| DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL | |
CITATION: | Sulusulu v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited [2025] NSWPICMP 711 |
CLAIMANT: | Faanoto (Grace) Sulusulu |
INSURER: | QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited |
REVIEW PANEL | |
MEMBER: | Alexander Bolton |
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: | Matthew Jones |
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: | John Baker |
DATE OF DECISION: | 15 September 2025 |
CATCHWORDS: | MOTOR ACCIDENTS – Review of decision of Medical Assessor (MA) who assessed the claimant as having 2% whole person impairment (WPI) and diagnosed a post-traumatic stress disorder with a dysthymic disorder; claimant involved in an accident; issue of whether the claimant’s psychiatric disability was affected by a pre-existing psychiatric disorder; the claimant's solicitors lost contact with their client and on failure of the claimant to attend a medical examination by the Review Panel it was only possible for the review of the certificate and reasons of the MA to proceed on the papers; Held – Review Panel assessed the claimant as having a 4% WPI and diagnosed a post-traumatic stress disorder in partial remission and an exacerbation of a persistent depressive disorder; certificate of MA revoked. |
DETERMINATIONS MADE: | CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION Determination 1. The Panel revokes the certificate and reasons of Medical Assessor Ng dated 2. The Panel assesses the claimant as having a Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder in partial remission and an exacerbation of a Persistent Depressive Disorder. 3. The Panel has assessed the claimant’s whole person impairment at 4%. 4. The Panel makes no deduction for any pre-existing psychiatric condition of the claimant. |
STATEMENT OF REASONS
INTRODUCTION
The claimant seeks a review of the Certificate and Reasons including the assessment
of Medical Assessor Bradley Ng (“Medical Assessor”) dated 4 October 2023, on the following grounds:
(a) Ground A: Failure to demonstrate a clear path of reasoning, and
(b) Ground B: Failure to provide transparency and illogical conclusion.
The Medical Assessor diagnosed the claimant with post-traumatic stress disorder as being wholly attributable to the subject motor accident and Dysthymic Disorder which was partially attributable to the motor accident.
The Medical Assessor found a whole person impairment (WPI) of 2% and thereafter deducted 1% due to the Dysthymic Disorder.
The following injuries were referred by the Personal Injury Commission (the Commission) for assessment of WPI:
(a) Psychological Sequelae, and
(b) Major Depressive Disorder.
Bundles of documents
The parties have each presented their respective bundles of documents upon which they rely. The Panel have read all the documentation. If a particular document is not referred to by the Panel, this does not mean that the Panel or a Panel Member has not read it, in much the same manner as parties not referring to or not specifically relying on a document in their own bundle and submissions.
The fact that evidence is not referred to in these reasons does not mean it has been overlooked and nor is it required that each piece of evidence be mentioned – see WAEE v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2003) 75 ALO 630 at [46]. The Panel is not required to “analyse every piece of information from every opinion…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Sulusulu v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] NSWPICMP 711
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the medical assessments and documentation, including the assessments by Dr. Bradley Ng and Dr. Ben Teoh, and noted the claimant's history of psychiatric issues prior to the accident, including her engagement with a psychologist and a history of problematic relationships and substance use. The court found that while the claimant had pre-existing mental health issues, the documentation did not provide sufficient evidence to conclude a significant pre-existing impairment. The court accepted that the claimant likely had a mild post-traumatic stress disorder in partial remission and an exacerbation of a persistent depressive disorder. The Review Panel assessed her WPI at 4%, differing from the MA's assessment of 2%. The court found the reasoning of the MA to be flawed, particularly in the deduction of 50% for pre-existing conditions, but generally valid given the available information.
The court concluded that the MA's certificate was revoked, and the claimant's WPI was assessed at 4%. The court acknowledged the challenges of assessing the claimant's condition based solely on documents due to her unavailability for examination. The Review Panel's assessment was deemed reasonable given the circumstances and the available evidence.
The final orders of the court included the revocation of the MA's certificate and the determination of the claimant's WPI at 4%.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Panel had made arrangements to medically examine the claimant but as explained earlier, she cannot be located or contacted. Accordingly, the Panel has had to proceed on the basis of an assessment of her psychiatric disabilities on the papers. This has been undertaken by Medical Assessor Jones. His report follows:“The Panel had previously convened to discuss Ms Sulusulu’s case. An assessment was booked for 28 January 2025 for the Medical Assessors to examine Ms Sulusulu however she failed to attend. The Panel has subsequently convened, and it is apparent that Ms Sulusulu is unable to be contacted by her legal representatives. Generally, this would occur in the context of a withdrawal of a claim. However, the Panel informed the parties, and particularly the claimant’s legal representatives that unless the claimant can be contacted on or before 20 June 2025 and informed that she is required to attend a medical examination, then the Panel would proceed to thereafter provide a review and assessment on the papers. This is an unenviable and challenging task given the intended purpose of a medical assessment is to ascertain the claimant’s mental status and level of impairment at the time of the assessment. Notwithstanding these limitations, the review of Ms Sulusulu’s case on the papers appears below.All of the documents provided were perused, however relevant documents are reviewed below, and following this, our conclusions will be stated.The PIC Certificate under review is by Dr Bradley Ng and was dated 4 October 2023. Dr Ng assessed that Ms Sulusulu suffered from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder which was wholly attributable to the accident, and Dysthymic Disorder (more formally likely Persistent Depressive Disorder under DSM-5-TR), which was partially attributable to the accident. In Dr Ng’s assessment of Ms Sulusulu, she was born in New Zealand and came to Sydney at the age of five with her brother and mother. She was raised in a single parent household. She finished high school in Year 10 and then completed nursing studies and worked as an Assistant in Nursing for three or four years. This was after working in retail and as a medical receptionist. She found her nursing work emotionally challenging and started working as a pick-packer on a full-time casual basis. The accident was described as Ms Sulusulu was driving alone, a car from a side-street went through a stop sign and crashed into the front left passenger side of her vehicle. She believed that she had a brief loss of consciousness. The car’s airbags were deployed. The car was written off and she was treated at Liverpool Hospital overnight, suffering a fracture to her right index finger, and a left wrist injury. She was later treated conservatively, had physiotherapy, hydrotherapy, and was on painkillers for a period. There was no further treatment for her physical injuries.Ms Sulusulu had some ongoing problems with respect to her physical injuries including related to her right index finger and her left wrist. She still had lower back pain at that stage.Ms Sulusulu re-engaged with a psychologist whom she had previously seen, Charmain Moubarak, at the end of 2019. Ms Sulusulu was having problems with her mother from mid to late 2019, including arguments at home and the relationship deteriorating. Her mother was accusing her of being lazy and not wanting to do anything around the house. Ms Sulusulu was angry at a lot of things and felt that no one understood her. She lost hope in herself and felt lifeless. She had suicidal ideas but no attempts and felt alone and heavy. She was not going out and was no longer exercising and was using increased amounts of marijuana. Ms Sulusulu saw the psychologist during 2019 and then once or twice in 2020. She did not see anyone during 2021 and 2022. She had attempted to re-engage with her psychologist in 2023, however the psychologist was not available. There were some phone consultations. She had not seen a psychiatrist for treatment and was not on psychiatric medications. Ms Sulusulu had a subsequent accident in August 2022 involving an electric scooter from she suffered left knee problems. She went to have an operation on this in May 2023, which was described as beneficial. At the time Ms Sulusulu was reportedly having three alcoholic drinks per day and up to a quarter of an ounce of marijuana per day, estimated to be about eight cones per day (Comment: There is approximately a ten-fold difference between these two estimates). Ms Sulusulu told Dr Ng that the marijuana relaxed her thoughts. She denied any other illicit drug use. Around the time of Dr Ng’s assessment, Ms Sulusulu had been feeling alone, lonely and down, and she had been experiencing a lengthy separation from her mother and family. She was unsure about her future, she felt numb, she had some suicidal ideation but no attempts. She admitted that she had been reckless with substances, and she was hurting herself with this behaviour. She was upset about the death of her dog, and she was anxious about her current housing situation and finances. She was worried about her employment prospects. She was concerned about her relationship with her family. Ms Sulusulu denied any flashbacks, however at the time had ongoing intrusive memories about the accident. She was also having distressing memories of her current life situation. She was avoiding places where her family might be. Ms Sulusulu, at the time of Dr Ng’s assessment, admitted to being violent to random members of the public. She described two situations where she had altercations with members of the public because she felt that they were attacking her. Ms Sulusulu had variable sleep, waking twice during the night and she would sometimes wake spontaneously and be wide awake. She at times had flashbacks of when she was younger, but not necessarily the accident. She had no particular dreams or nightmares that she remembered. Of note in her mental state examination at the time was that she was anxious about current life stresses and had some anxiety and intrusive memories about the accident. She was appropriately groomed and presented, was able to develop rapport, her speech was normal, her affect (expressed emotion) was congruent with her mood, there was no evidence of psychosis, there were no strong thoughts of harm to herself or others and her cognition, insight and judgment all appeared reasonable. Dr Ng noted no gross inconsistencies.With respect to her functioning around the time of that assessment, Ms Sulusulu had not returned to work as a pick-packer as her doctor had not given her clearance. She did obtain some work in merchandising and sales, starting in either 2020 or 2021, but finishing up there in late 2022. She was working from 16-30 hours per week, however the hours were not stable, nor were there consistent shifts, so she left the employment. She was not looking for any other work at the time of Dr Ng’s assessment. Ms Sulusulu described significant problems in her relationship with her family to Dr Ng. Between 2020 and 2022 she described herself as constantly angry whilst living at home. She had left home a few times. There was conflict with her mother about her “attitudes and habits.” She was drinking alcohol, smoking marijuana and “could not be bothered.” She had relationship problems with her brother and left the family home for the final time in January 2023 and was now estranged from her mother and brother. Ms Sulusulu had to euthanise her elderly dog after leaving home, and she was not in a relationship. She had ceased contact with her father, mother or brother and had “blocked them all” for “peace of mind.” At the time of Dr Ng’s assessment, Ms Sulusulu was in temporary housing and had no formal fixed abode. Her current accommodation, organised through a non-government organisation, had been for one week. She had been in four different temporary accommodations since the January of the year of the assessment. She confirmed that she was doing very little on a day-to-day basis, she sometimes slept through the day, although she was able to do chores and go to the local shops. She was able to cook and do her own laundry. There were eight other people in the accommodation at that time and she tended to keep to herself, but could interact if needed. She was accessing social media, watching videos on her phone, she might smoke marijuana in a local park where she goes for a walk, and she would also go to a hotel to have a few beers. She was in touch with one friend in Australia. She was able to use public transport and did not have a vehicle. On the day of the assessment, she reported that she became lost and had to take a taxi to the correct address. She was therefore late for the appointment. Dr Ng summarised the relevant documentation including a general practice record of Mediclinic Bankstown. This included a history of Ms Sulusulu having presented on 24 April 2017 with a “nervous breakdown after a fight with a family member.” The possible diagnoses included Adjustment Disorder and PTSD. Counselling was provided. The records following the accident included presentations for orthopaedic injuries and a note on 1 November 2019 that there had been a fight with her mother and she had left home. She was tearful on that occasion. There was a case conference noted on 20 November 2019 recording that Ms Sulusulu was avoiding heavy manual work, but her functional capacity had almost returned to normal. On 11 July 2020, she was noted to be tearful after a break-up with her partner. On 10 September 2020, it was noted her relationship with her mother had improved. In a note on 13 September 2022, Ms Sulusulu presented with insomnia and tiredness. She was sleeping during the day and waking up choking at night. The possibility of obstructive sleep apnoea was entertained. Dr Ng reviewed the clinical notes of Charmain Moubarak, Psychologist. This refers to an entry dated 22 April 2020 which did not mention the motor vehicle accident, Ms Sulusulu was complaining about medical issues and having issues with her boyfriend at the time. Dr Ng noted Dr Ben Teoh’s psychiatric report dated 28 April 2023. Dr Teoh diagnosed Major Depressive Disorder with a whole person impairment of 15%. Dr Ng also noted the permanent impairment medical assessment from Dr Farhan Shahzad, dated 11 June 2023, indicating 0% whole person impairment and that her physical injuries had resolved. Dr Ng’s overall opinion was that there had been some Post Traumatic Stress Disorder symptoms, many of which had resolved, and she now had residual symptoms. Dr Ng also noted longstanding depression and anxiety, noting pre-existing family strain and that there is no clear link between the motor vehicle accident and the conflict within the family. Dr Ng noted that the Post Traumatic Stress Disorder symptoms would have been attributable to the subject motor vehicle accident, but they were now minimal, and that the Dysthymic Disorder (Persistent Depressive Disorder) was only partially related to the subject motor vehicle accident. Dr Ng went on to assess current whole person impairment as 2% with, notably, a score of class 4 for social functioning, noting that she had been estranged from her family. Dr Ng utilised his own reasoning (which seems understandable but not in line with Motor Accident Guidelines) and deducted 50% of the whole person impairment due to the Dysthymic Disorder comprising most of the psychopathy. He opined a final whole person impairment of 1%. The claimant’s submissions with respect to Application for Review of the assessment of Medical Assessor Bradley Ng, dated 11 October 2023, was noted. This submission was based on a failure to demonstrate a clear path of reasoning and a failure to provide transparency, and illogical conditions. The first ground for the review was based on disagreement with Dr Ng’s clinical assessment of whole person impairment. The second ground rests on the claimant’s solicitors not understanding the reasoning behind the whole person impairment assessment. The submission seems to conflate the issue of the presence of symptoms with the presence of impairment, or an assessment of functioning, as is required with the PIRS. The Panel has reviewed Dr Ng’s PIRS assessment in his certificate and there is reasonable evidence, and reasoning, for his assessment of PIRS as at the time of his assessment of Ms Sulusulu. General Practitioner records of Mediclinic Bankstown are noted with her height of 161cm, and weight in 2009 of approximately 100kg, 109kg in 2010, 99kg after prescription of Duromine in 2010, 114kg in 2013, 113kg in 2016; a BMI of 50 in 2016. There is a noted presentation on 24 April 2017 indicating a “nervous breakdown” after a fight with her mother with the precipitating factor being a previous relationship problem. Her ex-boyfriend was violent and abusive, and he had threatened to harm himself, or her, in the past. The diagnosis was “Adjustment Disorder, PTSD?”. She was referred to Psychologist, Charmain Moubarak at that stage with a self-reported K-10, psychological distress, score of 34/50. Her weight was 126kg in October 2018 and the motor accident is noted on 18 March 2019. In November 2019 it is noted that her functional capacity had almost returned to normal and, in February 2020, it was indicated that she was performing full duties at home. Her weight is measured in February 2020 as 142kg. The first mention of a presentation for psychological reasons is 16 March 2020 when a Mental Health Care Plan was instigated. There is a note in September 2020 that she was caring for her mother and that her relationship with her mother had improved. There was nevertheless “stress/relationship counselling”. There was a presentation on 13 September 2021 for insomnia with tiredness, sleeping in the day, and waking up choking at night with the general practitioner questioning whether Ms Sulusulu’s morbid obesity was causing obstructive sleep apnoea. The records end in December 2021, with little in the way of presentations for mental health problems. The Mental Health Plan and Review dated 26 April 2017 is noted with the diagnosis being Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. Her K-10 score at that stage was 36/50. The first Certificate of Capacity noted regarding the accident had physical diagnoses listed, as did subsequent Certificates of Capacity and Certificates of Fitness.General Practitioner Mental Health Care Plan dated 16 March 2020 is noted with presenting issues of depressive symptoms, anxiety symptoms and stress. The diagnosis was mixed anxiety and depression, stress. There is a referral to Ms Charmain Moubarak, Psychologist, dated 16 March 2020, asking for opinion and management with Ms Sulusulu presenting with anxiety, depressive symptoms for further psychological intervention. There is no mention of the motor vehicle accident. There is a letter from Charmain Moubarak to Ms Sulusulu’s general practitioner, dated 20 June 2017, indicating she had attended five sessions of psychological therapy. Clinical notes from Ms Charmain Moubarak are noted including for 22 April 2020 with no mention of the motor vehicle accident. There is a note for 20 May 2020 that the appointment was cancelled indicating Ms Sulusulu was seeing another psychologist. There is a note on 13 July 2017, during a previous series of treatment, when Ms Sulusulu cancelled the appointment. There are notes for four preceding sessions in mid-2017 indicating problems at home, problems at work (and some cancellations of appointments and non-attendance).Psychiatric Report from Dr Ben Teoh dated 28 April 2023. This preceded Dr Ng’s assessment of Ms Sulusulu. This is a somewhat brief report and Dr Teoh diagnoses Major Depressive Disorder and subsequently opines a whole person impairment of 15%. Dr Teoh’s reasoning does not seem to justify his assessment of whole person impairment. For example, a loss of interest or motivation in previous activities does not necessarily justify a Class 3 impairment in Social and Recreational Activities; “she admitted that she has been aggressive and irritable. She reported a marked fluctuation in her mood” does not necessarily relate to Social Functioning descriptors, and if it did it would represent a Class 2; “She reported chronic pain and physical disabilities. She has been feeling depressed and worrying about her future and her physical condition. She reported insomnia and social isolation. She has been feeling lethargic and has been experiencing chronic pain”, does not necessarily relate to Concentration Persistence and Pace descriptors and focusses heavily on physical symptoms, that are excluded under current guidelines, and perhaps representing a Class 2 from a psychiatric perspective, and; “She is fit for suitable duties. Her capacity has been reduced since the motor vehicle accident. She has tried to return to work, unsuccessfully” is not informative with respect to delineating the Class of impairment in the Adaptation category and might represent a Class 2.There are various physiotherapy and orthopaedic records. In summary, contained in the claimant’s revised bundle of documents (over 500 pages) there is little to support a highly significant psychiatric injury caused by the motor vehicle accident or a whole person impairment above 10%, nor is there much in the way of information to suggest that the original Medical Assessment Certificate should be challenged. The insurer’s Review Application bundle of documents numbered approximately 136 pages. The submissions dated 19 October 2023 (post-assessor Ng’s certificate) are noted. The insurer’s PIC submissions dated 27 June 2022 are noted. They point out that by that date there had been no application for psychiatric injuries made. The insurer’s submissions dated 15 August 2023 are noted. They note that the end of Ms Sulusulu’s relationship with Crew Services, a merchandising company, was based on her stating that she was working for another merchandise company.PIC Certificate from Assessor Farhan Shahzad dated 11 June 2023, although for physical injuries, includes some mention of matters of psychological and psychiatric relevance. It notes that her scootering accident following the subject motor vehicle accident led to a knee injury and the need for knee surgery. There is mention of difficulties with sleeping and fatigue and that her ongoing pain makes her feel “angry and useless.” There is mention that she had gained over 60kg and had developed psychological symptoms of anxiety and depression. She was not taking any antidepressant medication but reported that she had been diagnosed with mental health issues. She reported to Assessor Shahzad that she was seeing Psychologist, Charmain Moubarak because of psychological disturbances following the motor vehicle accident. At that stage her height was 170cm and her weight was 119kg. Email from Crew Services Group indicating case notes that there was a text message from Ms Sulusulu on 20 January 2023, “Not available so can you go ahead and remove me off your database. I am working for another merchandise company, all the best.” CONSIDERATIONSThere has been little novel documentation for approximately two years, particularly as relates to Mr Sulusulu’s psychological and psychiatric status. The Panel has the challenge of attempting to make an opinion about Ms Sulusulu’s current psychiatric status, the presence of any diagnosis, her current level of functioning, and make sense of her pre-accident mental health history in a situation where she is uncontactable, unwilling, or unable, to attend Medical Review Panel assessments. Her history, as at the time Assessor Ng produced his Certificate and whole person impairment assessment with respect to the subject motor vehicle accident was that she had experienced psychological problems prior to the motor vehicle accident, including engaging with a psychologist, albeit only for approximately five sessions in 2017 with a variable attendance. She had a history of problematic relationships in her family, she had had a history of an abusive relationship with her partner, and she had previously drunk alcohol, smoked marijuana and been morbidly obese. She had an occupational history that was varied. Assessor Ng’s assessment of Ms Sulusulu appears to be the most comprehensive (and in fact the closest to contemporaneous) and the Panel considers her narrative reported to Assessor Ng, and Assessor Ng’s observations of Ms Sulusulu, to be valid. The claimant’s submissions challenging this Certificate revolved around his reasoning and logic with respect to his assessment of whole person impairment. The claimant’s submissions appear to have confused the presence of symptoms with the presence of impairment and although the Panel does not agree with Assessor Ng’s rationale for making a 50% deduction on whole person impairment based on pre-existing mental health problems (he diagnosed a Dysthymic Disorder, which would now be considered Persistent Depressive Disorder, because of DSM revisions), the information provided in his Certificate and his logic with respect to assessing current whole person impairment is considered by the Panel to be valid in the presence of the information available to him. There is no information available that contradicts his assessment, however the Panel notes that Dr Teoh’s independent medical assessment differed slightly with respect to the diagnosis (Major Depressive Disorder as opposed to ongoing Dysthymic Disorder), and the absence of any Post Traumatic Stress Disorder diagnosis, Dr Teoh differed in his assessment of whole person impairment, although in the Panel’s opinion his reasoning lacked validity because it contained an inherent lack of reasoning with respect to utilising the PIRS. . With respect to the issue of pre-existing mental health conditions, which likely existed, on the information available, utilising the appropriate Guidelines, an assessment of whole person impairment for a pre-existing impairment should be undertaken. This is an impossible task with respect to the information available, although this could be more properly explored in an in-person Medical Review Panel Assessment, were that to have been a possibility. There are potential areas of possible impairment with respect to her pre-existing mood disorder such as in the areas of social and recreational activities, social functioning or concentration, persistence and pace, and adaptability, however no fair or firm opinion could be made with respect to this, given the information available. As such, it can be assumed that, although Ms Sulusulu may have had a pre-existing psychiatric diagnosis and possibly a pre-existing impairment, an impairment level of 0% is a fair estimate. Therefore, despite the complexity of the case, Ms Sulusulu’s level of whole person impairment post-accident is low (last assessed as 2% by Assessor Ng) and there is no information available that would alter the Panel’s opinion of this level of impairment by any significant degree. The issue with respect to pre-existing impairment can be considered moot as the Panel accepts that there was likely a 0% whole person impairment. The Panel is not aware of any treatment that Ms Sulusulu is or has been undertaking. At the time of the previous medical assessment, she was not taking antidepressant medication, nor was she actively seeing a psychologist or a psychiatrist. With the information available to the Panel, there is no adjustment for treatment effect. Therefore, with the inherent significant limitations of an assessment on the papers, and in the absence of any further documents to inform the Panel, in its assessment that Ms Sulusulu’s diagnosis from the motor vehicle accident was a mild Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, in partial remission, and an exacerbation of a mood disorder, namely a Persistent Depressive Disorder of mild severity. The presence of a Substance Use Disorder is also likely, given Ms Sulusulu had reported daily ingestion of marijuana in an amount somewhere between 8 cones to a ¼ of an ounce a day. There was also daily alcohol ingestion, at the time of the medical assessment. As Ms Sulusulu was both drinking alcohol and smoking marijuana prior to the motor vehicle accident, the Panel is unable to pass any opinion whatsoever on the effect of the motor vehicle accident on any possible Substance Use Disorder. Again, taking into account the limitations of a paper assessment, not having assessed Ms Sulusulu, and an absence of meaningful recent or probative documentation or information, Ms Sulusulu most likely has a whole person impairment under 10% which is similar to that which was assessed by Assessor Ng, that is, 2%. The Panel assessors have assessed her Whole Person Impairment as 4%. The scores and reasoning is detailed in the table below. This is her final whole person impairment given that there is no adjustment for treatment effect and no way to adjust for pre-existing impairment. The Panel is not aware of any other subsequent events that would contribute to a post-accident impairment, however if these were present, it would reduce her whole person impairment related to the motor vehicle accident. Both medical assessors agree that the claimant has a 4% whole person impairment.”