STRACHAN THOMAS v CLOUGH
[1999] SASC 298
Magistrates Appeal: Civil
WILLIAMS J:
1. The Background
1 This is an appeal against a Master’s decision made on 7 May 1999 in which he ordered that the defendant (the appellant in this action) pay the costs of taxation of the plaintiff’s bill of costs up to 14 July 1998. On that last mentioned day the Master directed that an issue arising upon the taxation be made the subject of separate proceedings (compare King William Law Chambers & Ors v Mobitel (International) Pty Ltd (1982) 29 SASR 316 at 318-320).
2 Consequential upon the order of 14 July 1998 the plaintiff took separate proceedings in the Magistrates Court and a consent order was made on 24 February 1999 in the Magistrates Court.
3 The terms of that order were:
That the plaintiffs recover against the defendant the sum of $6,554.34.
That the defendant pay interest on the said sum, such interest to be calculated from the dates of the respective invoices comprised in the plaintiffs’ Claim.
That the defendant pay the plaintiffs’ costs of action to be agreed, or, in default of agreement, to be taxed.
That this judgment and order are not to create any issue estoppel(sic) in respect of any action now pending between the parties in the Supreme Court of South Australia."
4 The particulars of claim filed in the Magistrates Court action fairly disclose the issue which had arisen before the Master upon taxation. An extract from the particulars of claim in the Magistrates Court action reads as follows:
The plaintiffs are legal practitioners duly admitted to practise in the State of South Australia and at all material times carried on business as legal practitioners under the registered business name "Strachan Thomas".
The defendant is a legal practitioner duly admitted to practise in the State of Queensland and at all material times carried on business as a legal practitioner in that State.
On 24 January 1996 the defendant gave instructions to the plaintiffs to act as his agents in an action in the District Court of South Australia No 1466 of 1994 ("the action") in which his clients William Alex Wilson, Lorna Durrant Wilson and Alec Theodore Wilson ("Wilsons") were parties.
....The plaintiffs proceeded to act in the action in accordance with the defendant’s instructions and continued so to act until 1 October 1996.
The plaintiffs rendered four invoices to the defendant for their professional fees and disbursements.
Particulars
a. 15 March 1996 $1,837.75
b. 27 May 1996 $ 728.91
c. 16 September 1996 $3,323.83
d. 2 October 1996 $ 663.85
TOTAL $6,554.34
The plaintiffs have made demands for payment of the said sum but the defendant has made no payment whatsoever.
The plaintiffs have lodged a Bill of Costs for taxation in the Supreme Court of South Australia in action No 2239 of 1996. The taxation has been adjourned pending determination by this Court of the issues between the parties concerning the existence and scope of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Strachan Thomas v Clough No. Scgrg-96-2239 Judgment No. S298 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] SASC 298
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues in this case were whether a solicitor who acts in their own behalf is entitled to claim costs for their work and whether the right to recover costs of taxation merged in the consent judgment obtained in the Magistrates Court. The Court needed to determine whether the principle in Chorley's case should still be applied in South Australia, and if the appellant's right to recover costs of the taxation merged in the consent judgment.
The Court rejected the appellant's contention that a self-represented practitioner has no right to profit costs, as it was well established that when a solicitor acts in their own behalf, they are entitled to the same costs as if another solicitor had done the work. However, costs will not be recoverable for conferring with oneself. The Court held that the principle of Chorley's case should still be applied in South Australia until the High Court otherwise declares. In terms of the estoppel by record, the Court found that the appellant's right to recover costs of the taxation did not merge in the consent judgment obtained in the Magistrates Court, and the question of costs associated with the adjourned proceedings before the Supreme Court was a matter within the discretion of the court or a judge.
The appeal was dismissed, and the Court would reach the same conclusion as the Master in terms of the order for costs. Counsel were granted the opportunity to be heard upon consequential orders.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi