STRATIS v POLICE No. SCGRG-98-907 Judgment No. S6886

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

STRATIS v  POLICE

[1998] SASC 6886

Magistrates Appeals

Wicks J

1 This is an appeal against a conviction of the appellant by a magistrate of one count of assault occasioning actual bodily harm.  The alleged assault took place at premises known as the Planet Nightclub.  The appellant was at the nightclub celebrating his brother’s birthday with a group of friends.
2 Mr Christo Dimoglides had also been celebrating that evening with a number of male friends and had arranged to meet his girlfriend at the Planet at about 2.30 - 3.00 am.  He met up with his girlfriend at the nightclub as arranged earlier and they went downstairs together to the bar and dance floor area and stood off to one side between the dance floor and the bar.  Mr Dimoglides’ girlfriend’s sister and cousins were also present.
3 The area of the nightclub in question was dark, noisy and very crowded.  It was difficult to walk through the crowd without bumping into or rubbing shoulders with other people. 
4 Mr Dimoglides gave evidence that he had been at the Planet Nightclub for approximately half an hour when an old friend, Adam Retsas, walked past.  Mr Dimoglides reached out and grasped his friend giving him a bear hug intending to surprise him.  As they playfully wrestled with each other, they twice bumped into another person who was standing behind and to the left of Mr Retsas.  As they were greeting one another Mr Retsas felt a push from behind.  Mr Dimoglides became aware of a tall, dark figure standing behind Mr Retsas.  Mr Dimoglides said "What’s going on, what’s your problem?".  Mr Dimoglides said that he was then struck in the chest and fell backwards to the floor.  He got up immediately and was then struck again with what he described as a "clenched fist".  The blow was to the right side of the head and face.  He said that he then collapsed to the floor.  He then became disorientated and felt dizzy and also felt extreme pain.  He got up again and was struck this time on the left hand side of the face causing him to stagger and fall again to the floor.  He was then dragged away to the toilet by his friends.  While being carried he was struck again on the right side of the face. 
5 The staff of the nightclub intervened at that point and arranged for Mr Dimoglides to be taken to The Royal Adelaide Hospital for treatment. He said that he could not identify his assailant beyond giving a very general description of him as a tall dark person with collar length hair. 
6 Mr Dimoglides had been drinking that evening.  One of the witnesses, Miss Sophie Traiforos, described him as having had a big night.  In answer to a question put to her on the topic, she described him as "quite merry".
7 At the trial Mr Retsas gave evidence that he was present at the Planet Nightclub in the early…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read STRATIS v POLICE No. SCGRG-98-907 Judgment No. S6886 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] SASC 6886
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal against the conviction of the appellant for assault occasioning actual bodily harm, which occurred at the Planet Nightclub, was heard by Wicks J. The incident involved the appellant, who was celebrating his brother’s birthday, and Mr Christo Dimoglides, who was at the nightclub with his girlfriend and friends. The altercation began when Mr Dimoglides and his friend playfully wrestled, inadvertently bumping into a third person. This led to an exchange of words, resulting in the appellant pushing the third person, followed by a series of punches that left Mr Dimoglides severely injured. The appellant claimed that he only pushed the individual and did not punch him, and that any further injuries were caused by the appellant’s brother.

The legal issues before the court included whether the charge and conviction were bad for duplicity and uncertainty, and whether the learned magistrate erred in refusing to order the prosecution counsel to elect which blow was relied upon as constituting the assault occasioning actual bodily harm. The court considered the concept of latent duplicity and whether the incident should be treated as a single act of assault or separate incidents. The court found that the charge contained in the information was intended to cover the blow administered to Mr Dimoglides while he was being escorted to the toilet, and that there was no evidence of the identity of the assailant in respect of this assault. Therefore, the conviction could not stand due to latent duplicity.

Given the conclusion on the duplicity issue, the court did not find it necessary to discuss the other grounds of appeal. The court allowed the appeal, quashed the conviction, and dismissed the charge. The court considered that while there was sufficient evidence for a new trial, the considerable delay and discrepancies in witness testimonies due to the incident occurring in a crowded and dimly lit environment at 3:00 am made it inappropriate to order a new trial.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established