FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
T R Flanagan Smash Repairs Pty Ltd v Jones [1999] FCA 1391
No question of principle
T R FLANAGAN SMASH REPAIRS PTY LTD v BRUCE JONES
N 993 OF 1999
HELY J
7 OCTOBER 1999
SYDNEY
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
N 993 OF 1999
BETWEEN:
T R FLANAGAN SMASH REPAIRS PTY LTD
ApplicantAND:
BRUCE JONES
Respondent
JUDGE:
HELY J
DATE:
7 OCTOBER 1999
PLACE:
SYDNEY
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
On 20 September 1999 I granted an interlocutory injunction which restrained the respondent from reproducing, publishing or authorising the reproduction or publication of the applicant's AutoQuote Vehicle Directory and the applicant's AutoQuote Parts Database. The injunction was granted because I was satisfied, on the material before me, that the applicant had established a prima facie case of copyright infringement.
My reasons for decision, a copy of which was forwarded to both parties, indicated that the evidence at the time established, to the requisite degree, both that copyright subsisted in the publications in question and the applicant was the owner of that copyright. The evidence also established that the respondent had copied the material in question and that he intended to continue to do so. For the reasons which I gave in par 11 of that decision, I noted that the respondent appeared to me to be acting on a misconception of his legal entitlements. The application which was then before me was for an interlocutory injunction therefore I did not, and could not, determine the ultimate rights and wrongs of the matter. What I had to do was to consider whether the applicant had established a sufficiently arguable case to justify a maintenance of the status quo and to consider where the balance of convenience lay. In that sense, the decision which I gave was akin to a discretionary judgment because it was based on a practical evaluation of what was the best thing to do rather than an ultimate determination of the rights or wrongs of the matter.
I now have before me an application for leave to appeal by Mr Jones from that decision. Because my decision was an interlocutory judgment an appeal can only be made with the leave of the Court: see s 24(1A) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (“the Act”). Leave to appeal can be granted either by a single judge or by the Full Court: s 25(2)(a) of the Act.
Once an application for leave to appeal is determined by a single judge there is no further avenue of appeal to the Full Court: Thomas Borthwick and Sons (Pacific Holdings) Ltd v Trade Practices Commission (1988) 18 FCR 424 at 433. When Mr Jones first indicated that he was seeking leave to appeal from my decision, I explained to him that if the application were made to me and if it failed then he would have no further recourse to the Full Court. He told me that he understood this, and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read T R Flanagan Smash Repairs Pty Ltd v Jones and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] FCA 1391
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included whether the interlocutory decision warranted reconsideration by the Full Court and whether substantial injustice would result if leave to appeal was refused. Justice Hely found that the material presented by Jones did not sufficiently challenge the original decision's doubt or demonstrate substantial injustice. Jones's attempts to show a lack of originality in the works and disputes over copyright ownership were considered insufficient to warrant reconsideration by the Full Court. Additionally, Jones's financial limitations and lack of an undertaking as to damages further supported the denial of leave to appeal. Consequently, Justice Hely refused leave to appeal and dismissed Jones's motion for leave to appeal.
Furthermore, Jones sought interlocutory relief related to a computer program called the "Foxquote" program. Jones requested that Flanagan deliver a working copy of its AutoQuote Imaging Windows Program for inspection, restrain Flanagan from licensing the program until certain conditions were met, order Flanagan to delete the Foxquote program, and require Flanagan to swear a declaration against copying Foxquote features. Justice Hely noted that while Flanagan did not assert entitlement to use the Foxquote program, it had ignored Jones's demands to delete the program. However, an undertaking by Flanagan not to use the Foxquote material satisfied the court's concerns about the incomplete evidence of deletion. Consequently, Justice Hely denied the interlocutory relief, considering the delay in seeking such relief and the provided undertaking.
Background
Background to the litigation
On 20 September 1999, an interlocutory injunction was granted to the applicant against the respondent for copyright infringement. The respondent then applied for leave to appeal this decision. The respondent also filed a cross-claim seeking interlocutory relief in relation to the Foxquote program. The matter came before the court for a hearing on 7 October 1999.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether leave to appeal the interlocutory injunction should be granted.
2. Whether interlocutory relief should be granted in relation to the Foxquote program.
Held
1. Whether leave to appeal the interlocutory injunction should be granted.
The Court held that leave to appeal should not be granted. The Court found that the decision was not attended by sufficient doubt to warrant reconsideration by the Full Court and that no substantial injustice would result if leave were refused.
2. Whether interlocutory relief should be granted in relation to the Foxquote program.
The Court held that interlocutory relief should not be granted in relation to the Foxquote program. The Court found that the applicant had provided an undertaking to the Court that it would not make any use of the Foxquote material, and that the relief sought went beyond mere preservation of the status quo.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by:
In relation to the first issue, the Court considered whether leave to appeal should be granted. The Court noted that generally, leave to appeal should be granted if the decision is attended by sufficient doubt to warrant reconsideration by the Full Court or if substantial injustice would result if leave were refused. The Court found that neither of these criteria were met in this case. The Court found that the evidence relied upon by the respondent was not sufficient to indicate that the applicant's claim to copyright was one that would not succeed. The Court also found that no substantial injustice would result if leave were refused, as the respondent remained free to trade subject to the injunctions granted and the risk of lost sales was largely hypothetical. The Court noted that if both parties approached the preparation for the final hearing with diligence, the matter could be heard within a similar time frame as if the appeal were granted and reviewed by the Full Court.
In relation to the second issue, the Court considered whether interlocutory relief should be granted in relation to the Foxquote program. The Court found that the applicant had provided an undertaking to the Court that it would not make any use of the Foxquote material, which satisfied the concern arising from the failure to respond to the respondent's demand and the incomplete nature of the evidence as to deletion. The Court found that the relief sought went beyond mere preservation of the status quo and that the respondent had delayed for a period of up to a year in propounding his claim for interlocutory relief. The Court found that the respondent had not established a prima facie case of likely misappropriation by the applicant of the Foxquote system or any of its modules. The Court found that the undertaking given by the applicant was equivalent to an injunction in those terms and satisfied the concern which the Court had. The Court found that the relief sought went beyond mere preservation of the status quo and that the respondent had delayed for a period of up to a year in propounding his claim for interlocutory relief.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that interlocutory relief will not be granted where the applicant has provided an undertaking to the Court that it will not make any use of the material in question and where the relief sought goes beyond mere preservation of the status quo. The Court will consider whether the decision is attended by sufficient doubt to warrant reconsideration by the Full Court and whether substantial injustice would result if leave were refused when considering whether to grant leave to appeal.