SUMMERS v POLICE
[1998] SASC 6845
Full Court
Coram: Doyle CJ, Prior and Olsson JJ
Olsson J
1 This is an appeal, by leave, against the decision of a single Judge of this court. On 22 December 1997, he quashed an order of a stipendiary magistrate suspending two sentences of imprisonment and also directed that the suspension of certain earlier custodial sentences be revoked. This was the outcome of a prosecution appeal against sentence, on the ground that the relevant punishment was manifestly inadequate.
2 I will rehearse some of the pertinent background history, so that the events relevant to this appeal and the issues arising from them may be understood.
3 The appellant is a twenty three year old man, who, since he was sixteen years of age, has amassed what can only be described as a vast record of offending. This has spanned offences such as illegal use, assaults, breaking and entering, various street offences, larceny, a variety of driving offences and three offences of drive disqualified, committed prior to the offending which was under consideration by the learned magistrate.
4 At the time of the lastmentioned offending the appellant was subject to four separate bonds, the details of which were:-
. On 13 September 1993, he was convicted and sentenced to six months imprisonment on a charge of using a car without permission. That sentence of imprisonment was suspended upon his entry into a two year good behaviour bond. He appeared in court on 18 August 1995 on an application to enforce the breached bond on the basis that he had failed to comply with a condition of it, namely, that he perform community service. The breach was found proved and the bond was extended for a period of six months.
. On 13 September 1993, on a charge of illegal use, the respondent was separately convicted and sentenced to six months’ imprisonment, suspended upon his entering into a two year bond to be of good behaviour. That in turn was, on 18 August 1995, extended for a further period of six months, following proof that he had breached it by failing to be of good behaviour.
. On 18 August 1995, on a charge of driving whilst disqualified, the respondent was convicted and sentenced to three months’ imprisonment, suspended upon his entering into a further good behaviour bond of two years.
. On 18 August 1995 the appellant was convicted of illegal use of a motor vehicle. He was convicted and sentenced to six months’ imprisonment, suspended upon entering into a bond to be of good behaviour for two years, with a condition that he perform 120 hours of community service within nine months.
5 It was against that background that, on 27 August 1997, the appellant appeared before the learned magistrate charged with two separate offences of drive disqualified, one committed on 7 January 1996 and the other on 6 March 1996.
6 The first arose from an incident which occurred on the date in…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Summers v Police No. Scgrg-97-1394 Judgment No. S6845 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1998] SASC 6845
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Full Court found that the refusal to grant an adjournment was erroneous and carried a very real risk of miscarriage of justice. The learned Judge was aware that Mr Sprod was experiencing difficulty in obtaining instructions from his client. Despite this, the Judge proceeded ex parte and found himself in a partial information vacuum. The appellant had been unaware of the precise date and time fixed for the hearing of the appeal, and upon learning of the situation, promptly instructed Mr Sprod to seek counsel to represent him. The Full Court held that it was the clear duty of the learned Judge to refrain from proceeding to a judgment until the appellant had been afforded a reasonable opportunity of briefing and instructing counsel. The court concluded that the refusal of an adjournment carried with it a very real risk of a miscarriage of justice, considering the heavy onus which attaches to the appellant on a prosecution appeal. Therefore, the Full Court allowed the appeal, set aside the orders appealed against, and remitted the proceedings for re-hearing before another Judge.
The Full Court's decision in Summers v Police highlights the importance of allowing parties to make submissions and ensuring that all relevant information is considered before making a decision in cases involving the liberty of the subject. In this instance, the refusal to grant an adjournment resulted in a serious risk of miscarriage of justice, as the learned Judge was unable to properly assess the validity of some of the conclusions arrived at by the magistrate. The case serves as a reminder that, in matters touching the liberty of the subject, courts must always be vigilant in ensuring that justice is served, even in situations where case flow management considerations are salient.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi