Sullivan and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

[2012] AATA 774 

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2010/4482

Re

Donald Sullivan

APPLICANT

And

Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member J F Toohey and Dr I Alexander

Date 7 November 2012
Place Sydney

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

.........[sgd]...............................................................

Senior Member J F Toohey and Dr I Alexander

CATCHWORDS

DEFENCE FORCE RETIREMENT AND DEATH BENEFITS – applicant served with Australian peacekeeping force in the Sinai – discharged administratively – evidence that applicant suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder at time of discharge – whether applicant should be treated as if he was retired on ground of invalidity, or physical or mental incapacity to perform duties – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 s 37

CASES

Re Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Douglas Harry Britt (1984) 57 ALR 199

X and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (1980) 3 ALN No 37

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member J F Toohey and Dr I Alexander

7 November 2012

BACKGROUND

  1. Mr Donald Sullivan enlisted as a clerical officer in the Royal Australian Air Force (RAAF) in 1978 and served three terms of engagement.  During his last term, he spent four months with the Australian Contingent Multinational Force and Observers in the Sinai in Egypt.  He declined the offer of a further term and was discharged administratively in June 1987.

  2. In March 1988, Mr Sullivan was granted a pension at ten per cent of the General Rate with effect from 27 April 1987 on the ground of his defence-caused chronic lower back strain, chondromalacia patella and bilateral conjunctivitis.

  3. In these proceedings, Mr Sullivan claims that, at the time he was discharged, grounds existed on which he could have been medically retired.  In particular, he says he was incapable, because of his mental state, of performing his duties because of events that occurred during his service in the Sinai.  He says he should be treated as if retired on the ground of physical or mental incapacity to perform his duties.

    RELEVANT LEGISLATION

  4. Section 37 of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act1973 (the Act) confers on the respondent, (at the time of Mr Sullivan’s application the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority, a body which has since become part of the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation (CSC)), a discretion to treat a former contributing member as if he or she had been retired on the ground of invalidity even though that was not the case at the time. 

  5. Section 37 provides:

    Where a contributing member has been retired otherwise than on the ground of invalidity or of physical or mental incapacity to perform his duties but, after his retirement, the [Chief of Air Force or his or her delegate] informs the CSC that, at the time the member was retired, grounds existed on which he could have been retired on the ground of invalidity or of physical or mental incapacity to perform his duties, he may, for the purposes…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sullivan and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 774
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Sullivan and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation involved the applicant, Mr Sullivan, who served with the Australian peacekeeping force in the Sinai. Mr Sullivan was discharged administratively from his military service and applied for superannuation benefits, arguing that he should be treated as if he was retired on the ground of invalidity due to suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) at the time of his discharge. The court was required to determine whether Mr Sullivan was indeed incapacitated from performing his duties at the time of his discharge and, if so, whether his incapacity should be classified in a manner that would entitle him to certain benefits.

The court examined the evidence provided by Mr Sullivan, including his experiences during his deployment in the Sinai, his traumatic childhood, and the murder of his father while he was deployed. The court also considered the medical evidence, contemporaneous assessments of Mr Sullivan’s performance, and his subsequent employment history. The tribunal found that while Mr Sullivan experienced significant stressors during his service and thereafter, there was no evidence that his psychological condition led to any incapacity to perform his duties at the time of his discharge. The assessments of his performance by his supervising officer were consistently positive and did not indicate any impairment of functioning. Additionally, Mr Sullivan’s employment history, which included working long hours in real estate and other positions, suggested that he was capable of performing his duties.

Based on the evidence, the court concluded that Mr Sullivan was not incapacitated at the time of his discharge and, therefore, should not be treated as if he was retired on the ground of invalidity. The decision under review was affirmed, and Mr Sullivan’s application for superannuation benefits was dismissed. The court's reasoning focused on the lack of contemporaneous evidence of incapacity and the subsequent employment history that contradicted any claim of significant impairment at the time of his discharge.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At issue, is whether, at the time of his discharge, Mr Sullivan was in fact incapable of performing his duties for the reasons in s 37. If we so decide, we then have to determine the classification of Mr Sullivan’s incapacity in relation to civil employment. MR SULLIVAN’S EVIDENCEPosting to the Sinai Mr Sullivan was posted to the Sinai between 6 November 1985 and 2 April 1986. He gave evidence that, from shortly after his arrival, he was accommodated with a Corporal Niland who was clearly disturbed. Corporal Niland visibly agitated and nervous, and he would grind his teeth and groan at night and pace about. He later learned that Corporal Niland had received psychiatric treatment before being posted to the Sinai Medical evidence before the Tribunal describes in detail the traumatic nature of Mr Sullivan’s childhood, which included witnessing his step-father’s extreme violence against his mother and his threats to kill the family. There is no doubt that Mr Sullivan was deeply affected and psychologically vulnerable. The medical evidence is considered further below. In January 1986, Mr Sullivan was informed by his commanding officer that his father had been brutally murdered in the Philippines. He says his request to attend the funeral was refused on the ground that all personnel were essential to the successful withdrawal of the Australian contingent from Egypt by March 1986. A statement in evidence from Mr Sullivan’s supervising officer at the time suggests there were other reasons he was unable to attend the funeral but in the end nothing turns on this. Mr Sullivan says no one talked to him again about his father’s death or offered him any support; they were only concerned about Corporal Niland. Corporal Niland’s condition took a turn for the worse around the time that Mr Sullivan learned of his father’s murder. They continued to share a room until February 1986 when Corporal Niland was repatriated on medical grounds. In that time, Mr Sullivan says, Corporal Niland was extremely agitated, especially at night when he would pace the room. He could not sleep properly himself and was always on edge; he became nervous and agitated and started vomiting uncontrollably. His condition deteriorated and he asked several times to be moved but there was no alternative accommodation available. Mr Sullivan’s account is supported, in general terms, by letters from former Flight Lieutenant D J Bloomer, his supervising officer in the Sinai, and from Corporal Niland himself, to Mr Sullivan’s treating psychiatrist, Dr Grahame Pohlen. Mr Bloomer’s comments about the effects on Mr Sullivan of his father’s death and Corporal Niland’s behaviour are considered below. When his deployment to the Sinai ended, Mr Sullivan took leave before returning to Australia in June 1986 and serving at Amberley air base. In August 1986, he was offered a further term of engagement. He declined and requested a discharge at the end of his term on 26 June 1987. He took the period from early April 1987 until the end of his term as leave.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is particularly relevant that Mr Sullivan has not given evidence of any duties he was unable to perform, or even that he had had difficulty performing, at or around the time he was discharged. CONCLUSION Taking into account all of the evidence before us, we are not satisfied that any psychological condition that Mr Sullivan was suffering at the time of his discharge in 1987 led to any incapacity to perform his duties. We are not satisfied that he should be treated as if he were retired on that ground. As we are not satisfied that Mr Sullivan should be treated as if he were retired on the ground of mental incapacity to perform his duties, the question of the classification of any incapacity does not arise. We affirm the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Dr Gray thought that, over the ten years after his discharge, Mr Sullivan had to contend with very difficult circumstances but he could find no evidence of impaired functioning. He thought the fact that Mr Sullivan went on to work on Hamilton Island after his real estate work ended, and later to other work, showed he was adaptable and had a degree of resilience despite his psychological symptoms. He thought that, some time during the 1990s, Mr Sullivan’s symptoms worsened after he had experienced a number of other significant stressors, to the point that he was no longer able to work. Consideration The contemporaneous assessments of Mr Sullivan’s performance in the three years leading up to his discharge are persuasive evidence of his capacity to perform his duties at the relevant time. For Mr Sullivan it was submitted that the evaluation reports should be given little weight because they are RAAF documents, and not Mr Sullivan’s. We do not agree. Mr Sullivan signed each evaluation report, and he has not suggested to us that he disagreed with their contents. There is nothing to suggest he signed them under duress or that they reflect anything other than his performance at the time. There was ample scope in the evaluation forms for Mr Sullivan’s supervising officer to indicate if his performance was wanting in some respect but his assessments were consistently positive. Nothing in them suggests any impairment of functioning. In fact, he was rated most highly for the period after he returned from the Sinai and immediately before his discharge. We accept that Mr Sullivan felt aggrieved by what he perceived to be a lack of support around the time of his father’s death and the perceived more sympathetic treatment of Corporal Niland. Mr Bloomer acknowledged that he might have missed signs of problems given everything that was happening at the time. It is relevant, however, that he wrote that he might have missed signs if Mr Sullivan’s problems “were not really obvious or affecting his work performance”. Nothing in his letter suggests that Mr Sullivan’s capacity to perform his duties was in fact affected. To the contrary, Mr Bloomer acknowledges the contribution of Mr Sullivan’s hard work, long hours and commitment to the contingent’s withdrawal. Although, at this point, we are considering Mr Sullivan’s capacity to perform his service duties – and not his capacity to perform civilian duties – it is relevant that he went more or less straight from service to working long hours in real estate, and from there to other positions which he held for varying periods over a number of years. Dr Gray thought he would have had increasing difficulties over the years but Mr Sullivan’s employment record following his discharge, at least for several years, are consistent with his AERs and strongly suggest those assessments of his capacity were correct. The fact that Mr Sullivan was offered a further term of engagement following his return from the Sinai is further evidence that he was considered capable of performing his duties.