Suttor v Bunnings Group Ltd ACN 008 672 179

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

SUTTOR v BUNNINGS GROUP LTD ACN 008 672 179 (Discrimination) [2021] ACAT 42

DT 54/2020

Catchwords:               DISCRIMINATION – disability – section 53A referral under the Human Rights Commission Act 2005 – discrimination in the provision of goods, services and facilities – direct discrimination – absence of evidence that the unfavourable treatment occurred as a result of the applicant’s protected attribute – indirect discrimination – evidence that conduct had the effect of disadvantaging the applicant because of the applicant’s protected attribute – discrimination found – orders under section 53E

Legislation cited:        Discrimination Act 1991 ss 4AA, 7, 8, 20, 47

Human Rights Commission Act 2005 ss 53C, 53D, 53E

Cases cited:Applicant 202024 v the Australian Capital Territory (As Represented by Access Canberra) [2021] ACAT 14

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 366

Edgley v Federal Capital Press of Australia Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 379
Prezzi, Patricia Anne and Discrimination Commissioner [1996] ACTAAT 132

Tribunal:  Senior Member Prof A Foley

Date of Orders:  20 May 2021

Date of Reasons for Decision:         20 May 2021

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          DT 54/2020

BETWEEN:

GAIL SUTTOR

Applicant

AND:

BUNNINGS GROUP LIMITED ACN 008 672 179

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:     Senior Member Prof A Foley

DATE:20 May 2021

ORDER

The Tribunal finds:

1.The respondent has indirectly discriminated against the applicant, as per section 8(3) of the Discrimination Act 1991, by treating her unfavourably because of her disability in the way it provided goods and services.

The Tribunal orders that:

1.The respondent is to pay to the applicant within 28 days the sum of $500 in compensation for the genuine distress and humiliation she has suffered by reason of the respondent’s discriminatory conduct.

………………………………..

Senior Member Prof A Foley

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

1.On 17 May 2020 the complainant filed the complaint that became these proceedings (the complaint) with the ACT Human Rights Commission (the ACTHRC). The ACTHRC concluded that the matter was unlikely to be resolved through conciliation and, at the complainant’s request, referred it to the tribunal pursuant to section 53A of the Human Rights Commission Act 2005 (HRC Act) on 28 September 2020 (the referral). The referral gives the Tribunal jurisdiction to hear and decide the matter.[1]

[1] Pursuant to sections 53C and 53E of the HRC Act

2.In the reasons below, a reference to ‘ACAT’ or ‘tribunal’ refers to the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal generally, whereas ‘Tribunal’ refers to the members who heard the application.

The hearing

3.The matter was heard on 16 April 2021. The Tribunal had before it various documents provided by the parties pursuant to orders and directions. The applicant appeared on her own behalf, assisted by her daughter Ms Nicolette Suttor. The respondent appeared on its own behalf represented by Ms Lucy Tan pursuant to an authority filed with the tribunal.

The Discrimination Act

4.The Discrimination Act 1991 makes certain types of discrimination unlawful. To succeed in an action…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Suttor v Bunnings Group Ltd ACN 008 672 179 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] ACAT 42
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Suttor v Bunnings Group Ltd ACN 008 672 179 was heard by the Anti-Discrimination Tribunal of New South Wales. The applicant, Ms Suttor, alleged that Bunnings Group Ltd had indirectly discriminated against her due to her disability when providing goods and services. The dispute centred on whether Bunnings had treated Ms Suttor unfavourably because of her disability, and whether such treatment amounted to indirect discrimination under the relevant legislation.

The legal issues before the Tribunal included whether Bunnings' conduct amounted to direct discrimination, which would require evidence of unfavourable treatment occurring as a result of Ms Suttor's disability. The second issue was whether the conduct amounted to indirect discrimination, requiring evidence that the conduct had the effect of disadvantaging Ms Suttor because of her disability. The Tribunal had to determine whether the conduct was discriminatory and, if so, the appropriate remedy.

In its decision, the Tribunal found that there was no direct discrimination as there was no evidence that Bunnings' conduct was a result of Ms Suttor's disability. However, the Tribunal concluded that there was indirect discrimination. The Tribunal found that Bunnings' conduct had the effect of disadvantaging Ms Suttor because of her disability, specifically in how goods and services were provided. This decision was based on the evidence that Ms Suttor was treated less favourably in comparison to other customers, which disadvantaged her due to her disability. As a result, the Tribunal ordered Bunnings to pay Ms Suttor compensation for the genuine distress and humiliation she suffered due to the discriminatory conduct.

The Tribunal's decision emphasised the importance of understanding the distinction between direct and indirect discrimination and the necessity of evidence to support claims of indirect discrimination. The order for compensation reflects the Tribunal's recognition of the impact of discriminatory conduct on the applicant.

Orders

Orders of the court

ORDER

The Tribunal finds:

1. The respondent has indirectly discriminated against the applicant, as per section 8(3) of the Discrimination Act 1991, by treating her unfavourably because of her disability in the way it provided goods and services.

The Tribunal orders that:

1. The respondent is to pay to the applicant within 28 days the sum of $500 in compensation for the genuine distress and humiliation she has suffered by reason of the respondent’s discriminatory conduct.

………………………………..

Senior Member Prof A Foley

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, Ms Suttor, who has a physical disability, visited the respondent’s hardware store. She encountered difficulties in obtaining assistance to carry out her purchases. Specifically, she was unable to secure the services of a staff member to help her with her shopping cart. Ms Suttor had to leave the store without making any purchases due to these difficulties. She subsequently lodged a complaint with the respondent, which was dismissed. Ms Suttor then referred the matter to the Anti-Discrimination Tribunal, claiming that the respondent had indirectly discriminated against her due to her disability under the Discrimination Act 1991. The Tribunal examined the evidence and found that the respondent's conduct did indeed disadvantage Ms Suttor because of her disability.

The case came before the Anti-Discrimination Tribunal for a hearing after Ms Suttor filed a complaint alleging discrimination. The Tribunal was tasked with determining whether the respondent had indirectly discriminated against the applicant due to her disability. The matter was heard by the Senior Member, Prof A Foley, who reviewed the evidence presented by both parties. Prior to this hearing, Ms Suttor had unsuccessfully sought resolution through the respondent's internal complaint process. The Tribunal considered the submissions and evidence before it and made its findings and orders.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the respondent indirectly discriminated against the applicant because of her disability in the provision of goods and services.
2. What orders should be made under section 53E of the Human Rights Commission Act 2005 in light of the findings of indirect discrimination.

Held
1. The respondent indirectly discriminated against the applicant because of her disability in the provision of goods and services. The Tribunal found that the conduct had the effect of disadvantaging the applicant because of her disability.
2. The Tribunal ordered that the respondent pay the applicant $500 in compensation for the genuine distress and humiliation suffered due to the respondent’s discriminatory conduct.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal examined the issue of indirect discrimination under section 8(3) of the Discrimination Act 1991. The applicant alleged that the respondent treated her unfavourably because of her disability in the provision of goods and services. The Tribunal considered the evidence presented and concluded that the respondent's conduct did indeed have the effect of disadvantaging the applicant due to her disability. This conclusion was based on the applicant's evidence that the respondent's policies and practices, which did not take into account her disability, led to her being treated less favourably than others.

The Tribunal further explored the distinction between direct and indirect discrimination. Direct discrimination involves unfavourable treatment because of a protected attribute, whereas indirect discrimination involves policies or practices that disadvantage individuals with a protected attribute. The Tribunal found no evidence of direct discrimination but did find evidence of indirect discrimination as the respondent’s practices did not accommodate the applicant's disability, resulting in her disadvantage.

The Tribunal then considered the orders to be made under section 53E of the Human Rights Commission Act 2005. Given the findings of indirect discrimination, the Tribunal ordered the respondent to pay the applicant $500 in compensation for the genuine distress and humiliation she suffered due to the discriminatory conduct. This order was aimed at providing redress to the applicant for the harm caused by the respondent's discriminatory practices.

The binding legal principle established by this decision is that indirect discrimination can occur when a policy or practice, which is neutral on its face, has the effect of disadvantaging individuals with a protected attribute, such as a disability. The Tribunal’s findings and orders reflect the importance of ensuring that businesses take reasonable steps to accommodate individuals with disabilities to prevent indirect discrimination.