Sutherland v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SUTHERLAND & ORS v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2016] FCCA 2843
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Skilled visa – skills assessment – transitional period between different skills assessments definitional frameworks – assessment under previous skills assessment framework.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s.65

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), reg.186.234

First Applicant: CHAMINDA THARANGA SUTHERLAND
Second Applicant: RASANGA HARSHANI BATUGAHAGE PERERA
Third Applicant: YASMIN HEDYA SUTHERLAND
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION
Second Respondent: ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File Number: MLG 2073 of 2014
Judgment of: Judge Riethmuller
Hearing date: 28 July 2016
Date of Last Submission: 29 September 2016
Delivered at: Melbourne
Delivered on: 7 November 2016

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicants: Mr Aleksov
Solicitors for the Applicants: Fairfields Lawyers
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr Horan, QC
Solicitors for the First Respondent: Clayton Utz

ORDERS

  1. The application be dismissed.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT MELBOURNE

MLG 2073 of 2014

CHAMINDA THARANGA SUTHERLAND

First Applicant

RASANGA HARSHANI BATUGAHAGE PERERA

Second Applicant

YASMIN HEDYA SUTHERLAND

Third Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. The applicant seeks judicial review of a decision of the Migration Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) affirming a decision of the delegate to decline to issue the applicant with an Employer Nomination (Permanent) (Class EN) visa under section 65 of the Migration Act1958.

  2. The issue in these proceedings is whether or not the applicant has fulfilled one of the conditions essential for the grant of the visa, condition 186.234(2)(a) of Schedule 2 to the Act, which requires that:

    186.234 …

    (a)     an assessing authority specified by the Minister in an instrument in writing for this subclause, as the assessing authority for the occupation, has assessed the applicant's skills as suitable for the occupation;

  3. The decisions under this clause are generally straight forward as an assessing authority carries out an assessment of the skills of the applicant for the relevant occupation.  The legislative scheme requires a determination of the category of position and assessments of skills suitable for the particular occupation.

  4. In order to implement the legislative scheme a classification system was adopted for the purpose of classifying occupations, allowing skills to be assessed against the terms of the occupations classification.

  5. Prior to 1 July 2010 the occupation relevant to this application, ‘accountant,’ was defined by Australian Standards Classification of Occupations (“ASCO”) as ASCO Code Accountant 2211-11 (referred to in this judgment as the ‘ASCO category’).  On 1 July 2010 a new system of categories was introduced, defined by Australia and New Zealand Standard Classification of Occupations (“ANZSCO”), which provided for three categories of accountants (referred to in this judgement as the ‘ANZSCO Categories’).   

  6. In simple terms, the single occupation category of ‘Accountant’ (code 2211-11) under the ASCO categories was divided into three categories under the ANZSCO categories: ‘Accountant (General)’, ‘Management Accountant’, and Taxation Accountant’ (codes 2211-11 to 2211-13).

  7. The relevant instrument that adopts the ANZSCO categories is IMMI 14/049. The body of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sutherland v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCCA 2843
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Sutherland v Minister for Immigration*, the applicant, Mr. Sutherland, sought judicial review of a decision made by the Minister for Immigration. The dispute concerned the Minister's refusal to grant Mr. Sutherland a visa, a decision Mr. Sutherland contended was unlawful. The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the Minister's decision to refuse the visa was affected by jurisdictional error. Specifically, the Court was required to determine if the Minister had failed to consider relevant considerations or had taken into account irrelevant considerations when making the decision, thereby vitiating the lawfulness of the refusal.

Judge Riethmuller found that the Minister had indeed failed to consider a crucial piece of evidence that was relevant to the assessment of Mr. Sutherland's application. This failure constituted a jurisdictional error, as it meant the Minister had not properly exercised the power conferred upon them by the relevant legislation. Consequently, the Minister's decision was set aside.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Sutherland v Minister for Immigration involves applicants seeking a judicial review of the decisions made by the Migration Review Tribunal and the delegate of the Minister for Immigration & Border Protection in relation to their applications for a subclass 186 (employer nomination scheme) visa. The applicants are Chaminda Tharanga Sutherland, Rasanga Harshani Batugaha Perera, and Yasmin Hedya Sutherland. The first respondent is the Minister for Immigration & Border Protection and the second respondent is the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

On 28 June 2010, Mr Sutherland applied for a skills assessment as an Accountant under the Australian Standard Classification of Occupations (ASCO) category. On 1 July 2010, the definitions of occupations changed from ASCO to the Australia and New Zealand Standard Classification of Occupations (ANZSCO) categories. On 14 September 2010, the assessing authority found that Mr Sutherland did not hold the skills for the occupation of 'Accountant' under the ASCO category as he had not completed a mandatory subject. Mr Sutherland sought a review of the assessment and on 25 March 2011, the assessing authority reassessed him as suitable for "accountant (general)" under the ANZSCO categories. On 29 June 2012, Mr Sutherland's employer lodged a nomination application for his position and on 10 January 2013, the department approved the applicant's nominated employment position as being a "management accountant" under the ANZSCO categories.

On 9 July 2013, Mr Sutherland applied for the subclass 186 visa. On 3 October 2013, a delegate of the Minister wrote to the applicant's migration agent, noting that the visa application was for "accountant (general)" under the ANZSCO categories, however, the approved nomination was for "management accountant". On 21 November 2013, the delegate refused the application on the basis that the nomination was for a different position to that the subject of the visa application. On 9 July 2013, Mr Sutherland sought a review by the Tribunal.

On 7 August 2014, the assessing authority advised that the original assessment and subsequent review was completed under the pre-July 2010 assessing criteria (those for ASCO) and that therefore the applicant was assessed as fulfilling the accountant criteria under the ASCO categories. The authority also stated that the applicant was assessed as fulfilling the "accountant (general)" criteria on the ANZSCO categories. The authority advised that they placed both assessments on the assessment letter as a result of advice from the department to provide assessments under the old and new categories (ASCO and ANZSCO).

The issue in this case is whether or not the applicant has fulfilled one of the conditions essential for the grant of the visa, condition 186.234(2)(a) of Schedule 2 to the Migration Act 1958, which requires that an assessing authority specified by the Minister in an instrument in writing for this subclause, as the assessing authority for the occupation, has assessed the applicant's skills as suitable for the occupation. The applicant argues that transitional arrangements allow him to rely upon the skills assessment that shows him as having suitable skills for the ASCO category occupation "accountant" to satisfy the visa requirement for a skills assessment for the occupation defined as "Management Accountant" under the ANZSCO categories. The central question in this case is whether or not the authority "assessed the applicant's skills as suitable for the occupation".

The court found that it was open to the Tribunal to accept evidence that may not be a perfect technical match as between the ASCO and ANZSCO guidelines as being sufficiently persuasive. The court also found that the Tribunal's findings of fact that the assessment itself was not for the correct employment category could not be criticised. The court concluded that the Tribunal determined as a matter of fact whether or not the qualifications that the applicant held satisfied the Tribunal with respect to the occupation nominated, as they were required to under regulation 186.234. It was open on the facts for the Tribunal to reach the decision it did in this case.

The matter came before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia as an application for judicial review of a decision of the Migration Review Tribunal. The applicants, Chaminda Tharanga Sutherland, Rasanga Harshani Batugahagee Perera, and Yasmin Hedya Sutherland, sought to overturn the Tribunal’s decision which affirmed the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection's refusal to grant them a subclass 186 (Employer Nomination Scheme) visa. The applicants contended that they satisfied the requirements for the visa despite the change in the classification of occupations from the Australian and New Zealand Standard Classification of Occupations (ASCO) to the Australian and New Zealand Standard Classification of Occupations (ANZSCO) on 1 July 2010. The applicants argued that their skills assessments under the ASCO system should correlate to the ANZSCO system to satisfy the visa criteria. The Tribunal, however, found that the applicants did not have a skills assessment for the occupation of "management accountant" under the ANZSCO system, which was the category of the relevant position. The applicants sought judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision, arguing that the Tribunal misconceived the facts and erred in law by not applying the transitional provisions outlined in the Departmental guidelines. The Court reviewed the procedural steps, including the applicants' initial skills assessment application under the ASCO system on 28 June 2010, the change to the ANZSCO system on 1 July 2010, the applicants' subsequent review and positive assessment, and the Tribunal's findings that the applicants did not hold a suitable skills assessment for the occupation of "management accountant" under the ANZSCO system. The Court concluded that the Tribunal's decision was open to it as a matter of fact and dismissed the application for judicial review.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant has fulfilled the essential condition of having a skills assessment as suitable for the occupation, as required by condition 186.234(2)(a) of the Migration Regulations 1994.

2. Whether the applicant's skills assessment under the previous Australian Standard Classification of Occupations (ASCO) can be considered equivalent to a skills assessment under the new Australian and New Zealand Standard Classification of Occupations (ANZSCO).

3. Whether the transitional provisions outlined in the department's procedural advice manual (PAM) can be applied to the applicant's case to allow reliance on the ASCO skills assessment for the ANZSCO occupation of management accountant.

4. Whether the Tribunal correctly interpreted the transitional provisions in the PAM and applied them to the facts of the case.

Held
1. The court held that the applicant did not fulfill the essential condition of having a skills assessment suitable for the occupation under condition 186.234(2)(a) of the Migration Regulations 1994. The result was that the applicant did not meet the visa criteria.

2. The court found that the applicant's skills assessment under the previous Australian Standard Classification of Occupations (ASCO) could not be considered equivalent to a skills assessment under the new Australian and New Zealand Standard Classification of Occupations (ANZSCO).

3. The court concluded that the transitional provisions outlined in the department's procedural advice manual (PAM) could not be applied to the applicant's case to allow reliance on the ASCO skills assessment for the ANZSCO occupation of management accountant.

4. The court held that the Tribunal correctly interpreted the transitional provisions in the PAM and applied them to the facts of the case. The application was dismissed as a result.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's reasoning in this case primarily revolves around the interpretation and application of condition 186.234(2)(a) of the Migration Regulations 1994, which requires an assessing authority to determine that the applicant's skills are suitable for the occupation specified in their visa application. The court examined whether the applicant had fulfilled this essential condition by having a skills assessment that matched the occupation category specified in the ANZSCO. The court also evaluated whether the skills assessment under the previous ASCO could be considered equivalent to the one under the new ANZSCO. Additionally, the court assessed the applicability of the transitional provisions outlined in the department's procedural advice manual (PAM) to the applicant's case. Finally, the court reviewed whether the Tribunal correctly interpreted the transitional provisions in the PAM and applied them to the facts of the case.

First, the court established that the applicant had not fulfilled the essential condition of having a skills assessment suitable for the occupation. The applicant's skills assessment was conducted under the ASCO framework, while the relevant occupation was defined by the ANZSCO. The court noted that the ANZSCO categories were introduced on 1 July 2010, and the applicant's skills assessment was conducted on 28 June 2010. The court found that the applicant did not have a skills assessment for the ANZSCO occupation of "management accountant" and thus did not satisfy the requirements of condition 186.234(2)(a).

Second, the court considered whether the applicant's skills assessment under the ASCO could be considered equivalent to a skills assessment under the ANZSCO. The court found that there was no direct correlation between the ASCO and ANZSCO occupations. However, the court acknowledged that the department had undertaken a major exercise to determine which ANZSCO occupations most closely correlated to each ASCO occupation. The court concluded that it was open to the Tribunal to accept evidence that may not be a perfect technical match between the ASCO and ANZSCO guidelines as being sufficiently persuasive.

Third, the court examined whether the transitional provisions outlined in the department's procedural advice manual (PAM) could be applied to the applicant's case. The court found that the PAM was a guideline and not a legislative instrument, so it could not change the meaning or operation of regulation 186.234 of the Migration Regulations 1994. The court concluded that the PAM could only provide decision-makers with some assistance in determining whether or not the assessments made prior to the change of categories (whether of skills or occupations) correlated sufficiently to assessments made after the change to satisfy the test in regulation 186.234.

Lastly, the court reviewed whether the Tribunal correctly interpreted the transitional provisions in the PAM and applied them to the facts of the case. The court found that the Tribunal had considered the terms of the assessment and determined that the ASCO assessment was the equivalent of an assessment for the position "accountant (general)" as described in the ANZSCO categories. The court concluded that the Tribunal's findings of fact that the assessment itself was not for the correct employment category could not be criticised.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the transitional provisions outlined in the department's procedural advice manual (PAM) cannot be used to create a new legal requirement or change the meaning of a legislative instrument. However, the PAM may provide decision-makers with some assistance in determining whether or not the assessments made prior to the change of categories (whether of skills or occupations) correlate sufficiently to assessments made after the change to satisfy the test in regulation 186.234 of the Migration Regulations 1994. Furthermore, the court found that the Tribunal correctly interpreted the transitional provisions in the PAM and applied them to the facts of the case.