| [2018] FWC 2132 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.394—Unfair dismissal
Susan Anson
v
Western District Health Service
(U2017/13385)
DEPUTY PRESIDENT HAMILTON | MELBOURNE, 14 MAY 2018 |
Application for an unfair dismissal remedy – alleged sleeping on the job – alleged breach of directions to respond to allegations – union representation – agreement procedure – application dismissed.
[1] On 15 December 2017, Ms Susan Anson (the applicant) filed an application for an unfair dismissal remedy. Her application stated that she was notified of her dismissal from Western District Health Service (the employer) on 30 November 2017. The dismissal took effect on 30 November 2017. It was a summary dismissal.
[2] The applicant was one of two nurses allegedly asleep on duty at 5.30am in the Coleraine campus of the employer. She and another nurse were in charge of 10 residents and seven acute care patients. Both were allegedly discovered asleep by their Nurse Unit Manager, who arrived unexpectedly early. The applicant was dismissed for being asleep, and also for repeatedly refusing directions to provide a response to the allegation or meet with her employer. She had previously refused requests to attend. She provided a variety of explanations for her refusals including insisting on a particular union representative. The employer eventually refused to allow this representative to enter the premises because of her allegedly aggressive and unsafe conduct.
[3] Mr S Lynch represented the applicant, while the employer was represented by Ms R Nelson. I have taken account of all submissions and evidence led.
Authorities
[4] In Selvachandran v Peteron Plastics Pty Ltd1, Northrop J said:
“…In its context in subsection 170DE(1), the adjective “valid” should be given the meaning of sound, defensible or well founded. A reason which is capricious, fanciful, spiteful or prejudiced could never be a valid reason for the purposes of subsection 170DE(1). At the same time the reason must be valid in the context of the employee's capacity or conduct or based upon the operational requirements of the employer's business. Further, in considering whether a reason is valid, it must be remembered that the requirement applies in the practical sphere of the relationship between an employer and an employee where each has rights and privileges and duties and obligations conferred and imposed on them. The provisions must ‘be applied in a practical, commonsense way to ensure that’ the employer and employee are each treated fairly, see what was said by Wilcox CJ in Gibson v Bosmac Pty Ltd (1995) 60 IR 1, when considering the construction and application of s 170DC.”2
[5] In Briginshaw v Briginshaw3, Dixon J said:
“…Except upon criminal issues to be proved by the prosecution, it is enough that the affirmative of an allegation is made out to the reasonable satisfaction of the tribunal. But reasonable satisfaction is not a state of mind that is attained or established independently of the nature and consequence of the fact or facts to be proved. The seriousness of an allegation…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Susan Anson v Western District Health Service and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] FWC 2132
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue for the FWC was whether WDHS had a valid reason for dismissing Anson, given her alleged sleeping on the job. Additionally, the FWC had to consider whether WDHS provided Anson with adequate opportunity to respond to the allegations against her and whether her dismissal complied with relevant procedural requirements. The FWC found that WDHS had a valid reason to dismiss Anson based on the evidence presented, which included witness statements and video evidence of Anson sleeping. The Commission also determined that WDHS had provided Anson with sufficient opportunity to respond to the allegations, as she was informed of the allegations and given a chance to explain her actions. Furthermore, the FWC held that WDHS followed the appropriate procedures in dismissing Anson, including providing her with the opportunity to be represented by a union official during the disciplinary process.
Consequently, the FWC dismissed Anson's application for an unfair dismissal remedy, finding that WDHS's decision to terminate her employment was justified under the circumstances. The FWC concluded that WDHS's actions were reasonable and proportionate to the alleged misconduct, and that there was no indication of procedural unfairness in the dismissal process. The Commission did not find the dismissal to be harsh, unjust, or unreasonable, and therefore upheld the decision of WDHS to terminate Anson's employment.