the condition, age and value of the items at the time of the trial. The Magistrate found that much of the appellant’s property had been stored outside, exposed to the elements for many years, had deteriorated beyond repair and was worthless, as a consequence of the appellant’s own neglect. The Magistrate found that the appellant was not entitled to damages for loss of or damage to property.[7] The final conclusions reached and “orders” made by the Magistrate were as follows.[8] In view of the above, I make the following findings.On the claim, I find that Ms Tait has claimed the goods since commencement of proceedings. Ms Tait is to collect her goods and chattels and remove them from the land owned by the Cooperative within three months of the date of this judgment. For that purpose, the Cooperative is to allow Ms Tait reasonable access to the land. Any goods or chattels remaining on the land after the period of three months has elapsed shall be sold or disposed of by the Cooperative in accordance with Provisions [sic] 6, 7 and 8 of the Unclaimed Goods Act 1987. The Cooperative may claim up to $400.00 for storing the goods, in addition to the sum of $3,000 representing the value of Ms Tait’s share in the Cooperative, which sum shall be deducted from any amount owed by Ms Tait to the Cooperative and thereafter any balance from the sale of the goods payable to Ms Tait shall be paid within 28 days of the determination of the amount owing by Ms Tait, which determination shall be by agreement or as determined by the court. I accept the view of [the valuer] Mr Taormina that the structure is of no market value. In my view it should be demolished. It is an eyesore and not habitable. The material from which it is constructed should be made available for collection and removal by Ms Tait within 3 months of the date of this judgment. Any such material remaining on the land after the period of three months has elapsed shall be sold or disposed of by the Cooperative and the proceeds of such sale are to be deducted from the cost of dismantling the structure and disposing of the material. Any balance is to be paid to Ms Tait. I find that the claim of Ms Tait for special damages for damage and loss of property fails.Each party is to bear their own costs of these proceedings.[6] Magistrate’s Reasons at [17].[7] Magistrate’s Reasons at [19]-[20]. [8] Magistrate’s Reasons at [55]-[58].Appeal to the Supreme Court

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: NICHOLSON J

Full text does not contain this section.