Susu Pty Ltd v M Marinos Pty Ltd &Anor (No 8)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

SUSU PTY LTD v M MARINOS PTY LTD &ANOR (No 8)

[2011] SASC 65

Reasons of Judge Lunn a Master of the Supreme Court

18 April 2011

EQUITY

Compensation for loss from having given an undertaking not to sell assets pending hearing of injunction to prevent their sale - injunction refused - held no contract between the parties for their sale - undertaking prevented acceptance of offer from another person to purchase them in November 2006 for $35,200 - after undertaking discharged sold for $15,000 - held onus on respondent to claim for compensation to show claimant should reasonably have mitigated its loss by selling them for a higher price - that onus not discharged - compensation assessed at $20,200 - held no power to award exemplary damages.

SUSU PTY LTD v M MARINOS PTY LTD &ANOR (No 8)
[2011] SASC 65

JUDGE LUNN:

Reasons on inquiry as to damages

Background

  1. Part of the background is set out in the following passage from my reasons (No 7) published on 29 November 2010:

    1The plaintiff, Susu Pty Ltd (“Susu”), was the franchisee of the Trinity Gardens Cheesecake Shop from the first defendant M Marinos Pty Ltd (“Marinos”).[1]  Susu instituted this action seeking declarations about the terms of the franchise agreement and damages for its breach from Marinos.  Its pleaded causes of action did not directly involve the plant and equipment of Susu used in the business.

    2Marinos counterclaimed against Susu, inter alia, for an order that it sell to it the plant and equipment used by it in the business in accordance with an option in clause 19.9 of the franchise agreement.[2]  Susu disputed its obligation to sell this plant and equipment to Marinos.  Susu had removed the plant and equipment from the shop premises and had secreted it at a location not known to Marinos.

    3By an application of 19 July 2006, FDN22, Marinos applied, inter alia, for an injunction restraining Susu from disposing of the plant and equipment.  It asserted that its option to purchase it under clause 19.9 of the agreement would be defeated if Susu otherwise disposed of it.

    4On 12 September 2006, I noted an undertaking of Susu not to dispose of, or deal with, the plant and equipment until 26 September 2006.  I also noted the usual undertaking as to damages of Marinos, by its counsel, in respect of the subject matter of Susu’s undertaking.  Those undertakings were continued on 26 September, 11 October and 8 November 2006.  On 21 November 2006 the application of Marinos for the injunction was argued and was refused.

    5On 12 May 2010 Susu discontinued the action. On 23 September 2010 Marinos discontinued its counterclaim.

    6By an application taken out on 14 October 2010, FDN82, Susu applied to enforce the undertaking as to damages given by Marinos in relation to the undertakings of Susu not to sell the plant and equipment.[3]  Susu alleges that it suffered considerable loss through it being delayed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Susu Pty Ltd v M Marinos Pty Ltd &Anor (No 8) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] SASC 65
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Susu Pty Ltd v M Marinos Pty Ltd & Anor, the dispute centered around the losses incurred by Susu due to its undertaking in a previous court proceeding. The matter was heard by the court, which was tasked with determining the extent of Susu's damages and whether Marinos' objections to the evidence presented should preclude Susu from receiving compensation. The court found that Susu had indeed suffered a loss as a result of its undertaking, and that the evidence provided, though minimal, was sufficient to support this conclusion. The court also rejected the argument that the lack of additional evidence from third parties should deny Susu its claim.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether Susu was entitled to equitable compensation for the loss it suffered due to its undertaking in the previous court proceeding. Susu argued that it had lost an opportunity to sell its assets to Wheatley for $35,200, which lapsed before it could be acted upon, and subsequently sold the assets for $15,000 to Wheatley. Marinos contested the validity of Susu's evidence, arguing that Susu should have provided more detailed evidence regarding its dealings with Friedrich and Wheatley. The court found that Susu was not required to provide additional evidence from these parties as they were not aligned with Susu's position. The court held that the evidence presented by Susu was sufficient to establish its claim for damages.

The court concluded that Susu was entitled to equitable compensation for the loss it suffered due to its undertaking. The court found that Susu's director, Ms. Du Bois, was a credible witness and accepted her evidence regarding the offers made by Wheatley and Friedrich. The court rejected Marinos' argument that the offers were shams and found that Susu had indeed suffered a loss of $20,200 as a result of its undertaking. The court also found that Susu's conduct did not disentitle it to equitable relief and that it was not unconscionable to award Susu compensation for its loss. The court ordered that Susu be awarded equitable compensation for its loss.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Counsel for Marinos complained of the paucity of the evidence put forward by Susu about its relevant dealings with Friedrich and Wheatley. That evidence certainly was minimal but, as I find below, in the absence of any evidence to the contrary, it is sufficient to prove Susu’s loss resulting from its undertaking. No authority was cited that any such paucity of evidence should disentitle a claimant to relief in Equity.The evidence I accept the affidavit evidence of Susu. Its director, Ms Du Bois, was cross-examined on her affidavits. I find her to be a witness of truth. Nothing put forward in her cross-examination caused me not to accept her affidavits or her other evidence. Counsel for Marinos criticised the case put forward by Susu because it had not adduced affidavits from Mr Friedrich and Mr Wheatley. It was under no obligation to do so. Neither of those persons were shown to be so much in the camp of Susu[12] that it would be expected that they would give evidence on its behalf.[13] It was equally open to Marinos to have adduced evidence from these persons. If they would not cooperate, it could have sought their examination under Rule 87R 83.13. [12] Ms Du Bois denied that Mr Friedrich was her boyfriend. I accept her denial. No other evidence on the topic was adduced.[13] The Rule in Jones v Dunkel. See generally Cross on Evidence [1215]. I find that Susu received an offer from Wheatley for the assets for $35,200 inclusive of GST, which lapsed on 14 November. Susu’s undertaking precluded this offer from being accepted, but if it had not been for the undertaking, Susu would have accepted it. I accept the evidence of Ms Du Bois that shortly after 21 November Mr Wheatley informed her that he was not prepared to renew his offer in its previous terms. Although there is no direct evidence on the point, the likelihood seems to be that by this time Wheatley had entered into his lease with Friedrich and had made other arrangements for equipping his new shop. Likewise, I find that shortly after 21 November Ms Du Bois was advised by Friedrich that it was not prepared to extend its offer which had lapsed on 10 November. I find that on 15 February 2007 Susu sold the assets to Wheatley for $15,000 inclusive of GST. I accept the evidence of Ms Du Bois on the point. The original tax invoice for the sale would be expected to have gone to Wheatley as the purchaser. It is not surprising that Susu did not have a full copy of it in its records. The absence of any documentary evidence that the $15,000 was received and banked by Susu does not cause me to reject the evidence of Ms Du Bois that it occurred. I reject the submission of Marinos that Wheatley’s offer of 24 October 2006 and his purchase of the assets on 15 February 2007 were shams.Damage suffered by the plaintiff As stated above, I find that but for the undertaking it gave to the Court, Susu would have accepted the offer of Wheatley of 24 October 2006 and have sold the assets to it in November 2006 for $35,200 inclusive of GST. I find that Susu sold the assets on 15 February 2007 for $15,000. Therefore, as a result of the undertaking, it has suffered a loss of $20,200.Mitigation of damage

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Any price which was being offered by Marinos was disclosed by the valuation which accompanied the letter of 30 October 2006. However, the portion of that letter quoted above shows that Marinos was not making an offer to purchase the assets with some exceptions, but was pursuing the alleged contract under paragraph 19.9 and the letter of 17 March 2006. If Susu had accepted the proposal as contained in the letters of 27 and 30 October, it would have been an admission by it that Marinos in March 2006 had validly exercised the option for the assets. This would have had serious potential implications for what order might be made on the costs of the counterclaim. Insofar as those two letters and the valuation might otherwise have constituted an offer, Susu cannot be criticised in this application for not having accepted it. In any event, its amount was still lower than the offer from Wheatley.Equitable considerations As this Court is now exercising an equitable discretion, it is entitled to take the conduct of the parties into account on whether it would be unconscionable to award Susu equitable compensation for its loss.[11] I do not consider that Susu was guilty of any conduct which would disentitle it to equitable relief. It was under no legal obligation to sell the assets to Marinos and so was not required to allow Marinos to inspect or value them. There were some omissions by both parties in answering correspondence and there were various delays by both parties, but none of it by Susu significantly affected any rights of Marinos.[11] Rail Corporation of NSW v Leduva Pty Ltd, Einstein J, Supreme Court of NSW, 5 June 2007, [2007] NSW SC 571. Counsel for Marinos complained of the paucity of the evidence put forward by Susu about its relevant dealings with Friedrich and Wheatley. That evidence certainly was minimal but, as I find below, in the absence of any evidence to the contrary, it is sufficient to prove Susu’s loss resulting from its undertaking. No authority was cited that any such paucity of evidence should disentitle a claimant to relief in Equity.The evidence I accept the affidavit evidence of Susu. Its director, Ms Du Bois, was cross-examined on her affidavits. I find her to be a witness of truth. Nothing put forward in her cross-examination caused me not to accept her affidavits or her other evidence. Counsel for Marinos criticised the case put forward by Susu because it had not adduced affidavits from Mr Friedrich and Mr Wheatley. It was under no obligation to do so. Neither of those persons were shown to be so much in the camp of Susu[12] that it would be expected that they would give evidence on its behalf.[13] It was equally open to Marinos to have adduced evidence from these persons. If they would not cooperate, it could have sought their examination under Rule 87R 83.13. [12] Ms Du Bois denied that Mr Friedrich was her boyfriend. I accept her denial. No other evidence on the topic was adduced.[13] The Rule in Jones v Dunkel. See generally Cross on Evidence [1215].