SU (Review Guardianship and Medical Consent)

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

GUARDIANSHIP AND ADMINISTRATION BOARD
HOBART

SU – Review of Guardianship Order on the application of the Public Guardian and Application for Consent to Medical Treatment on the application of XXXX

SU (Review Guardianship and Medical Consent) [2012] TASGAB 23

REASONS FOR DECISION

Anita Smith (President)

Date of hearing 31 August 2012

Guardianship – consent to medical treatment – whether limited guardianship order or determination for consent to medical treatment is the least restrictive alternative – whether least restrictive alternative is theoretical or practical – best interests – role of person responsible – term of order made on review

Guardianship and Administration Act 1995 ss 6, 11(2), 20(2) and (4), 25(1), 26(1), 40, 41, 43, 44, 45, 67

Guardianship and Administration Regulations 2007 reg. 7

United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, Art. 12

Stuart v Kirkland-Veenstra [2009] HCA 15
Re M. & R and Guardianship and Administration Board (1988) 2 VAR 213
McDonald v Guardianship Board [1993] 1 VR 521
Public Trustee v Blackwood [1998] TASSC 130
Edwards v Edwards [2009] VSC 190
BND (Review of Administration) [2012] TASGAB 3

  1. SU is a 49 year old man.  He lives in shared accommodation that is supported by XXXX, a disability service provider.  He has been the subject of continuous limited guardianship orders since 2003.  The latest guardianship order was due for review on 19 February 2012.  In her final annual report to the Board under the terms of that order, the Public Guardian suggested that a determination by the Board to consent to medical treatment may be as effective and a less restrictive alternative to the continuation of the limited guardianship order.

  2. When the order was reviewed by the Board on 16 February 2012, there was no application before the Board to give consent to medical treatment pursuant to section 44 of the Act, meaning the Board was not in a position to substitute one order for another. Therefore proceedings were adjourned to enable the making of an application. A limited guardianship order was made on an interim basis during the adjournment. The matter returned to the Board on 31 August 2012 with an application pursuant to section 44 and an application for review of the guardianship order pursuant to section 67 listed before the Board simultaneously on the understanding that the applications were alternatives.

  3. SU did not attend the hearing as his medical practitioner indicated that his mental condition would prevent him from doing so.  Attendees at the hearing included representatives from XXXX and the Deputy Public Guardian. 

Circumstances of the Guardianship Order:

  1. SU has a moderate to severe intellectual disability and autism.  He was institutionalized from age seven at Willow Court and has had limited contact with an aunt, but not with any other family members since that time.  As part of the State Government process of de-institutionalisation, he moved to a group home in 1993.  He has limited speech but a better level of comprehension.  The behaviours for which he has been treated…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SU (Review Guardianship and Medical Consent) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] TASGAB 23
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves SU, a 49-year-old man with a moderate to severe intellectual disability and autism, who has been under continuous limited guardianship orders since 2003. The Public Guardian, who is responsible for SU's welfare, recommended a determination by the Board to consent to medical treatment as a less restrictive alternative to the continuation of the limited guardianship order. This recommendation was made due to the ongoing need for medication to control SU's behaviours, which sometimes result in self-injury and bruising to others. The legal issues the court had to decide were whether a limited guardianship order or a determination for consent to medical treatment was the least restrictive alternative for SU, and which of the two outcomes would be most appropriate considering the statutory requirements and the best interests of SU.

The court considered the principle of 'least restrictive alternative' and the importance of personal autonomy as highlighted in Stuart v Kirkland-Veenstra. The court noted that both a guardianship order limited to decisions about health care and a determination by the Board to consent to particular medical treatments would remove SU's personal autonomy to make decisions about treatment. However, the court found that the benefits of the ongoing and flexible relationship with a limited guardian, as well as the independent protection afforded by the guardianship relationship, outweighed the marginal loss of autonomy between a specific consent to treatment and a guardianship order limited to health care. The court also considered the practical implications of the two options, such as the potential delays in adjustments to the Board's consent, and concluded that the benefits of the guardianship relationship would more likely serve SU's best interests.

The court decided to dismiss the application for consent to medical treatment and continue the existing limited guardianship order with the Public Guardian as SU's guardian. The order was limited to decisions concerning consent to any health care that is in the best interests of SU and to refuse or withdraw consent to any such treatment. The court considered it appropriate to continue the order until shortly prior to SU turning 65 years of age, at which point the order would be reviewed.

In conclusion, the court found that the guardianship relationship provided the most appropriate solution for SU, considering both the statutory requirements and his best interests. The court's decision aimed to balance the importance of personal autonomy with the need for ongoing and flexible treatment decisions for SU's wellbeing.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established