Sutton v Cecil Tomkins (No. 2); Cahill v Cecil Tomkins (No. 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Sutton & Anor v Cecil Tomkins and Anor (No. 2); Cahill v Cecil Tomkins & Anor (No. 2) [2019] QCAT 325

PARTIES:

In OCR170-14:

SANDRA JOANNE SUTTON
DAVID JOHN SUTTON
(applicants)

v

PRIME REAL ESTATE AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
CECIL THOMAS JOHN TOMKINS

(respondent)

CHIEF EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE AND ATTORNEY-GENERAL

(intervenor)

In OCR176-14:

DAMIEN EDWARD CAHILL

(applicant)

v

PRIME REAL ESTATE AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
CECIL THOMAS JOHN TOMKINS

(respondent)

CHIEF EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE AND ATTORNEY-GENERAL

(intervenor)

APPLICATION NO/S:

OCR 170-14; OCR176-14

MATTER TYPE:

Occupational regulation matters

DELIVERED ON:

5 August 2019

HEARING DATE:

1 May 2018, 2 May 2018, 21 August 2018

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Paratz

ORDERS:

The claims made against the Fund maintained under the Property Agents and Motor Dealers Act 2000 (Qld) (and the Agents Financial Administration Act 2014 (Qld)) by Sandra Joanne Sutton, David John Sutton, and Damien Edward Cahill, on 19 March 2012, are rejected.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – where it was alleged that a real estate agent made representations as to purchase of home units ‘off the plan’ – whether representations were made – whether representations were false and misleading – whether representations were actionable – whether the representations gave rise to a claim against the fund maintained under the Agents Financial Administration Act 2014 (Qld)

Property Agents And Motor Dealers Act 2000 (Qld),
s 470(1), s 574
Agents Financial Administration Act 2014 (Qld), s 212

Cahill v Cecil Tomkins t/as Prime Real Estate [2014] QCAT 104
Cahill v Tomkins [2015] QCAT 410
Robertson & Anor v Airstrike Industrial Pty Ltd [2016] QCA 104
Sutton v Thompson Pty Ltd [1987] FCA 167
Sutton & Anor v Cecil Tomkins t/as Prime Real Estate [2014] QCAT 111
Sutton v Tomkins [2015] QCAT 411
Sutton & Ors v Tomkins [2017] QCATA 44

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

S Hogg of Counsel, instructed by Diamonds Solicitors

Respondent:

No appearance

Intervenor:

M Steele of Counsel, instructed by Crown Law

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. These two matters have been reheard together. I will issue Joint Reasons and Orders.

  2. The matters have a complex and extended history.

  3. I extended the time for filing of a claim against the claim fund by Mr and Ms Sutton, and Mr Cahill, on 21 March 2014, and referred the claim to the Chief Executive for processing.[1]

  4. I made a decision in the matter of Sutton (OCR170-14) on 7 October 2015 rejecting the claim made against the fund maintained under the Property Agents and Motor Dealers Act 2000 (Qld) (‘the Act’) and the Agents Financial Administration Act 2014 (Qld), by Sandra Joanne Sutton and David John Sutton (‘the Suttons’).[2]

  5. I made a decision in the matter of Cahill (OCR176-14) on 7 October 2015 rejecting…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sutton v Cecil Tomkins (No. 2); Cahill v Cecil Tomkins (No.... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCAT 325
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Sandra and David Sutton, along with Damien Cahill, brought claims against Cecil Tomkins, a real estate agent, and sought compensation from a fund maintained under the Agents Financial Administration Act 2014 (Qld). The Suttons and Cahill had entered into contracts to purchase units in a Gold Coast residential development, but they failed to complete the transactions and were subject to claims by their financiers. They alleged that Tomkins made false and misleading representations during the purchase process, which led to their financial difficulties. The court was tasked with determining whether the alleged misrepresentations were made, whether they were false and misleading, and if they gave rise to a claim against the fund.

The central legal issue was whether the alleged misrepresentations by Tomkins were actionable and if they justified a claim against the fund under the Property Agents and Motor Dealers Act 2000 (Qld). The court needed to examine the evidence and testimonies presented by the Suttons, Cahill, and Tomkins to ascertain the truth of the claims and decide if the alleged representations constituted misleading or deceptive conduct. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the Suttons and Cahill had suffered damages as a result of these alleged misrepresentations.

The court, after a thorough review of the evidence and testimonies, concluded that none of the alleged misrepresentations were shown to be actionable. The court found that Tomkins' belief, if he indeed expressed it, was reasonable and did not amount to misleading or deceptive conduct. The Suttons and Cahill had failed to provide sufficient evidence to prove that Tomkins made specific representations that were false or misleading. Consequently, the court rejected the claims against the fund, stating that the claimants had not established that the alleged misrepresentations warranted a claim under the relevant legislation.

The court rejected the claims made by Sandra Joanne Sutton, David John Sutton, and Damien Edward Cahill against the fund maintained under the Property Agents and Motor Dealers Act 2000 (Qld) and the Agents Financial Administration Act 2014 (Qld). The decision was grounded in the court's finding that the claimants had not demonstrated actionable misrepresentations by Cecil Tomkins, thereby not entitling them to compensation from the fund.

Orders

Orders of the court

The claims made against the Fund maintained under the Property Agents and Motor Dealers Act 2000 (Qld) (and the Agents Financial Administration Act 2014 (Qld)) by Sandra Joanne Sutton, David John Sutton, and Damien Edward Cahill, on 19 March 2012, are rejected.

Background

Background to the litigation

These are my reasons on the reconsideration of the matter as directed by the Appeal Tribunal, in respect of the claims by the Suttons and Mr Cahill in so far as they are based on the alleged misrepresentations of the Respondents.Facts giving rise to the claim The facts giving rise to the claim were set out in my earlier decisions.[4] For convenience, I will reproduce relevant extracts in these reasons.[4]Sutton v Tomkins [2015] QCAT 411; Cahill v Tomkins [2015] QCAT 410. Mr Tomkins was a Real Estate Agent. He was involved in transactions whereby Sandra Sutton and Mr Cahill signed contracts to purchase lots ‘off the plan’ in 2008 in a residential unit development on the Gold Coast known as ‘Elston’ at the corner of Hamilton Avenue and Surfers Paradise Boulevard. They allege that actions of Mr Tomkins, and loss suffered by them, give rise to their entitlement to claim on the Fund. Ms Sutton entered into a contract to buy a unit on Level 3 - Lot 24 for $469,000. The contract was entered into on 23 January 2008. An initial deposit of $1,000.00 was payable. Arrangements were made for the balance of the 10% deposit of $45,900 to be provided by means of a Deposit Bond provided by QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited by its authorised agent Deposit Access Pty Ltd. The application for the deposit bond was signed on 29 February 2008 and it was issued on 4 March 2008. Mr Sutton signed as Guarantor for the Deposit Bond. The price of the lot 24 Deposit Bond was $4,845 which was paid by Ms Sutton. The Contract was due to settle on 14 August 2009. The Suttons failed to complete the contract. On 14 October 2009, Ramsden Bow Lawyers, acting for the Vendor, wrote to the Solicitors for the Suttons advising them that the Seller terminated the contract and had directed that the deposit bond be called on immediately. On 14 December 2010 QBE paid the amount of $46,900 to the Vendor under the lot 24 bond. QBE instituted proceedings against Sandra Joanne Sutton and David John Sutton in the Local Court of NSW. An amended Statement of Claim was dated 20 July 2011. The claim was for a total of $50,770.16 being $47,340 for claim plus interest and fees and costs. The basis of the claim against David Sutton was under a Guarantee written and contained in the deposit bond application dated 29 February 2008. Judgment was given for QBE against Sandra Sutton and David Sutton on 29 February 2012 as per a Consent Order for the amount of $103,243.14. The judgment was entered on 3 April 2012. Mr Cahill entered into contracts to buy two units on Level 3 - Lot 22 for $468,000 and Lot 23 for $469,000. The contracts were entered into on 25 January 2008. Arrangements were made for the 10% deposit of $46,800 and $46,900 to be provided by means of a Deposit Bond provided by QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited by its authorised agent Deposit Access Pty Ltd. The deposit bonds were issued on 28 February 2008. The price of the lot 22 Deposit Bond was $4,845, and the price of the lot 23 Deposit Bond was $4,845, making a total of $9,690.00 which was paid by Mr Cahill.[5][5]Affidavit of Mr Cahill sworn 12 October 2011, [7].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Judgment was given for QBE against Mr Cahill on 29 February 2012 as per a Consent Order for the amount of $157,711.93. Evidence of the Suttons and Mr Cahill Ms Sutton gave evidence that she met the real estate agent, Mr Tomkins once or twice at Will Jamieson’s house. She said that Mr Jamieson was a ‘bit of a friend’ who had helped her with Body Corporate issues when she had a Body Corporate.[6][6]Transcript 2-31, Line 41. She said that Mr Jamieson rang and told her that Mr Tomkins was selling units in a complex on the Gold Coast, and said that it was only a $5,000 deposit, roughly, that’s all you had to pay.[7][7]Transcript 2-32, Line 18. She said that Mr Jamieson took her into the Tomkins Real Estate office in January 2008, and introduced her to Mr Tomkins, who introduced the receptionist as his wife. She said that she was not really able to recall what Mr Tomkins said to her, but that he brought out a brochure and a plan of the units, and explained how the deposit access process worked. She recalled that Mr Tomkins said that you had to pay about $50,000 deposit normally, but you didn’t have to pay that. She described what she was told about the deposit in the following way:[8]Q: What did Mr Tomkins say to you about the deposit access?A: That – that it was set up that you didn’t have to pay the 50,000, you just paid 4,000 whatever it was and that was a holding deposit on the unit. If you ever did default then it would go to the – that you would have to pay the original amount of the deposit. But it was set up that you didn’t have to do that and – and then he would be on-selling the units so that you never actually owned the unit. That he would on-sell the units before the units were completed.Q: Right. So, you used the word, or the words ‘set up ‘so that you wouldn’t own the units. Can you remember exactly what Mr Tomkins said to you?A: He just – he just said that you never owned - your name would never be on the documents that - it doesn’t show that you actually owned the units as such, it’s just a holding thing that was going to get sales for the developer. That showed that the developer had sold so many units. And then your name was just there showing that he’d just sold the units, but then it would be on-sold to Asian buyers before the units were completed.[8]Transcript 2-33, Line 10. She was asked what she would have done if she had known she had to pay the full deposit, or complete the contract, and replied as follows:[9]Mr Hogg: What would you have done if you’d known that you may have had to pay the deposit amount if you couldn’t – if you couldn’t complete the contract?Witness: If I’d had to pay $50,000 I wouldn’t have gone into it at all, because we couldn’t afford to do that.Mr Hogg: And what would you have done if you had known that you would have had to complete the contract if Mr Tomkins couldn’t sell on time?A: I wouldn’t have gone ahead with it. He didn’t indicate that there would be a problem, he said he did it all the time and that it wasn’t a problem.[9]Transcript 2-34, Line 19.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Consequently, even if Mr Tomkins had made the representation pleaded at paragraph 4(d), it is not established that it was not reasonable for him to have formed that belief, and that it was false or misleading for him to have expressed that reasonable belief to Ms Sutton and Mr Cahill.Conclusion Whilst it may be seen that the Suttons and Mr Cahill have acted in a gullible way, they did elect to enter into commercial transactions with a view to making a profit. I note that I:(a)have sympathy for the unfortunate financial position which the Suttons and Mr Cahill have found themselves in; (b)recognise the personal strains that this has put upon them; (c)have concerns that they received poor commercial, and other, advice from Mr Jamieson; and (d)have queries as to their dealings with their former Solicitor, Mr Gray. I also note that I did caution them back in 2014, when I granted leave for an extension of time for them to bring these claims, as to their prospects of success:[88][56] I have doubts as to whether the Suttons will ultimately be able to overcome the hurdles highlighted by the Chief Executive, and I would urge them to consider further action carefully as to its utility. That said, I am reluctant to deny them the opportunity to pursue the claim if they seek to do so, and consider they can establish it within the Act.…[64] For the reasons discussed, I am satisfied the requirements of s 511 are made out, and allow the extension of time, although I do so with the notes of caution I have made.[88]Sutton & Anor v Cecil Tomkins t/as Prime Real Estate [2014] QCAT 111, [56] and [64]; and similarly in Cahill v Cecil Tomkins t/as Prime Real Estate [2014] QCAT 104. I have reconsidered the claims according to law in respect of the claims insofar as they are based on the alleged misrepresentations of the Respondents. I have considered each of the alleged representations which were pursued, being 4(d), (e), (f), (g) and (h). I have considered the submissions made by the parties, and the evidence. I am not satisfied that any of the alleged representations are shown to have been actionable representations made by Mr Tomkins to Mr or Ms Sutton, or Mr Cahill, which come within section 574 of the Property Agents and Motor Dealers Act 2000 (Qld), and give rise to a claim upon the fund under that Act. I reject the claims made by Sandra Joanne Sutton, David John Sutton, and Damien Edward Cahill against the fund.