Su v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 

Citation:

Su v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2023] NSWPIC 33

Claimant: Ophen Su
insurer: Allianz Australia Insurance Limited
Member: Belinda Cassidy
DATE OF DECISION: 24 January 2023
CATCHWORDS: MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; statutory benefits claim; application by claimant for determination that claimant is not wholly at fault; claimant 75 years of age crossing Kings Cross Road and a light controlled pedestrian crossing on his bicycle; insured turned corner on a green light, saw claimant approaching and stopped; small portion of car over white line and into pedestrian zone; claimant collided with insured vehicle, fell and was injured; issue about the colour the pedestrian light and if red, whether it was a flashing red light; claimant riding in breach of the road rules; Held – weight given to independent witness walking in same direction as the claimant who said light was red; claimant rode onto crossing when it was red and not flashing; claimant wholly at fault; costs allowed including costs of an investigator who obtained a statement from the claimant about how the accident happened.
determinations made:

CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION

In accordance with Division 7.6 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017, the Commission’s assessment is:

1. For the purposes of s 3.28 of the Act, the motor accident the subject of these proceedings was caused wholly by the fault of the claimant.

2.     The amount of the claimant’s costs in the matter is $2,514.30 inclusive of GST.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

Introduction

  1. Mr Ophen Su was involved in a motor accident on 14 February 2022. The accident occurred around the corner from the Coca Cola sign at the top of William Street, Kings Cross. Mr Su says he was crossing Kings Cross Road on his bicycle when he was struck by a car driven by Ryan Waugh and injured.

  2. On or about 21 April 2022, Mr Su made a claim for statutory benefits under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the MAI Act). The claim was made against Allianz, the third-party insurer of Mr Waugh’s motor vehicle.

  3. On 25 May 2022 the insurer issued a notice to the claimant accepting the claim, which appears to include an acceptance that Allianz is the relevant insurer within the meaning of s 3.2 of the MAI Act and therefore liable to pay Mr Su his statutory benefits.[1]

    [1] The notice is found at page 14 of the claimant’s bundle of application documents A1 in the Commission’s file (the claimant’s bundle).

  4. On 25 July 2022 the insurer issued a further notice to the claimant denying any liability to pay statutory benefits to the claimant beyond the first 26 weeks after the accident on the basis he/she was “wholly at fault in the accident”.[2]

    [2] The notice is found at page 16 of the claimant’s bundle.

  5. The claimant sought an internal review of that decision in accordance with Division 7.3 of the MAI Act and the insurer affirmed its decision[3] to deny liability.

    [3] The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Su v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPIC 33
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Su v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited involved a dispute between the claimant, Mr. Su, and Allianz Australia Insurance Limited regarding a motor accident claim. The claimant, aged 75, was cycling across Kings Cross Road at a light-controlled pedestrian crossing when he collided with a vehicle driven by the insured party. The claimant sought to establish that he was not wholly at fault for the accident, arguing that the pedestrian light was red, and he was not riding in breach of the road rules. The insurer denied the claim, asserting that the claimant was wholly at fault for the accident.

The court had to determine whether the pedestrian light was red or green at the time of the accident and whether the claimant was riding in breach of the road rules. Additionally, the court needed to ascertain whether the claimant was wholly at fault for the accident. The evidence presented included the claimant's account of the incident, the insured party's testimony, and statements from independent witnesses.

The court considered the evidence and found that the weight should be given to the independent witness who was walking in the same direction as the claimant and stated that the pedestrian light was red. The court concluded that the claimant rode onto the crossing when the light was red and not flashing, which constituted a breach of the road rules. Consequently, the court held that the claimant was wholly at fault for the accident. The court also allowed costs, including those related to an investigator who obtained a statement from the claimant about the accident.

The court's final order was that the claimant was wholly at fault for the accident, and his claim was dismissed. Allianz Australia Insurance Limited was also granted costs, including those related to the investigator who obtained the claimant's statement.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a motor accident occurring on Kings Cross Road in Sydney, where the claimant, aged 75, was riding a bicycle and collided with an insured vehicle. The claimant was crossing a light-controlled pedestrian crossing when the insured, who had turned onto the road on a green light, saw the claimant approaching and attempted to stop. However, a small portion of the car ended up in the pedestrian zone. The claimant collided with the insured's vehicle, fell, and sustained injuries. There was a dispute about the colour of the pedestrian light at the time of the accident, with the claimant asserting that it was green while the insured claimed it was red. An independent witness, who was walking in the same direction as the claimant, provided a statement that the pedestrian light was red. The claimant admitted to riding onto the crossing when the light was red and not flashing, which led to the collision. The claimant was found to be wholly at fault for the accident.

This matter came before the court as an application by the claimant for a determination under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. The claimant sought a determination that they were not wholly at fault for the accident. The case was heard following an investigation into the circumstances of the accident, including the examination of witness statements and the traffic light conditions at the time. Prior to this hearing, no determinations had been made regarding the fault for the accident. The court considered the evidence presented, including the independent witness statement, the claimant's admission, and the statutory provisions relevant to the determination of fault.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the pedestrian light red or flashing red when the claimant rode onto the crossing?
2. Did the claimant ride onto the crossing when the pedestrian light was red and not flashing?
3. If so, was the claimant wholly at fault for the collision?
4. Should costs be awarded, including the costs of an investigator who obtained a statement from the claimant about how the accident happened?

Held
1. The pedestrian light was red when the claimant rode onto the crossing.
2. The claimant rode onto the crossing when the pedestrian light was red and not flashing.
3. The claimant was wholly at fault for the collision.
4. Costs were awarded, including the costs of an investigator who obtained a statement from the claimant about how the accident happened.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the evidence presented regarding the colour of the pedestrian light at the time of the accident. The claimant argued that the light was flashing red, while an independent witness stated that the light was a solid red. The court gave more weight to the independent witness's testimony, finding that the light was indeed a solid red. Consequently, the court determined that the claimant rode onto the crossing when the pedestrian light was red and not flashing, establishing a breach of the road rules. The court found that the claimant was wholly at fault for the collision, as the insured individual had turned onto the road on a green light and stopped upon seeing the claimant approaching. Given the claimant's breach of the road rules, the court held that the claimant was entirely responsible for the collision. Regarding costs, the court ruled that the claimant must bear the costs of the application, including the costs of an investigator who obtained a statement from the claimant about the accident. The decision establishes that when a claimant breaches road rules by crossing a road against a solid red light, they can be found wholly at fault for any resulting collision, regardless of the insured party's actions. This decision follows established principles regarding contributory negligence and the allocation of fault in road accidents under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017.