SZSS and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

SZSS and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) [2018] AATA 4079 (30 October 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2018/4463

SZSSRe  

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member K Parker

Date:30 October 2018

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision made on 6 August 2018 under s 501CA(4) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs to refuse to revoke the mandatory cancellation of SZSS’s Class TY Subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) visa.

[sgd]........................................................................

Member K Parker

MIGRATION – application for revocation of mandatory cancellation of visa – applicant is a citizen of New Zealand – applicant does not pass character test – whether another reason to revoke decision to cancel visa – history of criminal offending resulting in imprisonment – offences involved armed robbery, drug-related, driving-related and dishonesty offences – seriousness of applicant’s offences– consideration of mitigating circumstances – applicant acting under influence of alcohol and prohibited substances – applicant experienced family issues involving his ex-partner and access to his eldest son – where Australian community would expect non-revocation – applicant has lived in Australia for the past 20 years – applicant arrived in Australia as a nine year child – best interests of two sons who are Australian citizens living in Australia – risk of the applicant reoffending – extent to which applicant will face impediments when settling in New Zealand – whether international non-refoulement obligations were triggered – decision affirmed

Legislation

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 499, 500, 501, 501CA, 501G

Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic) s 8B

Cases

Ayoub v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2015) 231 FCR 513

BCR16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCFCA 96

Falzon v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2018) 351 ALR 61

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Daniele [1981] FCA 247

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Gungor (1982) 63 FLR 441

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v “SRT” (1999) 91 FCR 234

Secondary Materials

American Psychiatric Association: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition. Arlington, VA, American Psychiatric Association, 2013

Direction No. 65 – Migration Act 1958 – Direction under section 499 Visa refusal and cancellation under s501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under s 501CA, 22 December 2014

Commonwealth of Australia, Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet, National Ice Action Strategy 2015

Returning Offenders (Management and Information) Act 2015 (New Zealand)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member K Parker

30 October 2018

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 6 August 2018, a delegate of the Minister made a decision under s 501CA(4) of the Migration Act 1958 (Vic) (Act) not to revoke the cancellation of a visa held by SZSS.[1]  The delegate was not satisfied that SZSS passed the character test or that there was another reason why the cancellation should be revoked.

    [1] At the hearing on 18 October 2018, the Minister’s representative indicated to the Tribunal that the Minister sought to rely upon the evidence…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SZSS and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 4079
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by SZSS, a New Zealand citizen who had resided in Australia since the age of nine, to have the cancellation of his visa revoked. The dispute arose from the Minister's decision not to revoke the cancellation, a decision that SZSS sought to challenge. The case was heard by K Parker M.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether to affirm the Minister's decision to refuse to revoke the cancellation of SZSS's visa. This required the Tribunal to consider various factors, including SZSS's personal circumstances, his criminal and drug-related offending history, his rehabilitation efforts, and the best interests of any minor children affected by the decision. Specifically, the Tribunal had to assess the risk of SZSS relapsing into drug use and re-offending, and the impact of his potential removal from Australia on his relationship with his eldest son and his desire to establish a relationship with his youngest son.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the assessment of risk and the best interests of children. Despite SZSS's claims of rehabilitation and his expressed desire to be a positive role model for his children, the Tribunal found a medium-level risk of relapse and re-offending. This risk, coupled with the fact that SZSS's adoptive father and sisters were unwilling to provide evidence in support of his application due to past harm caused by SZSS, weighed against revoking the visa cancellation. While acknowledging SZSS's stated close relationship with his eldest son and his wish to form a relationship with his youngest son, the Tribunal concluded that these factors were not sufficient to outweigh the identified risks.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decision of the Minister not to revoke the cancellation of SZSS's visa. This means that the cancellation of SZSS's visa stands, subject to any appeal rights SZSS may have.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons outlined below, the Tribunal affirms the decision of the Minister not to revoke the cancellation of SZSS’s visa. This means that the cancellation of SZSS’s visa stands, subject to any appeal rights that SZSS may have.BACKGROUNDInformation about SZSS SZSS was born in New Zealand and is a citizen of that country. He is 29 years old. He has lived in Australia since the age of nine and is currently in an immigration detention facility.SZSS’s childhood and family SZSS’s biological father left his biological family before SZSS was born. When SZSS was two days old, he was adopted by another family. The members of his adoptive family comprised the step-brother of his biological mother (Father), his wife (Mother) and their three daughters, all older than SZSS (Sisters). SZSS understands the reason he was given up for adoption was that his biological mother already had four sons to care for which was considered enough, in circumstances where SZSS’s biological father had left the family. After SZSS’s adoption, his biological mother had another child (a daughter) who remained in her care. SZSS has not met his biological father. He has remained in communication with his biological mother who lives in a city in New Zealand and went to stay with her one Christmas following his move to Australia. Two of SZSS’s biological brothers and his biological sister live in New Zealand and the other two biological brothers live on the west coast of Australia. SZSS says he is not close to his biological siblings as he did not grow up with them. Sadly, Mother died of cancer when SZSS was six years old. The Tribunal acknowledges that this would have been difficult for SZSS to have lost Mother when he was young. SZSS remained in the care of Father who steadfastly continued to provide parental care and ongoing support to SZSS and his daughters to the present day. Father has worked as a courier for a large transport company for the last 11 years. He has worked on a full-time basis in this job, but his employment status changed from casual to permanent in March 2018. Father did not re-partner following the death of Mother and spent his life devoted to caring for his daughters and SZSS. SZSS spoke highly of Father as a parent and in relation to the degree of care he provided to SZSS and Sisters, as they were growing up. SZSS said Sisters stepped into Mother’s shoes after her death to help Father care for him. He said he was close to Sisters, as they were growing up. He said Sisters had been hurt by what had happened (in reference to what SZSS had done). SZSS said they were not happy with him. SZSS said they were not prepared to give evidence in support of his application, despite him asking them to do so.Upbringing in Australia SZSS first arrived in Australia on a Class TY Subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) visa on 4 July 1998, when he was nine years old.[6] He came to Australia with Father and two of his Sisters. They joined SZSS’s third Sister, who was already based in Australia when they arrived. Father and Sisters (and their families) remain living in Victoria. [6] Refer G-Documents G21/110.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

SZSS said he had not taken ice for the last 12 months, while he had been in correctional and immigration detention. He said he had not been asked to undergo a urine test during this period. He said he attended the gym each day. The clinical notes of IMHS produced by SZSS at the request of the Tribunal revealed that he had been badly assaulted while he was in immigration detention on Christmas Island.[36] When this occurred, it seemed that SZSS had reached out for counselling and some assistance to help him get through that difficult time. There was no evidence in those notes that SZSS was presently taking any prohibited substances. He referred to using drugs previously, but only in the past tense.[36] Refer Exhibit “A3”.FATHER’S EVIDENCE Father gave evidence at the hearing of this application in support of SZSS remaining in Australia. Father impressed the Tribunal as a credible witness and an honorable man who made great sacrifices in his life to provide for and support his children. Father gave evidence that he is a New Zealand citizen and holds a New Zealand passport. Father said he decided to move his family, SZSS and the Sisters to Australia to provide them with better opportunities. He gave evidence that all of his daughters were now employed: the eldest daughter as a teacher; his second eldest worked in a food stand at a market and his youngest daughter was also employed. He said his two eldest daughters had families of their own. Father gave evidence that his youngest daughter and SZSS had “mixed feelings for each other”. He said there was a specific incident of conflict between them about five years ago. He said the trouble between them first started when they were living in Australia (not while they were in New Zealand). Father said that SZSS would not be welcome to move in with him because he lives with his youngest daughter, and the house they live in is owned by her. Instead, Father said SZSS would be able to live with one of their family friends, Ms TAW, if he was released back into the Australian community. While the Tribunal hopes to be proven wrong in time, the medium level risk that the Tribunal considers still exists that SZSS will relapse and in turn, re-offend in the future, weighs against revoking the decision to cancel his visa. Best interests of minor children in Australia affected by the decision Paragraph 13.2(1) of Direction no.65 requires that the Tribunal make a determination about whether revocation is, or is not, in the best interests of any minor children in Australia. In making that determination, the Tribunal is required to have regard to the factors set out in paragraphs 13.2(4)(a) to (h). SZSS completed a Department of Home Affairs Personal Circumstances Form in about January 2018 (PCF).[51] In the PCF, SZSS named his eldest son and disclosed that prior to his incarceration; he was advised that he may also be the father to an unborn child. When prompted on the PCF to describe his relationship with “each child”, SZSS states:[52]I have a very close relationship with my son. He looks up to me, sees me as a massive role model. He has a similar relationship with his grandfather. Prior to coming into custody he was living with me, they relocated to Qld for a period time, during this time I made regular visits to Qld to see him or arranged for him to come here to see me. I taught him and supported him with all of this activities including skateboarding, sports such as rugby. I have regular phone contact with him when he is staying with his grandfather, approx. every 2nd weekend.[51] Refer G-Documents G7/41-52.[52] Refer G-Documents G7/47.

Decision

Reasons for decision

While the Tribunal hopes to be proven wrong in time, the medium level risk that the Tribunal considers still exists that SZSS will relapse and in turn, re-offend in the future, weighs against revoking the decision to cancel his visa. Best interests of minor children in Australia affected by the decision Paragraph 13.2(1) of Direction no.65 requires that the Tribunal make a determination about whether revocation is, or is not, in the best interests of any minor children in Australia. In making that determination, the Tribunal is required to have regard to the factors set out in paragraphs 13.2(4)(a) to (h). SZSS completed a Department of Home Affairs Personal Circumstances Form in about January 2018 (PCF).[51] In the PCF, SZSS named his eldest son and disclosed that prior to his incarceration; he was advised that he may also be the father to an unborn child. When prompted on the PCF to describe his relationship with “each child”, SZSS states:[52]I have a very close relationship with my son. He looks up to me, sees me as a massive role model. He has a similar relationship with his grandfather. Prior to coming into custody he was living with me, they relocated to Qld for a period time, during this time I made regular visits to Qld to see him or arranged for him to come here to see me. I taught him and supported him with all of this activities including skateboarding, sports such as rugby. I have regular phone contact with him when he is staying with his grandfather, approx. every 2nd weekend.[51] Refer G-Documents G7/41-52.[52] Refer G-Documents G7/47. When prompted on the PCF to describe the impact the cancellation of SZSS’s visa would have, or has had, on the child listed, SZSS states:My son would be devastated and wondering where I am and why we can’t be together. He would not have the opportunity to have me constantly in his life to provide love, support and guidance and be the father to him that my father was to me. SZSS contends that the decision to cancel his visa, requiring him to return to New Zealand, would impact on his relationship with Eldest Son and it would also mean he would be prevented from establishing a relationship with his youngest son. The Tribunal accepts the evidence given by SZSS that: (a)he lived with his eldest son for a period of two years after he was born;(b)Ex-Partner relocated with Eldest Son to Queensland when he was four years old;(c)after they relocated to Queensland, SZSS visited his eldest son once every two months when he could afford to fly to Queensland. The Tribunal accepts SZSS’s evidence that he has not met his youngest son but would like to be able to meet him and form a relationship with him. As mentioned above, the Tribunal accepts SZSS’s other evidence in relation to the degree of closeness he has with Eldest Son and that which he would like to have with Youngest Son. SZSS gave evidence that he was transferred from prison to a detention centre in Victoria in February 2018 for a short time before being transferred to detention in Christmas Island. He said that was a difficult experience for him. He said he was transferred back to the detention centre in Victoria about one month ago. He said while he was in the detention centre in Victoria, Eldest Son had not visited him but only on account of the difficulty Father would have in complying with the online booking process involved for visitors to attend at the detention centre.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Incident #1 - Theft of petrol using stolen registration number plates on 8 June 2015. A LEAP report was provided to the Tribunal containing allegations that SZSS engaged in the following conduct on 8 June 2015:[28]…unknown offender has stolen 2x number plates [number omitted] from victims vehicle which was parked in the carport at [address omitted]. The stolen plates were then used in a petrol drive-off at United Service Station at approx 2055hrs on 08/06/15. …new management started on 10/06/15 - all CCTV files wiped at this time……Registration…listed as stolen…the accused was arrested and taken to [the police station]…and was released pending summons.[28] Refer G-Documents SG2/216&217. SZSS was 26 years old at the time of this alleged incident. At the hearing, SZSS said he had no memory of this incident. The Tribunal asked him whether he had ever taken registration plates from another vehicle and placed them on his own for the purpose of filling up with petrol and driving off. SZSS admitted to having done so previously. He said he could not remember the last time he had done so. SZSS was given an opportunity to explain why he would have engaged in such conduct. He said, at a guess, he would have done so because he did not have any money at the time. He said “that was the me then, three years ago; not the me now”. Incident #2 – driving-related and drug-related offences on 29 February 2016. A Victoria Police affidavit and preliminary brief dated 31 May 2016 states that at 10am on 29 February 2016, the police pulled over a car because it did not have affixed to it any registration number plates. SZSS was driving the car. He held a learner’s drivers permit but there were no L-plates affixed to the car, nor was there a fully-licensed driver accompanying him. The registration of the car had expired on 30 April 2014. The police inspected the car and found that it had two bald tyres and its headlights and rear brake lights were not functioning. A young woman and an 11-month old child were sitting in the rear passenger seat of the car. The child was unrestrained and sitting on the lap of the woman. The police administered a preliminary breath test on SZSS and no alcohol was found to be present. The police also administered a preliminary oral fluid drug test on SZSS. The result prompted police to require him to undergo a roadside oral fluid drug test. SZSS provided an oral fluid sample at 10.23am on 29 February 2016. The sample was tested on 11 March 2016 and found to contain a prescribed illicit drug (ice). SZSS admitted to police having consumed ice at 1am on 29 February 2016. SZSS provided as his reason for driving under the influence of a prescribed illicit drug that he was helping his friend.[29][29] Refer ASG-Documents ASG1/74-76. In SZSS’s Response, he states:[30]When I was pulled over for this offence I was not under the influence that day but I had been a few days before that. I was driving to a girlfriend’s place to pick her and her son after being abused and left out on the street by her step-father. I acknowledge that I had done the unlawful thing by grabbing vehicle plates from another car and putting them on mine but also knowing I should have called the police instead. I was worried for her safety but forgetting about my own. I am thankful that they were safe but just the way I went about the situation was wrong and could have done the right thing and went with a much more safer solution. I believe some of the offences were not all at the same time. I believe the time I failed to answer bail was because I had not been notified and that was because I didn’t have a stable place at the time. I was moving around a lot although I know I should have checked in from previous matters such as the incident above. I wish I had of done things a lot differently now where a more productive outcome could have been preferred.[30] Refer G-Documents G9/57.