SZVCB v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SZVCB v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 479

Appeal from: SZVCB & Anor v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2015] FCCA 1172
File number: NSD 603 of 2015
Judge: MARKOVIC J
Date of judgment: 11 May 2017
Catchwords: MIGRATION – appeal from a decision of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia – whether Tribunal gave appellant clear particulars of information the Tribunal considered would be the reason or part of the reason for affirming the decision under review – whether Tribunal invited appellant to give evidence and present arguments relating to the issues arising in relation to the decision under review – appeal dismissed
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 424A, 424AA, 425
Cases cited:

SZBEL v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2006) 228 CLR 152

SZBYR v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2007) 235 ALR 609

SZLPO v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (No 2) (2009) 177 FCR 29

SZNKO v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and Another (2010) 184 FCR 505

Date of hearing: 21 February 2017
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 49
Counsel for the Appellants: Mr R Chia
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Ms L Buchanan, Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the Second Respondent: The second respondent filed a submitting notice, save as to costs

ORDERS

NSD 603 of 2015
BETWEEN:

SZVCB

First Appellant

SZVCC

Second Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

JUDGE:

MARKOVIC J

DATE OF ORDER:

11 MAY 2017

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

2.The first appellant pay the first respondent’s costs as agreed or taxed.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

MARKOVIC J:

  1. This is an appeal from orders made by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia on 8 May 2015 dismissing an application for judicial review under s 476 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Act) of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal, as it then was (now the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal)), made on 26 August 2014.  The Tribunal had affirmed an earlier decision made by a delegate of the first respondent (Minister) not to grant the appellants Protection (Class XA) visas. 

  2. The first and second appellants are mother and daughter respectively and citizens of the People’s Republic of China (China).  On 9 November 2016 Collier J made orders by consent in relation to the second appellant, allowing her appeal, quashing the Tribunal’s decision insofar as it affirmed the decision not to grant her a Protection (Class XA) visa and remitting her application for review of the Minister’s decision to the Tribunal for determination according to law.  At that time her Honour also made orders for the first appellant’s appeal to be fixed for final hearing and set a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SZVCB v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCA 479
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of SZVCB v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, the Federal Circuit Court of Australia was called upon to determine an appeal against a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The Appellant, SZVCB, sought review of a decision by the delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, who had affirmed the decision to refuse her application for a protection visa. The AAT had found the Appellant not to be a credible witness and affirmed the decision to refuse her application. The Appellant challenged the AAT’s decision on several grounds, including the AAT’s handling of documentary evidence and its failure to clearly explain how this evidence was inconsistent with her claims.

The central legal issues before the Court were whether the Tribunal had given the Appellant clear particulars of the information it considered to be relevant to the decision, and whether the Tribunal had invited the Appellant to give evidence and present arguments relating to the issues arising from the decision under review. The Court had to determine whether the Tribunal had complied with section 424AA(1)(b)(i) of the Migration Act 1958, which requires the Tribunal to inform the parties of the information it considers to be relevant to the review and to invite the parties to comment on or respond to that information.

The Court examined the transcript of the Tribunal hearing and found that the Tribunal had indeed informed the Appellant of the relevant information, specifically the inconsistencies between her evidence and the documentary evidence provided in her previous visa application. The Tribunal had also invited the Appellant to comment on these inconsistencies. The Appellant had been given an opportunity to explain or respond to the information, and the Tribunal had allowed additional time for the Appellant to do so. The Court concluded that the Tribunal had adequately fulfilled its obligations under section 424AA(1)(b)(i) of the Migration Act.

Given the Court’s findings, the appeal was dismissed. The Appellant was ordered to pay the costs of the first respondent, as agreed or taxed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The first appellant pay the first respondent’s costs as agreed or taxed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 30 April 2014 the Appellant applied to the Tribunal for review of the delegate’s decision. She appeared before the Tribunal to give evidence and present arguments. On 26 August 2014 the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review.THE TRIBUNAL DECISION The Tribunal found the Appellant not to be a credible witness. It noted that there were inconsistencies in her evidence, that some of her claims were implausible and found that the Appellant was not convincing or persuasive. The Tribunal’s concerns were as follows:(1)the Appellant gave evidence at the hearing that she was almost 50 years old and was no longer able to bear children. The Tribunal was of the view that it was therefore highly unlikely that the Chinese authorities would force her to undergo tubal ligation;(2)the Appellant claimed in her visa application that her husband had physically, mentally and sexually abused her; that she feared being physically, mentally and sexually harmed; and that the Chinese authorities regard sexual offences in a marriage as domestic matters and will not become involved. At the hearing the Appellant gave evidence that she separated from her husband when she left China and came to Australia in June 2007; that she had had no contact with her husband since 2009; and that she wishes to divorce him. She also said that if her husband did not agree to the divorce he would beat her to death. The Tribunal was of the view that if the Appellant and her husband had been separated since June 2007 and had had no contact since 2009 then it was highly unlikely that her husband would oppose their divorce, let alone “beat her to death”;(3)the Appellant claimed that her husband was controlling: he stalked her; opposed her taking a job as a masseuse or otherwise; and restricted her from doing as she wished. The Tribunal found that those claims were inconsistent with the husband permitting the Appellant to travel to Australia with her daughter, where he would have no control over what she did. The Tribunal also found that the Appellant’s claim that her husband prevented her from taking a job was inconsistent with the evidence she gave at the hearing that she did not have a job in China because she had to stay home with her four children;(4)the Appellant claimed that she would be harmed by debt collectors as a result of her husband borrowing money from loan sharks at high interest rates for his business ventures, fish farming and coal mining, because he could not borrow from a bank. The Tribunal found that this claim was inconsistent with the fact that the Appellant had provided evidence of a bank loan to her husband to support her student guardian visa application. Relevantly, at [32]-[34] of its decision record the Tribunal said:32.The Tribunal asked the second named applicant why her husband did not borrow the money from a bank rather than from a loan shark at high interest rates. She responded that they had nothing they would provide as security for a loan and that people from villages are unable to get bank loans. In her application for a Student Guardian visa, the second named applicant provided the Department with a number of documents including a letter from her husband's employer. It stated that he had worked as a manager of a Decoration Store since February 2000. When the Tribunal put this information to the second named applicant, pursuant to s.424AA of the Act, she responded that this was the job she referred to earlier where he made posters and advertising signs. The Tribunal does not accept this response as being a manager of a store is very different from making posters and advertising signs.33.In her application for a Student Guardian visa, the second named applicant provided the Department with a document from the CITIC Industrial Bank in relation to a study loan to her husband. She also provided the Department with a letter from her agent in China stating that her husband had borrowed 650,000 RMB from the bank to support her and their daughter in Australia. When the Tribunal put this information to the second named applicant, pursuant to s.424AA of the Act, she responded that the money her husband borrowed from the bank had to be repaid and he borrowed money from the loan shark to repay the bank. When the Tribunal noted that this was inconsistent with her earlier evidence, she responded that her husband looked after their financial affairs and she only had a rough idea about their finances.34.The documentary evidence that the second named applicant provided to the Department in support of her application for a Student Guardian visa indicates that her husband had obtained a loan from the bank which is inconsistent with her evidence to the Tribunal that they had no security, were unable to get a bank loan and that people from villages are unable to get bank loans. Her evidence that her husband borrowed money from a loan shark to invest in a fish farm and coal mining is inconsistent with her subsequent evidence that her husband borrowed money from a loan shark in order to repay the bank loan. These inconsistencies in the second named applicant’s evidence raise concerns in relation to her credibility and the veracity of her claims.(5)the Appellant had waited over six years after her arrival in Australia before lodging her protection visa application. The Tribunal was of the view that if the Appellant had genuine fears she would have taken steps to lodge her protection visa application prior to the expiry of her student guardian visa in 2008. The Tribunal did not accept the Appellant’s response for not doing so, namely, that she did not know how to apply and had poor English, finding that she was a very resourceful person; and(6)the Tribunal found that the Appellant was “prepared to say anything to obtain a Protection visa without any regard for the truth” and that she had fabricated her claims for the purpose of obtaining a protection visa.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Appellant also submitted that the Tribunal did not ensure that she understood the relevance of the Bank Document as required by s 424AA(1)(b)(i) and made no attempt to explain with what evidence and claims the Bank Document was inconsistent and how that inconsistency was relevant to the review. Similarly, the Appellant submitted that the Tribunal did not explain how the Employer’s Letter was inconsistent with her evidence and claims and the relevance of that inconsistency. She further submitted that by not identifying how the Bank Document and the Employer’s Letter were inconsistent with her evidence and claims and not explaining how the inconsistencies were relevant to the review the Tribunal failed to comply with s 424AA(1)(b)(i) of the Act. Consideration In order to consider the Appellant’s submissions it is of assistance to first set out the relevant extracts from the transcript of the Tribunal hearing, which was included in the appeal book, including an extract in which the Tribunal member took steps to comply with s 424AA of the Act. Relevantly, the following exchanges took place:Tribunal: What work does your husband do?Appellant:Like a poster or – the word postmaster – postmaster – a person with a sign.Tribunal:He makes posters and signs.Appellant:Yes. Then he tries to do fish – fish farming. And then coal – he mines matter – in coal all day.And later:Tribunal: Who was this person our husband borrowed money from?Appellant: A local – a loan shark.Tribunal: Why didn’t he borrow money from the bank?Appellant:Nothing can be a mortgage at home. Normally people from village are not able to get their loan – loan back.Tribunal: And what was the money borrowed for?Appellant: To do the investment in this business.Tribunal: How much is borrowed?Appellant:I’m not sure. The first loan is about 600,000 and the second one dozens of thousand.Tribunal:RMB?Appellant:Yes.And later:Tribunal:I want to talk to both of you now about something important. I’m going to first explain to you why it’s important and then we can talk about it. So I need you to please listen carefully. Now, I have information before me which would be the reason or part of the reason for affirming the decision made by the Department of Immigration. This information is important because it could lead to me forming the view that none of you are entitled to a protection visa. If I came to – sorry. If I came to this conclusion then I would have to make the same decision the department made. And what this would mean is that your application to the tribunal would not be successful, and you would not be entitled to the protection visas.So you understand why this is important. Now, I’m going to tell you what the information is and then give you an opportunity to comment on or respond to that information. You are not obliged to do so immediately. You can seek additional time to do so. If you seek additional time I will consider whether or not I should adjourn this review to give you the additional time. This is a legal requirement that I have to comply with to ensure that you have a fair hearing. This does not mean that I have already reached – made up my mind and reached a decision in your case. ...…Tribunal:[Appellant], this information relates to you. I have before me the department’s file in relation to your application for a student guardian visa. That file contains documents that you provided to the Department of Immigration. One of those documents is a letter from your husband’s employer. It states that he worked as the manager of a decoration store since February 2000. This is inconsistent with the evidence you gave today and your case - - - Appellant:That’s the one – decoration one. What I said is that one.Tribunal:You said you worked in posters and signs.Appellant:That’s the one I was talking about but I don’t know how to say it – the proper – I did not …Tribunal:This also relates to you, [Appellant]. Your file from the department in relation to the student guardian visa contains a document from the CITIC Industrial Bank in China. It says that your husband borrowed 650,000 RMB from the bank to support you and your daughter in Australia. This is inconsistent with your evidence today and with your claims.Appellant:The money needed to be repaid. There is the monthly repayment – interest. So gets the money from loan shark and then pay it back to the bank.Tribunal:That’s not what you said earlier today. You said that he had borrowed money from the loan shark to invest in the coal mining and the fish farming.…Tribunal:Do either of you want to say anything else?Appellant:Whatever more I want to add you don’t believe me.