SZMDZ v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SZMDZ v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] FCA 1304

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 424A and s 425

SZMDZ v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship [2009] FMCA 559
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259

SZMDZ, SZMEA, SZMEB and SZMEC v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP and REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL

NSD 729 of 2009

REEVES J
13 NOVEMBER 2009
SYDNEY

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 729 of 2009

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

SZMDZ
First Appellant

SZMEA
Second Appellant

SZMEB
Third Appellant

SZMEC
Fourth Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

REEVES J

DATE OF ORDER:

13 NOVEMBER 2009

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


The text of entered orders can be located using eSearch on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 729 of 2009

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

SZMDZ
First Appellant

SZMEA
Second Appellant

SZMEB
Third Appellant

SZMEC
Fourth Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

REEVES J

DATE:

13 NOVEMBER 2009

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. This is an appeal against a judgment of a Federal Magistrate delivered on 26 June 2009, dismissing an application for judicial review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”).

    BACKGROUND AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

  2. The appellants are citizens of India who arrived in Australia on 28 May 2007.  On 20 and 21 June 2007, the appellants lodged applications for protection visas with the Department of Immigration and Citizenship.  A delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (“the Minister”) refused those applications. 

  3. The appellants then applied to the Tribunal for a review of that decision. The Tribunal, originally constituted, affirmed the delegate’s decision in a decision handed down on 25 March 2008. On 30 June 2008, Federal Magistrate Scarlett made orders, by consent, quashing that decision and remitting the matter to be reconsidered according to law. This appears to have been brought about by the Tribunal’s failure to take evidence from the appellant’s wife: see [2009] FMCA 559 at [14].

  4. The second appellant is the wife of the first appellant (“the appellant”) and the third and fourth appellants are the children of the appellant and the second appellant.  The second, third and fourth appellants did not make any separate claims as to persecution.  They applied for protection visas on the basis of their membership of the appellant’s family.  It follows that whether they are found to be refugees under the terms of the Convention depends on the outcome of the appellant’s appeal.

    CLAIMS OF POLITICAL PERSECUTION

  5. Before the second, differently constituted, Tribunal the appellant claimed that he was a Muslim…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SZMDZ v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 1304
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This is an appeal against a decision of a Federal Magistrate who dismissed an application for judicial review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal, affirming a decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship to refuse protection visas to the appellants, citizens of India. The central issue for the court was whether the Federal Magistrate erred in finding no jurisdictional error in the Tribunal’s decision. The appellants argued that the Tribunal breached sections 424A and 425 of the Migration Act 1958 by failing to invite the appellant to comment on adverse information and by not providing an interpreter who translated accurately. The court examined the claims of procedural unfairness and jurisdictional error, and found that the Federal Magistrate had correctly considered the grounds of appeal and that the appellants had not demonstrated any jurisdictional error by the Tribunal. The court concluded that the Tribunal’s findings on the credibility of the appellant and the lack of evidence to support his claims were matters for the Tribunal, and that the Federal Magistrate was correct in finding no jurisdictional error. The court dismissed the appeal.

The court further found that the Federal Magistrate accurately interpreted the law regarding the adequacy of interpretation services, stating that an error only occurs if the interpretation was so incompetent that the appellant was effectively prevented from giving evidence. The court determined that the appellant had not provided specific information about adverse interpretation errors that would have amounted to a jurisdictional error. The appeal was therefore dismissed with no orders for costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an appeal against a judgment of a Federal Magistrate delivered on 26 June 2009, dismissing an application for judicial review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”).BACKGROUND AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY The appellants are citizens of India who arrived in Australia on 28 May 2007. On 20 and 21 June 2007, the appellants lodged applications for protection visas with the Department of Immigration and Citizenship. A delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (“the Minister”) refused those applications. The appellants then applied to the Tribunal for a review of that decision. The Tribunal, originally constituted, affirmed the delegate’s decision in a decision handed down on 25 March 2008. On 30 June 2008, Federal Magistrate Scarlett made orders, by consent, quashing that decision and remitting the matter to be reconsidered according to law. This appears to have been brought about by the Tribunal’s failure to take evidence from the appellant’s wife: see [2009] FMCA 559 at [14]. The second appellant is the wife of the first appellant (“the appellant”) and the third and fourth appellants are the children of the appellant and the second appellant. The second, third and fourth appellants did not make any separate claims as to persecution. They applied for protection visas on the basis of their membership of the appellant’s family. It follows that whether they are found to be refugees under the terms of the Convention depends on the outcome of the appellant’s appeal.CLAIMS OF POLITICAL PERSECUTION Before the second, differently constituted, Tribunal the appellant claimed that he was a Muslim and a local leader of the National Development Front (“NDF”). The appellant stated that in 1998 a person who had converted from Hinduism to Islam was murdered by a gang of Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (“RSS”) supporters. He claimed that the killers were acquitted but they were then killed by a Muslim youth. These killings gave rise to a fresh and heightened round of conflict between the RSS and NDF. The appellant claimed that he was falsely accused of the murder of an RSS member, Lakshmanan. He stated that the police raided his house, seizing NDF documents and threatening his wife and children, while he was hiding on another property in a neighbouring State. He stated that two of his colleagues were arrested, but released, and that the RSS continued to put pressure on his wife and children. The appellant claimed that he fled to Chennai; however he was recognised by RSS workers and he then sought a tourist visa to come to Australia in order to escape harm.THE TRIBUNAL AFFIRMS THE DELEGATE’S DECISION – APPELLANT NOT A CREDIBLE WITNESS In its decision handed down on 31 October 2008, the second Tribunal accepted that a number of events occurred in 2007 as claimed by the appellant, including the murder of Lakshmanan. However, the Tribunal did not believe the appellant’s claims that that he was in any way linked to these events.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

REEVES J
The appellant claimed that he fled to Chennai; however he was recognised by RSS workers and he then sought a tourist visa to come to Australia in order to escape harm.THE TRIBUNAL AFFIRMS THE DELEGATE’S DECISION – APPELLANT NOT A CREDIBLE WITNESS In its decision handed down on 31 October 2008, the second Tribunal accepted that a number of events occurred in 2007 as claimed by the appellant, including the murder of Lakshmanan. However, the Tribunal did not believe the appellant’s claims that that he was in any way linked to these events. The Tribunal found that the appellant was not a credible witness and therefore did not accept his claims to have been harassed. The Tribunal concluded that the appellant’s evidence about his activities with the NDF was variously: lacking in detail; unconvincing; and generally evasive and circular. The Tribunal further noted that the appellant gave confused evidence about his role in the local NDF structure. The Tribunal stated that overall it was “overwhelmingly dissatisfied” and was unconvinced by the appellant’s: poorly detailed and sometimes contradictory written and oral evidence about his involvement in the NDF. The Tribunal also relied upon the results of inquiries it had made with the local post of the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, which indicated that the appellant was not one of the accused in the Lakshmanan murder case. The Tribunal therefore did not accept that the appellant was a member of the NDF at any level, that he was implicated in the murder of Lakshmanan, or that he was suspected of any involvement or complicity before, during, or after the fact. The Tribunal also found that the RSS did not have any significant interest in the appellant. Accordingly, the Tribunal concluded that the appellant did not have a well-founded fear of Convention related persecution in India.THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATE FINDS NO JURISDICTIONAL ERROR The appellants filed an application for judicial review in the Federal Magistrates Court of Australia on 25 November 2008. On 13 February 2009, they filed an amended application which contained the following grounds (as summarised):1.The Tribunal breached s 424A of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”) by failing to invite the appellant to comment on adverse information. 2.The Tribunal failed to afford the appellant procedural fairness. The interpreter at the Tribunal hearing did not translate accurately or properly, effectively preventing the appellant from giving evidence at the hearing.3.The Tribunal breached s 425 of the Act as it did not consider the appellant’s request for a new hearing. The appellant provided six separate particulars of the first ground, which the Federal Magistrate noted were not all necessarily related to s 424A. His Honour dealt with those particulars in order. In particulars 1 and 2 of Ground 1, the appellant pointed to para [30] of the Tribunal’s reasons for decision and submitted that it contained information that plainly did not relate to the appellant and was not put to him for comment under s 424A.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: REEVES J

The appellant was content to rely upon the grounds stated in his notice of appeal. Similarly, Mr Bevan was content to rely upon the written outline of submissions which had been filed on behalf of the Minister.CONSIDERATIONFirst ground of appeal In the first sentence of the first ground of appeal before me, the appellant claims that the Federal Magistrate failed to consider the grounds of his application. From my reading of his Honour’s reasons for decision, I consider it is quite clear that his Honour carefully considered all of the grounds of review put forward by the appellant, including each of the six particulars to Ground 1. I therefore reject this aspect of Ground 1. In the second sentence of the first ground of appeal, the appellant claims that the Federal Magistrate ought to have found, on the evidence before the Tribunal, that he was a refugee. Absent jurisdictional error – and the appellant has not identified any such error in his notice of appeal – what the Tribunal ought to have found, on the evidence, about the appellant’s refugee status was entirely a matter for the Tribunal. Neither this Court, nor the Federal Magistrates Court, has any power to interfere with this fact-finding role of the Tribunal. Next, in the first ground of appeal, the appellant alleges that the Tribunal breached s 424A by failing to invite him to comment on adverse information. The appellant has not identified what adverse information he is referring to. Without this information, it is not possible to assess whether or not the Tribunal has committed any breach of s 424A. However, if the appellant intended to refer to the information he identified in the various grounds of review before the Federal Magistrate, I do not consider his Honour committed any error in rejecting that claim: see [17] – [21] above. Finally, the appellant alleges in the first ground of appeal that the interpreter used at the Tribunal hearing did not translate accurately and, as a result, he (the appellant) was effectively prevented from giving evidence at the hearing. This, he claims, amounted to a breach of s 425 of the Act. On this aspect, I consider the Federal Magistrate accurately stated the current state of the law when he observed (at [2009] FMCA 559 at [55]) that:… On current authorities, this obligation arose under ss.422B and 425 only if, in fact, “the interpretation was so incompetent that he was effectively prevented from giving his evidence” (see Perera v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 507; (1999) 92 FCR 6 at [39]). Later judgments which have applied this test have considered the nature of any insufficient or incomplete translations, the existence of material factual errors which were not corrected, and whether any errors “deprived the appellant of a fair opportunity to succeed” (compare Finkelstein J in VWFY v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2005] FCA 1723 at [27], and Gray J in M175 of 2002 v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship [2007] FCA 1212 at [51]).