Stuart and CEO, National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIS)

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

Stuart and CEO, National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIS) [2025] ARTA 804 (24 June 2025)

Applicant/s:  Joelene Stuart

Respondent:  CEO, National Disability Insurance Agency

Tribunal Number:                2023/1052

Tribunal:General Member N. Purcell

Place:Sydney

Date:24 June 2025

Decision:The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

........................................................................

General Member N. Purcell

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME –whether the Applicant meets NDIS access criteria – permanency – Complex Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder – Borderline Personality Disorder – Fibromyalgia – decision under review affirmed.

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2016 (Cth)

Cases

Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] FCA 544
National Disability Insurance Agency v Foster [2023] FCAFC 11
National Disability Insurance Agency v Davis [2022] FCA 1002
Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) [1979] AATA 179; (1979) 2 ALD 634
Beezley v Repatriation Commission (2015) FCAFC 165
Re Schwass and NDIA [2019] AATA 28
LPRK and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 4428

Secondary Materials

Our Guidelines – Becoming a participant – Applying to the NDIS, 14 October 2024 (pre-legislation changes)

Statement of Reasons

INTRODUCTION

  1. The issue before the Tribunal is whether the Applicant meets the access criteria to be a participant of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (‘the NDIS’ or ‘the scheme’), in accordance with section 21 of the National Disability Insurance Act 2013 (Cth) (‘the NDIS Act’ or ‘the Act’).

  2. The Applicant is a 42-year-old woman, who seeks to become a participant of the NDIS based on physical and psycho-social impairments arising from Complex Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (C-PTSD), Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) and Fibromyalgia. She lives in Sydney with her 8 year old daughter.

  3. On 3 February 2023, a delegate on behalf of the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of National Disability Insurance Agency (the Respondent) decided that although the Applicant satisfied the age and residency access criteria, she did not meet the disability requirements under section 24 or the early intervention requirements under section 25 of the Act.

  4. On 6 February 2023, the Applicant sought internal review of the original decision, pursuant to section 100 of the NDIS Act. On 16 February 2023, another delegate of the Respondent affirmed the original decision. The Applicant then sought review of the internal review decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) pursuant to section 103 of the NDIS Act on 21 February 2023.

  5. The AAT was abolished on 13 October 2024 and the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART) began on the 14 October 2024. By virtue of the transitional arrangements, the Applicant’s matter was automatically transferred to the ART.[1]

    [1] See Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential and Transitional Provisions No.1) Act 2024 (Cth).

  6. On 14 June 2024, the Applicant participated in an independent assessment with psychiatrist Dr Surabhi Verma, funded by the Respondent. Dr Verma subsequently prepared a report dated 25 June 2024.

  7. On 8 October 2024, the Applicant also participated in an independent assessment with occupational therapist (OT), Ms Trudie…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stuart and CEO, National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIS) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 804
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Stuart and CEO, National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIS), the applicant sought a review of a decision made by the respondent regarding her eligibility for the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). The applicant, who has been diagnosed with Complex Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (C-PTSD), Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD), and Fibromyalgia, argued that she met the access criteria for the NDIS. The respondent contested the applicant's eligibility on the grounds that her impairments were not permanent and that there were effective treatments available that could remedy the impairments. The case was heard and determined by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT).

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicant's impairments met the criteria for NDIS access, specifically whether they were permanent under section 24(1)(b) of the NDIS Act. The Tribunal had to consider the evidence provided by both parties, including expert medical reports, the applicant's testimony, and the respondent's submissions, to determine if the applicant's impairments were indeed permanent and if there were any available treatments that could remedy them.

The Tribunal acknowledged the applicant's traumatic experiences and the significant impact they had on her life, affirming that her mental health conditions, C-PTSD and BPD, were well-documented and ongoing. However, the Tribunal found that the applicant had engaged in various therapies and treatments, including Dialectical Behaviour Therapy (DBT) and trauma-focused Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (CBT), which suggested that her conditions could potentially be managed or treated. The Tribunal also noted that the applicant had not seen a psychiatrist for over ten years and that her medication had not been reviewed during this period. Given the available evidence-based treatments such as Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) and trauma-focused CBT, which are covered under a mental health care plan, the Tribunal concluded that the applicant's impairments were not permanent as they could be addressed through appropriate treatments.

Based on the findings, the Tribunal affirmed the decision of the respondent that the applicant did not meet the NDIS access criteria. The Tribunal emphasised that while the applicant's conditions were serious and ongoing, the existence of effective treatments meant that her impairments did not qualify as permanent under the NDIS Act. The Tribunal also highlighted the applicant's recent participation in a residential healing program and ongoing counselling sessions, indicating her proactive efforts to manage her conditions.

The final orders of the Tribunal were that the decision under review, which denied the applicant NDIS access, was affirmed. The applicant was not deemed eligible for NDIS support based on the findings that her impairments were not permanent and that there were effective treatments available to manage her conditions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Respondent conceded that the Applicant’s impairments impact her social and economic participation (section 24(1)(d)) and that she would require NDIS supports for her lifetime if her impairments were found to be permanent (section 24(1)(e)).EVIDENCE REGARDING PERMANENCY The concept of permanency under section 24(1)(b) appears to cause considerable confusion and distress, particularly for some Applicants who feel that their experiences and/or diagnosis are called into question through discussions about permanency of impairments. This is both understandable and unfortunate especially when an Applicant’s traumatic experiences are part of the factual matrix being considered. In this case, it is clear from the material that the Applicant has gone through some very challenging periods in her life. There is no doubt in the Tribunal’s mind that the Applicant has experienced several highly traumatic incidents. These experiences have undoubtedly impacted the Applicant’s life and appear, to a significant extent, to underlie her mental health diagnosis. The Tribunal does not intend to elaborate on these matters, except to say that the Applicant has clearly worked very hard, both in respect of her mental health and her life more generally to create stability and safety for herself and youngest daughter. She should feel proud of her efforts. The Tribunal also accepts that the Applicant may live with a diagnosis of BPD and/or C-PTSD for the rest of her life.Physical or sensory impairments The physical or sensory impairments were not clearly articulated by either party during the proceedings however the Tribunal understands from Ms Warner’s report that they can perhaps best be described as chronic pain, fatigue, limited mobility and physical function, incontinence and gastrointestinal issues involving nausea, vomiting and urgent trips to the toilet.[16][16] R2 of JHB, p401-402. In a letter dated 23 August 2022,[17] Dr Beverley Ng, Consultant Rheumatologist, noted she had reviewed the Applicant in relation to fibromyalgia. It is unclear from this letter when the fibromyalgia was first suspected or diagnosed. Dr Ng confirmed that since her last review, the Applicant had undergone a bone scan which did not reveal any concerning pathology. Dr Ng’s impression was that the Applicant was experiencing cervical and lumbar osteoarthritis with concurrent fibromyalgia which was being exacerbated by poor sleep. [17] T22 of JHB, p118. Dr Ng recommended physiotherapy, ongoing counselling and psychotherapy to assist with sleep, regular exercise and to follow up in 6 months.[18] [18] T22 of JHB, p118. On 9 November 2022, the Applicant’s GP at the time, Dr Sanaz Aria wrote “based on information provided by [the Applicant]” she has received remedial massage, chiropractor and physiotherapy for Fibromyalgia.[19][19] T30 of JHB, p136. At hearing, the Applicant’s evidence was somewhat unclear in relation to her physiotherapy treatment. She told the Tribunal she had been seeing a physiotherapist at a hospital but hadn’t gone for a few months and “I just ring up when I need to”. The Applicant indicated that there had been a period when the appointments were scheduled “then it was dropped down to when I next need it, which is actually after this injection”. The Tribunal understands the Applicant was scheduled to receive an injection associated with neck pain in a couple of weeks following the hearing. The Applicant later indicated that she sees her physiotherapist every fortnight but that it would probably be monthly going forward. The Applicant did not file a recent report from her physiotherapist or call them to give any oral evidence. [20][20] Applicant’s oral evidence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As the Applicant has not met either the disability requirements or the early intervention requirements of the Act, the Tribunal must affirm the decision under review.DECISION: The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Based on the above evidence in relation to the Applicant’s psychosocial impairments, the Tribunal makes the following findings and observations (a)The Applicant undertook a 20-week DBT course in 2020 for her BPD.(b)The Applicant has engaged with a range of therapists over several years and made good progress in understanding and managing her mental health.(c)The Applicant has focused on trauma as part of her CBT however the exact modality, goals and outcomes achieved through this therapy is relatively unclear from the reports provided from the Applicant’s most recent treating psychologist Mr Lloyd.(d)The Tribunal accepts that the Applicant’s engagement with the 20-week DBT course and some trauma focused CBT may have partially treated her C-PTSD as there is some cross-over in symptoms between BPD and C-PTSD.(e)The Applicant has not seen a psychiatrist for over 10 years.(f)A psychiatrist has not reviewed the Applicant’s medication for over 10 years. (g)The Applicant’s GP can arrange a referral to a private psychiatrist with an initial out of pocket contribution in the vicinity of $600-700.(h)It will take approximately 4 weeks before the efficacy of the increased Cymbalta dose can be assessed.(i)EMDR is an effective form of treatment for C-PTSD which is available under a mental care health plan. Trauma focused CBT is also available under a mental health care plan.(j)Attendance at a day program for C-PTSD is also an effective form of treatment. (k)The Applicant did not provide details of her financial circumstances however the Tribunal accepts that as a single mother in receipt of Centrelink payments that her means are relatively modest. However, the Applicant recently paid $600 to attend a 5-day residential healing program and has been paying a counsellor $80 per session 3 or 4 times this year.CONSIDERATIONDisability – subsection 24(1)(a) The Respondent accepts that subsection 24(1)(a) is met with respect to the Applicant’s physical impairments. The evidence indicates that the physical impairments are chronic pain, fatigue, limited mobility and physical function, incontinence and gastrointestinal issues including nausea, vomiting and urgent trips to the toilet. The psychosocial impairments arising from C-PTSD and BPD can be described as emotional instability, fear of abandonment, intense mood swings, panic attacks, nightmares, intrusive memories, social phobia and isolation, anxiety and chronic feelings of emptiness. The Applicant has engaged with various practitioners and therapists in relation to these issues, including how these impairments effect the Applicant’s daily life and functional capacity. The Tribunal finds the Applicant’s physical impairments and impairments attributable to her psychosocial conditions satisfy section 24(1)(a).Permanency – subsection 24(1)(b) The Respondent contended that the evidence did not support a finding that the Applicant’s physical or psychosocial impairments are permanent. The Respondent further submits there are known, available and appropriate evidence-based clinical, medical or other treatments that would be likely to remedy the impairments.