SZNLB v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SZNLB v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] FCA 1344

SZNLB v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP and REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL

NSD 1014 of 2009

COWDROY J
20 NOVEMBER 2009
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1014 of 2009

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

SZNLB
Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

COWDROY J

DATE OF ORDER:

20 NOVEMBER 2009

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

2.The Appellant pay the costs of the First Respondent.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


The text of entered orders can be located using eSearch on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1014 of 2009

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

SZNLB
Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

COWDROY J

DATE:

20 NOVEMBER 2009

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. The appellant appeals from the decision of Federal Magistrate Smith delivered on 26 August 2009 which dismissed an application for judicial review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’) handed down on 16 March 2009. The Tribunal’s decision affirmed the decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (‘the Minister’) to refuse to grant a Protection (Class XA) visa to the appellant.

    BACKGROUND

  2. The appellant is a citizen of India who arrived in Australia on 27 July 2008. On 28 August 2008 the appellant lodged an application for a protection visa with the Department of Immigration and Citizenship. A delegate of the Minister refused the application for a protection visa on 30 October 2008. On 24 November 2008 the appellant applied to the Tribunal for a review of that decision.

  3. In an unsigned statutory declaration attached to his protection visa, the appellant claimed that his father was a member of the ‘Communist Party of India Maoist Party’. He claimed that he was a member of that party’s youth wing, the Radical Youth League (‘RYL’). He claimed that in March 2006 his father was arrested and taken away by the Tamil Nadu Q branch state police and had not been seen since. He claimed that he had sent letters to government authorities and to the Indian Prime Minister about his father’s disappearance, but had not received any response. He stated that he moved to Bangalore in 2007 to look for work but that he was arrested and taken to Trichey, where he was detained without bail for three months. He claimed that the police told him to stop looking for his father or else he would be gaoled or killed.

    THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION

  4. The Tribunal found that the appellant was not a reliable witness, stating that his evidence was undermined by vagueness, inconsistency…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SZNLB v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 1344
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of SZNLB v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, the appellant, an Indian citizen, appealed against the decision of Federal Magistrate Smith, who dismissed the appellant’s application for judicial review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal. The Tribunal had affirmed the decision of a delegate of the Minister to refuse the appellant a Protection (Class XA) visa. The appellant argued that the Tribunal failed to provide procedural fairness and did not properly consider his claims of potential future harm if returned to India.

The court was required to determine whether the Tribunal had erred in its handling of the appellant’s claims and whether it had complied with the procedural requirements under the Migration Act 1958. Specifically, the court examined whether the Tribunal had provided the appellant with an adequate opportunity to address the inconsistencies in his evidence and whether it had correctly assessed the "real chance" of persecution he might face in India.

Federal Magistrate Smith found that the Tribunal had not denied the appellant procedural fairness. The Magistrate held that the Tribunal had appropriately considered the inconsistencies in the appellant’s evidence and had given him an opportunity to comment on these matters. Furthermore, the Magistrate concluded that the Tribunal had correctly assessed the appellant’s claims of future harm, finding that there was no real chance of Convention-related persecution in India. The Tribunal’s findings were deemed to be reasonably open on the material before it, and thus, the appeal was dismissed. The appellant was ordered to pay the costs of the Minister.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The Appellant pay the costs of the First Respondent.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant appeals from the decision of Federal Magistrate Smith delivered on 26 August 2009 which dismissed an application for judicial review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’) handed down on 16 March 2009. The Tribunal’s decision affirmed the decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (‘the Minister’) to refuse to grant a Protection (Class XA) visa to the appellant.BACKGROUND The appellant is a citizen of India who arrived in Australia on 27 July 2008. On 28 August 2008 the appellant lodged an application for a protection visa with the Department of Immigration and Citizenship. A delegate of the Minister refused the application for a protection visa on 30 October 2008. On 24 November 2008 the appellant applied to the Tribunal for a review of that decision. In an unsigned statutory declaration attached to his protection visa, the appellant claimed that his father was a member of the ‘Communist Party of India Maoist Party’. He claimed that he was a member of that party’s youth wing, the Radical Youth League (‘RYL’). He claimed that in March 2006 his father was arrested and taken away by the Tamil Nadu Q branch state police and had not been seen since. He claimed that he had sent letters to government authorities and to the Indian Prime Minister about his father’s disappearance, but had not received any response. He stated that he moved to Bangalore in 2007 to look for work but that he was arrested and taken to Trichey, where he was detained without bail for three months. He claimed that the police told him to stop looking for his father or else he would be gaoled or killed. THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION The Tribunal found that the appellant was not a reliable witness, stating that his evidence was undermined by vagueness, inconsistency and apparently ill-researched improvisation. The Tribunal did not accept that the appellant’s father was ever arrested in connection with the membership of any political party because the appellant was deeply confused as to which party he had joined. The appellant sometimes claimed that the party was known as the CPI(ML) party, other times the CPI-Maoist party (CPI being short for Communist Party of India). The Tribunal found and put to the appellant that both the abovementioned parties are different and are actually in conflict with each other. Further, the appellant claimed to have joined the CPI-Maoist party in 2001, however, the Tribunal found and put to the appellant that the CPI-Maoist party did not exist before 2004. In both circumstances, the Tribunal found that the appellant was not able to provide reasons for the discrepancies and inaccuracies in his account. The Tribunal rejected all of the appellant’s claims flowing from its conclusion that he was not a witness of truth, and that he had fabricated his core claim. The Tribunal was not satisfied that the appellant faced a real chance of Convention-related persecution in India. The Tribunal therefore affirmed the decision of the delegate not to grant the appellant a Protection (Class XA) visa.FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

COWDROY J
In an unsigned statutory declaration attached to his protection visa, the appellant claimed that his father was a member of the ‘Communist Party of India Maoist Party’. He claimed that he was a member of that party’s youth wing, the Radical Youth League (‘RYL’). He claimed that in March 2006 his father was arrested and taken away by the Tamil Nadu Q branch state police and had not been seen since. He claimed that he had sent letters to government authorities and to the Indian Prime Minister about his father’s disappearance, but had not received any response. He stated that he moved to Bangalore in 2007 to look for work but that he was arrested and taken to Trichey, where he was detained without bail for three months. He claimed that the police told him to stop looking for his father or else he would be gaoled or killed. THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION The Tribunal found that the appellant was not a reliable witness, stating that his evidence was undermined by vagueness, inconsistency and apparently ill-researched improvisation. The Tribunal did not accept that the appellant’s father was ever arrested in connection with the membership of any political party because the appellant was deeply confused as to which party he had joined. The appellant sometimes claimed that the party was known as the CPI(ML) party, other times the CPI-Maoist party (CPI being short for Communist Party of India). The Tribunal found and put to the appellant that both the abovementioned parties are different and are actually in conflict with each other. Further, the appellant claimed to have joined the CPI-Maoist party in 2001, however, the Tribunal found and put to the appellant that the CPI-Maoist party did not exist before 2004. In both circumstances, the Tribunal found that the appellant was not able to provide reasons for the discrepancies and inaccuracies in his account. The Tribunal rejected all of the appellant’s claims flowing from its conclusion that he was not a witness of truth, and that he had fabricated his core claim. The Tribunal was not satisfied that the appellant faced a real chance of Convention-related persecution in India. The Tribunal therefore affirmed the decision of the delegate not to grant the appellant a Protection (Class XA) visa.FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT By Application filed in the Federal Magistrates Court of Australia on 9 April 2009, and by Amended Application filed on 13 July 2009, the appellant sought judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision. Before Federal Magistrate Smith the appellant claimed in the Amended Application:1. The Refugee Review Tribunal denied the Applicant procedural fairness by reaching adverse conclusions that the applicant was not a witness of truth, being conclusions that were not obviously open on the known material, without giving the applicant the opportunity to be heard in respect of those matters. 3.The Tribunal failed to comply with s424 of the Migration Act 1958. Particulars i. The Tribunal asked question invited the applicant to give information additional to that which the Tribunal had obtained. (a) The invitation was not given in accordance with ss 424(3)(a) and 424B of the Migration Act. i. The invitation did not specify the way in which the additional information may be given. ii. The invitation did not specify the period within which the information was to be given.4. The Tribunal member had failed to honour his undertaking. The requirement to put information to an applicant is contained in S424A which relevantly states:424A applicant must be given certain information1. Subject to subsection (3), the Tribunal must: a) Give to the applicant, in a way that the Tribunal consider appropriate in the circumstances, particulars of any information that the Tribunal consider would be the reason, or part of the reason, for affirming the decision that is under review; and b) Ensure, as for as is reasonably practicable, that the applicant understand why it is relevant to the review and c) Invite the applicant to comment on it.It is my case that the Tribunal ignore its undertaking to give me an opportunity to make written submission about the inconsistencies in my evidence and lacked credibility; therefore the Tribunal had erred by denying me procedural fairness in respect of this issues. If I would provide a submission prior to RRT decision, I believe that I would have a different decision. Therefore the I submit that the Tribunal failed to analyse properly the “future harm” that I may face if I have to go back to India. Hence, due to this failure, the Tribunal had committed a serious jurisdictional error by failing to assess or carry out the ‘real chance’ test, before dismissing my claim.[all errors are those of the Amended Application]

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: COWDROY J