Strang Stevedoring Australia Pty Ltd v Fitzgibbon

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR
__________________________________________________________________

CITATION: Strang Stevedoring Australia Pty Ltd v Gregory Allan Fitzgibbon
[2003] NSW WCC PD 14
APPELLANT: Strang Stevedoring Australia Pty Ltd
RESPONDENT: Gregory Allan Fitzgibbon
INSURER: QBE Workers Compensation (NSW) Ltd
FILE NO: WCC1032-2002
DATE OF DECISION: 12 May, 2003
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: Deputy President Gary Byron
DECISION UNDER APPEAL: That the Respondent [employer] is liable to make weekly payments of $200 per week from 20 April, 2001 and continuing.  Application to review decision as to: failure to give sufficient weight to evidence of incapacity; error in finding that workers’ capacity to find work adversely affected by injury, or alternatively, failure to give sufficient reasons as to exercise of discretion pursuant to section 40(2); error in assessing  probable earnings; error regarding extent of incapacity; failure to make findings on credit; failure to consider effect of prior consent award.
DATE OF DECISION UNDER APPEAL: 17 December, 2002
HEARING: Determined on the papers
REPRESENTATION: Appellant: Diana Benk, QBE Workers Compensation (NSW) Ltd
Respondent: Paul Mantach, MRM Solicitors, Newcastle
ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL: Leave to appeal is refused.  The Appellant is to pay the Respondent worker’s costs as agreed or assessed.

THE APPEAL

  1. On 17 January, 2003 the Respondent in the proceedings before the Arbitrator, Strang Stevedoring Australia Pty Ltd, (“the Appellant”) lodged an appeal with the Workers Compensation Commission (“the Commission”) against a decision dated 17 December, 2002, that the Appellant “is liable to make weekly payments [to Mr. Gregory Allan Fitzgibbon, the Applicant in the proceedings before the Arbitrator, (“the Respondent”)] of $200 per week from 20 April, 2001 and continuing”.  The Arbitrator found on the balance of probabilities that the Respondent’s injury “must” have some effect on his ability to sell his labour on the open market.

  2. The issues in dispute before the Arbitrator, as summarised by him, were:

    ·For what period was the Applicant [Respondent] partially incapacited?  (WCA s 40)

    ·In respect of any period of partial incapacity for work;

    (a)what is the weekly amount which the Applicant would probably have been earning but for the injury had he/she (sic) continued to be employed in the same or comparable employment? (WCA ss 40(2)(a), 42, 43)

    (b)what is the average weekly amount the Applicant is earning or would be able to earn in some suitable employment from time to time after the injury?  (WCA ss 40(2)(b), (3), 42, 43, 43A (definition)).

THE ISSUES IN DISPUTE IN THE APPEAL

  1. The grounds of the appeal are summarised as follows:

    (1)The Arbitrator failed to give sufficient weight to the oral and documentary evidence in the case which established that the worker was not incapacitated for his pre-injury employment from 20.04.01 and that there should not be any weekly compensation awarded because of the facts in evidence.

    (2)The Arbitrator erred in finding that the worker’s capacity to obtain work on the open labour market has been adversely affected by his injury.  In the alternative, if the worker is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Strang Stevedoring Australia Pty Ltd v Fitzgibbon and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] NSWWCCPD 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Strang Stevedoring Australia Pty Ltd v Fitzgibbon is a workers' compensation case heard by the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission. The dispute involved an employer's liability for making weekly compensation payments to an employee who suffered an injury. The employee sought review of a decision that found the employer liable for compensation payments of $200 per week from April 20, 2001, and continuing. The employer contested the decision on several grounds, including the weight given to evidence of the employee's incapacity, the impact of the injury on the employee's capacity to find work, the assessment of probable earnings, the extent of incapacity, the consideration of prior consent awards, and the failure to make findings on credit.

The legal issues before the court were whether the Commission's decision adequately addressed the employer's objections, and whether the Commission had the authority to extend the 28-day time limit for appealing a decision under section 352(4) of the Workers Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003. The court examined whether the Commission's discretion under rule 5(2) of the Interim Workers Compensation Commission Rules 2001 could override the statutory time limit for appeals.

The court found that the Commission did not err in its assessment of the evidence and its exercise of discretion. The court ruled that the Commission did not have the authority to extend the 28-day time limit for appeals under section 352(4) of the Act, as this was not a matter subject to the rules made under section 364(1)(g) of the Act. Consequently, the Commission could not dispense with the time limit through rule 5(2).

ORDERS:
Leave to appeal is refused. The Appellant is to pay the Respondent worker’s costs as agreed or assessed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Leave to appeal is refused. The Appellant is to pay the Respondent worker’s costs as agreed or assessed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a claim for workers' compensation by a worker against Strang Stevedoring Australia Pty Ltd. The worker alleges that the Respondent employer is liable to make weekly payments of $200 from 20 April, 2001, and continuing. The dispute revolves around the assessment of the worker's incapacity, earnings, and the extent of the incapacity resulting from an injury. The case includes a review of a decision made by the Commission constituted by an Arbitrator, where the worker challenges several findings and the exercise of discretion by the Arbitrator. The worker's application for review is based on multiple grounds, including the failure to give sufficient weight to evidence of incapacity, errors in assessing probable earnings, and the extent of incapacity, among others.

The case came before the Commission as a result of an appeal by the worker against a decision made by the Commission constituted by an Arbitrator. The worker applied for leave to appeal the decision on several grounds, as outlined in the case. The key procedural step involved the consideration of whether the Commission should grant leave to appeal, considering the criteria set out in section 352 of the Act. The Commission examined the amount of compensation at issue, which needed to be at least $5,000 and at least 20% of the amount awarded in the decision appealed against, to grant leave to appeal. The Commission also considered the time limit for lodging the appeal, which is 28 days after the decision was made, as per section 352(4) of the Act. The worker's application for an extension of time to lodge the appeal was also evaluated in light of the rules made under the Act and the discretion available to the Commission under rule 5(2).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 352 of the Act provides:“352Appeal against decision of the Commission constituted by an Arbitrator(1)A party to a dispute in connection with a claim for compensation may, with leave of the Commission constituted by a Presidential member, appeal to the Commission as so constituted against a decision in respect of the dispute by the Commission constituted by the Arbitrator.(2)The Commission is not to grant leave to appeal unless the amount of compensation at issue on the appeal is both:(a)at least $5,000 (or such other amount as may be prescribed by the regulations), and(b)at least 20% of the amount awarded in the decision appealed against.(3)If the Commission refuses to grant leave to appeal, the Commission must state reasons for the refusal in writing to the parties.(4)An appeal can only be made within 28 days after the making of the decision appealed against.(5)An appeal under this section is to be by way of review of the decision appealed against.(6)Evidence that is fresh evidence or evidence in addition to or in substitution for the evidence received in relation to the decision appealed against may not be given on an appeal to the Commission except with the leave of the Commission.(7)On appeal, the decision may be confirmed or may be revoked and a new decision made in its place.(8)In this section, decision includes an award, interim award, order, determination, ruling and direction.” Section 364 of the Act provides, inter alia:“364 Rules of the Commission(1)The Minister may from time to time by order make Rules of the Commission for or with respect to any aspect of procedures to be followed in connection with the jurisdiction or functions of the Commission, including provisions for or with respect to:…(g)the extension or abridgment of any period referred to in this Part,…” The reference in the section to “this Part” is to Part 9, Proceedings before Commission, and includes all sections from section 349 to section 365. The rules made under the Act are the Interim Workers Compensation Commission Rules 2001 (“the Rules”). No rule has been made as to “the extension or abridgment of any period referred to in this Part”, pursuant to section 364(1)(g) of the Act. Section 364(1) of the Act provides for the making of rules with respect to a whole range of matters that are set out in the section. One such rule is rule 5(2) which allows the Commission to dispense with compliance with the requirements of the rules. Consequently, “the Commission may if it thinks fit on terms dispense with compliance with any of the requirements of these rules, either before or after the occasion for the compliance arises.” Rule 5(2) applies to rule 50(2) which is complementary to section 352(4) of the Act, and which provides that an application for an appeal against the decision of an Arbitrator “must be lodged with the Registrar within 28 days after the making of the decision appealed against.” However, this is not enough to overcome the 28 day time limit prescribed in section 352(4) of the Act, as the section is not subject to the rules (including rule 5(2)), in the absence of a rule made pursuant to section 364(1)(g).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the application for leave to appeal against the decision of the Arbitrator under section 352 of the Act. Firstly, it assessed the amount of compensation at issue, determining that it did not meet the statutory criteria of being at least $5,000 and at least 20% of the amount awarded in the decision appealed against. Consequently, leave to appeal was refused under section 352(1) and (2) of the Act. The court also considered the timeliness of the appeal, noting that it was not lodged within the 28-day period stipulated in section 352(4) of the Act. The court held that the statutory time limit for lodging an appeal is mandatory and cannot be extended by the Commission, despite rule 5(2) of the Interim Workers Compensation Commission Rules 2001. The court emphasised that the Act does not permit the Commission to dispense with the prescribed time limit for lodging an appeal against the decision of an Arbitrator. The court's decision is based on the clear statutory provisions and the mandatory nature of the time limit, establishing that the Commission cannot grant an extension of time under the circumstances presented.