| [2014] FWC 7775 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s 394 - Application for unfair dismissal remedy
Susan Francis
v
Patrick Stevedores Holdings Pty Ltd
(U2014/279)
DEPUTY PRESIDENT SAMS | SYDNEY, 3 NOVEMBER 2014 |
Termination of employment - dismissal for serious misconduct - allegations of physical assault - onus of proof - allegation of inappropriate use of two-way radio - alleged collaboration of allegations by other employees - wharfies’ ‘code of silence’ - employees’ duty to cooperate - respondent’s investigation seriously flawed - no corroboration of allegations - inconsistencies of versions of events - flawed findings and recommendation of dismissal not available on the evidence - inexperience of investigator - failures of senior management to properly investigate allegations and counter-allegations - onus of proof not discharged - substantive and procedural unfairness - applicant’s dismissal ‘harsh, unreasonable and unjust’ - no valid reason for applicant’s dismissal - remedy of reinstatement not inappropriate - reinstatement ordered - orders for payment of lost remuneration and continuity of service Application for relief from unfair dismissal.
INTRODUCTION
[1] Ms Susan Francis (the ‘applicant’) was employed by Patrick Stevedores Holdings Pty Ltd (‘Patrick’ or the ‘respondent’) from 10 September 2012 until 13 January 2014, when she was dismissed for misconduct. At the time of her dismissal, she was a Senior Tally Clerk. In this role, she was responsible for ensuring the movement of correct cargo on and off a ship and into its correct placement. The applicant is 42 years old and is the sole carer for her four year old daughter. The applicant had previously worked for Newcastle Stevedores between 2002 and 2009, but stopped working to care for her child, before taking up her job with the respondent.
[2] This decision arises from an application, filed by the applicant on 3 February 2014, pursuant to s 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the ‘Act’) for a remedy from unfair dismissal. The matter was the subject of an unsuccessful telephone conciliation on 17 March 2014 and was allocated to me for arbitration, beginning 27 May 2014 in Newcastle. While the parties engaged in some brief settlement discussions on that day, these were ultimately unsuccessful and the matter progressed to arbitration. At the commencement of the proceeding, I granted permission, pursuant to s 596 of the Act, for the applicant to be represented by Mr A Howell of Counsel, instructed by Mr A Jacka for the Maritime Union of Australia (‘MUA’ or the ‘Union’) and for the respondent to be represented Mr S Burke, Solicitor, instructed alternately by Ms T Green and Ms C Ross of the respondent.
[3] When the applicant was dismissed on 13 January 2014, she was given a letter from Mr Warwick Sommer, General Manager - Stevedoring, expressed in the following terms:
‘I refer to [your employment with the respondent] and the allegations regarding your behaviour and actions of Wednesday 27 November 2013.
I wish to reiterate that Patrick views inappropriate behaviour and contravention of our Bullying…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Susan Francis v Patrick Stevedores Holdings Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] FWC 7775
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues included whether the employer discharged the onus of proof that Francis committed the alleged misconduct, whether the investigation was conducted fairly, and whether the dismissal was substantively and procedurally fair. The Commission examined whether the employer's investigation was flawed and whether the findings of misconduct were supported by evidence. It also considered the impact of the so-called 'code of silence' among employees and whether Francis' dismissal was harsh, unreasonable, or unjust.
The Commission found that the employer's investigation was seriously flawed due to the inexperience of the investigator and the failures of senior management to properly investigate the allegations and counter-allegations. The employer did not provide sufficient corroboration for the allegations, and there were inconsistencies in the versions of events provided by the witnesses. The Commission concluded that the onus of proof was not discharged, and the findings of dismissal were not available on the evidence. The dismissal was deemed to be both substantively and procedurally unfair. Consequently, the Commission ordered the reinstatement of Francis and the payment of lost remuneration and continuity of service.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.