Story, G. L. v Boulton, W. M

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

CATCHWORDS

BANKRUPTCY - application for rescission under S. 37 -

importance of the public interest - effect of Bankruptcy Amendment Act 1991 - whether retrospective in relation to an extant appeal - comment that working of new sections 73 and 74 should be monitored with a view to consideration of further amendments to protect the public, including future creditors.

Bankruptcy Act 1966, ss. 37, 73 and 74
Bankruptcy Amendment Act 1991, S . 51(1)

Acts Interpretation Act 1901, S . 8

In re Hester. Ex parte Hester (1889) 22 QBD 632
Re Stern fa bankrupt1 [l9821 1 WLR 860 at 866

Totterdell v. Nelson (1990) 26 FCR 523

GREGORY LAIRD STORY v WILLIAM McLEAN BOULTON

QG 94 of 1992

AUSTFULlA

Burchett, French and Einfeld JJ.

Sydney

18 September 1992

RECEIVED

FEDERAL COURT OF

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )
1
QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY
1 QG 94 of 1992
1
GENERAL DIVISION )
BETWEEN:  GREGORY LAIRD STORY

Appellant

AND:  WILLIAM McLEAN BOULTON

Respondent

Judges Making Order: Burchett, French and Einfeld JJ.

Where Order Made:  Sydney
Date of Order:  18 September 1992

MINUTE OF ORDER OF THE COURT

THE COURT ORDERS THAT the appeal be dismissed.

Note:  Settlement and entry of orders dealt with in Order
36 of the Federal Court Rules.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA  )
9UEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY  QG 94 of 1992

1

GENEFAL DIVISION )
BETWEEN :  GREGORY LAIRD STORY

Appellant

AND :  WILLIAM McLEAN BOULTON

Respondent

CORAM: Burchett, French and Einfeld JJ.
PLACE: Sydney

DATE : 18 September 1992

EX TEMPORE REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

BURCHETT J.: A sequestration order was made against the appellant, M r Story, on 17 March 1992, but was not immediately signed and sealed by the registrar. The petitioning creditor shortly afterwards applied for orders suspending the operation of the sequestration order or rescinding it. These orders were sought under S. 37 of the Bankruptcv Act 1966, which then provided for rescission or suspension of the operation of a sequestration order, but only where it had not been signed and

order was subsequently signed and sealed. The present appeal sealed. The application was refused on 4 June 1992, and the
from the refusal of the application was then filed by the
bankrupt.

However, before the appeal could be heard, a substituted S. 37 came into force on 1 July 1992 by virtue of the proclamation of the provisions of S. 8 of the Bankruptcy Amendment Act 1991 (number 9 of 1992). Section 51(1) of that Act provides:

"Subject to this section, each amendment of the Principal Act that is made by this Act, other than the amendment of section 19 of the Principal Act that is made by section 6 of this Act, and relates to bankruptcies applies according to its tenor in relation to persons who were bankrupt at the commencement of that amendment as it applies in relation to persons who become bankrupt after that commencement."

Although the meaning of S. 51(1) is somewhat obscured by
the words "and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Story, G. L. v Boulton, W. M and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1992] FCA 1004
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Story v Boulton, the appellant, Mr Story, appealed against the decision of a judge who refused his application for the rescission or suspension of a sequestration order made against him. The appeal was filed before the Bankruptcy Amendment Act 1991 came into effect, which introduced new provisions for annulment. The appellant argued that there was a difference between rescission and annulment, and that the success of the appeal would invalidate the scheme of arrangement that led to the annulment of his bankruptcy. The court considered the implications of the new provisions and the potential impact on the public interest and future creditors.

The court held that the Bankruptcy Amendment Act 1991 may have removed the power under section 37 for the rescission or suspension of a sequestration order. However, the court found that the Act's Interpretation Act 1901, section 8, may have preserved the section 37 power for the purposes of the particular appeal. The court also noted that the new provisions for annulment permit an automatic annulment by arrangement with creditors, which goes against the previous policy maintained for over a century.

The court found that the appeal should be dismissed, as the judge had considered the public interest and the interests of future creditors when deciding whether to terminate the bankruptcy. The court also found that there was no error in the judge's approach, and the appeal could not be allowed based on incidental errors. The court agreed with the presiding judge that the appellant's deficiency of approximately $12 million, and the rather shadowy arrangements to which most of the creditors were raising no opposition, were not capable of being regarded as open to full scrutiny.

The court also commented on the potential consequences of the 1991 amendments to the Bankruptcy Act, stating that it is difficult to believe that Parliament intended to remove protection of the public from considerations arising upon the discharge of bankrupts or the annulment of bankruptcies. The court noted that the present consequence of the 1991 amendments is that bankrupts may rejoin the community as fully participating incurrers of new debt and acceptors of fresh credit merely by persuading past creditors to agree that they do so. The court found that there was little objective evidence to support the appellant's optimism about his future prospects.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 17 March 1992, a sequestration order was made against the appellant, Mr Story, but it was not signed and sealed by the registrar at the time. The petitioning creditor applied for orders to suspend or rescind the sequestration order under section 37 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966. This application was refused on 4 June 1992, and Mr Story appealed from the refusal. Before the appeal could be heard, a substituted section 37 came into force on 1 July 1992 under the Bankruptcy Amendment Act 1991. The bankrupt then submitted a scheme of arrangement under section 73, and obtained an automatic discharge under section 74(5) on 28 July 1992. The appeal was pressed on the basis that there is a difference between rescission and annulment, and that success in the appeal would overthrow the scheme of arrangement.

The case originated with a sequestration order made against the appellant on 17 March 1992. The petitioning creditor applied for orders under section 37 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 to suspend or rescind the sequestration order, which was refused on 4 June 1992. The appellant appealed from the refusal. Before the appeal could be heard, the Bankruptcy Amendment Act 1991 came into force on 1 July 1992, substituting section 37. The appellant then submitted a scheme of arrangement under section 73, and obtained an automatic discharge under section 74(5) on 28 July 1992. The appeal was heard on 18 September 1992.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Bankruptcy Amendment Act 1991 applies retrospectively to the appellant's extant appeal.
2. Whether the new sections 73 and 74 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 provide sufficient protection to the public, including future creditors.

Held
1. The Bankruptcy Amendment Act 1991 does not apply retrospectively to the appellant's extant appeal.
2. The new sections 73 and 74 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 do not provide sufficient protection to the public, including future creditors.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court considered whether the Bankruptcy Amendment Act 1991 applies retrospectively to the appellant's appeal, which was filed before the Act came into effect. The Court examined section 51(1) of the Bankruptcy Amendment Act 1991, which states that amendments apply according to their tenor in relation to persons who were bankrupt at the commencement of the amendment as it applies in relation to persons who become bankrupt after that commencement. However, the Court found that the Acts Interpretation Act 1901, section 8, may have preserved the section 37 power for the purposes of this particular appeal. The Court concluded that the Bankruptcy Amendment Act 1991 does not apply retrospectively to the appellant's appeal.

The Court also considered whether the new sections 73 and 74 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 provide sufficient protection to the public, including future creditors. The Court noted that the new provisions permit a virtually automatic annulment by arrangement with creditors, which flies in the face of the policy maintained for well over one hundred years. The Court found that the amendments to the Act should be monitored carefully, and if they continue to work in this way, consideration ought to be given to appropriate further amendments to protect the public. The Court concluded that the new sections 73 and 74 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 do not provide sufficient protection to the public, including future creditors. The Court's reasoning was based on the principle that creditors have individual interests and cannot be expected to throw their own good money after bad in the general commercial interests of the rest of the community. The Court referred to several authorities, including In re Hester. Ex parte Hester, Re Stern, and Totterdell v. Nelson, to support its reasoning. The ratio decidendi of the decision is that the Bankruptcy Amendment Act 1991 does not apply retrospectively to an extant appeal and that the new sections 73 and 74 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 do not provide sufficient protection to the public, including future creditors.