Sutton v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read
100 CLR 518

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION 11. Income Tax (Cth.)-Amended assessment-Objection by taxpayer-Disallowed by

commissioner-Reference to board of review-Request by taxpayer for particulars w

as to how amended assessments made up-Refusal by commissioner-Request SYDNEY,

to board to order commissioner to supply particulars-Power of board to do 80~ 1958,

Statement furnished by commissioner to board-Whether compliance with regu- Dec. 18;

lations-Power of board to order commissioner to furnish further statement- Income Tax and Social Services Contribution Regulations, reg. 35 (1) (c). MELBOURNE,

A board of review in reviewing at the instance of taxpayers the work of the 1959,

Commissioner of Taxation in dealing with objections is an administrative Feb. 26.

tribunal and is not exercising judicial power. Accordingly, the basis does not exist for implying in the board a power over the commissioner as a litigant party to impose on him a legal obligation to formulate his case by pleadings or particulars or to give discovery by answering interrogatories or otherwise or to fulfil some other procedural requirement borrowed from the courts of justice. To enable the board to impose such obligations upon the commis- sioner express authority would be necessary.

Regulation 35 of the Income Tax and Social Services Contribution Regula- tions provides :-" (1) The Commissioner, in referring a decision to a Board of Review

shall furnish the Board with a printed or typewritten statement containing-

(c) the Commissioner's reasons for disallowing the taxpayer's claim."

Held, that the board has no authority to impose on the commissioner a legal obligation to give more reasons than are contained in his statement to the board.

Observations on the relations between the commissioner and boards of

REFERENCE to the High Court pursuant to S. 196 (2) of the Income Tax and Social Services Contribution Assessment Act 1936-1958.

On the hearing before a board of review of objections by a taxpayer, one Ada Sutton, to certain amended assessments issued against her

100 CLR 519

by the Commissioner of Taxation the board at the request of the taxpayer referred certain questions of law to the High Court pursuant to S. 196 (2) of the Income Tax and Social Services Contribution Assessment Act 1936-1958 in the form of a case stated, the material parts whereof were substantially as follows :-

1. Ada Sutton (hereinafter called the appellant) duly lodged returns of income with the Commissioner of Taxation for each of the years of income ended 30th June 1940 to 1953. Subject to certain specific adjustments notified to her the appellant was assessed on the basis of the incomes disclosed in the returns.

3. By an original assessment dated 13th November 1952 and amended assessments dated 14th November 1952 the commissioner increased the taxable income of the appellant for each of the years ended 30th June 1940 to 30th June 1949 and forwarded an adjust- ment sheet. [The terms of the adjustment sheet then appeared in full in the case.]

4. By notices dated 17th December 1952 the appellant objected against the original and amended assessments…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sutton v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1959] HCA 3
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned a reference to the High Court of Australia by a Board of Review regarding questions of law arising from objections lodged by Ada Sutton against amended income tax assessments issued by the Commissioner of Taxation. The dispute centred on the taxpayer's requests for particulars regarding how the amended assessments were calculated and the Commissioner's refusal to provide them, as well as the adequacy of the reasons provided by the Commissioner to the Board of Review.

The legal issues before the High Court were whether the Board of Review had the power to order the Commissioner of Taxation to supply the taxpayer with detailed particulars of the amended assessments, and whether the reasons provided by the Commissioner in his statement to the Board of Review complied with Regulation 35(1)(c) of the Income Tax and Social Services Contribution Regulations, and if not, whether the Board had the power to compel compliance. The taxpayer sought specific details concerning the basis of the assessments, the calculation of additional income, the sources of that income, and whether it was alleged to have arisen from betting or the sale of liquor.

The High Court held that a Board of Review is an administrative tribunal, not a court exercising judicial power. Consequently, it does not possess the implied power to impose procedural obligations on the Commissioner, such as requiring him to provide pleadings, particulars, or discovery, as would a court. Express statutory authority would be necessary for the Board to compel the Commissioner to furnish such particulars. Regarding the Commissioner's reasons for disallowing the objection, the Court found that while the reasons provided were brief, they did not necessarily fail to comply with Regulation 35(1)(c), which is primarily intended to inform the Board, not necessarily the taxpayer in detail. The Court concluded that the Board had no authority to impose a legal obligation on the Commissioner to provide more extensive reasons than those already supplied.

The High Court answered the questions referred by the Board of Review as follows: the Board has no power to make an order imposing a legal obligation to supply particulars; the Commissioner's statement did constitute compliance with Regulation 35(1)(c); and the third question, concerning the Board's power to order compliance if the statement was non-compliant, did not arise but would have been answered in the negative based on the lack of power established in the first question. The taxpayer was ordered to pay the costs of the reference.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.