On 21 January 2007, the first appellant (now 48 years of age) and her (now 19 year old) daughter arrived in Australia from China.
On 30 January 2007, they lodged an application for refugee status with the (then) Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (‘the Department’) pursuant to the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (‘the Act’), together with a separate statement outlining the first appellant’s claims.
The second appellant makes no separate claims, instead relying upon her membership of the first appellant’s family group. Accordingly, for the purposes of these reasons, the first appellant will be referred to singularly, as the appellant.
On 11 April 2007, a delegate of the first respondent (‘the Minister’) refused the grant of a protection visa. On 11 May 2007, the appellant applied to the Refugee Review Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’).
On 21 May 2007, the Tribunal invited the appellant to attend a hearing of the Tribunal and informed the appellant by letter that it was not able to make a favourable decision based solely on the information before it, which the appellant accepted.
On 13 July 2007, both appellants attended a hearing of the Tribunal at which they gave oral evidence and also provided further documents. On 20 July 2007, the Tribunal wrote to the appellants pursuant to s 424A of the Act inviting them to comment on information.
On 3 August 2007 the first appellant replied, via her migration agent, submitting a Statutory Declaration to the Tribunal.
On 23 August 2007, the Tribunal handed down a decision made on 13 August 2007. That decision affirmed the decision of the delegate not to grant the protection visa.
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read SZLIR v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship and more:
In the matter of SZLIR v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship, the appellants, a mother and her daughter, sought to appeal a decision of the Federal Magistrates Court which upheld a refusal by the Minister for Immigration & Citizenship to grant them protection visas. The appellants had arrived in Australia from China in January 2007 and applied for refugee status, citing religious persecution and domestic violence. The Refugee Review Tribunal rejected their claims, finding inconsistencies in their evidence and doubts about their credibility.
The legal issues before the court involved the Tribunal's assessment of the appellants' credibility and the sufficiency of their evidence to establish a well-founded fear of persecution under the Convention relating to the Status of Refugees. The court had to determine whether the Tribunal's findings were supported by the evidence and whether any errors of law had been made. The appellants argued that the Tribunal had failed to properly consider their evidence and had erred in its assessment of their credibility.
The court examined the Tribunal's decision in detail, considering the consistency of the appellants' accounts, the availability of documentary evidence, and the plausibility of their claims in light of independent country information. The court found that the Tribunal had appropriately evaluated the evidence and had not erred in law. The inconsistencies and gaps in the appellants' accounts, as well as the absence of corroborating evidence, justified the Tribunal's conclusions that the appellants had not established a well-founded fear of persecution.
The appeal was dismissed, and the appellants were ordered to pay the Minister's costs. The court held that the Tribunal's decision was supported by the evidence and that no error of law had been identified. The appellants' claims were found to be lacking in credibility and insufficient to meet the threshold for granting a protection visa.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal be dismissed.
2. The appellants pay the first respondent’s costs.
Note:
Background
Background to the litigation
The appellants appeal from the judgment of Federal Magistrate Barnes that was delivered on 26 June 2008: see SZLIR & Anor v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2008] FMCA 857.BACKGROUND On 21 January 2007, the first appellant (now 48 years of age) and her (now 19 year old) daughter arrived in Australia from China. On 30 January 2007, they lodged an application for refugee status with the (then) Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (‘the Department’) pursuant to the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (‘the Act’), together with a separate statement outlining the first appellant’s claims. The second appellant makes no separate claims, instead relying upon her membership of the first appellant’s family group. Accordingly, for the purposes of these reasons, the first appellant will be referred to singularly, as the appellant. On 11 April 2007, a delegate of the first respondent (‘the Minister’) refused the grant of a protection visa. On 11 May 2007, the appellant applied to the Refugee Review Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’). On 21 May 2007, the Tribunal invited the appellant to attend a hearing of the Tribunal and informed the appellant by letter that it was not able to make a favourable decision based solely on the information before it, which the appellant accepted. On 13 July 2007, both appellants attended a hearing of the Tribunal at which they gave oral evidence and also provided further documents. On 20 July 2007, the Tribunal wrote to the appellants pursuant to s 424A of the Act inviting them to comment on information. On 3 August 2007 the first appellant replied, via her migration agent, submitting a Statutory Declaration to the Tribunal. On 23 August 2007, the Tribunal handed down a decision made on 13 August 2007. That decision affirmed the decision of the delegate not to grant the protection visa.THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION The Tribunal:(a)Found, overall, that the appellants did not have a well-founded fear of persecution.(b)Had concerns about the credibility of both appellants and observed that it had conducted a relatively lengthy hearing during which it had the opportunity to hear from both appellants. The Tribunal found the appellant’s oral evidence to be ‘inconsistent with some of her written claims’ and at times ‘vague and confused’.(c)Considered the appellant’s explanation about the name of the person who introduced her to the Shouters faith and the name of the aunt (namely, that the appellant was confused and nervous at the hearing), but found that explanation to be unconvincing.(d)Had regard to the fact that the appellant had only claimed to have been questioned every four or five days after her release from detention on 30 November 2006, for the first time at the Tribunal hearing. In considering the appellant’s explanation (that she had not provided all the details in support of her protection visa application), the Tribunal found the explanation unconvincing.(e)Found the appellant’s explanation at the hearing for failing to have any Shouter materials to produce, to be unpersuasive. The appellant claimed to have come to Australia in such a hurry that she had not had an opportunity to bring any material with her. The Tribunal found the absence of such material raised doubts about the appellant’s claims and her general credibility.(f)Referred to independent country information regarding the appellant’s claim to have travelled on her own passport and was of the view that the fact the appellant was able to depart China without difficulty suggested that she had not been of adverse interest to the Chinese authorities, raising serious doubts about her claims and credibility generally.(g)Addressed the second appellant’s oral evidence about her mother being a Shouter and, having considered the second appellant’s explanations for the shortcomings in her evidence, was not satisfied that she had suffered from any (psychological) condition which it needed to take into account in assessing the appellant’s claims.(h)Found that the fact there was no mention throughout the primary stage of the daughter’s ‘new’ claim at hearing to have become a Shouter in Australia, raised doubts about the veracity of such a claim and also the genuineness of the second appellant’s alleged religious activities in Australia. The Tribunal found this suggested that the second appellant had not engaged in the Shouter activities in Australia, otherwise than for the purpose of strengthening her claim to be a refugee.(i)Found, based on the evidence as a whole, that the appellant had ‘fabricated her claims of being a Shouter in China (and any consequential harm) in order to support her refugee claims’.(j)Was not satisfied that the appellant had ever practised the Shouter faith or been involved in activities relating to the Local Church in China.(k)Was not satisfied that the appellant had engaged in any religious activities in Australia otherwise than for the purpose of strengthening her claim to be a refugee and therefore disregarded the conduct pursuant to s 91R(3) of the Act.(l)Addressed the appellant’s domestic violence claims and, whilst accepting as plausible that the appellant had been married to a violent spouse and had suffered injuries as a result of domestic violence, was not satisfied that any serious harm she had suffered was essentially and significantly related to a Convention ground, including but not limited to membership of a particular social group.(m)Was not satisfied that the appellant was forced to leave China or to sell her house for religious reasons or for any other Convention reason.(n)Found there was no Convention-related reason why the appellants could not return to China and did not accept there was a real chance of Convention-related harm occurring to the appellants in the reasonably foreseeable future.APPLICATION TO THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
EDMONDS J
On 23 August 2007, the Tribunal handed down a decision made on 13 August 2007. That decision affirmed the decision of the delegate not to grant the protection visa.THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION The Tribunal:(a)Found, overall, that the appellants did not have a well-founded fear of persecution.(b)Had concerns about the credibility of both appellants and observed that it had conducted a relatively lengthy hearing during which it had the opportunity to hear from both appellants. The Tribunal found the appellant’s oral evidence to be ‘inconsistent with some of her written claims’ and at times ‘vague and confused’.(c)Considered the appellant’s explanation about the name of the person who introduced her to the Shouters faith and the name of the aunt (namely, that the appellant was confused and nervous at the hearing), but found that explanation to be unconvincing.(d)Had regard to the fact that the appellant had only claimed to have been questioned every four or five days after her release from detention on 30 November 2006, for the first time at the Tribunal hearing. In considering the appellant’s explanation (that she had not provided all the details in support of her protection visa application), the Tribunal found the explanation unconvincing.(e)Found the appellant’s explanation at the hearing for failing to have any Shouter materials to produce, to be unpersuasive. The appellant claimed to have come to Australia in such a hurry that she had not had an opportunity to bring any material with her. The Tribunal found the absence of such material raised doubts about the appellant’s claims and her general credibility.(f)Referred to independent country information regarding the appellant’s claim to have travelled on her own passport and was of the view that the fact the appellant was able to depart China without difficulty suggested that she had not been of adverse interest to the Chinese authorities, raising serious doubts about her claims and credibility generally.(g)Addressed the second appellant’s oral evidence about her mother being a Shouter and, having considered the second appellant’s explanations for the shortcomings in her evidence, was not satisfied that she had suffered from any (psychological) condition which it needed to take into account in assessing the appellant’s claims.(h)Found that the fact there was no mention throughout the primary stage of the daughter’s ‘new’ claim at hearing to have become a Shouter in Australia, raised doubts about the veracity of such a claim and also the genuineness of the second appellant’s alleged religious activities in Australia. The Tribunal found this suggested that the second appellant had not engaged in the Shouter activities in Australia, otherwise than for the purpose of strengthening her claim to be a refugee.(i)Found, based on the evidence as a whole, that the appellant had ‘fabricated her claims of being a Shouter in China (and any consequential harm) in order to support her refugee claims’.(j)Was not satisfied that the appellant had ever practised the Shouter faith or been involved in activities relating to the Local Church in China.(k)Was not satisfied that the appellant had engaged in any religious activities in Australia otherwise than for the purpose of strengthening her claim to be a refugee and therefore disregarded the conduct pursuant to s 91R(3) of the Act.(l)Addressed the appellant’s domestic violence claims and, whilst accepting as plausible that the appellant had been married to a violent spouse and had suffered injuries as a result of domestic violence, was not satisfied that any serious harm she had suffered was essentially and significantly related to a Convention ground, including but not limited to membership of a particular social group.(m)Was not satisfied that the appellant was forced to leave China or to sell her house for religious reasons or for any other Convention reason.(n)Found there was no Convention-related reason why the appellants could not return to China and did not accept there was a real chance of Convention-related harm occurring to the appellants in the reasonably foreseeable future.APPLICATION TO THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT