ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:
SZNPB First Appellant
SZNPC Second Appellant
AND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP First Respondent
REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL Second Respondent
JUDGE:
COWDROY J
DATE OF ORDER:
12 FEBRUARY 2010
WHERE MADE:
SYDNEY
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The Appeal be dismissed.
2.The Appellants pay the costs of the First Respondent.
Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules. The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
NSD 1168 of 2009
ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:
SZNPB First Appellant
SZNPC Second Appellant
AND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP First Respondent
REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL Second Respondent
JUDGE:
COWDROY J
DATE:
12 FEBRUARY 2010
PLACE:
SYDNEY
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
The appellants appeal from the decision of Federal Magistrate Nicholls delivered on 25 September 2009 which dismissed an application for judicial review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’) dated 20 April 2009. The Tribunal’s decision affirmed the decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (‘the Minister’) to refuse to grant Protection (Class XA) visas to the appellants.
BACKGROUND
The appellants, who are husband and wife, are citizens of India who arrived in Australia on 4 September 2008. On 30 September 2008 the appellants lodged applications for protection visas with the Department of Immigration and Citizenship. A delegate of the first respondent refused the applications on 21 December 2008. On 16 January 2009 the appellants applied to the Tribunal for a review of such decisions.
The appellant husband (‘the appellant’) claimed to fear persecutory harm from Hindus of a higher caste, with links to the Bharatiya Janata Party (‘BJP’), who had sold land to his family, and who subsequently wanted to recover the land because it had increased in value. The appellant also claimed that he was ‘targeted’ because he had founded a ‘Farmers Association’. He claimed he had been accused…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read SZNPB v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:
The appellants, Indian citizens who arrived in Australia on 4 September 2008, sought judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision to deny their applications for Protection (Class XA) visas. The appellant husband claimed persecution from Hindus of a higher caste, linked to the BJP, who had sold and sought to recover land. The wife’s claim was based on her husband’s persecution. The Federal Magistrates Court, in dismissing the appeal, considered whether the Tribunal’s use of video link for the hearing complied with statutory requirements and whether the Tribunal denied procedural fairness by making adverse credibility findings without allowing the appellants to be heard.
The court found that the use of video link was permissible under s 429A of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), as it empowered the Tribunal to conduct hearings via various means of communication. The court rejected the appellants' argument that they were not "before" the Tribunal because they were not physically present in the same location. The court noted the appellants did not object to the video link and acknowledged the arrangements made by the Tribunal. Additionally, the court held that the Tribunal did not deny procedural fairness by reaching conclusions on the credibility of the appellants without providing an opportunity to be heard, as the appellants did not object to the Tribunal's approach.
In conclusion, the Federal Magistrates Court dismissed the appeal and ordered the appellants to pay the costs of the First Respondent. The court found no jurisdictional error in the Tribunal's use of video link and no procedural unfairness in the Tribunal's handling of the appellants' claims.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The Appeal be dismissed.
2. The Appellants pay the costs of the First Respondent.
Note:
Background
Background to the litigation
The appellants appeal from the decision of Federal Magistrate Nicholls delivered on 25 September 2009 which dismissed an application for judicial review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’) dated 20 April 2009. The Tribunal’s decision affirmed the decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (‘the Minister’) to refuse to grant Protection (Class XA) visas to the appellants.BACKGROUND The appellants, who are husband and wife, are citizens of India who arrived in Australia on 4 September 2008. On 30 September 2008 the appellants lodged applications for protection visas with the Department of Immigration and Citizenship. A delegate of the first respondent refused the applications on 21 December 2008. On 16 January 2009 the appellants applied to the Tribunal for a review of such decisions. The appellant husband (‘the appellant’) claimed to fear persecutory harm from Hindus of a higher caste, with links to the Bharatiya Janata Party (‘BJP’), who had sold land to his family, and who subsequently wanted to recover the land because it had increased in value. The appellant also claimed that he was ‘targeted’ because he had founded a ‘Farmers Association’. He claimed he had been accused of being associated with Muslims, and that his persecutors attempted to seize his land, attacked him, threatened his farm workers, harassed him and his family, and prevented his farming. He claimed that police ‘interrogated’ and ‘tortured’ him, and that they asked him to ‘leave’ his ‘birthplace’. The appellant claimed he was fearful of the BJP, who had won a recent election and had started to create more ‘problems’ for him and his family. He claimed that he could not access the legal system to obtain redress. The appellant wife relied on the claims of her husband as part of the family unit.THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION The Tribunal hearing took place on 20 March 2009 by video link. The Tribunal accepted that the appellant was the owner of a farm in India. However, the Tribunal found that because of ‘contradictions, implausibility and inconsistencies’ in his evidence, it did not believe that the appellant was ‘truthful or credible’. The Tribunal was thus ‘not satisfied that the incidents described by the appellant, ever occurred’. It therefore found that Australia did not have protection obligations to the appellant, or his wife. The Tribunal affirmed the decisions not to grant the appellants Protection (Class XA) visas.FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT By application filed in the Federal Magistrates Court of Australia on 13 May 2009 the appellants sought judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision. Before Nicholls FM the appellants claimed: 1.The Tribunal failed to provide the applicant with an opportunity to appear before it, and thus failed to comply with the mandatory requirements of section 425(1). PARTICULARS: (i) Section 425 mandates an oral hearing at which both the Applicant and the Tribunal are physically present (giving the word ‘before’ its natural English meaning, in the context of ‘in front of’) in the one place, in order that the Applicant may present their case. (ii) The Tribunal was not present at the hearing, because the Tribunal was in Sydney, and thus the Applicant did not ‘appear before’ the Tribunal. 2.The Refugee Review Tribunal denied the applicant procedural fairness by reaching adverse conclusions that applicant claims were implausible, being conclusion that were not obviously open on the known material, without giving the applicant the opportunity to be heard in respect of those matters. 3.The applicants satisfy the four key elements of the Convention definition ... The Tribunal has not considered this aspect and therefore committed factual and legal error. 4.The RRT has failed to investigate applicant claims, specially the grounds of persecution, in India. Therefore, the Tribunal decision dated 20 April 2009 was effected by actual bias constituting judicial error.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
His Honour found that whilst s 425(1) requires the Tribunal to invite an applicant ‘to appear before the Tribunal’ such requirement when read with s 429A of the Act empowered the Tribunal to proceed by way of video. Section 429A provides:Oral evidence by telephone etc. For the purposes of the review of a decision, the Tribunal may allow the appearance by the applicant before the Tribunal, or the giving of evidence by the applicant or any other person, to be by: (a) telephone; or (b) closed‑circuit television; or (c) any other means of communication. His Honour’s finding was based upon the decision in SZJYD v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2007] FCA 798 and also upon the decision in SZJTK v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2008] FCA 1712 in which Reeves J held that the appearance before the Tribunal did not require the physical presence of the applicant before it. Nicholls FM observed that the Tribunal proceeded to receive evidence from the appellants by video because the appellants lived at Tooleybuc, New South Wales, a town near Deniliquin which is situated a substantial distance from Sydney. His Honour concluded that it was appropriate for the Tribunal to have made that arrangement. Nicholls FM observed that there was nothing to indicate that the appellants encountered any difficulty or were ‘otherwise disadvantaged’ because the hearing was conducted by video link, nor was any such complaint made before him. His Honour concluded that the appellants were provided with a proper and meaningful opportunity to make their claims and give their evidence as provided by s 425 of the Act. Accordingly, his Honour found that there was no jurisdictional error committed by the Tribunal. Significantly, s 429A of the Act empowers the Tribunal to use any of the methods referred to in ss 492A(a)-(c) inclusive, to ‘allow the appearance by the applicant before the Tribunal’, or ‘the giving of evidence by that person. In this instance the Tribunal used video facilities permitted by either or both ss 429A(b) and (c) to receive evidence. The Court is satisfied that no jurisdictional error exists, as alleged. The appellants did not object to the hearing by video, and signed the ‘Response to Hearing Invitation’ acknowledging that they would appear in Griffith in accordance with the arrangements made by the Tribunal. It was unnecessary in the view of s 429A for the appellant to be physically present before the Tribunal. The ground of appeal has no merit, as was pointed out by the learned Federal Magistrate in his decision. Since the claims of the second appellant are dependant upon the result of the first appellant’s claims, her claim must also fail. Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed with costs.
Decision
Reasons for decision
The appellant wife relied on the claims of her husband as part of the family unit.THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION The Tribunal hearing took place on 20 March 2009 by video link. The Tribunal accepted that the appellant was the owner of a farm in India. However, the Tribunal found that because of ‘contradictions, implausibility and inconsistencies’ in his evidence, it did not believe that the appellant was ‘truthful or credible’. The Tribunal was thus ‘not satisfied that the incidents described by the appellant, ever occurred’. It therefore found that Australia did not have protection obligations to the appellant, or his wife. The Tribunal affirmed the decisions not to grant the appellants Protection (Class XA) visas.FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT By application filed in the Federal Magistrates Court of Australia on 13 May 2009 the appellants sought judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision. Before Nicholls FM the appellants claimed: 1.The Tribunal failed to provide the applicant with an opportunity to appear before it, and thus failed to comply with the mandatory requirements of section 425(1). PARTICULARS: (i) Section 425 mandates an oral hearing at which both the Applicant and the Tribunal are physically present (giving the word ‘before’ its natural English meaning, in the context of ‘in front of’) in the one place, in order that the Applicant may present their case. (ii) The Tribunal was not present at the hearing, because the Tribunal was in Sydney, and thus the Applicant did not ‘appear before’ the Tribunal. 2.The Refugee Review Tribunal denied the applicant procedural fairness by reaching adverse conclusions that applicant claims were implausible, being conclusion that were not obviously open on the known material, without giving the applicant the opportunity to be heard in respect of those matters. 3.The applicants satisfy the four key elements of the Convention definition ... The Tribunal has not considered this aspect and therefore committed factual and legal error. 4.The RRT has failed to investigate applicant claims, specially the grounds of persecution, in India. Therefore, the Tribunal decision dated 20 April 2009 was effected by actual bias constituting judicial error. In respect of ground 1, the Federal Magistrate found that this ground was disingenuous. His Honour noted that s 425 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (‘the Act’), when read with s 429A, does not require a hearing where the Tribunal and the applicant are physically present in the same location (see SZJTK v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship [2008] FCA 1712). Further, the Federal Magistrate found that there was no evidence that the appellants expressed any opposition to the Tribunal proceeding to conduct the hearing by video link. To the contrary, they responded that they would attend the hearing by video link as had been arranged. The Federal Magistrate noted that the Tribunal’s letter specifically invited a response if there was a preference to physically attend in Sydney, to which there was no reply.