Symons v Scenic Rim Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Symons v Scenic Rim Regional Council  [2023] QCATA 111

PARTIES:

DARRYL KEITH SYMONS

(applicant)

v

SCENIC RIM REGIONAL COUNCIL

(Council)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR404-22, GAR405-22 and GAR406-22

MATTER TYPE:

Appeals

DELIVERED ON:

31 August 2023

HEARING DATE:

21 August 2023

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Richard Oliver

ORDERS:

1.     The decision of the Scenic Rim Regional Council is set aside.

2.     The applicant’s dogs, Reno, Wombat and Rawhide be declared dangerous dogs pursuant to section 89(1) of the Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) 2008.

3. Publication of any information that might identify the witness Jane referred to in these reasons, other than to the parties to this proceeding, is prohibited pursuant s 66 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – animals – dangerous dogs – where unprovoked attack causing physical injury and fear – where identity of the dogs in dispute – where respondent satisfied that the applicant was the owner of the dogs – where menacing dog declarations made – whether the applicant responsible for the dogs wandering onto the street – whether applicant owner of the dogs – whether a dangerous dog declaration should be made on review.

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 20, s 24 and 66

Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Act 2008 (Qld), 60,
s 89, and s 94
Criminal Code s 7 and Ch V

Roy v Brisbane City Council [2019] QCAT 311

Brisbane City Council v Roy [2020] QCATA 147

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Self-represented

Council:

Mr Dillon of counsel instructed by King & Co

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. On the morning of 22 April 2022, Jane[1] went for a morning jog in the locality where she lives in Beaudesert. As part of her usual jogging route she passes the property owned by the applicant at 106 Brolga Road, Beaudesert. She left her house about 6:10am but had to be home to get the school bus at 6:45am.

    [1]A pseudonym for the young girl who was attacked by the dogs whose name has been de-identified. Refer to [32] hereof.

  2. As she was passing the applicant’s property she was unexpectedly attacked by three dogs. This resulted in physical injury, fear and distress from the trauma of the attack. She was assisted during the attack by a passer-by Mr Dunn. The dogs returned to the applicant’s property and she then jogged home and told her mother about the incident. Jane’s mother then reported the attack to the respondent Council.

  3. An investigation was undertaken by the Council. It was satisfied Jane was the subject of a dog attack and the three dogs that attacked her were Wombat, Reno and Rawhide (“the dogs”). The dogs belonged to the applicant, Mr Symons.

  4. On 29 June 2022 the Council issued a Proposed Regulated Dog Declaration Notice under s 90 of the Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Act 2008 (“AMA”) in respect of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Symons v Scenic Rim Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QCATA 111
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Symons v Scenic Rim Regional Council involves a dispute regarding the classification of certain dogs as dangerous under the Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Act 2008. The Scenic Rim Regional Council issued notices declaring the dogs Reno, Wombat and Rawhide to be dangerous dogs following an unprovoked attack on a person, causing physical injury and fear. The applicant, Symons, contested the Council's decision, arguing that he was not the owner of the dogs at the time of the incident and that the Council's decision was therefore flawed.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the applicant was the owner of the dogs at the time of the incident, and if so, whether the Council's decision to declare the dogs dangerous was justified. The Court considered the relevant provisions of the Act, including section 89, which allows for the declaration of a dog as dangerous if it has seriously attacked, or acted in a way that caused fear to, a person or another animal. The Court also considered section 94, which requires the Council to make the declaration if it is satisfied that the relevant ground still exists after considering any written representations and evidence.

The Court found that the applicant was indeed the owner of the dogs at the time of the incident, and that the Council's decision to declare the dogs dangerous was justified. The Court noted that the applicant had not provided any evidence to dispute the Council's findings, and that the attack on the person was unprovoked and caused significant physical harm. The Court also noted that the applicant had failed to provide any evidence to suggest that the dogs were not dangerous, or that they would not pose a risk to the community if not declared dangerous. The Court concluded that the Council's decision was therefore lawful, and that the applicant's appeal should be dismissed.

The final orders of the Court were that the decision of the Scenic Rim Regional Council be set aside, and that the applicant's dogs Reno, Wombat and Rawhide be declared dangerous dogs pursuant to section 89(1) of the Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) 2008. The Court also prohibited the publication of any information that might identify the witness Jane referred to in the reasons, other than to the parties to the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The decision of the Scenic Rim Regional Council is set aside.

2. The applicant’s dogs, Reno, Wombat and Rawhide be declared dangerous dogs pursuant to section 89(1) of the Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) 2008.

3. Publication of any information that might identify the witness Jane referred to in these reasons, other than to the parties to this proceeding, is prohibited pursuant s 66 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Council can declare a dog dangerous in certain circumstances. Section 89 of the Act relevantly provides that: (1) Any local government may, by complying with the requirements of this part – (a)declare a particular dog to be a declared dangerous dog (a dangerous dog declaration); or (b)declare a particular dog to be a declared menacing dog (a menacing dog declaration); or …(2)A dangerous dog declaration may be made for a dog only if the dog: (a)has seriously attacked, or acted in a way that caused fear to, a person or another animal; or (b)may in the opinion of an authorised person having regard to the way the dog has behaved towards a person or other animal, seriously attacked, or acted in a way that causes fear to, the person or animal. (3) A menacing dog declaration may be made for a dog only if a ground mentioned in subsection (2) exists for the dog except that the attack was not serious. …(7) In this section seriously attacked means to attack in a way causing bodily harm, grievous bodily harm or death. Upon undertaking the investigation and considering the response from the issuing of the Notice, if the Council considers that the requirements of s 89 have been satisfied, it can then make a declaration under s 94. That section provides that: (1) The local government must consider any written representations and evidence accompanying them within the period stated in the proposed declaration notice. (2) If after complying with subsection (1), the local government is satisfied that the relevant ground under section 89 still exists, it must[8] make the regulated dog declaration for the dog. [8] My emphasis The application of the Animal Management Act (Cats and Dogs) Act 2008 was discussed at some length Roy v Brisbane City Council.[9] In that case I considered the role of the Tribunal in circumstances where there was no dispute about the attack or the identity of the dog that did the attacking. The comments there are apposite here now that I have made a finding of fact that Jane was attacked by the dogs, and that those dogs belonged to Mr Symons.The Council submits that because the bite resulted in bodily harm within the definition of serious attack, s 89(2)(a) applies and therefore there is no alternative under s 94(2) but to declare the dog a dangerous dog. It is submitted by the Council that once it has considered the representations after giving notice of the proposed declaration, and it is satisfied that the relevant ground still exists, it must make the regulated dog declaration for the dog under s 94(2) of the Act. This submission in effect means that the Council has no choice, where it is admitted that the dog did cause bodily harm and irrespective of the circumstances or what is contained in the representations in response to the Notice, but make the proposed declaration. Similarly, if the legislation mandates that the Council must make the declaration in these circumstances, then it follows that this Tribunal must also make the declaration and the review process, both internally and before this Tribunal, is pointless.[9][2019] QCAT 311 and upheld on appeal in Brisbane City Council v Roy [2020] QCATA 147 (save for the menacing dog declaration).