Sulo MGB Australia Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

Sulo MGB Australia Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs [2018] AATA 1324 (17 May 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2015/2533

Re:Sulo MGB Australia Pty Ltd  

APPLICANT

Comptroller-General of CustomsAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Egon Fice, Senior Member

Date:17 May 2018  

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution determines that the Applicant’s wheels for its mobile garbage bins are correctly classified to subheading 8716.90.00. The Tribunal finds that the Applicant’s wheels for its mobile garbage bins are eligible for concessional entry under Tariff Concession Order 0512190

[sgd]........................................................................

Egon Fice, Senior Member

CUSTOMS – remittal from Federal Court – classification of Sulo’s wheelie bins – consideration of all possible classifications – use of extrinsic materials in aid of interpretation – meaning of other household articles – use of words not found in the legislation or extrinsic materials – identification of the correct descriptor of the goods – plastic wheels suitable for use solely or principally with Sulo’s wheelie bins – application of Tariff Concession Order

Legislation

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 s.15AB

Customs Tariff Act 1995 Chapters 39, 40, 73, 87

Cases

Barry R Liggins Pty Ltd v Comptroller-General of Customs and Others (1991) 103 ALR 565
Collector of Customs v Agfa-Gevaert Ltd (1995) 186 CLR 389
Gardner Smith Pty Ltd v Collector of Customs, Victoria (1986) 66 ALR 377
Primaplas Pty Ltd v Chief Executive Officer of Customs (2016) 242 FCR 268

Re Toyota Tsusho Australia Pty Ltd and Nippondenso Australia Pty Ltd v Collector of Customs [1992] FCA 211

Secondary Materials

Harmonised Commodity Description and Coding System Explanatory Notes
The Macquarie Dictionary
The Shorter Oxford English Dictionary

The Urban Dictionary

REASONS FOR DECISION

Egon Fice, Senior Member

17 May 2018

  1. This matter was first heard by me on 24 November 2015 following which I set aside the decision of the Chief Executive Officer of Customs (now the Comptroller-General of Customs) (Customs). I found that the wheels imported by Sulo MGB Australia Pty Limited (Sulo) for its mobile garbage bins were parts suitable for use solely or principally with its wheelie bin, as its mobile garbage bins are generally described. In establishing the correct classification for those wheels, I found that the wheelie bins were correctly classified as vehicles, not mechanically propelled, and fell under Heading 8716 of the Customs Tariff Act 1995 (the Tariff Act).

  2. On appeal to the Federal Court of Australia (Moshinsky J), the Court found that my decision should be set aside in the matter remitted for redetermination according to law. The grounds stated by the Court were summarised as follows:

    (a)As a matter of principle, I accept the proposition that there can be only one proper classification of the wheelie bins, and this must be determined consistently whether the case is directly concerned with the classification of wheelie bins or is concerned with the classification of wheels as a “part thereof”. However, in light of my conclusion in relation to the Comptroller’s second contention, it seems unlikely…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sulo MGB Australia Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Custom... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 1324
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Sulo MGB Australia Pty Ltd against a decision of the Comptroller-General of Customs regarding the classification of imported wheels for mobile garbage bins. The dispute centred on whether these wheels should be classified under subheading 4012.90.00, as determined by the Comptroller-General, or under subheading 8716.90.00, with eligibility for concessional entry under Tariff Concession Order (TCO) 0512190, as contended by Sulo. The decision was made by Senior Member Egon Fice of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was the correct classification of the imported wheels for mobile garbage bins under the Customs Tariff Act 1995. This involved determining whether the wheels, when considered in conjunction with the mobile garbage bins, qualified for classification as parts of a vehicle not mechanically propelled, and consequently, whether they met the criteria for concessional entry under TCO 0512190. A secondary issue raised by Sulo was whether the Tribunal had erred by failing to consider all other possible classifications for the wheelie bins.

The Tribunal reasoned that the general rules for the interpretation of Schedule 3 of the Tariff Act, particularly Rule 2(b) and Rule 3(b), were applicable. Rule 2(b) states that a reference to a material or substance includes mixtures or combinations thereof, and goods consisting wholly or partly of such material or substance. Rule 3(b) provides that composite goods shall be classified as if they consisted of the material or component which gives them their essential character. The Tribunal found that the mobile garbage bins, including their wheels, were correctly classified under Heading 8716 as vehicles not mechanically propelled, designed for the transport of rubbish. Furthermore, the imported plastic wheels, despite having an extruded centring device, satisfied the description of items falling under TCO 0512190. The Tribunal also addressed Sulo's contention regarding other possible classifications, noting that Heading 3924 had been considered and discarded by the Tribunal at an earlier stage in relation to the wheels.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the decision of the Comptroller-General of Customs and substituted a determination that the wheels for Sulo's mobile garbage bins were correctly classified under subheading 8716.90.00 and were eligible for concessional entry under TCO 0512190.

Background

Background to the litigation

Sulo MGB Australia Pty Ltd, a company that manufactures and sells wheelie bins in Australia, imported plastic wheels to be fitted to their wheelie bins. The wheels had an extruded centring device allowing them to rotate about the axle and be retained properly. The Comptroller-General of Customs classified the wheels under subheading 4012.90.00 of the Tariff Act, denying Sulo's application for concessional entry under Tariff Concession Order 0512190. Sulo challenged this decision before the Federal Court, arguing that the wheels were correctly classified under subheading 8716.90.00 and that they qualified for the tariff concession. The case turned on the proper classification of the imported wheels and wheelie bins.

The Federal Court considered whether the Tribunal erred by not considering other possible classifications of the wheelie bins. The Court noted that the Tribunal had in fact considered and discarded other classifications, including Heading 3924, at the hearing. The Court found that the Tribunal was not obligated to examine all possible classifications since it had already properly classified the wheelie bins under Heading 8716 based on their essential character as vehicles, not mechanically propelled, designed to transport rubbish or other goods. The wheels were also correctly classified under subheading 8716.90.00 despite having the extruded centring device.

This case came before the court as an appeal from a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT), which had previously set aside a decision of the Comptroller-General of Customs (Comptroller) regarding the classification of certain imported goods. Sulo MGB Australia Pty Ltd (Sulo) had imported wheels intended for use on their mobile garbage bins. The Comptroller initially classified these wheels under subheading 4012.90.00 of the Tariff Act, denying Sulo's claim for preferential entry under Tariff Concession Order 0512190 (TCO). Dissatisfied with this decision, Sulo appealed to the AAT, which found in Sulo's favour, determining that the wheels were correctly classified under subheading 8716.90.00, thereby eligible for the tariff concession. The Comptroller then sought judicial review of the AAT's decision in the Federal Court, which led to the present appeal by Sulo to the Federal Court of Appeal. Throughout the proceedings, various interlocutory applications and orders were made, including the filing of appeals, cross-appeals, and submissions on the correct interpretation of tariff classifications and the application of relevant tariff orders. The court’s role in this appeal is to review the AAT's decision, ensuring it was legally sound and based on proper consideration of the applicable tariff rules and orders.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Given the above description of the articles in question, I find that the wheels imported by Sulo for the sole purpose of fitting to their wheelie bins satisfies precisely the description of the item which falls under TCO 0512190. Furthermore, I have found that the wheels are a part of a vehicle, not mechanically propelled and fall to be classified under subheading 8716.90.00 which is the subheading to which the item must be classified in order to satisfy the TCO. I find that Sulo is entitled to the benefit of TCO 0512190 in respect of the wheels, the subject matter of this dispute.CONCLUSION I have found that Sulo’s wheelie bins are correctly classified to Heading 8716. That is because they are properly described as vehicles, not mechanically propelled. They are constructed to transport goods or persons, which includes rubbish. Another appropriate description for the wheelie bin is trash cart. If its purpose is essential for identification of the item which goes to classification, which I doubt, then its sole or principal purpose is to transport accumulated rubbish to a point of disposal from either residential or commercial premises. I have also found that the imported goods, which are properly described as plastic wheels, satisfied the description in TCO 0512190. That is so despite having an extruded centring device which allows the wheel to rotate about the axle, properly centred and able to be retained. Accordingly, I find that the decision made by the Comptroller-General of Customs on 28 January 2015 classifying the wheels for Sulo’s mobile garbage bins to subheading 4012.90.00 of the Tariff act and denying the application of TCO 0512190 was not the correct decision. I set aside that decision and in substitution determined that Sulo’s wheels for its mobile garbage bins are correctly classified to subheading 8716.90.00. I find that Sulo’s wheels for its mobile garbage bins are eligible for concessional entry under TCO 0512190.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The general rules for the interpretation of Schedule 3 are set out in s. 7 of Schedule 2 of the Tariff Act. The relevant passages are:Classification of goods in Schedule 3 shall be governed by the following principles:1. The titles of Sections, Chapters and sub-Chapters are provided for ease of reference only; for legal purposes, classification shall be determined according to the terms of the headings and any relative Section or Chapter Notes and, provided such headings or Notes do not otherwise require, according to the following provisions:2. (a) …(b) Any reference in a heading to a material or substance shall be taken to include a reference to mixtures or combinations of that material or substance with other materials or substances. Any reference to goods of a given material or substance shall be taken to include a reference to goods consisting wholly or partly of such material or substance. The classification of the goods consisting of more than one material or substance shall be in accordance to the principles of Rule 3.3.When by application of Rule 2(b) or for any other reason, goods are, prima facie, classifiable under two or more headings, classification shall be effected as follows:(a)The heading which provides the most specific description shall be preferred to headings providing a more general description. However, when two or more headings each refer to part only of the materials or substances contained in mixed or composite goods or to part only of the items in the set put up for retail sale, those headings are to be regarded as equally specific in relation to those goods, even if one of them gives a more complete or precise description of the goods.(b)Mixtures, composite goods consisting of different materials or made up of different components, and goods put up in sets for retail sale, which cannot be classified by reference to 3(a), shall be classified as if they consisted of the material or component which gives them their essential character, in so far as this criterion is applicable.(c)When goods cannot be classified by reference to 3(a) or 3(b), they shall be classified under the heading which occurs last in numerical order among those which equally merit consideration.4. Goods which cannot be classified in accordance with the above Rules shall be classified under the heading appropriate to the goods to which they are most akin.5. …6. For legal purposes, the classification of goods in the subheadings of a heading shall be determined according to the terms of those subheadings and any related Subheading Notes and, mutatis mutandis, to the above Rules, on the understanding that only subheadings at the same level are comparable. For the purposes of this Rule the relative Section and Chapter Notes also apply, unless the context otherwise requires.CONSIDERATION OF OTHER POSSIBLE CLASSIFICATIONS The question of law determined by the Court was whether the Tribunal erred by not considering other possible classifications of the wheelie bins. The first thing that must be said about this contention put by Mr Millea is that the transcript of the hearing before me at first instance shows that statement to be factually incorrect. Other classifications, including Heading 3924 in particular, were considered and discarded by Mr Millea at the hearing. That was in respect of the classification of the wheels, the imported goods. Having expressly discarded it for that purpose, it was never raised again in relation to the classification of the wheelie bins. In any event, with respect to the Court, its decision on this point seems somewhat equivocal. It relies on the acceptance of Customs’ second contention regarding the correct classification of the wheelie bins to find that the Tribunal ought to have examined all other possible classifications under which the wheelie bins in question may fall.