SZFTD v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SZFTD v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2006] FMCA 1873
MIGRATION – Refugee – applicant claimed fear of persecution by government authorities and supporters of the National Democratic Party – the Tribunal failed to address a principal claim, or integer, of a claim – jurisdictional error – application granted.
Migration Act 1958, s.414

Htunv Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs (2001) 194 ALR 244
NABE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (No. 2) [2004] FCAFC 263
Appellant S395/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2003) 216 CLR 473
WAEEv Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 184
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259

Applicant: SZFTD
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL & INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS
Second Respondent: REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
File Number: SYG 432 of 2005
Judgment of: Nicholls FM
Hearing date: 7 September 2006
Date of Last Submission: 6 September 2006
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 20 December 2006

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr. J. R. Young
Solicitors for the Applicant: Simon Diab & Associates
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr. J. A.C. Potts
Solicitors for the Respondents: Clayton Utz

ORDERS

  1. The Refugee Review Tribunal is joined as the second respondent in these proceedings.

  2. The reference to the name of the first respondent be amended to read “Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs”.

  3. A writ of certiorari issue, quashing the decision of the second respondent.

  4. A writ of mandamus issue, requiring the second respondent to redetermine the matter according to law.

  5. The first respondent pay the applicant’s costs set in the amount of $4,500.

FEDERAL MAGISTRATES
COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT
SYDNEY

SYG 432 of 2005

SZFTD

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL & INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS

First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. This is an application filed in this Court on 18 February 2005 seeking review of the decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) signed on 31 December 2004 (see Court Book (“CB”) page 78) to affirm the decision of a delegate of the respondent Minister to refuse a protection visa to the applicant. The Tribunal is joined as the second respondent in these proceedings.

    Background

  2. The applicant is a citizen of Nepal who arrived in Australia on


    28 March 2004. On 7 May 2004 he lodged an application for a protection visa with the first respondent’s Department. On 3 August 2004 a delegate of the respondent Minister refused to grant a protection visa, and on 31 August 2004 the applicant applied for review of that decision.

  3. The applicant’s claims for protection can be found in his application for a protection visa (reproduced at CB 1 to CB 23, and in particular in an attached statement at CB 24 to CB 27), in a further attached statement enclosing photographs at CB 31 to CB 33, and in his application for review to the Tribunal (reproduced at CB 41…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SZFTD v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FMCA 1873
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of SZFTD v Minister for Immigration, the applicant, a citizen of Nepal, sought judicial review of the decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal to affirm a refusal to grant him a protection visa. The applicant claimed that he faced caste-based harassment and threats due to his anti-monarchical views and alleged past affiliation with the Communist party, which led him to flee Nepal for Australia. The court considered whether the Tribunal had failed to properly consider the applicant’s anti-monarchical claim, which was argued to be a live issue during the Tribunal hearing. The court examined the submissions and found that while the applicant’s initial application may have been vague, the Tribunal had attempted to clarify and address the claim during the hearing. However, the court concluded that the Tribunal had still not adequately considered the anti-monarchical claim in its decision.

The legal issues before the court involved whether the Tribunal's decision contained jurisdictional errors, particularly concerning its failure to properly consider the anti-monarchical claim. The court referenced the precedent set in NABE (No.2) and the High Court’s decision in Appellant S395/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, which emphasized the importance of considering the basis upon which an application was made. The court found that the Tribunal had an obligation to address the anti-monarchical claim as it was a live issue, but the Tribunal's failure to do so constituted a jurisdictional error.

In its reasoning, the court held that the Tribunal had not properly considered the anti-monarchical claim as required by law. The court quashed the decision of the Tribunal and issued a writ of mandamus, mandating that the Tribunal redetermine the matter according to law. The court also ordered the Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs to pay the applicant’s costs in the amount of $4,500.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The Refugee Review Tribunal is joined as the second respondent in these proceedings.

2.

The reference to the name of the first respondent be amended to read “Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs”.

3.

A writ of certiorari issue, quashing the decision of the second respondent.

4.

A writ of mandamus issue, requiring the second respondent to redetermine the matter according to law.

5.

The first respondent pay the applicant’s costs set in the amount of $4,500.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application filed in this Court on 18 February 2005 seeking review of the decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) signed on 31 December 2004 (see Court Book (“CB”) page 78) to affirm the decision of a delegate of the respondent Minister to refuse a protection visa to the applicant. The Tribunal is joined as the second respondent in these proceedings.Background The applicant is a citizen of Nepal who arrived in Australia on 28 March 2004. On 7 May 2004 he lodged an application for a protection visa with the first respondent’s Department. On 3 August 2004 a delegate of the respondent Minister refused to grant a protection visa, and on 31 August 2004 the applicant applied for review of that decision. The applicant’s claims for protection can be found in his application for a protection visa (reproduced at CB 1 to CB 23, and in particular in an attached statement at CB 24 to CB 27), in a further attached statement enclosing photographs at CB 31 to CB 33, and in his application for review to the Tribunal (reproduced at CB 41 to CB 44).Claims In short, the applicant’s claims derive from what he said was caste-based harassment from “upper caste people” and Hindu fundamentalists in Nepal. Further, that he criticised the monarchical system in Nepal and was accused of being a Maoist by government security personnel. But also was threatened by the Maoists because he refused to join them. The Tribunal set out the applicant’s claims in its decision record: 1)In a statement, in support of his protection visa application, the applicant claimed:a) He experienced caste-based discrimination and harassment at the hands of the upper caste people (CB 56.8).b) He engaged in activities criticising the monarchical system in Nepal (CB 56.9).c) He was asked to join the Maoists by a group in his village (Gujra) but he refused and managed to “disappear” (CB 57.1).d) He was threatened by the Maoists on the one hand, and also accused of being a Maoist by government security personnel on the other hand, because he was opposed to the monarchy (CB 57.2).e) He was identified as an anti-monarchist and was threatened with arrest and other forms of persecution by the police.f) That the cumulative effect of the above instances led him to leave Nepal for Australia (CB 57.3).g) That in 1998 he joined the Communist party of Nepal (Marxist/Leninist) and worked for the party as a “low profile” activist until 2000 when he left the party (CB 57.4).h) That in 2001 he established a society called the “Elders Against Corruption Club” in his village where he was appointed as secretary (CB 57.4).i) That in January 2004 the Maoists came to the village and asked members of the club to join their movement, and subsequently took over (CB 57.6).j) He pretended he was a Maoist to “escape from their anger” (CB 57.8).k) The government security personnel accused him of being a Maoist, even though he was not a Maoist (CB 57.9).l) He was “always” harassed and persecuted by the police and supporters of the National Democratic Party, which is affiliated with the monarchy and is in power in Nepal, because they “suspected” that he was a Maoist (CB 58.2).m) He faced continued persecution because of suspicions against him that he was a Maoist activist, even though he was “only a former member of the Communist party” (CB 58.3).2)In evidence to the Tribunal at the hearing before it on 1 December 2004 the applicant:a) Claimed that immediately before he left Nepal he served as the secretary of an organisation called Elders’ Anti Oppression Club and was involved for 2 years with the Communists (CB 59.1).b) When asked why he left Nepal, claimed he had always been against the monarchy in the country and he also became a victim of the Maoists (CB 60.3).c) When questioned why he opposed the monarchy, claimed that he was “very disenchanted” by them (CB 60.4).d) Claimed that he used to be a member of the Marxist/Leninist party and was therefore suspected of being a Communist, which caused the National Democratic Party (aligned with the monarchy) to see him as a “potential Maoist”, and further made him the target of police and military (CB 60.7).e) Claimed that after he left the Communist party and joined the club the National Democratic Party kept harassing him because of his past involvement (CB 61.5).f) Stated that he was harassed by the police and army because of the suspicion they had that given his former association with the Communist party he could be a Maoist (CB 61.6).g) Claimed that he was beaten by the police in April/May 2003 in relation to his past association with the Communist party (CB 61.7).Tribunal’s findings

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr. Potts referred to NABE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (No. 2) [2004] FCAFC 263 (“NABE (No.2)”), a case dealing with a situation where the Tribunal had made a factual mistake about the nature of the applicant's claim. However, in particular he sought to rely on what was said at [62]:“Whatever the scope of the Tribunal's obligations it is not required to consider criteria for an application never made...”Further, in quoting from the Chief Justice of the High Court in Appellant S395/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2003) 216 CLR 473; 203 ALR 112; (2003) HCA 71 at [1]:“… Proceedings before the tribunal are not adversarial; and the issues are not defined by pleadings, or any analogous process. Even so, this court has insisted that, on judicial review, a decision of the tribunal must be considered in the light of the basis upon which the application was made, not upon an entirely different basis which may occur to an applicant, or an applicant's lawyers, at some later stage in the process.”Consideration Mr. Potts’s submission was that the issue for the Court now is whether, in light of the exchange at the Tribunal hearing, and the questioning of the applicant by the Tribunal, the “anti-monarchy claim” was still “a live one”, and one that was therefore required to be dealt with by the Tribunal in discharge of its review functions pursuant to s.414 of the Act. In considering this issue, I must first note that I did not understand Mr. Potts to be critical of the applicant in his description of the statement attached to the protection visa application as a “mishmash”. I understood his submission to be that the lack of specificity in that document led to the need for the Tribunal to seek to clarify and to attach some detail and specificity to the claims at the hearing with the applicant. Having said that however, I do not agree with the description of this document as a “mishmash”. To the extent that this term has some pejorative element to its meaning, then I do not accept this description. The Macquarie Dictionary (revised Third Edition) defines “mishmash” as:“A hodgepodge jumble.” I do not see this statement as meeting this definition. Further, given the many such statements seen by this Court in reviewing Tribunal decisions, this document, in my view, stands at the more articulate end of the range of such statements (noting of course that there are many cases where there is not even an attempt to put in any statement). Further, I did not understand the parties to be at odds over whether the applicant actually ever raised (at least, some sort of) claim involving his anti-monarchical views. The respondent’s issue was that it was a vague, bare claim that required clarification and explanation. This is what the Tribunal attempted to do at the hearing. In any event, such a claim is plain in the applicant's statement. It must be remembered that this statement was expressed to be “in support of my application” for a protection visa. In answer to the question in his application (CB 17) as to why he left Nepal, the applicant says “see my statement attached”. In his answers to subsequent questions relating to issues going to his fear of persecution the applicant makes reference to “see the statement to follow”, which in context, given that no other statement is in the material before the Court now, is the statement of 7 May 2004 set out at CB 24 to CB 27. This statement therefore is plainly meant by the applicant to be his presentation of his claims for a protection visa, that is, his refugee claims.