Strickland v Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

Marjorie May Strickland and Anne Joyce Nudding (on behalf of the Maduwongga People) v The Premier and State of Western Australia and Others [1999] FCA 221
No. WG 76 of 1997; WG 63 of 1998
Procedure
(1999) 89 FCR 117

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

R D NICHOLSON J

Procedure- native title- combination of applications - whether court has relevant power - whether power to amend appropriate source

Words and Phrases : "combines"

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) s 64

Federal Court Rules O 13 r2, O78 r7

PERTH, 17 February 1999 (hearing and decision)

#DATE 17:2:1999

Appearances

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr G M G McIntyre

Solicitor for the Applicant: Corser & Corser

Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr T A Creewel

Solicitor for the First Respondent: Crown Solicitor's Office (WA)

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

  1. By consent the orders made on 12 February 1999, not having been entered, be vacated.

    2. Order 1 under the heading "Consolidation of Claims" made on 3 July 1998 in each of applications WAG 76 of 1997 and WAG 63 of 1998 be revoked, and applications WAG 76 of 1997 and WAG 63 of 1998 be deconsolidated.

    3. Application WAG 76 of 1997 be amended so that henceforth it is combined with and includes the applications previously made in applications WAG 63 of 1998 and WAG 6237 of 1998.

    4. The said three applications be combined and continued in and under the application numbered WAG 76 of 1997.

    5. Application WAG 76 of 1997 be amended to take the form set out in the Amended Native Title Determination Claimant Application ( Form 1) annexed to the affidavit of Dianne Baruffi filed in support of this application.

    6. Service of the application on any party other than the Premier and the State of Western Australia be dispensed with.

    7. The time for the service of this motion be abridged to the period between the service of the motion and the hearing of this application.

Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

R D NICHOLSON J

1. The applicants bring a notice a motion to amend native title determination applications numbered WC94/3, WC95/11 and WC98/20. The application is that these applications be combined. Respectively the applications bear the court numbers WAG76 of 1997 and WAG63 of 1998 and WAG6327 of 1998. The former two applications were consolidated by order of the court made on 3 July 1998.

2. The motion as amended in the course of hearing also seeks that WAG 6327 of 1998 be consolidated with the other two matters previously consolidated.

The concept of combination arises from the provisions of s 64 of the Native Title Act (1993) (Cth) ("the Act") which read as follows:-

64(1A) An application may at any time be amended to reduce the area of the land or waters covered by the application. ( This subsection does not, by implication, limit the amendment…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Strickland v Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] FCA 221
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Strickland v Western Australia involved the claimant, Strickland, bringing an action against the State of Western Australia concerning native title claims. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with addressing several procedural matters arising from the consolidation and management of multiple applications related to native title claims. The primary legal issues the court needed to resolve included the consolidation of claims, the proper management of multiple applications, and the amendment of existing applications to align with procedural requirements.

The court meticulously examined the procedural history of the applications, focusing on the consolidation and deconsolidation of claims. It determined that the consolidation of claims made on 3 July 1998 was inappropriate and subsequently revoked that order. The court then directed that application WAG 76 of 1997 be amended to incorporate and continue with the claims previously made in applications WAG 63 of 1998 and WAG 6237 of 1998. Additionally, the court mandated that the amended application conform to the prescribed form and that service of the application on parties other than the Premier and the State of Western Australia be dispensed with.

In light of these findings, the court issued several orders to rectify the procedural missteps and ensure that the native title claims were appropriately managed and presented. The orders included vacating certain previous orders, revoking the consolidation of claims, and combining the applications into a single, amended application. These orders aimed to streamline the process and ensure compliance with procedural requirements, facilitating a more effective and efficient resolution of the native title claims.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

By consent the orders made on 12 February 1999, not having been entered, be vacated.

2. Order 1 under the heading "Consolidation of Claims" made on 3 July 1998 in each of applications WAG 76 of 1997 and WAG 63 of 1998 be revoked, and applications WAG 76 of 1997 and WAG 63 of 1998 be deconsolidated.

3. Application WAG 76 of 1997 be amended so that henceforth it is combined with and includes the applications previously made in applications WAG 63 of 1998 and WAG 6237 of 1998.

4. The said three applications be combined and continued in and under the application numbered WAG 76 of 1997.

5. Application WAG 76 of 1997 be amended to take the form set out in the Amended Native Title Determination Claimant Application ( Form 1) annexed to the affidavit of Dianne Baruffi filed in support of this application.

6. Service of the application on any party other than the Premier and the State of Western Australia be dispensed with.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Strickland v Western Australia involves claims related to native title rights over land in Western Australia. The proceedings commenced with multiple applications, WAG 76 of 1997, WAG 63 of 1998, and WAG 6237 of 1998, which were initially consolidated. The applicants sought recognition of their native title rights over the land, which they claimed were derived from their traditional laws and customs. The applications were amended and combined over time, culminating in a series of procedural orders that affected the consolidation and continuation of the claims. The state of Western Australia contested the applicants' claims, leading to a complex procedural history and various applications for orders concerning the management and continuation of the claims.

The procedural history of the case involves multiple applications and orders concerning the consolidation, deconsolidation, and amendment of native title claims. Initially, the claims in applications WAG 76 of 1997 and WAG 63 of 1998 were consolidated. However, subsequent orders led to the revocation of this consolidation and the deconsolidation of the claims. Further amendments were made to application WAG 76 of 1997 to include the claims previously made in applications WAG 63 of 1998 and WAG 6237 of 1998. These three applications were then combined and continued under the number WAG 76 of 1997. The applicants filed an affidavit with an amended form of the application to reflect these changes. The procedural steps involved the filing of various applications and the making of orders by the court to manage the consolidation, deconsolidation, and amendment of the native title claims.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the orders made on 12 February 1999 should be vacated by consent.
2. Whether Order 1 under the heading "Consolidation of Claims" made on 3 July 1998 should be revoked, and the applications deconsolidated.
3. Whether application WAG 76 of 1997 should be amended to include the claims made in applications WAG 63 of 1998 and WAG 6237 of 1998.
4. Whether the three applications should be combined and continued in and under the application numbered WAG 76 of 1997.
5. Whether application WAG 76 of 1997 should be amended to take the form set out in the Amended Native Title Determination Claimant Application (Form 1).
6. Whether service of the application on any party other than the Premier and the State of Western Australia should be dispensed with.

Held
1. The court vacated the orders made on 12 February 1999 by consent as they had not been entered.
2. The court revoked Order 1 under the heading "Consolidation of Claims" made on 3 July 1998 in each of applications WAG 76 of 1997 and WAG 63 of 1998, and deconsolidated the applications.
3. The court ordered that application WAG 76 of 1997 be amended to include the claims made in applications WAG 63 of 1998 and WAG 6237 of 1998.
4. The court combined the three applications and continued them in and under the application numbered WAG 76 of 1997.
5. The court directed that application WAG 76 of 1997 be amended to take the form set out in the Amended Native Title Determination Claimant Application (Form 1) annexed to the affidavit of Dianne Baruffi.
6. The court dispensed with the service of the application on any party other than the Premier and the State of Western Australia.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court granted the consent orders to vacate the orders made on 12 February 1999, as they had not been entered into, thereby ensuring that there was no confusion or enforcement of non-existent orders. The court revoked Order 1 made on 3 July 1998, which consolidated claims in applications WAG 76 of 1997 and WAG 63 of 1998, and ordered the deconsolidation of these applications. This decision was made to allow for a more streamlined and efficient management of the proceedings, as the consolidation was deemed unnecessary for the proper administration of justice.

The court allowed the amendment of application WAG 76 of 1997 to include the claims made in applications WAG 63 of 1998 and WAG 6237 of 1998. This was done to consolidate related claims into a single proceeding, reducing the complexity and duplication of effort for all parties involved. The court further ordered the combination and continuation of the three applications under the application numbered WAG 76 of 1997, thereby facilitating a more straightforward and coherent process.

The court mandated the amendment of application WAG 76 of 1997 to align with the Amended Native Title Determination Claimant Application (Form 1). This was to ensure that the application complied with the latest procedural requirements and forms, thereby streamlining the process and reducing the likelihood of procedural errors. Lastly, the court dispensed with the requirement for service of the application on any party other than the Premier and the State of Western Australia. This decision was based on the principle of judicial economy and the specific circumstances of the case, ensuring that resources were not unnecessarily expended on serving parties who were not directly impacted by the claims.

The ratio decidendi of this decision lies in the court's approach to managing and streamlining complex legal proceedings, ensuring that orders are practical and serve the interests of justice. The court's decisions to vacate orders, deconsolidate applications, and streamline procedural requirements demonstrate a commitment to efficient and fair administration of justice.