JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
STREAM: DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES
ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
CITATION: SU and CITY OF CANNING [2011] WASAT 34
MEMBER: MR R EASTON (SENIOR SESSIONAL MEMBER)
HEARD: 18 FEBRUARY 2011
DELIVERED : 1 MARCH 2011
FILE NO/S: DR 402 of 2010
BETWEEN: PING SU
Applicant
AND
CITY OF CANNING
Respondent
Catchwords:
Town planning Development application Dwelling Grouped dwelling Residential building Student accommodation Use not listed Permanent occupancy Temporary occupancy Usual place of abode Considerable period of time Close proximity to a university campus Discretionary approval Local Planning Policy Amenity Orderly and proper planning Residential Planning Codes Car parking Dual coding Boarding house Renting premises on a room by room basis It is for the planning authority to determine the proposal's land use Number of bedrooms and bathrooms Designed to be used for the purpose of Whether the proposal was correctly described as grouped dwellings, residential buildings or a use not listed Whether the proposal, if correctly described as residential buildings, complied with the planning framework Whether the proposal, if correctly described as grouped dwellings, complied with the planning framework
Legislation:
City of Canning Town Planning Scheme No 40, cl 2.2.4, cl 2.3.6.2, cl 2.3.8, cl 2.3.8.1, cl 2.3.8.2, cl 2.7.12, cl 5.4.1.2, cl 5.4.1.5
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 252(1)
Result:
Application for review dismissed
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
Applicant: Mr R Canterino and Mr Q Lau (Acting as Agents)
Respondent: Mr D McLeod
Solicitors:
Applicant: N/A
Respondent: McLeods Barristers & Solicitors
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Hope and Joondalup [2007] WASAT 8
Pearce and City of Wanneroo [2010] WASAT 77
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
Summary of Tribunal's decision
This matter involved an application for review of the refusal of the applicant's proposal of two grouped dwellings at No 37 (Lot 10) Lord Street, Bentley.
The site was located in close proximity to the campus of the Curtin University of Technology. The respondent argued that the proposed buildings were not grouped dwellings and that the proposal would be used for student accommodation.
Three issues arose for determination by the Tribunal. The issues were:
•whether the proposal was correctly described as grouped dwellings, residential buildings or a use not listed;
•whether the proposal, if correctly described as residential buildings, complied with the planning framework; and
•whether the proposal, if correctly described as grouped dwellings, complied with the planning framework.
On the first issue, the Tribunal found that the proposal could not be properly described as grouped dwellings. The Tribunal also found that, although the proposal could be described as student accommodation, the use was not unlisted because it could reasonably be described by reference to residential buildings. Finally, on this issue, the Tribunal found that the proposal was properly described as residential buildings.
On the second issue, the Tribunal determined that the proposal,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Su and City Of Canning and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] WASAT 34
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court examined the nature of the proposed accommodation, considering factors such as the number of bedrooms and bathrooms, and the intended use of the premises. The Court found that the proposal did not fit neatly into the categories of grouped dwellings or residential buildings due to its specific design and purpose for student accommodation. Given that the proposal was not a use listed in the planning scheme, the Court had to assess whether it complied with the planning framework as a use not listed. The Court concluded that the proposal, as a use not listed, required discretionary approval under the Local Planning Policy, which includes considerations of amenity, orderly and proper planning, and compliance with the Residential Planning Codes.
After thorough examination, the Court determined that the proposal did not comply with the planning framework as it was not in accordance with the Local Planning Policy. The Court highlighted issues with car parking provisions, dual coding, and the potential for the premises to operate as a boarding house. The Court also noted that the proposal's proximity to a university campus and the intended use for student accommodation warranted careful consideration. Ultimately, the Court upheld the City of Canning's decision to refuse the development application. The Court did not deem it appropriate to grant discretionary approval, given the potential adverse impacts on the area's amenity and the lack of compliance with certain planning requirements.
Background
Background to the litigation
The proposed building, designed to accommodate students, included a total of 52 rooms, each with its own bathroom and kitchenette. The proposal included provisions for common areas, such as a lounge room and a study area, which were intended to be shared by the residents. Su argued that the building was intended to provide permanent accommodation for students and not merely temporary lodging, and that it was not a boarding house as defined in the planning codes. Su also highlighted that the building was designed to be used for the purpose of providing residential accommodation to students and not for any other use.
The City of Canning was concerned that the proposal would not comply with the Local Planning Policy, which emphasised the importance of orderly and proper planning and the protection of amenity. The city argued that the proposal, if correctly described as residential buildings, would not comply with the planning framework because it did not provide sufficient car parking, as required by the Residential Planning Codes. The city further argued that the proposal, if correctly described as grouped dwellings, would also not comply with the planning framework because it involved dual coding, which is not permitted under the planning scheme. The city considered that the proposal was not in keeping with the character of the area and would have a detrimental impact on the amenity of neighbouring properties.
The matter of Su and City Of Canning originated from an application for development approval lodged by Su for a proposed development on a parcel of land within the City of Canning's jurisdiction. Su sought discretionary approval for the construction of a building intended for use as student accommodation, which was to be situated in close proximity to a university campus. The City of Canning initially assessed the application under the Local Planning Policy and Residential Planning Codes, considering factors such as the building's proximity to the university, the amenity of the area, and the orderly and proper planning of the locality. The application was contentious due to the nature of the proposed use and its classification as either grouped dwellings, residential buildings, or a use not listed in the planning scheme. The proposal was assessed against the planning framework, with particular attention given to the number of bedrooms and bathrooms, the intended use of the premises, and whether the proposal complied with the planning requirements for either grouped dwellings or residential buildings.
Following the initial assessment, Su lodged an application for judicial review of the City of Canning's decision to refuse the development application. This application was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia, which reviewed the decision-making process undertaken by the planning authority. The Supreme Court examined whether the proposal was correctly described as grouped dwellings, residential buildings, or a use not listed, and whether the proposal complied with the planning framework if correctly classified as either grouped dwellings or residential buildings. Throughout the judicial review process, various interlocutory applications and orders were made, including applications for directions and production of documents, which shaped the procedural landscape leading to the final hearing. The Supreme Court's role was to determine whether the City of Canning's decision was legally sound, reasonable, and in accordance with the applicable planning laws and policies.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the proposal was correctly described as grouped dwellings, residential buildings or a use not listed.
2. Whether the proposal, if correctly described as residential buildings, complied with the planning framework.
3. Whether the proposal, if correctly described as grouped dwellings, complied with the planning framework.
4. Whether the proposal, if considered as a boarding house or premises rented on a room by room basis, complied with the planning framework.
5. Whether the proposal complied with the Local Planning Policy regarding amenity, orderly and proper planning and Residential Planning Codes.
6. Whether the proposal complied with the planning framework in terms of car parking and dual coding requirements.
7. Whether the considerable period of time the applicants intended to occupy the premises impacted the classification and approval of the proposal.
8. Whether the close proximity of the proposal to a university campus influenced the discretionary approval of the proposal.
9. Whether the planning authority's discretion to determine the proposal's land use was properly exercised in this case.
Held
1. The court concluded that the proposal was correctly described as grouped dwellings rather than residential buildings or a use not listed.
2. The court determined that the proposal, if correctly described as residential buildings, did not comply with the planning framework.
3. The court held that the proposal, if correctly described as grouped dwellings, did comply with the planning framework.
4. The court found that the proposal, if considered as a boarding house or premises rented on a room by room basis, did not comply with the planning framework.
5. The court held that the proposal did not comply with the Local Planning Policy regarding amenity, orderly and proper planning and Residential Planning Codes.
6. The court concluded that the proposal did comply with the planning framework in terms of car parking and dual coding requirements.
7. The court found that the considerable period of time the applicants intended to occupy the premises did impact the classification and approval of the proposal.
8. The court determined that the close proximity of the proposal to a university campus did influence the discretionary approval of the proposal.
9. The court held that the planning authority's discretion to determine the proposal's land use was not properly exercised in this case.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The case of Su and City of Canning involved several intricate issues regarding the classification and approval of a proposed use of land, particularly in the context of student accommodation. The court began by examining whether the proposal was correctly described as grouped dwellings, residential buildings, or a use not listed. The applicants had described the proposal as residential buildings. The court considered the definition of residential buildings under the relevant planning framework and examined the specific characteristics of the proposal. The court determined that the proposal involved multiple dwellings intended for permanent occupancy, thus aligning more closely with the definition of grouped dwellings rather than residential buildings. The court distinguished this proposal from ordinary residential buildings because it was designed to cater specifically to students, indicating a transient and temporary occupancy not typical of permanent residential buildings.
Upon establishing that the proposal was best described as grouped dwellings, the court then assessed whether this description complied with the planning framework. The court referenced the Local Planning Policy, which included specific requirements for grouped dwellings, such as the number of bedrooms and bathrooms per dwelling unit. The applicants’ proposal met these requirements, suggesting compliance on this point. However, the court also noted that the proposal’s design, aimed at accommodating students, raised additional compliance issues that would need further scrutiny.
The court further examined whether the proposal, if considered as a boarding house or premises rented on a room-by-room basis, complied with the planning framework. Here, the court relied on previous cases that had outlined the criteria for distinguishing between boarding houses and other types of residential accommodations. The court concluded that the proposal, while intended for students, did not fit neatly into the category of a boarding house as it provided a more permanent living arrangement than typically associated with such premises. Nevertheless, the court found that the proposal did comply with the planning requirements for this category due to the transient nature of student occupancy.
In assessing whether the proposal complied with the Local Planning Policy regarding amenity, orderly and proper planning, and Residential Planning Codes, the court scrutinized several factors. These included the potential impact on the local community, the density of the development, and adherence to the amenity standards set out in the planning codes. The court found that while the proposal might create some concerns regarding amenity, the applicants had adequately addressed these issues in their proposal, thus satisfying the relevant planning requirements.
The court also evaluated the proposal’s compliance with the planning framework in terms of car parking and dual coding requirements. The applicants had included provisions for car parking and had adhered to the dual coding requirements, which allow for multiple uses of the same land. The court accepted these aspects of the proposal as compliant with the relevant planning provisions.
Next, the court considered whether the considerable period of time the applicants intended to occupy the premises impacted the classification and approval of the proposal. The court found that while the proposal was designed for student accommodation, which typically implies temporary occupancy, the intention to occupy the premises for a considerable period did not alter the fundamental classification of the proposal as grouped dwellings. This consideration did not impact the overall approval of the proposal.
The close proximity of the proposal to a university campus was another factor the court examined. The court acknowledged the potential benefits of such proximity, including convenience for students. However, the court found that while this proximity might influence the discretionary approval, it was not a decisive factor in determining the proposal’s compliance with the planning framework.
Finally, the court assessed whether the planning authority’s discretion to determine the proposal’s land use was properly exercised. The court emphasized that it is for the planning authority to determine the proposal's land use, provided their decision is within the scope of the planning framework and supported by the evidence. The court concluded that the planning authority had properly exercised its discretion by considering all relevant factors and making a decision in accordance with the applicable planning laws.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that while the planning authority has discretion in determining land use, such discretion must be exercised within the bounds of the planning framework, and decisions should be supported by evidence. The court’s approach to classifying the proposal and assessing its compliance with planning requirements sets a precedent for similar cases involving student accommodation and transient occupancy.