Stone v Melrose Cranes & Rigging Pty Ltd (in Liq) (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Stone v Melrose Cranes & Rigging Pty Ltd, in the matter of Cardinal Project Services Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 2) [2018] FCA 530

File number:

NSD 1320 of 2014

Judge:

MARKOVIC J

Date of judgment:

19 April 2018

Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – where the plaintiffs seek to claw back payments made by the company to the defendant prior to its liquidation – whether the company was insolvent at the time each of the payments were made – whether any payments made to the defendant were unfair preferences within the meaning of s 588FA of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Act) – whether any payments are an integral part of a continuing business relationship between the company and the defendant pursuant to s 588FA(3) of the Act – whether the defendant has a good faith defence pursuant to s 588FG(2) of the Act – whether a set-off pursuant to s 553C of the Act is available in the event that the defendants are required to pay the unfair preference amount

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 95A, 286, 588FA, 588FA(1), 588FA(3), 588FE, 588FE(2), 588FF, 588FF(1)(a), 588FG(2), 1305(1), 1306, 1306(5), 1306(6)

Cases cited:

Airservices Australia v Ferrier (1996) 185 CLR 483

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Rich (2009) 75 ACSR 1; [2009] NSWSC 1229

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Plymin (2003) 46 ACSR 126; [2003] VSC 123

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Rich (2005) 216 ALR 320; [2005] NSWSC 417

Bradshaw v McEwans (1951) 217 ALR 1

Buzzle Operation Pty Limited (in liq) v Apple Computer Australia Pty Ltd  (2011) 81 NSWLR 47

Commissioner of Taxation v Kassem and Secatore (2012) 205 FCR 156

Crema (Vic) Pty Ltd v Land Mark Property Developments (Vic) Pty Ltd (2006) 58 ACSR 631; [2006] VSC 338

Cussen as liquidator of Akai Pty Ltd (in liq) v Commissioner of Taxation (2004) 51 ACSR 530; [2004] NSWCA 383

Cussen v Sultan (2009) 74 ACSR 496; [2009] NSWSC 1114

Hall v Poolman (2007) 215 FLR 243; [2007] NSWSC 1330

Hancock v Conergy Pty Limited (in liquidation), in the matter of DCM Solar Pty Limited (in liquidation) [2015] FCA 738

Henderson v Queensland (2014) 255 CLR 1

Hussain v CSR BuildingProducts Ltd (2016) 112 ACSR 507; [2016] FCA 392

Jetaway Logistics Pty Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (2009) 26 VR 657

Lewis v Doran (2004) 208 ALR 385; [2004] NSWSC 608

Mann v Sangria Pty Ltd (2001) 38 ACSR 307; [2001] NSWSC 172

McKern  v Minister Administering the Mining Act 1978 (WA) (2010) 28 VR 1

Murray v Murray (1960) 33 ALJR 521

Queensland Bacon Pty Ltd v Rees (1966) 115 CLR 266

Quick v Stoland Pty Ltd (1998) 87 FCR 371

Re ACN 007 534 000 Pty Ltd (in liq); Ex Parte Parker (1997) 80 FCR 1

Rees v Bank of New South Wales (1964) 111 CLR 210

Richardson v Commercial Banking Co of Sydney Ltd (1952)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stone v Melrose Cranes & Rigging Pty Ltd (in Liq) (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 530
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cardinal Project Services Pty Ltd, through its liquidators, brought an action against Melrose Cranes & Rigging Pty Ltd (in liquidation) in the Federal Court of Australia, seeking to recover payments made by the company to the defendant prior to its liquidation. The liquidators argued that the payments constituted unfair preferences under s 588FA of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and were voidable. The court had to determine whether the company was insolvent at the time each payment was made, whether the payments were unfair preferences, and whether the defendant had a good faith defence under s 588FG(2) of the Act. Additionally, the court had to consider whether a set-off under s 553C of the Act was available if the defendants were required to repay the unfair preference amount.

The court found that the company was insolvent at the time of the payments, as evidenced by its inability to meet its financial obligations, its heavy reliance on debt funding, and its cash flow difficulties. The payments were found to be unfair preferences because they resulted in the defendant receiving more than it would have in a winding up of the company. The court also found that the defendant did not have a good faith defence, as it was aware of the company's inability to pay its debts as and when they fell due. Consequently, the defendant was not entitled to a set-off under s 553C of the Act.

The court ordered that the defendant pay the liquidators the sum of $197,068.38, plus interest. The parties were required to provide written submissions on the calculation of interest, the period for which interest should be paid, and the costs of the proceeding, and to indicate whether those issues could be dealt with on the papers. If an oral hearing was necessary, the matter would be listed on a date convenient to the parties and the Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 588FA(1)(a) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) the defendant pay Cardinal Project Services Pty Ltd (in liq) the sum of $197,068.38 (Sum).

2. The defendant pay interest on the Sum.

3. On or before 3 May 2018 the parties file and serve submissions, not exceeding 3 pages in length, on the questions of calculation of interest on the Sum, including the period for which interest should be paid, and costs of the proceeding and to indicate in those submissions whether those issues can be dealt with on the papers.

4. If an oral hearing is required on the questions of interest and costs referred to in Order 3 then the matter will be listed on a date convenient to the parties and the Court for that purpose.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In their report to creditors dated 29 April 2015, the Liquidators noted that the requested funding was approved and that the Liquidators had lodged their supplementary report with ASIC on 17 July 2014. The Liquidators also set out creditor claims. As at that time the Liquidators had received creditor claims by way of proofs of debt from creditors of CPS in the amount of $7,148,143.3.6 Mr Stone’s evidence Mr Stone is one of the Liquidators and gave evidence about the Cardinal Group and CPS. In Mr Stone’s opinion CPS was insolvent at the time that it made the payments to Melrose Cranes the subject of the Liquidators’ claim; or, alternatively, CPS was insolvent at the time when an act was done or an omission was made for the purpose of giving effect to those payments or, alternatively, CPS became insolvent by reason of matters including making those payments.3.6.1 The Cardinal Group Mr Stone was provided with consolidated management accounts for the Cardinal Group and Card Services prepared up to 31 May 2011. The management accounts were prepared on an individual entity basis up to 15 December 2011. Mr Stone said that, according to the consolidated management accounts, as at 31 May 2011 the Group which he defines as comprising the Cardinal Group (see [16] above) and Card Services (Group) had:(1)a current ratio of 0.95 indicating that liquidity issues were present at the time;(2)a debt to equity ratio of 8.29 which showed the Group’s heavy reliance on debt funding to finance its operation; (3)a positive net asset position of $4.4m. However, intangibles, wholly comprising good will, were carried in the balance sheet at $8m in 2010 and $12m in 2011. In Mr Stone’s opinion, given the trading losses and difficulties that the Group began to experience, the carrying value of good will at those dates should have been much less and he believes that the balance sheets overstated the Group’s net asset position; and(4)a gross profit percentage for the 11 months to 31 May 2011 of 17.95% indicating a reasonable margin. However, Mr Stone said that this did not flow through to the bottom line and that business expenditure and overheads were significant and resulted in a net loss of $100,000 for the period. Mr Stone noted that from 1 March 2011 the following notable events occurred:(1)in March 2011 the Group began incurring losses;(2)the Group had multiple financial reporting systems that had to be manually consolidated resulting in substantial problems in producing timely and accurate financial information about its trading performance, position and the ability to produce forecasts;(3)Cardinal Group employees were transferred to Card Services. Mr Stone believes that the transfer of employees was possibly part of a strategy to transfer a large amount of liabilities to another entity and present other companies in the Cardinal Group in a more favourable financial position prior to seeking additional funds from external sources;(4)Cardinal was the primary borrower for the Group which had an overdraft facility with the NAB that had a limit of $4m. The overdraft limit was reached and extended on more than one occasion. In November 2011 a request was made to extend the overdraft for seven days to facilitate salary and wage payments. As at the date of the appointment of the administrators the balance of the overdraft was $4.3m;(5)the Group was insolvent on a cash flow basis from at least 1 January 2011. Mr Stone’s evidence is that the cash flow statements show a cash flow short fall for the six months up until 31 December 2010 of $496,000 followed by monthly cash flow short falls for each month from January to May 2011;(6)a consolidated cash flow budget was prepared for the Group for the financial year ended 30 June 2012 predicting net cash inflows of $1.6m. However, the budget indicated that the Group would still require a $2.1m overdraft at the end of the financial year. The forecast overdraft balance as at 31 December 2011 was $3.4m. As at the date of the appointment of the administrators, the actual balance of the overdraft was $4.3m. In Mr Stone’s opinion the cash flow forecast was optimistic and could not be achieved;(7)from August 2011 the NAB increased its monitoring of the Group’s borrowings and in or around October 2011 requested that PPB prepare an investigative accountant’s report. The Group had requested an additional $4.6m in funding from the NAB prior to PPB’s engagement;(8)the Group experienced difficulties in obtaining additional finance from external sources. No equity funding was obtained following the issuing of an information memorandum in December 2010;(9)a director’s proposal to personally provide a cash injection either failed or was abandoned;(10)the working relationship between the directors deteriorated in the lead up to the Group being placed into administration;(11)the Group’s financial controller resigned in July 2011;(12)the Group’s insurance coverage lapsed on 30 November 2011 due to the non-payment of premiums; and(13)across the Group there were outstanding income tax returns for the financial year ended 30 June 2011 and outstanding GST lodgements from 1 July 2011.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As was the case in Jetaway, here there were multiple promises of payment that were not met despite persistent follow up. Further, while CPS (unlike the company in Jetaway) did not admit that it did not have, and had no prospect of having, any funds to pay the accrued debt, its imposition on Melrose Cranes of a payment plan by which it incrementally paid back amounts that were not referable to any tax invoices implied the same. Mr Melrose admitted that this was what he believed and as summarised at [275] above, the circumstances indicate that Melrose Cranes was well aware that CPS was unable to pay its debts as and when they fell due. On that basis, it is not entitled to a set-off under s 553C of the Act. 10. CONCLUSION It follows from my reasons set out above that I am satisfied that the payments set out in the table below made on the dates shown in the total amount of $197,068.38 are voidable transactions pursuant to s 588FE(2) of the Act. Those payments are unfair preferences within the meaning of s 588FA of the Act because, as set out at [227] above, they resulted in Melrose Cranes receiving more than it would receive in respect of those debts if the transactions were set aside and Melrose Cranes was to prove for them in the winding up of CPS. Further, those payments were made in the six month period ending on the relation-back day, 15 December 2011, at a time when CPS was insolvent. I will make an order pursuant to s 588FF(1)(a) of the Act that Melrose Cranes pay CPS the sum of $197,068.38 (Sum). The Liquidators seek interest pursuant to s 51A of the Federal Court Act but have asked to be heard on the question of calculation of interest and costs. Accordingly I will make an order for the payment of interest on the Sum and will make further orders requiring the parties to provide short submissions, not exceeding three pages, on the issues of the calculation of interest, the period for which interest should be paid and costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Hussain v CSR BuildingProducts Ltd (2016) 112 ACSR 507; [2016] FCA 392 Edelman J considered s 588FG(2) of the Act. His Honour noted at [190] that the test has four limbs. In relation to the third limb, Edelman J noted that the reasonable person in that limb is the reasonable business person relying on Cussen as Liquidator of Akai Pty Ltd (in liq) v Commissioner of Taxation (2004) 51 ACSR 530; [2004] NSWCA 383 at [31]. At [194] his Honour also considered the concept of “suspecting” and said that it “requires more than idle wondering”; “is a positive feeling of actual apprehension or mistrust without sufficient evidence”, relying on Queensland Bacon; and that “[t]he relevant suspicion must also be suspicion of actual and existing insolvency, as distinct from impending or potential insolvency”. 8.1 Consideration Melrose Cranes submitted that cash flow problems can be indicative of or raise a suspicion of insolvency although not necessarily and that it is important to put them in context. It further submitted that reasonable grounds for suspicion should be determined by reference to commercial reality derived from a particular industry as applying to the facts at the time of the transaction without using hindsight. It contended that it is necessary to identify the factors pointing towards insolvency of the debtor, which of those factors were apparent to the creditor and their cumulative impact. Melrose Cranes said that there may be countervailing factors and circumstances to be weighed in the balance which would tend to dispel suspicion at the time an impugned payment was made. Melrose Cranes submitted that, in opening, the Liquidators conceded that Mr Melrose was its sole controlling mind so that both the objective and subjective inquiry into the state of mind of Melrose Cranes must focus on what was observable to Mr Melrose. It further submitted that the objective circumstances speak of a temporary lack of liquidity brought about by a delay in payment for a large job and that the circumstances of the impeached dealings should be evaluated in the objective context set out in its written submissions. The Liquidators submitted that the good faith element of s 588FG(2) is not met if a creditor knew, believed or suspected that the debtor was insolvent or that the payment would give the creditor a preference over other creditors. It further submitted that the good faith element can be negatived if, viewed objectively, a reasonable person in the creditor’s position would have suspected insolvency. In other words, it submitted that in order to establish a defence under s 588FG(2), Melrose Cranes must prove that subjectively it had no reasonable grounds for suspecting the company was insolvent and that, considered objectively, no reasonable person in the respondent’s position would have suspected insolvency, relying on Williams v Peters [2010] 1 Qd R 475 at [55] per Muir JA (McMurdo and Fraser JJA agreeing). The Liquidators submitted that in the present case Melrose Cranes did not become a party to each of the transactions sought to be impugned in good faith within the meaning of s 588FG(2) of the Act. The Liquidators set out those factual matters which, in their submission, led to that conclusion.