The first appellant appeared in person with the assistance of an interpreter
Counsel for the Second Appellant:
The second appellant did not appear
Counsel for the Third Appellant:
The third appellant did not appear
Solicitor for the First Respondent:
Ms K Hooper of DLA Piper
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
NSD 1720 of 2013
ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:
SZRPG First Appellant
SZRQL Second Appellant
SZRQM Third Appellant
AND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION First Respondent
REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL Second Respondent
JUDGE:
COWDROY J
DATE OF ORDER:
22 NOVEMBER 2013
WHERE MADE:
SYDNEY
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The appeal be dismissed.
2.The First Appellant pay the costs of the First Respondent.
Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
NSD 1720 of 2013
ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:
SZRPG First Appellant
SZRQL Second Appellant
SZRQM Third Appellant
AND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION First Respondent
REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL Second Respondent
JUDGE:
COWDROY J
DATE:
22 NOVEMBER 2013
PLACE:
SYDNEY
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
By notice of appeal filed on 22 August 2013, the first appellant appeals from a decision of a judge of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia delivered on 2 August 2013 dismissing an application for judicial review of a decision of the second respondent (‘the Tribunal’) dated 30 May 2012: SZRPG v Minister for Immigration [2013] FCCA 994 (‘the primary judgment’).
The second and third appellants are the first appellant’s husband and son respectively.
BACKGROUND
The appellants are each citizens of the People’s Republic of China (‘China’). They arrived in Australia on 11 July 2011, each of them holding a visitor visa. On 25 August 2011, the first appellant applied for a protection visa (‘the visa’). The second and third appellants were included in that application as member of the same family unit as the first appellant: see ss 5 and 36(2) of the
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read SZRPG v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:
SZRPG v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection was a case involving three Chinese nationals who sought to have their application for a protection visa affirmed by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The applicants claimed they had been persecuted in China due to their practice of Falun Gong, a spiritual and meditation practice that was banned in China in 1999. The applicants argued that they had been arrested, detained, hospitalised, and regularly harassed by the police in China because of their practice of Falun Gong. The Refugee Review Tribunal rejected their claims and upheld the decision of the delegate to refuse their application for a visa. The applicants sought judicial review of the Tribunal's decision, raising several grounds of appeal.
The legal issues before the court were whether the Tribunal had erred in finding the applicants were not credible witnesses, and whether the Tribunal had failed to take into account relevant considerations in reaching its decision. The applicants argued that the Tribunal had ignored relevant evidence and had made errors in its interpretation of the evidence. The Minister submitted that the Tribunal had properly exercised its discretion in finding that the applicants were not credible witnesses.
The court held that the Tribunal had not erred in finding the applicants were not credible witnesses. The court found that the Tribunal had properly exercised its discretion in evaluating the credibility of the applicants and their evidence. The court also held that the Tribunal had not failed to take into account relevant considerations in reaching its decision. The court found that the Tribunal had considered all of the relevant evidence before it and had provided reasons for its decision.
The appeal was dismissed and the applicants were ordered to pay the costs of the Minister. The court held that the Tribunal had properly exercised its discretion in evaluating the credibility of the applicants and their evidence, and that the Tribunal had not failed to take into account relevant considerations in reaching its decision. The applicants' claims of persecution in China due to their practice of Falun Gong were not accepted by the Tribunal, and the decision of the delegate to refuse their application for a visa was affirmed.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal be dismissed.
2. The First Appellant pay the costs of the First Respondent.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
The second and third appellants are the first appellant’s husband and son respectively.BACKGROUND The appellants are each citizens of the People’s Republic of China (‘China’). They arrived in Australia on 11 July 2011, each of them holding a visitor visa. On 25 August 2011, the first appellant applied for a protection visa (‘the visa’). The second and third appellants were included in that application as member of the same family unit as the first appellant: see ss 5 and 36(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (‘the Act’) and r 1.12 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). A delegate of the first respondent (‘the Minister’) made a decision to refuse their application on 28 October 2011. The first appellant claimed that she practised the exercises of Falun Gong between 1998 and 1999 in China, in part due to health benefits. As a result, the first appellant claimed that she was arrested by the police, detained and hospitalised twice in 1999. Subsequently, the appellant claimed that she was regularly harassed and required to report to the police. The appellant claimed to have fled to Australia to escape this treatment. Further, she claims that since arriving in Australia, the police have approached her family in China on two or three occasions. She claims to fear that she will be harmed by the police due to her Falun Gong beliefs should she return to China.THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION The Tribunal accepted that the first appellant had practised Falun Gong exercises for health reasons until it was banned in China in 1999. However, the Tribunal found numerous inconsistencies in the evidence before it, particularly relating to the period of time the first appellant practised Falun Gong in China and events claimed to have occurred therein. The Tribunal did not accept the first appellant’s explanations, considering them in part ‘contrived’, and it rejected a medical report and a summons submitted as ‘disingenuous’. The Tribunal concluded that the appellant was not a credible witness and it disregarded her practice of Falun Going in Australia pursuant to s 91R(3) of the Act. Ultimately, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the appellant feared persecution for a convention reason or met the criteria for complementary protection and it affirmed the decision of the delegate to refuse the grant of a visa.THE PROCEEDINGS IN THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA In an amended application filed on 27 August 2012, the appellant advanced the following grounds in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia:1.The Refugee Review Tribunal has ignored relevant considerations in making the decision.2.In paragraph 87 of the decision, the Tribunal found there is “considerable variation and confusion surrounding the evidence about the period of the applicant practiced Falun Gong in China”. The Tribunal failed to consider the actual reason why the answers provided by my husband were different from mine. When RRT member asked my husband when I started to practice Falun Gong, my husband answered 1998. Later RRT member asked my husband how long I have been practicing Falun Gong. My husband said it’s more than ten years, which is from 1998 until now. When interpreter translated this to RRT member, interpreter said it’s around ten years. This misleading translation caused confusion. RRT member didn’t accept my explanation of this inconsistency. Then, based on this inconsistency, RRT member reached the conclusion that things including my arrest, Chinese police’s interrogation against me, my injury and the period I stayed in hospital are all false.3.In paragraph 88 of the RRT decision record, the inconsistency of the answers between my husband and I was mentioned. RRT member didn’t consider that my husband was in Europe for many years. We were separated during that period. After many years passed, my husband forgot about many things that happened to me in the past. I think this is human nature. I enclosed my husband’s passport copy as evidence of his period of stay in Europe.4.The Refugee Review Tribunal rejected the applicant’s claimed involvement in Falun Gong in China without considering the all of information the applicant provided.5.Paragraph 89 of the decision record, RRT member mentioned that I said I was sent to hospital by police. My husband said I left from the hospital gate. The reason my husband said that was because my mother told him so. My mother didn’t want my husband to know I was tortured by police to a severe level. My mother didn’t want my husband to worry about me too much. RRT member didn’t ask about the reason why my mother made this up. I said my skin was burnt by cigarette. My husband said I was scalded by boiling water. RRT member didn’t consider the photo I provided. The scar on the photo is definitely from a cigarette burn. RRT member didn’t consider that my husband was in Europe for many years. We were separated during that period. After many years passed, my husband forgot about many things that happened to me in the past. RRT member mentioned that the doctor certificate I provided stated that my injury was caused by boiling water. But RRT member didn’t consider that doctor’s report was written under Police’s order. The scar on my body is the truth. I have enclosed the photo of my scar. I can show you my scar if necessary.6.The Tribunal made its decision relied on the information which is incorrect. The translation provided by my previous migration agent was wrong. This misleading information caused RRT member to have wrong judgement of me. In paragraph 90 of the decision record, RRT member pointed out that I was treated for 23 days in hospital according to medical report, which I was hospitalised on 11 November 1999 and released from hospital on 23 November 1999. I have the correct translation enclosed.7.In paragraph 91 of the decision record, RRT member mentioned that I didn’t provide the summons to immigration department. When I lodged application to immigration, I have provided the summons to my previous migration agent, but that migration agent didn’t provide it to immigration department. 8.In paragraph 92, RRT mentioned “the Tribunal considers that it is implausible that the police would interrogate her harshly but take her to hospital because they were afraid of being held responsible”. But no matter what Tribunal considers, that was the truth.9.In paragraph 93 of the decision record, RRT member writes: “The Tribunal also considers that the applicant’s claims regarding the requirement to report are highly inconsistent between the department and the Tribunal.” In its decision record: “at the hearing the applicant claims that she was required to report to police every 3 days for 6 months after the incident in November 1999 and then as requested by at least once a month until she came to Australia in July 2011.” But during the interview with immigration department officer, this matter was not mentioned by immigration officer. The duration of immigration’s interview was much shorter than Refugee Review Tribunal’s hearing and the questions asked were different. I am sure there are many questions asked by Immigration officer are not same as Tribunal member asked.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
The appellant claimed to have fled to Australia to escape this treatment. Further, she claims that since arriving in Australia, the police have approached her family in China on two or three occasions. She claims to fear that she will be harmed by the police due to her Falun Gong beliefs should she return to China.THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION The Tribunal accepted that the first appellant had practised Falun Gong exercises for health reasons until it was banned in China in 1999. However, the Tribunal found numerous inconsistencies in the evidence before it, particularly relating to the period of time the first appellant practised Falun Gong in China and events claimed to have occurred therein. The Tribunal did not accept the first appellant’s explanations, considering them in part ‘contrived’, and it rejected a medical report and a summons submitted as ‘disingenuous’. The Tribunal concluded that the appellant was not a credible witness and it disregarded her practice of Falun Going in Australia pursuant to s 91R(3) of the Act. Ultimately, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the appellant feared persecution for a convention reason or met the criteria for complementary protection and it affirmed the decision of the delegate to refuse the grant of a visa.THE PROCEEDINGS IN THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA In an amended application filed on 27 August 2012, the appellant advanced the following grounds in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia:1.The Refugee Review Tribunal has ignored relevant considerations in making the decision.2.In paragraph 87 of the decision, the Tribunal found there is “considerable variation and confusion surrounding the evidence about the period of the applicant practiced Falun Gong in China”. The Tribunal failed to consider the actual reason why the answers provided by my husband were different from mine. When RRT member asked my husband when I started to practice Falun Gong, my husband answered 1998. Later RRT member asked my husband how long I have been practicing Falun Gong. My husband said it’s more than ten years, which is from 1998 until now. When interpreter translated this to RRT member, interpreter said it’s around ten years. This misleading translation caused confusion. RRT member didn’t accept my explanation of this inconsistency. Then, based on this inconsistency, RRT member reached the conclusion that things including my arrest, Chinese police’s interrogation against me, my injury and the period I stayed in hospital are all false.3.In paragraph 88 of the RRT decision record, the inconsistency of the answers between my husband and I was mentioned. RRT member didn’t consider that my husband was in Europe for many years. We were separated during that period. After many years passed, my husband forgot about many things that happened to me in the past. I think this is human nature. I enclosed my husband’s passport copy as evidence of his period of stay in Europe.4.The Refugee Review Tribunal rejected the applicant’s claimed involvement in Falun Gong in China without considering the all of information the applicant provided.5.Paragraph 89 of the decision record, RRT member mentioned that I said I was sent to hospital by police. My husband said I left from the hospital gate. The reason my husband said that was because my mother told him so. My mother didn’t want my husband to know I was tortured by police to a severe level. My mother didn’t want my husband to worry about me too much. RRT member didn’t ask about the reason why my mother made this up. I said my skin was burnt by cigarette. My husband said I was scalded by boiling water. RRT member didn’t consider the photo I provided. The scar on the photo is definitely from a cigarette burn. RRT member didn’t consider that my husband was in Europe for many years. We were separated during that period. After many years passed, my husband forgot about many things that happened to me in the past. RRT member mentioned that the doctor certificate I provided stated that my injury was caused by boiling water. But RRT member didn’t consider that doctor’s report was written under Police’s order. The scar on my body is the truth. I have enclosed the photo of my scar. I can show you my scar if necessary.6.The Tribunal made its decision relied on the information which is incorrect. The translation provided by my previous migration agent was wrong. This misleading information caused RRT member to have wrong judgement of me. In paragraph 90 of the decision record, RRT member pointed out that I was treated for 23 days in hospital according to medical report, which I was hospitalised on 11 November 1999 and released from hospital on 23 November 1999. I have the correct translation enclosed.7.In paragraph 91 of the decision record, RRT member mentioned that I didn’t provide the summons to immigration department. When I lodged application to immigration, I have provided the summons to my previous migration agent, but that migration agent didn’t provide it to immigration department. 8.In paragraph 92, RRT mentioned “the Tribunal considers that it is implausible that the police would interrogate her harshly but take her to hospital because they were afraid of being held responsible”. But no matter what Tribunal considers, that was the truth.9.In paragraph 93 of the decision record, RRT member writes: “The Tribunal also considers that the applicant’s claims regarding the requirement to report are highly inconsistent between the department and the Tribunal.” In its decision record: “at the hearing the applicant claims that she was required to report to police every 3 days for 6 months after the incident in November 1999 and then as requested by at least once a month until she came to Australia in July 2011.” But during the interview with immigration department officer, this matter was not mentioned by immigration officer. The duration of immigration’s interview was much shorter than Refugee Review Tribunal’s hearing and the questions asked were different. I am sure there are many questions asked by Immigration officer are not same as Tribunal member asked.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
By notice of appeal filed 22 August 2013 the appellants raise four grounds of appeal. They are, without alteration:1.The Refugee Review Tribunal has ignored relevant considerations in making the decision.2.In paragraph 87 of the [Tribunal’s] decision, the Tribunal found there is “considerable variation and confusion surrounding the evidence about the period of the applicant practiced Falun Gong in China.” The Tribunal failed to consider the actual reason why the answers provided by my husband were different from mine. When RRT [i.e. the Refugee Review Tribunal] member asked my husband when I started to practice Falun Gong, my husband answered 1998. Later RRT member asked my husband how long I have been practicing Falun Gong. My husband said it’s more than ten year, which is from 1998 until now. When interpreter translated this to RRT member, interpreter said it’s around ten years. This misleading translation caused confusion. RRT member didn’t accept my explanation of this inconsistency. Then, based on this inconsistency, RRT member reached the conclusion that things including my arrest, Chinese police’s interrogation against me, my injury and the period I stayed in hospital are all false.3.In paragraph 88 of RRT decision record, the inconsistency of the answers between my husband and I was mentioned. RRT member didn’t consider that my husband was in Europe for many years. We were separated during that period. After many years passed, my husband forgot about many things that happened to me in the past. I think this is human nature. I enclosed my husband’s passport copy as evidence of his period of stay in Europe. 4.The Refugee Review Tribunal rejected the applicant’s claimed involvement in Falun Gong in China without considering the all of information the applicant provided.CONSIDERATION No particulars have been provided in respect of any of the grounds of appeal, although some information has been incorporated into the second and third grounds as reflected immediately above. No written submissions were received from the appellants, and only limited oral submissions were made by the first appellant. Further, the grounds of appeal are essentially identical to grounds of the appellants’ application before the primary judge. This is not a criticism of the appellants given that they are self-represented and not fluent in English. They are matters that are important to note however, as it is not the role of this Court on judicial review to make the case of an appellant. As to the first ground of appeal, it is not clear which relevant considerations the Tribunal is said to have ignored. In oral submissions, the first appellant argued that the evidence that the appellants relied on before the Tribunal was true. She also referred in an abstract manner to an obligation on Australia to protect refugees. Such arguments as they were framed do not disclose a failure on the part of the Tribunal to take into account relevant considerations.