SZFMS v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SZFMS & ANOR v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2007] FMCA 32
MIGRATION – Refugee – Tribunal invited the applicant to a hearing pursuant to s.441A – no evidence to show conduct of migration agent was fraudulent – Tribunal was entitled to proceed to make a decision – no denial of procedural fairness – no arguable case – no jurisdictional error –application dismissed.
Migration Act 1958, ss.36(2), 425, 426, 441
Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs v SZFML & Anor [2006] FCAFC 152
NASF v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCAFC 162
NADK of 2002 v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2002] FCAFC 184
Re Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs; Ex parte Lam (2003) 77 ALJR 699
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259
Applicants: SZFMS & ANOR
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL & INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS
Second Respondent: REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
File Number: SYG 130 of 2005
Judgment of: Nicholls FM
Hearing date: 21 November 2006
Date of Last Submission: 5 December 2006
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 31 January 2007

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Nil
Solicitors for the Applicant: Nil
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms. McWilliam
Solicitors for the Respondents: Sparke Helmore

ORDERS

  1. The reference to the name of the first respondent be amended to read “Minister for Immigration and Citizenship”.

  2. The application is dismissed.

  3. The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs set in the amount of $6,000.

FEDERAL MAGISTRATES
COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT
SYDNEY

SYG 130 of 2005

SZFMS & ANOR

Applicants

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL & INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS

First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Background

  1. I have before me an application filed in this Court on 17 January 2005 seeking review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) said to have been made on 14 March 2000 and handed down on 30 March 2000 affirming a decision of a delegate of the respondent Minister to refuse protection visas to the applicants.

  2. The applicants before the Tribunal are brothers from Fiji. 

  3. When the matter first came on for hearing before me on 21 August 2006, the younger of the two brothers (“Applicant SZFMT” – “the second applicant”) indicated that he had already been granted “permanent residence” in Australia and did not wish to proceed with his application to the Court.  The second applicant was therefore given leave to withdraw from these proceedings. 

  4. It became apparent during the course of this “first” hearing that both the applicant, who was assisted by a Mr. Laba Sarkis, a self-styled “community volunteer”, and the Minister sought to rely on material not in evidence before this Court, and sought to provide evidence by way of assertion from the Bar table. I adjourned the proceedings to allow both sides to file and serve evidence by way of affidavit and any further written submissions in light of that evidence. 

  5. When…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SZFMS v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FMCA 32
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of SZFMS v Minister for Immigration, the applicants, born in Fiji, sought a protection visa in Australia. After the original refusal, they lodged a review application with the Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT). The dispute centred on whether the Tribunal was entitled to proceed with the decision in the applicants' absence at the scheduled hearing and whether the Tribunal properly notified the applicants of the hearing. The court examined the statutory obligations of the Tribunal under section 426A of the Act, which allows the Tribunal to make a decision if the applicant fails to appear without further action to enable their appearance.

The court found that the Tribunal had complied with its statutory obligations in notifying the applicants of the hearing. The Tribunal sent the invitation to the applicants' personal address and to their migration agent's address. The evidence, including the registered post records and the copy of the invitation letter, supported this finding. Despite the applicants' claim that they did not receive the notice, the court found their evidence unconvincing. Consequently, the Tribunal was entitled to proceed with the decision in the applicants' absence.

The court dismissed the application and ordered the applicants to pay the respondent's costs in the amount of $6,000. The decision underscored the importance of adhering to statutory notification requirements and the consequences for applicants who fail to appear at scheduled hearings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The reference to the name of the first respondent be amended to read “Minister for Immigration and Citizenship”.

2.

The application is dismissed.

3.

The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs set in the amount of $6,000.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant’s history, as it relates to his pursuit for a protection visa and the subsequent reviews of the original refusal, is summarised in a chronology set out in the respondent’s written submissions of 14 August 2006:“BACKGROUND First applicant born in Fiji 26 May 1977Second applicant born in Fiji 13 February 1987Applicants arrive in Australia 20 July 1997DIMIAApplication for a protection visa lodged 28 September 1999Delegate’s decision 6 November 1999RRTApplication for review lodged 18 November 1999RRT hearing (applicants did not attend) 1 March 2000RRT decision handed down 30 March 2000High Court – A115 of 2003Affidavit of Mark Clisby- annexing draft orders nisi lodged 28 February 2006Orders of Hayne J remitting Matter to Federal Court 11 June 2003Federal Court S690 of 2003Orders of Selway J re further conduct of matter 2 December 2003Notice of discontinuance filed 10 March 2004Directions hearing 12 March 2004Orders of Mansfield J granting leave to file notice of discontinuance 12 March 2004Federal Magistrates Court- SYG130 of 2005 Application for judicial review lodged 17 January 2005Directions hearing 10 February 2005Amended application filed 7 April 2005Respondent’s notice of motion filed 4 May 2005(Further) amended application filed 7 June 2005Respondent’s notice of motion withdrawn 14 June 2005.”Relevant Material in the Court Book The application for a protection visa is reproduced at CB 1 to CB 26. A letter from the applicant’s then migration agent (“Tahmina & Associates – Immigration Services”) of the same date is at CB 27 to CB 28. The application for review to the Tribunal, received by the Tribunal on 18 November 1999, is reproduced at CB 34 to CB 37. A letter received by the Tribunal on the same day from the applicant's migration agent is reproduced at CB 38 to CB 39. While the agent's letter confirmed that the applicant [and his younger brother] were seeking a protection visa (CB 39.4):“We now request you to please consider our client’s case and decide favourably by granting them a protection visa.”the letter contained the following contradictory statement (CB 38.5):“We would like to highlight the fact that our clients applied for the protection visa not under grounds of persecution but that of economic helplessness.” and further (at CB 38.9):“Our clients’ have no one to return to in Fiji. They have no one in Fiji from whom they could ask for help. In the event of forced to go back to Fiji, they just cannot survive there because they are helpless in the economic sense. They are very young and have no options left.” (I note that at the time of the writing of that letter, the applicant was well over 22 years of age). By letter dated 21 December 1999, the Tribunal wrote to the applicant (the exact circumstances are subject to further consideration below), and advised that it had looked at all the material relating to the applicant's application, but was not able to make a favourable decision and invited the applicant to attend a hearing before it on 1 March 2000 (CB 40 to CB 41). What exactly occurred after that is the subject of dispute between the parties and further consideration below, but in any event, the applicant did not attend at that hearing (see CB 51) and the Tribunal proceeded to make a decision in the applicant's absence.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The court book (at CB 48) also contains a printout of the Tribunal's electronic record of action taken in relation to the applicant’s case. This commentary is in the following terms:“18.11.99 Address information left blank on application - received FM ORP/SYD. K Kilby26.11.1999 consolidation check complete. J. Pniewski15.12.99 Pre-constitution check completed. A. Shamsuzzaman4.1.2000 response to hearing faxed in by applicant who will attend and seeks Hindi Interpreter. J brignell. 22.02.00 Fax from advisor – extension on review time sought. Penczek.24.02.00 'Hard Copy' of Letter from advisor seeking extension of review time to provide documents. Penczek28.2.00 Advisor rang to confirm if RRT received the letter from her, seeking extension of review time. I confirmed it to her and said the letter is in member's office and when the member looks at the letter, she will decide on your request for review time. SSri Ganeshan.28.2.00 Phoned Member re. the above request. The Member advised that she is not prepared to grant an extension. She said she would discuss the nature of the documents, that the applicant is trying to obtain, at the hearing, and if she considers them relevant to his case she may allow time after the hearing for the documents to be provided. I phoned the advisor and informed her of the Member's response. I said I would confirm this by fax. The advisor said she would contact the applicant to find out if he will be attending the hearing and will advise the Tribunal later today. S Alexandrou. 1.3.00 - 11.30 am: Phoned Tahmina Rahim, advisor, to find out if the applicant was intending to come to the hearing today. Ms. Rahim said she had sent a fax advising that the applicant did not want to attend the hearing. After checking the comments box, I informed her that we hadn't received the fax and asked her to send it through again. She said she would fax it through immediately. S Alexandrou1.3.00 Received fax from advisor stating that the applicant is not ready to attend a hearing. S Alexandrou.1.3.00 Phoned advisor re. the above fax. I said the applicant may have misunderstood the term ‘invitation’ on the invitation to hearing letter. I said this did not imply that the applicant could choose to come at another time if he felt he was not ready to attend at this time. I reminded her that the Member had already stated she would not postpone the hearing and that she would discuss the nature of the documents he was intending to provide at the hearing and may allow time for submissions after the hearing. I said if the applicant chose not to attend the hearing, then the Member would go ahead and make a decision. He did not have the option of rescheduling at his convenience. The advisor said the applicant she would speak to the applicant and get back to me later today. I said I was not sure whether the Member was prepared to reschedule another hearing, but said I would consult the Member and get back to her. S Alexandrou1.3.00 - 4.05 pm: Phoned advisor again. She said she had spoken to the applicant who had advised that he wanted to cancel everything. I asked if that meant the hearing or his application. She said the hearing. I asked if he still wanted the Member to go ahead and make a decision. She said yes. The advisor said she was currently attempting to fax confirmation of this to the Tribunal, but was having difficulty getting through. S Alexandrou.”Applicant’s evidence to the Court by way of affidavit

Decision

Reasons for decision

Further, it is clear that the Tribunal’s letter of invitation to the hearing was dated 21 December 1999 and sent on the same date. Even if the applicant was honestly mistaken, despite his confirmation that his last communication with the migration advisor was in January, or February 2001, but even if he meant “January or February 2000”, there is nothing to explain beyond the assertion of the alleged “fraudulent conduct of the migration agent” why the agent would not have mentioned to him, in January, or February of 2000, that the letter of invitation to hearing had been received by her. There is simply no evidence before the Court to indicate let alone show and explain that the migration agent pursued a course of conduct over some time that can be said to be, even in part, fraudulent conduct. Was the Tribunal entitled to proceed to a decision? I also considered these aspects of this case in consideration of a question not raised directly by the applicant, but as to whether the Tribunal was entitled to proceed to a decision in the way that it did. Section 426A of the Act is, and was at the relevant time, in the following terms:“SECT 426A Failure of applicant to appear before Tribunal1) If the applicant: (a)is invited under s 425 to appear before the Tribunal and(b)does not appear before the Tribunal on the day on which or at the time and place at which the applicant is scheduled to appear;the Tribunal may make a decision on the review without taking any further action to allow or enable the applicant to appear before it … Relevantly, the evidence before the Court is:(1)That the applicant had authorised his agent only to act for him when she had provided him with relevant information and to then act on his instruction. (2)That the letter of invitation to the hearing set the relevant time and date for the hearing as 11 a.m. on Wednesday 1 March 2000. It specified a place for that hearing. (3)The Tribunal received a response to its letter by way of the “Invitation to Hearing” form (which the applicant says he knew nothing about), which indicated that he would attend at that time, date and place. While an extension of time was requested (CB 45) by the migration agent, the agent received the Tribunal's “negative” response prior to the hearing (CB 46).(4)As at 11 a.m. on 1 March 2000, which was scheduled as the hearing date and time, the Tribunal had not heard anything further from, relevantly, the agent, and the applicant did not appear at the hearing. It was not until 11:54 a.m. of 1 March 2000 (CB 47) that the Tribunal would have received the communication from the migration agent that the applicant “is not ready to attend the hearing on 1st March 2000”. The Tribunal's decision record reveals the following:“On 29 February 2000, the advisor wrote to the Tribunal advising the applicant was “not ready” to attend the hearing on 1 March 2000. This letter was not received until the afternoon of 1 March 2000, by which time the applicants had already failed to attend the hearing. The advisor subsequently wrote to the Tribunal informing it that the applicants did not want to attend the hearing. In a telephone conversation with a Tribunal officer, she stated that the applicants wanted the application to be determined, but did not want a hearing. Accordingly, this application has been determined on the basis of the written material before the Tribunal.” (CB 56.5)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal's obligation under the then relevant statutory provisions was that it had to invite the applicant to appear at a hearing before the Tribunal (s.425), and that the notice of this invitation should be given by one of the methods specified in s.441A (s.425A(2)). Relevantly, s.441A provide that a notice under s.425A (s.441A(3)(c)) is taken to be duly given to an applicant if the document is sent physically (relevantly) to the last residential address provided by the applicant in connection with his application for review (s.441A(1)(a)(ii)). Consideration The first issue for the Court, therefore, is whether the Tribunal complied with its statutory obligation in giving notice of the hearing to the applicant. The applicant says he never received any such notification personally from the Tribunal, and that the Tribunal was therefore in breach of the relevant statutory requirement. There is some contradiction in the evidence before the Court now. The copy of the letter of invitation (at CB 40 to CB 41) addressed to the applicant indicates that a copy was directed to the applicant, care of his advisor, at the advisor's address, and also indicates that another copy was sent to the advisor, also at the advisor's address. The actual registered post record of the Tribunal, however (see annexure “A” to the affidavit of Ms. Nesbitt of 19 September 2006) shows that the Tribunal sent a letter with the registered post number “RP8696170” to the applicant, care of his migration agent at the migration agent's address, on the relevant date. But that the letter of invitation to the hearing was also sent to the applicant personally, and directly, to his home address. The home address which he gave to the Tribunal at the time of making his application to the Tribunal – an application which he confirmed he signed. There is nothing before the Court now to show the applicant had subsequently provided any other home, or residential, address to the Tribunal. Further, this address is identical with what is written on the copy of the letter of invitation (at CB 40) where the word “residential” is followed by the registered post number “RP8696171”, which is the same reference number appearing in the postal log reproduced at annexure “A” to the affidavit of Ms. Nesbitt. The applicant relies on what is set out at CB 40.3 and CB 41.9. Despite opportunity to address the evidence at annexure “A” of Ms. Nesbitt’s affidavit of 19 September 2006 the applicant relies only on his evidence that he never personally received the letter of invitation to the hearing. On balance, given all the material before the Court, I accept that the letter of invitation was sent both to the agent's address, and to the applicant at the applicant's residential address. In addition to what is stated in the Tribunal's relevant registered post records, I am persuaded to this finding. I am also persuaded to this finding because in his application for review, the applicant provided no address for service. The Tribunal recognised this as set out in the first item in the Tribunal's case record (CB 48.3) dated 18 November 1999 (being the date on which the application was received) there is the notation:“Address information left blank on application.”