Tahir (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

Tahir (Migration) [2023] AATA 4175 (7 December 2023)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

APPLICANT:  Mr Ismael Abdulwahab Tahir

REPRESENTATIVE:  Mr Ashwin Tyagi (MARN: 1575846)

CASE NUMBER:  2204750

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S): BCC2022/56058 BCC202256058

MEMBER:Simone Burford

DATE:7 December 2023

PLACE OF DECISION:  Perth

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicant a Resident Return (Class BB) visa.

Statement made on 07 December 2023 at 12:18pm

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs on 15 March 2022 to refuse to grant the visa applicant a Return (Residence) (Class BB) Subclass 155 visa under s 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act).

  2. The visa applicant applied for the visa on 16 February 2022.

  3. The delegate refused to grant the visa on the basis that the applicant did not meet the criteria for the visa. 

  4. For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision under review should be affirmed.  The Tribunal recommends the matter be referred for consideration of Ministerial intervention.

    Background

  5. The applicant is an Ethiopian national who was born in Dire Dama, Ethiopia in 1996. 

  6. The applicant’s biological father passed away in 2008. His mother’s whereabouts is unknown and he was raised by his father and grandmother. In 2010 he was adopted by his aunt, his father’s sister, Ms Kin Hashi who came to Australia in 1989 and is an Australian Citizen.

  7. In 2009 Ms Hashi married to Mr Wendmagegn Weldermariam. On 25 September 2012 the applicant arrived in Australia as a dependant on Mr Weldermariam’s UF 309 visa.  The sponsor for the visa was Ms Hashi. 

  8. On 6 August 2013 he was granted a Partner visa (permanent) Subclass 100 visa.

  9. The applicant’s aunt and Mr Weldermariam separated sometime in 2014/2015 and on 29 April 2014 Mr Weldermariam’s visa was cancelled.  On 13 March 2015 the applicant’s visa was cancelled by operation of law.  He was not notified of this cancellation until 12 January 2022.

  10. On 9 June 2020 the applicant applied for Australian citizenship.  On 21 April 2021 he was invited to an interview with respect to his citizenship application for 10 June 2021.

  11. On 12 January 2022 the applicant was notified by mail of his visa cancellation.  On 20 January 2022 his application for citizenship was refused on the basis that he was an unlawful non-citizen.

  12. On 16 February 2022 the applicant applied for the Resident Return visa while onshore. The applicant has not left Australia since arriving in 2012.

    Review

  13. The applicant appeared before the Tribunal on 6 December 2023 to give evidence and present arguments. The Tribunal hearing was conducted via telephone.

  14. The applicant was represented in relation to the application for the visa and the review.  The applicant’s representative attended the hearing and made written and oral submissions.

  15. The applicant provided the following documents in support of the application:

    ·            Statement dated 14 February 2022 (submitted with visa application);

    ·            Representative’s submissions dated 31 March…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tahir (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 4175
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered an application for a Resident Return (Class BB) visa by an Ethiopian national. The applicant, who arrived in Australia in 2012 and was granted a Partner visa (Subclass 100) in 2013, had his visa cancelled by operation of law in March 2015. However, he was not notified of this cancellation until January 2022. The applicant subsequently applied for a Resident Return visa while onshore, having not left Australia since his arrival.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicant met the criteria for a Subclass 155 (Five Year Resident Return) visa, specifically clauses 155.211 and 157.211. This involved assessing his eligibility for such a visa despite the prior cancellation of his permanent visa and the significant delay in notification.

The Tribunal noted that the applicant had resided in Australia for a lengthy period with his adoptive mother, an Australian citizen, and had established substantial cultural and personal ties to the country. Crucially, the Tribunal considered departmental advice from March 2015 which indicated that the applicant's visa would not be automatically cancelled as a consequence of his sponsor's visa cancellation, and that there would be no good reason to cancel the applicant's visa. Despite this, the applicant's visa was later cancelled, and he was not informed for almost seven years. The Tribunal acknowledged the applicant's participation in the community and his efforts to obtain Australian citizenship, which was refused due to his unlawful non-citizen status.

Ultimately, the Tribunal affirmed the decision not to grant the applicant a Resident Return visa. However, the Tribunal recommended that the matter be referred for consideration of Ministerial intervention, acknowledging the unique circumstances of the case, including the delayed notification of visa cancellation and the applicant's established ties to Australia.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision under review should be affirmed. The Tribunal recommends the matter be referred for consideration of Ministerial intervention.Background The applicant is an Ethiopian national who was born in Dire Dama, Ethiopia in 1996. The applicant’s biological father passed away in 2008. His mother’s whereabouts is unknown and he was raised by his father and grandmother. In 2010 he was adopted by his aunt, his father’s sister, Ms Kin Hashi who came to Australia in 1989 and is an Australian Citizen. In 2009 Ms Hashi married to Mr Wendmagegn Weldermariam. On 25 September 2012 the applicant arrived in Australia as a dependant on Mr Weldermariam’s UF 309 visa. The sponsor for the visa was Ms Hashi. On 6 August 2013 he was granted a Partner visa (permanent) Subclass 100 visa. The applicant’s aunt and Mr Weldermariam separated sometime in 2014/2015 and on 29 April 2014 Mr Weldermariam’s visa was cancelled. On 13 March 2015 the applicant’s visa was cancelled by operation of law. He was not notified of this cancellation until 12 January 2022. On 9 June 2020 the applicant applied for Australian citizenship. On 21 April 2021 he was invited to an interview with respect to his citizenship application for 10 June 2021. On 12 January 2022 the applicant was notified by mail of his visa cancellation. On 20 January 2022 his application for citizenship was refused on the basis that he was an unlawful non-citizen. On 16 February 2022 the applicant applied for the Resident Return visa while onshore. The applicant has not left Australia since arriving in 2012.Review The applicant appeared before the Tribunal on 6 December 2023 to give evidence and present arguments. The Tribunal hearing was conducted via telephone. The applicant was represented in relation to the application for the visa and the review. The applicant’s representative attended the hearing and made written and oral submissions. The applicant provided the following documents in support of the application:· Statement dated 14 February 2022 (submitted with visa application);· Representative’s submissions dated 31 March 2022;·Emails from the Department of Home Affairs to the applicant dated 21 January 2022;· Partner visa (Subclass 100) grant notice dated 6 August 2013;· Representative’s submissions dated 18 October 2023;· Copy of the applicant’s Ethiopian passport (bio page) issued 30 May 2022;· Statutory declaration from the applicant regarding loss of birth certificate;· Copy of the applicant’s Australian driver’s licence;· Copy of the applicant’s Medicare card;· Copy of the applicant’s Private Security licences;· Copy of Miss Kin’s Australian passport (bio page) issued 11 October 2017· Copy of Partner (Subclass 309) visa;· Copy of Partner (Subclass 100) visa;· Email from Department of Home Affairs dated 5 March 2015;· Email from Department of Home Affairs dated 6 March 2015;· Applicant’s High School graduation certificate;· Participation certificate for Yarra Soccer Pathways Program 2016;· Citizenship application form;· Citizenship interview appointment letter;· Email from Home Affairs Status Resolution Team dated 18 January 2022;·Email from applicant to Home Affairs Status Resolution Team dated 19 January 2022;·Email from Visa Cancellations dated 19 January 2022;·Notification of visa cancellation dated 12 January 2022;·Citizenship application refusal dated 20 January 2022;·Application for review;·Victoria University Certificate III in Non-Emergency Patient Transport;·Melbourne Training College Certificate II in Security Operations;·Australian Federal Police National Police Check;·Representative’s submissions dated 22 November 2023;·Applicant’s birth certificate;·Enrolment confirmation Australian Catholic University;·Letter of support, Christopher Mc Geachan, GR8M8S Foundation dated 19 October 2023;·Medical certificate from Doctor Sunday Morakinyo, My Doctor Collingwood, dated 30 October 2023;·Letter of support, Annabel Darbyshire, Yarra Youth Services dated 3 November 2023;·Letter of support from Adam Bandt, MP dated 13 November 2023; ·Letter of support from Fitzroy Lions dated 8 November 2023;·Letter of support from Victoria University;·Letter of support from Foresite Training and Licensing dated 23 October 2023;CRITERIA FOR THE VISA

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal has considered the applicant’s case and the Ministerial guidelines relating to the discretionary power set out in the Department’s Procedures Advice Manual (PAM3) and will refer the matter to the Department for consideration for Ministerial Intervention. Further documents and submissions addressing this matter should be directed to the Department.DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicant a Resident Return (Class BB) visa.Simone BurfordSenior Member

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The issue in this case is whether the applicant satisfies clause 155.211 and 157.211. CONSIDERATIONApplicant’s migration history The applicant is an Ethiopian national who was born in Dire Dama, Ethiopia in 1996. The applicant’s biological father passed away in 2008. His mother’s whereabouts is unknown and he was raised by his father and grandmother. In 2010 he was adopted by his aunt, his father’s sister, Ms Kin Hashi who came to Australia in 1989 and is an Australian Citizen. In 2009 Ms Hashi married to Mr Wendmagegn Weldermariam in Ethiopia. On 25 September 2012 the applicant arrived in Australia as a dependant on Mr Weldermariam’s UF 309 visa. The sponsor for the visa was Ms Hashi. The applicant confirmed he has not left Australia since arriving in 2012. On 6 August 2013 he was granted a Partner visa (permanent) Subclass 100 visa. The applicant’s aunt and Mr Weldermariam separated sometime in 2014/2015 and on 29 April 2014 Mr Weldermariam’s visa was cancelled. As noted above, information before the Tribunal suggests that the applicant’s Partner visa (permanent) Subclass 100 visa was cancelled on 13 March 2015 under subsection 140(1) by operation of law however the applicant was not notified of this cancellation until 12 January 2022. Material submitted by the applicant suggested that at the time of the cancellation of Mr Weldermariam’s visa, the applicant’s adoptive parent, Ms Hashi, engaged in correspondence with the Department of Immigration and Border Protection regarding the cancellation of the applicant’s visa. While it was initially suggested that the applicant’s visa would be consequentially cancelled as a result of cancellation of Mr Weldermariam’s visa, the Department later indicated in an email that the applicant’s visa would not be automatically cancelled and there would be no good reason for cancelling his visa. The email, from Mr Adam Kosack, Visa Cancellation Officer, Visa Cancellation Unit – NSW, Department of Immigration and Boarder Protection, dated 6 March 2015 provided:I want to confirm our conversation on 6 March 2015 about the possible cancellation of [the applicant’s] visa.During that conversation told you that your nephew/adopted so ,[ the applicant ], v now holds a Partner visa granted because Mr Weldemariam held a Partner Visa. If his visit was cancelled then [the applicant’s] visa would be cancelled automatically. This is so called consequential cancellation. I told you that if [the applicant] was granted different then [the applicant’s] visa would not be cancelled result of cancelling Mr Weldemariam’s. I suggested that [the applicant] might want to apply for a Resident Return visa (RRV). I did not know if he would get it. If he was granted the RRV then it would not be cancelled automatically upon cancellation of Mr Weldemariam’s. I could however technically choose to cancel and RRV but given [the applicant’s] circumstances I said I could not see a good reason for doing that.In summary, I suggested [the applicant] might apply for, and possibly get, and RRV as a way of avoiding cancellation.When we spoke I was ignorant of the fact that [the applicant] had only been a permanent resident of Australia since August 2013. Generally there is a requirement that the person applying for an RRV has been a permanent resident for two years. [The applicant] hasn’t so I can’t see how he might be granted and RRV despite my early suggestion. However, I have looked over the relevant law about consequential cancellation and discussed it with a colleague. I no longer believe that cancellation of Mr Weldemariam’s partner visa would bring about the automatic cancellation of [the applicant’s] partner visa. In summary, if [the applicant] did apply for an RRV he might not get it. In any case I now believe that if Mr Weldemariam’s visa is cancelled then [the applicant’s] visa will not be cancelled.